Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2503.00617 · Molecular Physics

Comparing perturbative and commutator-rank-based truncation schemes in unitary coupled-cluster theory

Justin T. Phillips, Lauren N. Koulias, Stephen H. Yuwono, A. Eugene DePrince

Published Jun 24, 2025• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Unitary coupled-cluster (UCC) theory offers a promising Hermitian alternative to conventional coupled-cluster (CC) theory, but its practical implementation is hindered by the non-truncating nature of the Baker–Campbell–Hausdorff (BCH) expansion of the similarity-transformed Hamiltonian (H¯). To address this challenge, various truncation strategies have been developed to approximate H¯ in a compact and reliable manner. In this work, we compare the numerical performance of approximate UCC with single and double excitations (UCCSD) methods that employ many-body perturbation theory (MBPT) and commutator-rank-based truncation schemes. Our results indicate low-order MBPT-based schemes, such as UCC(2) and UCC(3), yield reasonable results near equilibrium, but they become unreliable at stretched geometries. Higher-order MBPT-based schemes do not necessarily improve performance, as the UCCSD(4) and UCCSD(5) amplitude equations sometimes lack solutions. In contrast, commutator-rank-based truncations exhibit greater numerical stability, with the Bernoulli representation of the BCH expansion enabling more rapid convergence to the UCCSD limit compared to the standard BCH formulation.

DOI
10.1080/00268976.2025.2522382

Related papers

An Attractive Way to Correct for Missing Singles Excitations in Unitary Coupled Cluster Doubles Theory

Zachary W. Windom, Daniel Claudino, Rodney J. Bartlett

Coupled cluster methods based exclusively on double excitations are comparatively “cheap” and interesting model chemistries, as they are typically able to capture the bulk of the dynamic electron correlation effects. The trade-off in such approximations is that the effect of neglected excitations, particularly single excitations, can be considerable. Using standard and electron-pair-restricted T 2 operators to define two flavors of unitary coupled cluster doubles (UCCD) methods, we investigate the extent to which missing single excitations can be recovered from low-order corrections in many-body perturbation theory (MBPT) within the unitary coupled cluster (UCC) formalism. Our analysis includes the derivations of finite-order UCC energy functionals, which are used as a basis to define perturbative estimates of missed single excitations. This leads to the novel UCCD[4S] and UCCD[6S] methods, which consider energy corrections for missing single excitations through fourth- and sixth-order in MBPT, respectively. We also apply the same methodology to the electron-pair-restricted ansatz, but the improvements are only marginal. Our findings show that augmenting UCCD with these post hoc perturbative corrections can lead to UCCSD-quality results.

arXiv:2406.09174•The Journal of Physical Chemistry A•Aug 8, 2024•5 citations

Reducing the Cost of Unitary Coupled Cluster via Active Space Partitioning

Prateek Vaish, Brenda M. Rubenstein

Unitary Coupled Cluster (UCC) theory is a promising variational method for electronic structure calculations, particularly for systems that exhibit strong electronic correlation and for implementation on quantum computers. However, its practical application is limited to small chemical systems with small basis sets due to its steep computational scaling, which results from its nonterminating Baker-Campbell-Hausdorff expansion. Here, we introduce an active space UCCSD(4)/MP2 approach that leverages a fourth-order many-body perturbation theory truncation of UCCSD within a selected active space while treating external excitations at the MP2 level. We explore two variants: a composite method that sums separate internal and external contributions and an interacting method that couples the amplitudes for potentially greater accuracy. We test our approach on a range of systems, including molecules from the GW100 data set in their equilibrium geometries, a moderately correlated metaphosphate hydrolysis reaction, and the strongly correlated torsion of ethylene. Our results suggest that the interacting method with canonical orbitals is robust and stable for both weakly and moderately correlated systems and accurately reproduces the full UCCSD(4) potential energy curves, including only 15-25% of the virtual orbitals in its active space. In comparison, the composite formulation exhibits greater sensitivity to the choice of orbital basis and active space size, leading to less systematic behavior across the benchmark set. For ethylene torsion, a system dominated by strong static correlation, both the composite and interacting formulations employing canonical orbitals closely track the full UCCSD(4) reference while preserving the qualitative behavior of the parent method, including the breakdown in strongly multireference regimes. This active space framework offers a computationally tractable approach for modeling correlated molecules and reactions on classical computers and provides a viable path for scaling UCC calculations for resource-constrained quantum hardware.

