Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2501.17222 · Journal of High Energy Physics

Nesting is not contracting

Bartłomiej Czech, Sirui Shuai

Published Jun 12, 2025• 8 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A bstract The default way of proving holographic entropy inequalities is the contraction method. It divides Ryu-Takayanagi (RT) surfaces on the ‘greater than’ side of the inequality into segments, then glues the segments into candidate RT surfaces for terms on the ‘less than’ side. Here we discuss how proofs by contraction are constrained and informed by entanglement wedge nesting (EWN)—the property that enlarging a boundary region can only enlarge its entanglement wedge. We propose that: (i) all proofs by contraction necessarily involve candidate RT surfaces, which violate EWN; (ii) violations of EWN in contraction proofs of maximally tight inequalities occur commonly and — where this can be quantified — with maximal density near boundary conditions; (iii) the non-uniqueness of proofs by contraction reflects inequivalent ways of violating EWN. As evidence and illustration, we study the recently discovered infinite families of holographic entropy inequalities, which are associated with tessellations of the torus and the projective plane. We explain the logic, which underlies their proofs by contraction. We find that all salient aspects of the requisite contraction maps are dictated by EWN while all their variable aspects set the scheme for how to violate EWN. We comment on whether the tension between EWN and contraction maps might help in characterizing maximally tight holographic entropy inequalities.

DOI
10.1007/jhep06(2025)122

Related papers

Holographic entropy inequalities and the topology of entanglement wedge nesting

Bartłomiej Czech, Sirui Shuai, Yixu Wang +1 more

We prove two new infinite families of holographic entropy inequalities. A key tool is a graphical arrangement of terms of inequalities that is based on entanglement wedge nesting. It associates the inequalities with tessellations of the torus and the projective plane, which reflect a certain topological aspect of entanglement wedge nesting. The inequalities prove a prior conjecture about the holographic entropy cone. We discuss their relation to black hole physics and differential entropy, and sketch applications to quantum error correction, quantifying randomness of quantum states, and others. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2309.15145•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•May 10, 2024•28 citations

Constraints from entanglement wedge nesting for holography at a finite cutoff

Krishan Saraswat

A bstract We explore constraints that arise from associating an entanglement wedge (EW) to subregions of a cutoff boundary at a finite distance in AdS/CFT, using a subcritical end-of-the-world (ETW) brane acting as a cutoff. In particular, we consider the case of two intervals in the holographic dual to a BCFT, with one interval A located at the asymptotic boundary and the second interval B located on the ETW brane. We discuss in detail subtleties that arise near the RT end-points when defining the EW for this configuration, particularly in the connected phase. Entanglement wedge nesting (EWN) requires that $$ {\mathcal{W}}_E(A) $$ W E A ∪ $$ {\mathcal{W}}_E(B) $$ W E B ⊆ $$ {\mathcal{W}}_E\left(A\cup B\right) $$ W E A ∪ B . We demonstrate that already in the simplest example of an AdS 3 bulk geometry, EWN can be violated even if A and B are spacelike separated through the bulk and instead we must require the stronger condition that $$ {\mathcal{W}}_E(A) $$ W E A be spacelike separated from $$ {\mathcal{W}}_E(B) $$ W E B , which highlights the non-local nature of the cutoff theory. Our prescription to associate EWs to subregions on the ETW brane is different from the restricted maximin procedure [1] but will agree within the subset of parameter space where EWN is respected. Additionally, we study EWN in a two sided BTZ black hole geometry with an ETW brane in one of the exteriors. In the BTZ black hole example we find that our condition for EWN disallows configurations where the RT surface goes from the brane to the black hole singularity.

arXiv:2501.15024•Journal of High Energy Physics•Jul 9, 2025•0 citations

Properties of the contraction map for holographic entanglement entropy inequalities

Ning Bao, Joydeep Naskar

A bstract We present a deterministic way of finding contraction maps for candidate holographic entanglement entropy inequalities modulo choices due to actual degeneracy. We characterize its complexity and give an argument for the completeness of the contraction map proof method as a necessary and sufficient condition for the validity of an entropy inequality for holographic entanglement.

arXiv:2403.13283•Journal of High Energy Physics•Jun 7, 2024•15 citations

Zoo of Correlation Inequalities in Holography and Beyond

Kyan Louisia, Takato Mori, Herbie Warner

Information-theoretic inequalities often impose nontrivial constraints on holographic states. In this work, we study measurement-based classical and quantum correlations in holography, focusing on the proposed duals of classical correlation $J_W$, quantum discord $D_W$, and one-shot distillable entanglement $E_D$, defined in terms of the entanglement wedge cross section (EWCS). We develop a homological framework tailored to inequalities involving multiple EWCSs and Ryu-Takayanagi surfaces, and use it to prove a family of inequalities, including monotonicity and monogamy/polygamy-type relations, as well as one-way strong superadditivity. For strong superadditivity, we additionally confirm its two-way version using Haar random states. We also examine holography-inspired boundary duals in terms of the reflected entropy and provide proofs and counterexamples for their information-theoretic inequalities. Taken together, our results provide further evidence for the duality between the EWCS and its proposed boundary counterparts -- measurement-based correlations and one-shot distillable entanglement -- while also furnishing a unified, rigorous method for proving multi-EWCS inequalities.

