Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2501.11826 · International Symposium on Symbolic and Algebraic Computation

A Noncommutative Nullstellensatz for Perfect Two-Answer Quantum Nonlocal Games

Tianshi Yu, Lihong Zhi

Published Jul 28, 2025• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

This paper introduces a noncommutative version of the Nullstellensatz, motivated by the study of quantum nonlocal games. It has been proved that a two-answer nonlocal game with a perfect quantum strategy also admits a perfect classical strategy. We generalize this result to the infinite-dimensional case, showing that a two-answer game with a perfect commuting operator strategy also admits a perfect classical strategy. This result induces a special case of noncommutative Nullstellensatz.

DOI
10.1145/3747199.3747541

Related papers

A Characterization of Perfect Strategies for Mirror Games

Sizhuo Yan, Jianting Yang, T. Yu +1 more

We associate mirror games with the universal game algebra and use the *-representation to describe quantum commuting operator strategies. We provide an algebraic characterization of whether or not a mirror game has perfect commuting operator strategies. This new characterization uses a smaller algebra introduced by Paulsen and others for synchronous games and the noncommutative Nullstellensatz developed by Cimpric, Helton and collaborators. An algorithm based on noncommutative Gröbner basis computation and semidefinite programming is given for certifying that a given mirror game has no perfect commuting operator strategies.

arXiv:2302.04557•International Symposium on Symbolic and Algebraic Computation•Jul 5, 2023•4 citations

Transitive nonlocal games

Prem Nigam Kar, Jitendra Prakash, David E. Roberson

We study a class of nonlocal games, called transitive games, for which the set of perfect strategies forms a semigroup. We establish several interesting correspondences of bisynchronous transitive games with the theory of compact quantum groups. In particular, we associate a quantum permutation group with each bisynchronous transitive game and vice versa. We prove that the existence of a C*-strategy, the existence of a quantum commuting strategy, and the existence of a classical strategy are all equivalent for bisynchronous transitive games. We then use some of these correspondences to establish necessary and sufficient conditions for some classes of correlations, that arise as perfect strategies of transitive games, to be nonlocal.

arXiv:2312.12040•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jul 1, 2024•0 citations

Perfect quantum strategies with small input cardinality

Stefan Trandafir, Junior R. Gonzales-Ureta, Adán Cabello

A perfect strategy is one that allows the mutually in-communicated players of a nonlocal game to win every trial of the game. Perfect strategies are basic tools for some fundamental results in quantum computation and crucial resources for some applications in quantum information. Here, we address the problem of producing qudit-qudit perfect quantum strategies with a small number of settings. For that, we exploit a recent result showing that any perfect quantum strategy induces a Kochen-Specker set. We identify a family of KS sets in even dimension $d \ge 6$ that, for many dimensions, require the smallest number of orthogonal bases known: $d+1$. This family was only defined for some $d$. We first extend the family to infinitely many more dimensions. Then, we show the optimal way to use each of these sets to produce a bipartite perfect strategy with minimum input cardinality. As a result, we present a family of perfect quantum strategies in any $(2,d-1,d)$ Bell scenario, with $d = 2^kp^m$ for $p$ prime, $m \geq k \geq 0$ (excluding $m=k=0$), $d = 8p$ for $p \geq 19$, $d=kp$ for $p > ((k-2)2^{k-2})^2$ whenever there exists a Hadamard matrix of order $k$, other sporadic examples, as well as a recursive construction that produces perfect quantum strategies for infinitely many dimensions $d$ from any dimension $d'$ with a perfect quantum strategy. We identify their associated Bell inequalities and prove that they are not tight, which provides a second counterexample to a conjecture of 2007.

arXiv:2407.21473•Jul 31, 2024•1 citation

Extended Nonlocal Games from Quantum-Classical Games

Russo, Vincent, John Watrous

Several variants of nonlocal games have been considered in the study of quantum entanglement and nonlocality. This paper concerns two of these variants, called quantum-classical games and extended nonlocal games. We give a construction of an extended nonlocal game from any quantum-classical game that allows one to translate certain facts concerning quantum- classical games to extended nonlocal games. In particular, based on work of Regev and Vidick, we conclude that there exist extended nonlocal games for which no finite-dimensional entangled strategy can be optimal. While this conclusion is a direct consequence of recent work of Slofstra, who proved a stronger, analogous result for ordinary (non-extended) nonlocal games, the proof based on our construction is considerably simpler, and the construction itself might potentially have other applications in the study of entanglement and nonlocality.