arXiv:2602.04783•Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation•Jun 5, 2026•1 citation

Analysis of Fourth-, Fifth-, and Infinite-Order Triple Excitations in Unitary Coupled Cluster Theory

Zachary W. Windom, Daniel Claudino

In this work, we introduce a perturbative correction to the unitary coupled cluster method with single and double excitations (UCCSD) that incorporates the effects of missing triple excitations through fifth-order in many-body perturbation theory (MBPT). Referred to as UCCSD[T-5], this method is benchmarked alongside the previously developed UCCSD[T] to lend insight into the behavior of perturbative triples corrections relative to UCCSDT, which inherently provides an infinite-order treatment of triple excitations, as well as full configuration interaction (FCI). Two key findings emerge from this analysis. First, UCCSD[T] consistently yields ground-state energies in closest agreement with FCI, outperforming both UCCSD[T-5] and UCCSDT. Second, UCCSD[T-5] largely emulates the behavior of UCCSDT, suggesting a close relationship between fifth- and infinite-order triple-excitation contributions. Given the growing interest in UCC ansätze for quantum computing and the limitations of current quantum hardware, these results highlight the potential of classically computed perturbative corrections within UCC theory to capture triple-excitation effects without the additional quantum resources required by the UCCSDT ansatz.

arXiv:2509.05184•The Journal of Physical Chemistry A•Feb 10, 2026•0 citations

Unitary coupled-cluster based self-consistent polarization propagator theory: A quadratic unitary coupled-cluster singles and doubles scheme

Junzi Liu, Lan Cheng

The development of a quadratic unitary coupled-cluster singles and doubles (qUCCSD) based self-consistent polarization propagator method is reported. We present a simple strategy for truncating the commutator expansion of the unitary version of coupled-cluster transformed Hamiltonian H̄. The qUCCSD method for the electronic ground state includes up to double commutators for the amplitude equations and up to cubic commutators for the energy expression. The qUCCSD excited-state eigenvalue equations include up to double commutators for the singles-singles block of H̄, single commutators for the singles-doubles and doubles-singles blocks, and the bare Hamiltonian for the doubles-doubles block. Benchmark qUCCSD calculations of the ground-state properties and excitation energies for representative molecules demonstrate significant improvement of the accuracy and robustness over the previous UCC3 scheme derived using Møller-Plesset perturbation theory.

arXiv:2107.01099•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Nov 1, 2021•20 citations

A new “gold standard”: Perturbative triples corrections in unitary coupled cluster theory and prospects for quantum computing

Zachary W. Windom, Daniel Claudino, Rodney J. Bartlett

A major difficulty in quantum simulation is the adequate treatment of a large collection of entangled particles, synonymous with electron correlation in electronic structure theory, with coupled cluster (CC) theory being the leading framework for dealing with this problem. Augmenting computationally affordable low-rank approximations in CC theory with a perturbative account of higher-rank excitations is a tractable and effective way of accounting for the missing electron correlation in those approximations. This is perhaps best exemplified by the "gold standard" CCSD(T) method, which bolsters the baseline CCSD with the effects of triple excitations using considerations from many-body perturbation theory (MBPT). Despite this established success, such a synergy between MBPT and the unitary analog of CC theory (UCC) has not been explored. In this work, we propose a similar approach wherein converged UCCSD amplitudes are leveraged to evaluate energy corrections associated with triple excitations, leading to the UCCSD[T] method. In terms of quantum computing, this correction represents an entirely classical post-processing step that improves the energy estimate by accounting for triple excitation effects without necessitating new quantum algorithm developments or increasing demand for quantum resources. The rationale behind this choice is shown to be rigorous by studying the properties of finite-order UCC energy functionals, and our efforts do not support the addition of the fifth-order contributions as in the (T) correction. We assess the performance of these approaches on a collection of small molecules and demonstrate the benefits of harnessing the inherent synergy between MBPT and UCC theories.

arXiv:2401.06036•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jun 4, 2024•16 citations

