Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2501.19261 · Quantum

Entanglement and Stabilizer entropies of random bipartite pure quantum states

Daniele Iannotti, Gianluca Esposito, Lorenzo Campos Venuti, Alioscia Hamma

Published Jul 21, 2025• 35 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The interplay between non-stabilizerness and entanglement in random states is a very rich arena of study for the understanding of quantum advantage and complexity. In this work, we tackle the problem of such interplay in random pure quantum states. We show that while there is a strong dependence between entanglement and magic, they are, surprisingly, perfectly uncorrelated. We compute the expectation value of non-stabilizerness given the Schmidt spectrum (and thus entanglement). At a first approximation, entanglement determines the average magic on the Schmidt orbit. However, there is a finer structure in the average magic distinguishing different orbits where the flatness of entanglement spectrum is involved.

DOI
10.22331/q-2025-07-21-1797

Related papers

Stabilizer entropy in nonintegrable quantum evolutions

Jovan Odavić, Michele Viscardi, Alioscia Hamma

Entanglement and stabilizer entropy are both involved in the onset of complex behavior in quantum many-body systems. Their interplay is at the root of complexity of simulability, scrambling, thermalization and typicality. In this work, we study the dynamics of entanglement, stabilizer entropy, and the anti-flatness of the entanglement spectrum after a quantum quench in a spin chain. We find that free-fermion theories show a gap in the long-time behavior of these resources compared to their random matrix theory value while non-integrable models saturate it.

arXiv:2412.10228•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jul 22, 2025•50 citations

Magic-protected entanglement and Clifford-irreducible structure in magic state space

Alejandro Borda Kuhlmann, Julian Rincon

We develop a Clifford-orbit framework for studying magic-protected entanglement, which we refer to as magical entanglement: the part of bipartite entanglement that remains after optimal stabilizer simplification. This construction leverages residual entanglement under Clifford reduction as a state-level organizing principle for magic state space. It defines canonical representatives, spectra, and ranks that characterize the Clifford-irreducible structure of a state. We identify two regimes of the magic-entanglement interplay. In the $T$-magic regime, local nonstabilizer resources can coexist with entanglement, but the protected component remains weak and state-dependent. In the $W$-magic regime, by contrast, entanglement is Clifford-irreducibly tied to nonstabilizerness, producing typical, strongly self-averaging behavior. Analytical examples and random-circuit numerics support a crossover from broad $T$-magic fluctuations to concentrated, Haar-like $W$-magic behavior. These results identify magical entanglement as an orbit-level diagnostic of how nonstabilizerness protects quantum correlations against Clifford reduction.

quant-pharXiv:2607.18400•Jul 22, 2026•1 citation

Entanglement spectrum of random-singlet quantum critical points

Maurizio Fagotti, Pasquale Calabrese, Joel E. Moore

The entanglement spectrum (i.e., the full distribution of Schmidt eigenvalues of the reduced density matrix) contains more information than the conventional entanglement entropy and has been studied recently in several many-particle systems. We compute the disorder-averaged entanglement spectrum in the form of the disorder-averaged moments $\stackrel{\underline{}}{\mathrm{Tr}{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\rho}}}_{\mathrm{A}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}}$ of the reduced density matrix ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{A}$ for a contiguous block of many spins at the random-singlet quantum critical point in one dimension. The result compares well in the scaling limit with numerical studies on the random $\mathit{XX}$ model and is also expected to describe the (interacting) random Heisenberg model. Our numerical studies on the $\mathit{XX}$ case reveal that the dependence of the entanglement entropy and spectrum on the geometry of the Hilbert space partition is quite different than for conformally invariant critical points.

arXiv:1009.1614•Physical Review B•Jan 31, 2011•79 citations

Asymptotically independent fluctuations of stabilizer Rényi entropy and entanglement in random unitary circuits