arXiv:1709.01837•Sep 5, 2017•6 citations

Quantum Perfect Matchings

David Cui, Laura Mančinska, Seyed Sajjad Nezhadi +1 more

Abstract We investigate quantum and nonsignaling generalizations of perfect matchings in graphs using nonlocal games. Specifically, we introduce nonlocal games that test for L-perfect matchings in bipartite graphs, perfect matchings in general graphs and hypergraphs, and fractional perfect matchings. Our definitions come from the fact that these games are classical property tests for the corresponding matching conditions. We use the existence of perfect quantum and nonsignaling strategies for these games to define quantum and nonsignaling versions of perfect matchings. Finally, we provide characterizations of when graphs exhibit these extended properties: For nonsignaling matchings, we give a complete combinatorial characterization. In particular, a graph has a nonsignaling perfect matching if and only if it admits a fractional perfect matching that has bounded value on triangles. In bipartite graphs, the nonsignaling L-perfect matching property is achieved exactly when the left component of the graph can be split into two disjoint subgraphs: one with a classical L-perfect matching and another with left-degree 2. In the quantum setting, we show that complete graphs $$K_n$$ K n with odd $$n \ge 7$$ n ≥ 7 have quantum perfect matchings. We prove that a graph has a quantum perfect matching if and only if the quantum independence number of its line graph is maximal, extending a classical relationship between perfect matchings and line graph independence numbers. For bipartite graphs, we establish that the L-perfect matching game does not exhibit quantum pseudotelepathy, but we characterize the quantum advantage for complete bipartite graphs $$K_{n,2}$$ K n , 2 . Additionally, we prove that deciding quantum perfect matchings in hypergraphs is undecidable and leaves open the question of its complexity in graphs.

arXiv:2502.05136•Annales Henri Poincaré•Oct 14, 2025•3 citations

Complete characterization of perfect quantum strategies in quantum magic rectangle games

Yueying Wu

We provide a complete structural characterization of perfect quantum strategies for arbitrary quantum magic rectangle games. We derive necessary and sufficient conditions that jointly constrain the shared state and measurement operators, establishing a unified analytical framework for perfect nonlocal strategies in this setting. Our results show that all perfect quantum solution states (PQSS) must exhibit a specific algebraic--combinatorial structure, ruling out a priori assumptions about particular entangled resources and clarifying the full class of states compatible with perfect correlations. We further show that perfect quantum strategies do not exist for $2 \times n$ quantum magic rectangle games with odd $n$, and introduce a corresponding quantum magic rectangle inequality to characterize optimal non-perfect strategies. While our results are structural, they may provide a foundation for future developments in quantum information and quantum cryptography based on perfect nonlocal correlations.

