Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2502.01696 · Journal of Quantum Information Science

Local Quantum Mechanical Prediction of the Singlet State Using Geometric Algebra

Carl F. Diether

Published Jan 1, 2025• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We deduce the quantum mechanical prediction of −a⋅b for the singlet spin state employing local measurement functions following Bell’s approach. This result represents the quantum mechanical expectation value for the joint measurement of spin projections in the singlet state. And is equal to the negative cosine of the angle between vectors a and b . Our derivation is corroborated through a computational simulation conducted in the Mathematica programming environment using geometric algebra.

DOI
10.4236/jqis.2025.154010

Related papers

Beyond Quantum Mechanics: Local QM Space‑Time Algebra Prediction of the Singlet State — Computational Notebooks and Simulations Package

Carl F. Diether

I derive the quantum mechanical prediction $-\mathbf{a}\cdot\mathbf{b}$ for the singlet spin state using local measurement functions within the Space-Time Algebra (STA) framework. I establish a compact and computationally tractable STA representation of the two-particle singlet state, $\Psi = \tfrac{1}{2}(I\sigma_2^{(1)} - I\sigma_2^{(2)})$, which is simpler than previously published forms but is not required for the correlation calculation. The analysis shows that STA naturally generates both scalar dot-product terms ($\mathbf{a}\cdot\mathbf{s}_1$ and $\mathbf{s}_2\cdot\mathbf{b}$) and bivector wedge-product terms ($\mathbf{a}\wedge\mathbf{s}_1$ and $\mathbf{s}_2\wedge\mathbf{b}$) from local spin–detector interactions, whereas standard quantum mechanics retains only the scalar contributions through expectation-value projection. Because the standard quantum formalism represents correlations via operator expectation values, the antisymmetric (cross‑product) contributions are averaged out at the level of observables. In contrast, the STA formulation keeps these bivector terms explicit in the intermediate geometric products, raising the question of whether potentially meaningful geometric structure is being hidden by the quantum averaging procedure. I verify the analytical derivation using computational simulations in Mathematica with a Clifford algebra package, confirming that local measurement functions reproduce the standard quantum correlation $-\cos\theta$, where $\theta$ is the angle between measurement directions $\mathbf{a}$ and $\mathbf{b}$. The correlation $-{\bf a}\cdot {\bf b}$ is the scalar coordinate of 3-sphere rotors.

•Feb 25, 2026•1 citation

Beyond Quantum Mechanics: Local QM Space-Time Algebra Prediction of the Singlet State

Carl F. Diether

I derive the quantum mechanical prediction −a·b for the singlet spin state using local measurement functions within the Space-Time Algebra (STA) framework. I establish a compact and computationally tractable STA representation of the two-particle singlet state, Ψ= 1 2 ( I σ 2 ( 1 ) −I σ 2 ( 2 ) ) , which is simpler than previously published forms but is not required for the correlation calculation. The analysis shows that STA naturally generates both scalar dot-product terms ( a· s 1 ) and ( s 2 ·b ) and bivector wedge-product terms ( a∧ s 1 ) and ( s 2 ∧b ) from local spin-detector interactions, whereas standard quantum mechanics retains only the scalar contributions through expectation-value projection. Because the standard quantum formalism represents correlations via operator expectation values, the antisymmetric (cross-product) contributions are averaged out at the level of observables. In contrast, the STA formulation keeps these bivector terms explicit in the intermediate geometric products, raising the question of whether potentially meaningful geometric structure is being hidden by the quantum averaging procedure. I verify the analytical derivation using computational simulations in Mathematica with a Clifford algebra package, confirming that local measurement functions reproduce the standard quantum correlation −cosθ , where θ is the angle between measurement directions a and b . The correlation −a·b is the scalar coordinate of 3-sphere rotors.