Dominik Szombathy, Angelo Valli, Cătălin Paşcu Moca +2 more

We investigate numerically the joint distribution of magic (as described by the stabilizer 2-Rényi entropy M 2 ) and entanglement (as described by the von Neumann entropy S ) in N -qubit Haar-random quantum states. The distribution P N ( M 2 , S ) and the marginals become exponentially localized, and centered around the typical values, M 2 ̃ → N − 2 and S ̃ → N / 2 as N → ∞ . Magic and entanglement fluctuations are, however, found to become exponentially uncorrelated. While the set of stabilizer states grows exponentially with N , they nevertheless form a measure-zero subset of Haar-random states and thus occur with vanishing probability. Typical quantum states are characterized by large magic and entanglement entropy, and uncorrelated magic and entanglement fluctuations. The mutual information of the joint distribution vanishes exponentially as N → ∞ , implying that fluctuations of these two resources are not only uncorrelated but asymptotically independent.

arXiv:2501.11489•Physical Review Research•Sep 15, 2025•30 citations

Non-stabilizerness and entanglement in $(2+1)$-dimensional SU(2) lattice gauge theory using tensor networks

Raghav G. Jha, Jaber I. Taher, Muhammad Asaduzzaman +3 more

We study non-stabilizerness (magic) in the ground state of $(2+1)$-dimensional $\mathrm{SU}(2)$ Hamiltonian lattice gauge theory with matter, formulated in the dressed-site basis in the hardcore-gluon truncation and restricted to the zero baryon-number sector. Using matrix product states, we compute three facets of magic: the second-order stabilizer Rényi entropy (SRE) $M_2$, its non-local component $M_2^{\rm NL}$, estimated by the SRE $M_2(\tildeψ)$ of the computational-basis Schmidt representative $\tildeψ$, and a lower bound in terms of the anti-flatness $F$ of the entanglement spectrum. We also prove a stronger form of the sandwich relation: $-\log_2(1-4F)\le M_2^{\rm NL}\le M_2$; the lower bound rests on a stronger inequality that we obtain for arbitrary Schmidt bases and rank, with an optimal constant. Combined with recent results, this yields the unconditional bracket $\max\{-\log_2(1-4F),\,M_2(\tildeψ)-4\}\le M_2^{\rm NL}\le M_2(\tildeψ)$. We emphasize a structural distinction that makes the non-local quantities the physically preferred diagnostics: whereas the full SRE depends on the (non-unique) encoding of the gauge-invariant local Hilbert space into qubits, the non-local magic, its estimate $M_2(\tildeψ)$, and the anti-flatness are invariant under site-local re-encodings and are therefore intrinsic to the state and bipartition. By varying the gauge coupling for two values of the fermion mass on lattices up to $8\times 8$ ($\sim 288$ qubits) with bond dimension up to $128$, we find that the non-local magic, as estimated by $M_2(\tildeψ)$, furnishes a sharper and more bond-dimension-friendly probe of the gauge-matter delocalization crossover compared to the full SRE or the gauge-invariant entanglement entropy, retaining a clear signal at bond dimensions well below those needed to converge the ground state itself.

quant-pharXiv:2609.28634•Sep 25, 2026•4 citations

Bipartite entanglement of large quantum systems

Antonella De Pasquale

In this thesis we study the behavior of bipartite entanglement of a large quantum system, by analyzing the distribution of the Schmidt coefficients of the reduced density matrix. Applying the general methods of classical statistical mechanics, we develop a canonical approach for the study of the distribution of these coefficients for a fixed value of the average entanglement. We introduce a partition function depending on a fictitious temperature, which localizes the measure on the set of states with higher and lower entanglement, if compared to typical (random) states with respect to the Haar measure. The purity of one subsystem, which is our entanglement measure/indicator, plays the role of energy in the partition function. This thesis consists of two parts. In the first part, we completely characterize the distribution of the purity and of the eigenvalues for pure states. The global picture unveils several locally stable solutions exchange stabilities, through the presence of first and second order phase transitions. We also detect the presence of metastable states. In the second part, we focus on mixed states. Through the same statistical approach, we determine the exact expression of the first two moments of the local purity and the high temperature expansion of the first moment. We also bridge our problem with the theory of quantum channels, more precisely we exploit the symmetry properties of the twirling transformations in order to compute the exact expression for the first moment of the local purity.