quant-pharXiv:2604.18317•Apr 21, 2026•0 citations
This paper introduces a noncommutative version of the Nullstellensatz, motivated by the study of quantum nonlocal games. It has been proved that a two-answer nonlocal game with a perfect quantum strategy also admits a perfect classical strategy. We generalize this result to the infinite-dimensional case, showing that a two-answer game with a perfect commuting operator strategy also admits a perfect classical strategy. This result induces a special case of noncommutative Nullstellensatz.
We associate mirror games with the universal game algebra and use the *-representation to describe quantum commuting operator strategies. We provide an algebraic characterization of whether or not a mirror game has perfect commuting operator strategies. This new characterization uses a smaller algebra introduced by Paulsen and others for synchronous games and the noncommutative Nullstellensatz developed by Cimpric, Helton and collaborators. An algorithm based on noncommutative Gröbner basis computation and semidefinite programming is given for certifying that a given mirror game has no perfect commuting operator strategies.
We study a class of nonlocal games, called transitive games, for which the set of perfect strategies forms a semigroup. We establish several interesting correspondences of bisynchronous transitive games with the theory of compact quantum groups. In particular, we associate a quantum permutation group with each bisynchronous transitive game and vice versa. We prove that the existence of a C*-strategy, the existence of a quantum commuting strategy, and the existence of a classical strategy are all equivalent for bisynchronous transitive games. We then use some of these correspondences to establish necessary and sufficient conditions for some classes of correlations, that arise as perfect strategies of transitive games, to be nonlocal.
A perfect strategy is one that allows the mutually in-communicated players of a nonlocal game to win every trial of the game. Perfect strategies are basic tools for some fundamental results in quantum computation and crucial resources for some applications in quantum information. Here, we address the problem of producing qudit-qudit perfect quantum strategies with a small number of settings. For that, we exploit a recent result showing that any perfect quantum strategy induces a Kochen-Specker set. We identify a family of KS sets in even dimension d≥6d \ge 6d≥6 that, for many dimensions, require the smallest number of orthogonal bases known: d+1d+1d+1. This family was only defined for some ddd. We first extend the family to infinitely many more dimensions. Then, we show the optimal way to use each of these sets to produce a bipartite perfect strategy with minimum input cardinality. As a result, we present a family of perfect quantum strategies in any (2,d−1,d)(2,d-1,d)(2,d−1,d) Bell scenario, with d=2kpmd = 2^kp^md=2kpm for ppp prime, m≥k≥0m \geq k \geq 0m≥k≥0 (excluding m=k=0m=k=0m=k=0), d=8pd = 8pd=8p for p≥19p \geq 19p≥19, d=kpd=kpd=kp for p>((k−2)2k−2)2p > ((k-2)2^{k-2})^2p>((k−2)2k−2)2 whenever there exists a Hadamard matrix of order kkk, other sporadic examples, as well as a recursive construction that produces perfect quantum strategies for infinitely many dimensions ddd from any dimension d′d'd′ with a perfect quantum strategy. We identify their associated Bell inequalities and prove that they are not tight, which provides a second counterexample to a conjecture of 2007.
Several variants of nonlocal games have been considered in the study of quantum entanglement and nonlocality. This paper concerns two of these variants, called quantum-classical games and extended nonlocal games. We give a construction of an extended nonlocal game from any quantum-classical game that allows one to translate certain facts concerning quantum- classical games to extended nonlocal games. In particular, based on work of Regev and Vidick, we conclude that there exist extended nonlocal games for which no finite-dimensional entangled strategy can be optimal. While this conclusion is a direct consequence of recent work of Slofstra, who proved a stronger, analogous result for ordinary (non-extended) nonlocal games, the proof based on our construction is considerably simpler, and the construction itself might potentially have other applications in the study of entanglement and nonlocality.
Abstract We investigate quantum and nonsignaling generalizations of perfect matchings in graphs using nonlocal games. Specifically, we introduce nonlocal games that test for L-perfect matchings in bipartite graphs, perfect matchings in general graphs and hypergraphs, and fractional perfect matchings. Our definitions come from the fact that these games are classical property tests for the corresponding matching conditions. We use the existence of perfect quantum and nonsignaling strategies for these games to define quantum and nonsignaling versions of perfect matchings. Finally, we provide characterizations of when graphs exhibit these extended properties: For nonsignaling matchings, we give a complete combinatorial characterization. In particular, a graph has a nonsignaling perfect matching if and only if it admits a fractional perfect matching that has bounded value on triangles. In bipartite graphs, the nonsignaling L-perfect matching property is achieved exactly when the left component of the graph can be split into two disjoint subgraphs: one with a classical L-perfect matching and another with left-degree 2. In the quantum setting, we show that complete graphs KnK_nKn​ K n with odd n≥7n \ge 7n≥7 n ≥ 7 have quantum perfect matchings. We prove that a graph has a quantum perfect matching if and only if the quantum independence number of its line graph is maximal, extending a classical relationship between perfect matchings and line graph independence numbers. For bipartite graphs, we establish that the L-perfect matching game does not exhibit quantum pseudotelepathy, but we characterize the quantum advantage for complete bipartite graphs Kn,2K_{n,2}Kn,2​ K n , 2 . Additionally, we prove that deciding quantum perfect matchings in hypergraphs is undecidable and leaves open the question of its complexity in graphs.
We provide a complete structural characterization of perfect quantum strategies for arbitrary quantum magic rectangle games. We derive necessary and sufficient conditions that jointly constrain the shared state and measurement operators, establishing a unified analytical framework for perfect nonlocal strategies in this setting. Our results show that all perfect quantum solution states (PQSS) must exhibit a specific algebraic--combinatorial structure, ruling out a priori assumptions about particular entangled resources and clarifying the full class of states compatible with perfect correlations. We further show that perfect quantum strategies do not exist for 2×n2 \times n2×n quantum magic rectangle games with odd nnn, and introduce a corresponding quantum magic rectangle inequality to characterize optimal non-perfect strategies. While our results are structural, they may provide a foundation for future developments in quantum information and quantum cryptography based on perfect nonlocal correlations.