Journal of Quantum Information Science•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Spin-1/2 one- and two- particle systems in physical space without eigen-algebra or tensor product

Sokol Andoni

Abstract A new representation for spin 1/2 in the even 3D subalgebra of the spacetime algebra (STA) combines in a single geometric object the roles of the standard Pauli spin vector and spin state. It is a vector quantity comprising a gauge phase. In the one-particle case the representation (1) is Hermitian; (2) chiral; (3) reproduces all standard expectation values, including the total one-particle spin modulus ; (4) constrains a spinor basis representing opposite spins to preserve handiness (chirality); (5) the gauge phase allows to explicitly formalize irreversibility in spin measurement. In the two-particle case it (1) identifies entangled spin pairs as having opposite handiness and precise gauge phase relations; (2) doubles the dimensionality of the spin space due to variation of handiness; (3) the four maximally entangled states are naturally derived by pairing spins that are reflections (triplets) and inversions (singlet) of each-other. The cross-product terms in the expression for the squared total spin of two particles can be affected by experiment and they yield the standard expectation values after measurement. Here I directly define and transform spin in 3D orientation space, without invoking concepts like abstract Hilbert space and tensor product as in the standard formulation. The STA formalism allows working with whole geometric objects instead of only components, thereby helping keep a clear geometric picture of ‘on paper’ (controlled gauge phase) and ‘on lab’ (uncontrolled gauge phase) spin transformations.

•Mar 9, 2021•0 citations

Spin 1/2 one‐ and two‐particle systems in physical space without eigen‐algebra or tensor product

Sokol Andoni

Under the spin–position decoupling approximation, a vector with a phase in 3D orientation space endowed with geometric algebra substitutes the vector–matrix spin model built on the Pauli spin operator. The standard quantum operator‐state spin formalism is replaced with vectors transforming by proper and improper rotations in the same 3D space—isomorphic to the space of Pauli matrices. In the single‐spin case, the novel spin 1/2 representation (1) is Hermitian, (2) shows handedness, (3) yields all the standard results and its modulus equals the total spin angular momentum , (4) formalizes irreversibility in measurement, and (5) permits adaptive imbedding of the 2D spin space in 3D. Maximally entangled spin pairs (1) are in phase and have opposite handedness, (2) relate by one of the four basic improper rotations in 3D: plane reflections (triplets) and inversion (singlet), (3) yield the standard total angular momentum, and (4) all standard expectation values for bipartite and partial observations follow. Depending on whether proper and improper rotors act one—or two—sided, the formalism appears in two complementary forms, the “spinor” or the “vector” form, respectively. The proposed scheme provides a clear geometric picture of spin correlations and transformations entirely in the 3D physical orientation space.

arXiv:2212.09463•Mathematical Methods in the Applied Sciences•Dec 13, 2022•7 citations

Bell state measurement locally explained

Eugen Muchowski

Abstract Entangled quantum systems can connect to the environment by means of a Bell state measurement. This is true for instance for teleportation and entanglement swapping. While the results are well understood it is not quite clear if they involve nonlocal action or if they are determined in advance. Models based on the fact that the partners of an entangled pair have the same value of a statistical parameter do not apply here. Therefore, in this work a model is presented which reproduces the quantum mechanical predictions for expectation values with spin measurements, but is not based on shared statistical parameters. The coupling of the entangled particles is instead based on the conservation of the spin angular momentum. The model refutes Bell's theorem and explains teleportation and entanglement swapping in a local manner as well. Multilevel entanglements can also be explained locally by the model. The manuscript is thus a step forward towards a complete theory describing quantum physical reality as thought possible by Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen.

•Feb 24, 2023•0 citations

Analyzing the correlations for spin-1/2 particles and singlet pairs

de Faria, Edson, Tresser, Charles

We revisit the computation of correlations of spin projections onto unit vectors for spin-1/2 particles in Quantum Mechanics. We then choose one of the Boole inequalities that, as we recall, must be obeyed by collections of sequences of normalized spin-1/2 projections onto unit vectors that belong to, say, the plane that is orthogonal to the classical trajectory or to the three dimensional space. Next we define the concept of being a-p for i-indexed sequences of spin-1/2 particles: it turns out that a sequence of spin-1/2 particles is a-p if and only if the particles behave as if they had indeed been prepared (in the usual sense) to have definite spins +1 or -1 along the axis a, the sequence of signs being pre-determined. The a-p property is formulated in a way abstract enough to let one generalize it and we define the concept of being a-p and b-p. However, using our chosen Boole inequality we prove that no particle sequence can be both a-p and b-p when a and b are not co-linear. We next consider two modifications of Quantum Mechanics: - The first one by assuming both Weak Realism, the weakest form of Realism needed to develop any main theorem in Bell's Theory, and Locality. - The second one by assuming Weak Realism and an hypothesis that turns out to be none else than (relativistic) Causality extended to cover as well the observable values that make sense only if one assumes Weak Realism. In both cases we arrive at the conclusion that in the EPRB setting where successive pairs of spin-1/2 particles are prepared in the so-called singlet state, one of these particles sequences is both a-p and b-p and a and b are the opposite of the vectors respectively used to project the spin of the other particle and to get the Realism-based alternate value for a projection. Thus the usual discussions of Bell's inequalities under such hypotheses do not even make physical sense.