hep-thCross-listedarXiv:2511.21870•Journal of High Energy Physics•Nov 28, 2025•2 citations

Explorations in Holographic Entanglement Entropy

Aitor Lewkowycz

In this Dissertation, different aspects of holographic entanglement entropy are explored. In quantum information theory, entanglement is a useful resource needed to perform quantum operations. Entanglement entropy quantifies this resource and even if computable in quantum field theories, it is quite hard to calculate explicitly. However, in the context of gauge/gravity duality, (holographic) entanglement entropy was proposed by Ryu and Takayanagi (RT) to be captured by the area of a minimal surface in Anti DeSitter (AdS) space, which is extremely simple to compute. We begin by using the holographic dictionary to derive the RT formula. This is done by first considering smooth bulk geometries which are dual to n copies of the boundary geometry glued in a particular way. The action of these geometries computes the Renyi entropies S_n for any integer n. We give a prescription to analytically continue the action to non-integer n and argue that, as n goes to 1,S_1, the entanglement entropy, is given by the area of a minimal surface, reproducing the RT conjecture. That is, we reduced the RT proposal to the equality between bulk and boundary partition functions, a standard entry in the dictionary. We then generalize the previous formalism to account for corrections due to bulk quantum fields (1/N corrections in the boundary). This allows us to derive a new formula: boundary entanglement entropy is given by the area of the minimal surface plus bulk entanglement entropy. This extends RT beyond the planar limit and we present several predictions of the proposal. Our exploration of holographic entanglement entropy continues by considering different states: by comparing the quantum corrected entropy for nearby states we obtain the modular hamiltonian operator in bulk perturbation theory. From this expression of the modular hamiltonian, we derive that relative entropy is bulk relative entropy and that the modular flow is the bulk modular flow.

•Sep 27, 2016•0 citations

Spacetime as Optimal Allocation: Deriving the Ryu–Takayanagi Formula from Distributed Resource Constraints in Tensor Network Holography

Brandon Christopher Russell

We derive the Ryu–Takayanagi (RT) formula for holographic entanglement entropy from a resource-allocation principle. We model bulk reconstruction as a budget-constrained distributed optimization problem: spacelike-separated boundary observers must decide which bulk operators to reconstruct under a shared budget, without communicating their local inputs. We prove three results. (1) Any local (non-communicating) protocol for this game achieves expected utility at most 1/2, while a centralized protocol achieves 2/3; the gap Δ = 1/6 is tight. (2) The information cost of closing this gap is O(1) bits per degree of freedom, with residual loss decaying as 4−k in the number of communicated bits k. (3) In holographic tensor networks (HaPPY codes and random tensor networks), the allocation decisions across distinct bonds on the minimal surface are independent, so the total information cost sums linearly: S(A) = |γA| log2 χ, reproducing the RT formula. The derivation is non-circular: the RT formula emerges as the output, not an input. We identify the bipartite inefficiency ratio η(2) = 1/4 and discuss its possible connection to the Bekenstein–Hawking prefactor. We also characterize the entanglement wedge phase transition as a discrete reallocation event in the bond-level optimization landscape.Extended proofs available at doi:10.5281/zenodo.19213268.

