In [arXiv:2409.00161v1 (2024)] Cavendish et al. raise three criticisms against our time of arrival proposal [L. Maccone and K. Sacha, Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 110402 (2020)]. Here we show that all three criticisms are without merit. One of them is founded on a logical mistake.
In the note by Khemani et al. [arXiv:2001.11037] the authors express conceptual disagreement with our recent paper on quantum time crystals [Phys. Rev. Lett. 123, 210602]. They criticise the idealized nature of the considered quantum time crystal, and make several points about properties of Hamiltonians presented in our work. In this reply we answer one-by-one all questions raised in the discussion. As for the ideological dispute, it brightly highlights a bizarre nature of time crystalline order in closed quantum systems, and we offer a different vision for the development of the field.
It is shown that a class of exponentially decaying time-of-arrival probability distributions, suggested by W\l{}odarz [Phys. Rev. A 65, 044103 (2002)], Marchewka and Schuss [Phys. Lett. A 240, 177 (1998), Phys. Rev. A 63, 032108 (2001); Phys. Rev. A 65, 042112 (2002)], and Jurman and Nikoli\ifmmode \acute{c}\else \'{c}\fi{} [Phys. Lett. A 396, 127247 (2021)], and a semiclassical distribution implicit in time-of-flight momentum measurements do not show the expected behavior for a Gaussian wave train. This casts doubts on the physical adequacy of these arrival-time proposals. In contrast, the quantum flux distribution (a special case of the Bohmian arrival-time distribution) displays the expected behavior.