arXiv:1201.0051•Dec 30, 2011•1 citation
We deduce the quantum mechanical prediction of −a⋅b for the singlet spin state employing local measurement functions following Bell’s approach. This result represents the quantum mechanical expectation value for the joint measurement of spin projections in the singlet state. And is equal to the negative cosine of the angle between vectors a and b . Our derivation is corroborated through a computational simulation conducted in the Mathematica programming environment using geometric algebra.
I derive the quantum mechanical prediction −a⋅b-\mathbf{a}\cdot\mathbf{b}−a⋅b for the singlet spin state using local measurement functions within the Space-Time Algebra (STA) framework. I establish a compact and computationally tractable STA representation of the two-particle singlet state, Ψ=12(Iσ2(1)−Iσ2(2))\Psi = \tfrac{1}{2}(I\sigma_2^{(1)} - I\sigma_2^{(2)})Ψ=21​(Iσ2(1)​−Iσ2(2)​), which is simpler than previously published forms but is not required for the correlation calculation. The analysis shows that STA naturally generates both scalar dot-product terms (a⋅s1\mathbf{a}\cdot\mathbf{s}_1a⋅s1​ and s2⋅b\mathbf{s}_2\cdot\mathbf{b}s2​⋅b) and bivector wedge-product terms (a∧s1\mathbf{a}\wedge\mathbf{s}_1a∧s1​ and s2∧b\mathbf{s}_2\wedge\mathbf{b}s2​∧b) from local spin–detector interactions, whereas standard quantum mechanics retains only the scalar contributions through expectation-value projection. Because the standard quantum formalism represents correlations via operator expectation values, the antisymmetric (cross‑product) contributions are averaged out at the level of observables. In contrast, the STA formulation keeps these bivector terms explicit in the intermediate geometric products, raising the question of whether potentially meaningful geometric structure is being hidden by the quantum averaging procedure. I verify the analytical derivation using computational simulations in Mathematica with a Clifford algebra package, confirming that local measurement functions reproduce the standard quantum correlation −cos⁡θ-\cos\theta−cosθ, where θ\thetaθ is the angle between measurement directions a\mathbf{a}a and b\mathbf{b}b. The correlation −a⋅b-{\bf a}\cdot {\bf b}−a⋅b is the scalar coordinate of 3-sphere rotors.
I derive the quantum mechanical prediction −a·b for the singlet spin state using local measurement functions within the Space-Time Algebra (STA) framework. I establish a compact and computationally tractable STA representation of the two-particle singlet state, Ψ= 1 2 ( I σ 2 ( 1 ) −I σ 2 ( 2 ) ) , which is simpler than previously published forms but is not required for the correlation calculation. The analysis shows that STA naturally generates both scalar dot-product terms ( a· s 1 ) and ( s 2 ·b ) and bivector wedge-product terms ( a∧ s 1 ) and ( s 2 ∧b ) from local spin-detector interactions, whereas standard quantum mechanics retains only the scalar contributions through expectation-value projection. Because the standard quantum formalism represents correlations via operator expectation values, the antisymmetric (cross-product) contributions are averaged out at the level of observables. In contrast, the STA formulation keeps these bivector terms explicit in the intermediate geometric products, raising the question of whether potentially meaningful geometric structure is being hidden by the quantum averaging procedure. I verify the analytical derivation using computational simulations in Mathematica with a Clifford algebra package, confirming that local measurement functions reproduce the standard quantum correlation −cosθ , where θ is the angle between measurement directions a and b . The correlation −a·b is the scalar coordinate of 3-sphere rotors.
Abstract A new representation for spin 1/2 in the even 3D subalgebra of the spacetime algebra (STA) combines in a single geometric object the roles of the standard Pauli spin vector and spin state. It is a vector quantity comprising a gauge phase. In the one-particle case the representation (1) is Hermitian; (2) chiral; (3) reproduces all standard expectation values, including the total one-particle spin modulus ; (4) constrains a spinor basis representing opposite spins to preserve handiness (chirality); (5) the gauge phase allows to explicitly formalize irreversibility in spin measurement. In the two-particle case it (1) identifies entangled spin pairs as having opposite handiness and precise gauge phase relations; (2) doubles the dimensionality of the spin space due to variation of handiness; (3) the four maximally entangled states are naturally derived by pairing spins that are reflections (triplets) and inversions (singlet) of each-other. The cross-product terms in the expression for the squared total spin of two particles can be affected by experiment and they yield the standard expectation values after measurement. Here I directly define and transform spin in 3D orientation space, without invoking concepts like abstract Hilbert space and tensor product as in the standard formulation. The STA formalism allows working with whole geometric objects instead of only components, thereby helping keep a clear geometric picture of ‘on paper’ (controlled gauge phase) and ‘on lab’ (uncontrolled gauge phase) spin transformations.