•Mar 21, 2026•2 citations
A bstract The default way of proving holographic entropy inequalities is the contraction method. It divides Ryu-Takayanagi (RT) surfaces on the ‘greater than’ side of the inequality into segments, then glues the segments into candidate RT surfaces for terms on the ‘less than’ side. Here we discuss how proofs by contraction are constrained and informed by entanglement wedge nesting (EWN)—the property that enlarging a boundary region can only enlarge its entanglement wedge. We propose that: (i) all proofs by contraction necessarily involve candidate RT surfaces, which violate EWN; (ii) violations of EWN in contraction proofs of maximally tight inequalities occur commonly and — where this can be quantified — with maximal density near boundary conditions; (iii) the non-uniqueness of proofs by contraction reflects inequivalent ways of violating EWN. As evidence and illustration, we study the recently discovered infinite families of holographic entropy inequalities, which are associated with tessellations of the torus and the projective plane. We explain the logic, which underlies their proofs by contraction. We find that all salient aspects of the requisite contraction maps are dictated by EWN while all their variable aspects set the scheme for how to violate EWN. We comment on whether the tension between EWN and contraction maps might help in characterizing maximally tight holographic entropy inequalities.
We prove two new infinite families of holographic entropy inequalities. A key tool is a graphical arrangement of terms of inequalities that is based on entanglement wedge nesting. It associates the inequalities with tessellations of the torus and the projective plane, which reflect a certain topological aspect of entanglement wedge nesting. The inequalities prove a prior conjecture about the holographic entropy cone. We discuss their relation to black hole physics and differential entropy, and sketch applications to quantum error correction, quantifying randomness of quantum states, and others. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
A bstract We explore constraints that arise from associating an entanglement wedge (EW) to subregions of a cutoff boundary at a finite distance in AdS/CFT, using a subcritical end-of-the-world (ETW) brane acting as a cutoff. In particular, we consider the case of two intervals in the holographic dual to a BCFT, with one interval A located at the asymptotic boundary and the second interval B located on the ETW brane. We discuss in detail subtleties that arise near the RT end-points when defining the EW for this configuration, particularly in the connected phase. Entanglement wedge nesting (EWN) requires that WE(A) {\mathcal{W}}_E(A) WE​(A) W E A ∪ WE(B) {\mathcal{W}}_E(B) WE​(B) W E B ⊆ WE(A∪B) {\mathcal{W}}_E\left(A\cup B\right) WE​(A∪B) W E A ∪ B . We demonstrate that already in the simplest example of an AdS 3 bulk geometry, EWN can be violated even if A and B are spacelike separated through the bulk and instead we must require the stronger condition that WE(A) {\mathcal{W}}_E(A) WE​(A) W E A be spacelike separated from WE(B) {\mathcal{W}}_E(B) WE​(B) W E B , which highlights the non-local nature of the cutoff theory. Our prescription to associate EWs to subregions on the ETW brane is different from the restricted maximin procedure [1] but will agree within the subset of parameter space where EWN is respected. Additionally, we study EWN in a two sided BTZ black hole geometry with an ETW brane in one of the exteriors. In the BTZ black hole example we find that our condition for EWN disallows configurations where the RT surface goes from the brane to the black hole singularity.
Information-theoretic inequalities often impose nontrivial constraints on holographic states. In this work, we study measurement-based classical and quantum correlations in holography, focusing on the proposed duals of classical correlation JWJ_WJW​, quantum discord DWD_WDW​, and one-shot distillable entanglement EDE_DED​, defined in terms of the entanglement wedge cross section (EWCS). We develop a homological framework tailored to inequalities involving multiple EWCSs and Ryu-Takayanagi surfaces, and use it to prove a family of inequalities, including monotonicity and monogamy/polygamy-type relations, as well as one-way strong superadditivity. For strong superadditivity, we additionally confirm its two-way version using Haar random states. We also examine holography-inspired boundary duals in terms of the reflected entropy and provide proofs and counterexamples for their information-theoretic inequalities. Taken together, our results provide further evidence for the duality between the EWCS and its proposed boundary counterparts -- measurement-based correlations and one-shot distillable entanglement -- while also furnishing a unified, rigorous method for proving multi-EWCS inequalities.
In this Dissertation, different aspects of holographic entanglement entropy are explored. In quantum information theory, entanglement is a useful resource needed to perform quantum operations. Entanglement entropy quantifies this resource and even if computable in quantum field theories, it is quite hard to calculate explicitly. However, in the context of gauge/gravity duality, (holographic) entanglement entropy was proposed by Ryu and Takayanagi (RT) to be captured by the area of a minimal surface in Anti DeSitter (AdS) space, which is extremely simple to compute. We begin by using the holographic dictionary to derive the RT formula. This is done by first considering smooth bulk geometries which are dual to n copies of the boundary geometry glued in a particular way. The action of these geometries computes the Renyi entropies S_n for any integer n. We give a prescription to analytically continue the action to non-integer n and argue that, as n goes to 1,S_1, the entanglement entropy, is given by the area of a minimal surface, reproducing the RT conjecture. That is, we reduced the RT proposal to the equality between bulk and boundary partition functions, a standard entry in the dictionary. We then generalize the previous formalism to account for corrections due to bulk quantum fields (1/N corrections in the boundary). This allows us to derive a new formula: boundary entanglement entropy is given by the area of the minimal surface plus bulk entanglement entropy. This extends RT beyond the planar limit and we present several predictions of the proposal. Our exploration of holographic entanglement entropy continues by considering different states: by comparing the quantum corrected entropy for nearby states we obtain the modular hamiltonian operator in bulk perturbation theory. From this expression of the modular hamiltonian, we derive that relative entropy is bulk relative entropy and that the modular flow is the bulk modular flow.
We derive the Ryu–Takayanagi (RT) formula for holographic entanglement entropy from a resource-allocation principle. We model bulk reconstruction as a budget-constrained distributed optimization problem: spacelike-separated boundary observers must decide which bulk operators to reconstruct under a shared budget, without communicating their local inputs. We prove three results. (1) Any local (non-communicating) protocol for this game achieves expected utility at most 1/2, while a centralized protocol achieves 2/3; the gap Δ = 1/6 is tight. (2) The information cost of closing this gap is O(1) bits per degree of freedom, with residual loss decaying as 4−k in the number of communicated bits k. (3) In holographic tensor networks (HaPPY codes and random tensor networks), the allocation decisions across distinct bonds on the minimal surface are independent, so the total information cost sums linearly: S(A) = |γA| log2 χ, reproducing the RT formula. The derivation is non-circular: the RT formula emerges as the output, not an input. We identify the bipartite inefficiency ratio η(2) = 1/4 and discuss its possible connection to the Bekenstein–Hawking prefactor. We also characterize the entanglement wedge phase transition as a discrete reallocation event in the bond-level optimization landscape.Extended proofs available at doi:10.5281/zenodo.19213268.