arXiv:1206.6749•Jun 28, 2012•4 citations
The interplay between non-stabilizerness and entanglement in random states is a very rich arena of study for the understanding of quantum advantage and complexity. In this work, we tackle the problem of such interplay in random pure quantum states. We show that while there is a strong dependence between entanglement and magic, they are, surprisingly, perfectly uncorrelated. We compute the expectation value of non-stabilizerness given the Schmidt spectrum (and thus entanglement). At a first approximation, entanglement determines the average magic on the Schmidt orbit. However, there is a finer structure in the average magic distinguishing different orbits where the flatness of entanglement spectrum is involved.
Entanglement and stabilizer entropy are both involved in the onset of complex behavior in quantum many-body systems. Their interplay is at the root of complexity of simulability, scrambling, thermalization and typicality. In this work, we study the dynamics of entanglement, stabilizer entropy, and the anti-flatness of the entanglement spectrum after a quantum quench in a spin chain. We find that free-fermion theories show a gap in the long-time behavior of these resources compared to their random matrix theory value while non-integrable models saturate it.
We develop a Clifford-orbit framework for studying magic-protected entanglement, which we refer to as magical entanglement: the part of bipartite entanglement that remains after optimal stabilizer simplification. This construction leverages residual entanglement under Clifford reduction as a state-level organizing principle for magic state space. It defines canonical representatives, spectra, and ranks that characterize the Clifford-irreducible structure of a state. We identify two regimes of the magic-entanglement interplay. In the TTT-magic regime, local nonstabilizer resources can coexist with entanglement, but the protected component remains weak and state-dependent. In the WWW-magic regime, by contrast, entanglement is Clifford-irreducibly tied to nonstabilizerness, producing typical, strongly self-averaging behavior. Analytical examples and random-circuit numerics support a crossover from broad TTT-magic fluctuations to concentrated, Haar-like WWW-magic behavior. These results identify magical entanglement as an orbit-level diagnostic of how nonstabilizerness protects quantum correlations against Clifford reduction.
The entanglement spectrum (i.e., the full distribution of Schmidt eigenvalues of the reduced density matrix) contains more information than the conventional entanglement entropy and has been studied recently in several many-particle systems. We compute the disorder-averaged entanglement spectrum in the form of the disorder-averaged moments $\stackrel{\underline{}}{\mathrm{Tr}{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\rho}}}_{\mathrm{A}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}}$ of the reduced density matrix ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{A}$ for a contiguous block of many spins at the random-singlet quantum critical point in one dimension. The result compares well in the scaling limit with numerical studies on the random XX\mathit{XX}XX model and is also expected to describe the (interacting) random Heisenberg model. Our numerical studies on the XX\mathit{XX}XX case reveal that the dependence of the entanglement entropy and spectrum on the geometry of the Hilbert space partition is quite different than for conformally invariant critical points.
We investigate numerically the joint distribution of magic (as described by the stabilizer 2-Rényi entropy M 2 ) and entanglement (as described by the von Neumann entropy S ) in N -qubit Haar-random quantum states. The distribution P N ( M 2 , S ) and the marginals become exponentially localized, and centered around the typical values, M 2 ̃ → N − 2 and S ̃ → N / 2 as N → ∞ . Magic and entanglement fluctuations are, however, found to become exponentially uncorrelated. While the set of stabilizer states grows exponentially with N , they nevertheless form a measure-zero subset of Haar-random states and thus occur with vanishing probability. Typical quantum states are characterized by large magic and entanglement entropy, and uncorrelated magic and entanglement fluctuations. The mutual information of the joint distribution vanishes exponentially as N → ∞ , implying that fluctuations of these two resources are not only uncorrelated but asymptotically independent.