Under the spin–position decoupling approximation, a vector with a phase in 3D orientation space endowed with geometric algebra substitutes the vector–matrix spin model built on the Pauli spin operator. The standard quantum operator‐state spin formalism is replaced with vectors transforming by proper and improper rotations in the same 3D space—isomorphic to the space of Pauli matrices. In the single‐spin case, the novel spin 1/2 representation (1) is Hermitian, (2) shows handedness, (3) yields all the standard results and its modulus equals the total spin angular momentum , (4) formalizes irreversibility in measurement, and (5) permits adaptive imbedding of the 2D spin space in 3D. Maximally entangled spin pairs (1) are in phase and have opposite handedness, (2) relate by one of the four basic improper rotations in 3D: plane reflections (triplets) and inversion (singlet), (3) yield the standard total angular momentum, and (4) all standard expectation values for bipartite and partial observations follow. Depending on whether proper and improper rotors act one—or two—sided, the formalism appears in two complementary forms, the “spinor” or the “vector” form, respectively. The proposed scheme provides a clear geometric picture of spin correlations and transformations entirely in the 3D physical orientation space.
Abstract Entangled quantum systems can connect to the environment by means of a Bell state measurement. This is true for instance for teleportation and entanglement swapping. While the results are well understood it is not quite clear if they involve nonlocal action or if they are determined in advance. Models based on the fact that the partners of an entangled pair have the same value of a statistical parameter do not apply here. Therefore, in this work a model is presented which reproduces the quantum mechanical predictions for expectation values with spin measurements, but is not based on shared statistical parameters. The coupling of the entangled particles is instead based on the conservation of the spin angular momentum. The model refutes Bell's theorem and explains teleportation and entanglement swapping in a local manner as well. Multilevel entanglements can also be explained locally by the model. The manuscript is thus a step forward towards a complete theory describing quantum physical reality as thought possible by Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen.
We revisit the computation of correlations of spin projections onto unit vectors for spin-1/2 particles in Quantum Mechanics. We then choose one of the Boole inequalities that, as we recall, must be obeyed by collections of sequences of normalized spin-1/2 projections onto unit vectors that belong to, say, the plane that is orthogonal to the classical trajectory or to the three dimensional space. Next we define the concept of being a-p for i-indexed sequences of spin-1/2 particles: it turns out that a sequence of spin-1/2 particles is a-p if and only if the particles behave as if they had indeed been prepared (in the usual sense) to have definite spins +1 or -1 along the axis a, the sequence of signs being pre-determined. The a-p property is formulated in a way abstract enough to let one generalize it and we define the concept of being a-p and b-p. However, using our chosen Boole inequality we prove that no particle sequence can be both a-p and b-p when a and b are not co-linear. We next consider two modifications of Quantum Mechanics: - The first one by assuming both Weak Realism, the weakest form of Realism needed to develop any main theorem in Bell's Theory, and Locality. - The second one by assuming Weak Realism and an hypothesis that turns out to be none else than (relativistic) Causality extended to cover as well the observable values that make sense only if one assumes Weak Realism. In both cases we arrive at the conclusion that in the EPRB setting where successive pairs of spin-1/2 particles are prepared in the so-called singlet state, one of these particles sequences is both a-p and b-p and a and b are the opposite of the vectors respectively used to project the spin of the other particle and to get the Realism-based alternate value for a projection. Thus the usual discussions of Bell's inequalities under such hypotheses do not even make physical sense.