A stochastic approach to unitary coupled cluster

Maria-Andreea Filip, Alex J. W. Thom

Unitary coupled cluster (UCC), originally developed as a variational alternative to the popular traditional coupled cluster method, has seen a resurgence as a functional form for use on quantum computers. However, the number of excitors present in the Ansatz often presents a barrier to implementation on quantum computers. Given the natural sparsity of wavefunctions obtained from quantum Monte Carlo methods, we consider here a stochastic solution to the UCC problem. Using the coupled cluster Monte Carlo framework, we develop cluster selection schemes that capture the structure of the UCC wavefunction, as well as its Trotterized approximation, and use these to solve the corresponding projected equations. Due to the fast convergence of the equations with order in the cluster expansion, this approach scales polynomially with the size of the system. Unlike traditional UCC implementations, our approach naturally produces a non-variational estimator for the energy in the form of the projected energy. For unitary coupled cluster singles and doubles (UCCSD) in small systems, we find that this agrees well with the expectation value of the energy and, in the case of two electrons, with full configuration interaction results. For the larger N2 system, the two estimators diverge, with the projected energy approaching the coupled cluster result, while the expectation value is close to results from traditional UCCSD.

arXiv:2011.08344•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Dec 2, 2020•39 citations
Unitary coupled-cluster (UCC) theory offers a promising Hermitian alternative to conventional coupled-cluster (CC) theory, but its practical implementation is hindered by the non-truncating nature of the Baker–Campbell–Hausdorff (BCH) expansion of the similarity-transformed Hamiltonian (H¯). To address this challenge, various truncation strategies have been developed to approximate H¯ in a compact and reliable manner. In this work, we compare the numerical performance of approximate UCC with single and double excitations (UCCSD) methods that employ many-body perturbation theory (MBPT) and commutator-rank-based truncation schemes. Our results indicate low-order MBPT-based schemes, such as UCC(2) and UCC(3), yield reasonable results near equilibrium, but they become unreliable at stretched geometries. Higher-order MBPT-based schemes do not necessarily improve performance, as the UCCSD(4) and UCCSD(5) amplitude equations sometimes lack solutions. In contrast, commutator-rank-based truncations exhibit greater numerical stability, with the Bernoulli representation of the BCH expansion enabling more rapid convergence to the UCCSD limit compared to the standard BCH formulation.
Coupled cluster methods based exclusively on double excitations are comparatively “cheap” and interesting model chemistries, as they are typically able to capture the bulk of the dynamic electron correlation effects. The trade-off in such approximations is that the effect of neglected excitations, particularly single excitations, can be considerable. Using standard and electron-pair-restricted T 2 operators to define two flavors of unitary coupled cluster doubles (UCCD) methods, we investigate the extent to which missing single excitations can be recovered from low-order corrections in many-body perturbation theory (MBPT) within the unitary coupled cluster (UCC) formalism. Our analysis includes the derivations of finite-order UCC energy functionals, which are used as a basis to define perturbative estimates of missed single excitations. This leads to the novel UCCD[4S] and UCCD[6S] methods, which consider energy corrections for missing single excitations through fourth- and sixth-order in MBPT, respectively. We also apply the same methodology to the electron-pair-restricted ansatz, but the improvements are only marginal. Our findings show that augmenting UCCD with these post hoc perturbative corrections can lead to UCCSD-quality results.
Unitary Coupled Cluster (UCC) theory is a promising variational method for electronic structure calculations, particularly for systems that exhibit strong electronic correlation and for implementation on quantum computers. However, its practical application is limited to small chemical systems with small basis sets due to its steep computational scaling, which results from its nonterminating Baker-Campbell-Hausdorff expansion. Here, we introduce an active space UCCSD(4)/MP2 approach that leverages a fourth-order many-body perturbation theory truncation of UCCSD within a selected active space while treating external excitations at the MP2 level. We explore two variants: a composite method that sums separate internal and external contributions and an interacting method that couples the amplitudes for potentially greater accuracy. We test our approach on a range of systems, including molecules from the GW100 data set in their equilibrium geometries, a moderately correlated metaphosphate hydrolysis reaction, and the strongly correlated torsion of ethylene. Our results suggest that the interacting method with canonical orbitals is robust and stable for both weakly and moderately correlated systems and accurately reproduces the full UCCSD(4) potential energy curves, including only 15-25% of the virtual orbitals in its active space. In comparison, the composite formulation exhibits greater sensitivity to the choice of orbital basis and active space size, leading to less systematic behavior across the benchmark set. For ethylene torsion, a system dominated by strong static correlation, both the composite and interacting formulations employing canonical orbitals closely track the full UCCSD(4) reference while preserving the qualitative behavior of the parent method, including the breakdown in strongly multireference regimes. This active space framework offers a computationally tractable approach for modeling correlated molecules and reactions on classical computers and provides a viable path for scaling UCC calculations for resource-constrained quantum hardware.