Non-stabilizerness and entanglement in (2+1)(2+1)(2+1)-dimensional SU(2) lattice gauge theory using tensor networks
We study non-stabilizerness (magic) in the ground state of (2+1)(2+1)(2+1)-dimensional SU(2)\mathrm{SU}(2)SU(2) Hamiltonian lattice gauge theory with matter, formulated in the dressed-site basis in the hardcore-gluon truncation and restricted to the zero baryon-number sector. Using matrix product states, we compute three facets of magic: the second-order stabilizer Rényi entropy (SRE) M2M_2M2​, its non-local component M2NLM_2^{\rm NL}M2NL​, estimated by the SRE M2(ψ~)M_2(\tildeψ)M2​(ψ~​) of the computational-basis Schmidt representative ψ~\tildeψψ~​, and a lower bound in terms of the anti-flatness FFF of the entanglement spectrum. We also prove a stronger form of the sandwich relation: −log⁡2(1−4F)≤M2NL≤M2-\log_2(1-4F)\le M_2^{\rm NL}\le M_2−log2​(1−4F)≤M2NL​≤M2​; the lower bound rests on a stronger inequality that we obtain for arbitrary Schmidt bases and rank, with an optimal constant. Combined with recent results, this yields the unconditional bracket max⁡{−log⁡2(1−4F), M2(ψ~)−4}≤M2NL≤M2(ψ~)\max\{-\log_2(1-4F),\,M_2(\tildeψ)-4\}\le M_2^{\rm NL}\le M_2(\tildeψ)max{−log2​(1−4F),M2​(ψ~​)−4}≤M2NL​≤M2​(ψ~​). We emphasize a structural distinction that makes the non-local quantities the physically preferred diagnostics: whereas the full SRE depends on the (non-unique) encoding of the gauge-invariant local Hilbert space into qubits, the non-local magic, its estimate M2(ψ~)M_2(\tildeψ)M2​(ψ~​), and the anti-flatness are invariant under site-local re-encodings and are therefore intrinsic to the state and bipartition. By varying the gauge coupling for two values of the fermion mass on lattices up to 8×88\times 88×8 (∼288\sim 288∼288 qubits) with bond dimension up to 128128128, we find that the non-local magic, as estimated by M2(ψ~)M_2(\tildeψ)M2​(ψ~​), furnishes a sharper and more bond-dimension-friendly probe of the gauge-matter delocalization crossover compared to the full SRE or the gauge-invariant entanglement entropy, retaining a clear signal at bond dimensions well below those needed to converge the ground state itself.
In this thesis we study the behavior of bipartite entanglement of a large quantum system, by analyzing the distribution of the Schmidt coefficients of the reduced density matrix. Applying the general methods of classical statistical mechanics, we develop a canonical approach for the study of the distribution of these coefficients for a fixed value of the average entanglement. We introduce a partition function depending on a fictitious temperature, which localizes the measure on the set of states with higher and lower entanglement, if compared to typical (random) states with respect to the Haar measure. The purity of one subsystem, which is our entanglement measure/indicator, plays the role of energy in the partition function. This thesis consists of two parts. In the first part, we completely characterize the distribution of the purity and of the eigenvalues for pure states. The global picture unveils several locally stable solutions exchange stabilities, through the presence of first and second order phase transitions. We also detect the presence of metastable states. In the second part, we focus on mixed states. Through the same statistical approach, we determine the exact expression of the first two moments of the local purity and the high temperature expansion of the first moment. We also bridge our problem with the theory of quantum channels, more precisely we exploit the symmetry properties of the twirling transformations in order to compute the exact expression for the first moment of the local purity.