In this work, we introduce a perturbative correction to the unitary coupled cluster method with single and double excitations (UCCSD) that incorporates the effects of missing triple excitations through fifth-order in many-body perturbation theory (MBPT). Referred to as UCCSD[T-5], this method is benchmarked alongside the previously developed UCCSD[T] to lend insight into the behavior of perturbative triples corrections relative to UCCSDT, which inherently provides an infinite-order treatment of triple excitations, as well as full configuration interaction (FCI). Two key findings emerge from this analysis. First, UCCSD[T] consistently yields ground-state energies in closest agreement with FCI, outperforming both UCCSD[T-5] and UCCSDT. Second, UCCSD[T-5] largely emulates the behavior of UCCSDT, suggesting a close relationship between fifth- and infinite-order triple-excitation contributions. Given the growing interest in UCC ansätze for quantum computing and the limitations of current quantum hardware, these results highlight the potential of classically computed perturbative corrections within UCC theory to capture triple-excitation effects without the additional quantum resources required by the UCCSDT ansatz.
The development of a quadratic unitary coupled-cluster singles and doubles (qUCCSD) based self-consistent polarization propagator method is reported. We present a simple strategy for truncating the commutator expansion of the unitary version of coupled-cluster transformed Hamiltonian H̄. The qUCCSD method for the electronic ground state includes up to double commutators for the amplitude equations and up to cubic commutators for the energy expression. The qUCCSD excited-state eigenvalue equations include up to double commutators for the singles-singles block of H̄, single commutators for the singles-doubles and doubles-singles blocks, and the bare Hamiltonian for the doubles-doubles block. Benchmark qUCCSD calculations of the ground-state properties and excitation energies for representative molecules demonstrate significant improvement of the accuracy and robustness over the previous UCC3 scheme derived using Møller-Plesset perturbation theory.
A major difficulty in quantum simulation is the adequate treatment of a large collection of entangled particles, synonymous with electron correlation in electronic structure theory, with coupled cluster (CC) theory being the leading framework for dealing with this problem. Augmenting computationally affordable low-rank approximations in CC theory with a perturbative account of higher-rank excitations is a tractable and effective way of accounting for the missing electron correlation in those approximations. This is perhaps best exemplified by the "gold standard" CCSD(T) method, which bolsters the baseline CCSD with the effects of triple excitations using considerations from many-body perturbation theory (MBPT). Despite this established success, such a synergy between MBPT and the unitary analog of CC theory (UCC) has not been explored. In this work, we propose a similar approach wherein converged UCCSD amplitudes are leveraged to evaluate energy corrections associated with triple excitations, leading to the UCCSD[T] method. In terms of quantum computing, this correction represents an entirely classical post-processing step that improves the energy estimate by accounting for triple excitation effects without necessitating new quantum algorithm developments or increasing demand for quantum resources. The rationale behind this choice is shown to be rigorous by studying the properties of finite-order UCC energy functionals, and our efforts do not support the addition of the fifth-order contributions as in the (T) correction. We assess the performance of these approaches on a collection of small molecules and demonstrate the benefits of harnessing the inherent synergy between MBPT and UCC theories.
Unitary coupled cluster (UCC), originally developed as a variational alternative to the popular traditional coupled cluster method, has seen a resurgence as a functional form for use on quantum computers. However, the number of excitors present in the Ansatz often presents a barrier to implementation on quantum computers. Given the natural sparsity of wavefunctions obtained from quantum Monte Carlo methods, we consider here a stochastic solution to the UCC problem. Using the coupled cluster Monte Carlo framework, we develop cluster selection schemes that capture the structure of the UCC wavefunction, as well as its Trotterized approximation, and use these to solve the corresponding projected equations. Due to the fast convergence of the equations with order in the cluster expansion, this approach scales polynomially with the size of the system. Unlike traditional UCC implementations, our approach naturally produces a non-variational estimator for the energy in the form of the projected energy. For unitary coupled cluster singles and doubles (UCCSD) in small systems, we find that this agrees well with the expectation value of the energy and, in the case of two electrons, with full configuration interaction results. For the larger N2 system, the two estimators diverge, with the projected energy approaching the coupled cluster result, while the expectation value is close to results from traditional UCCSD.