Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2501.08432 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Energy density and stress fields in quantum systems

Richard M. Martin, N. Chetty, Dallas R. Trinkle

Published Nov 13, 2025• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

There has been an enduring interest and controversy about whether or not one can define physically meaningful energy density and stress fields, $e(\mathbf{r})$ and ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\beta}}(\mathbf{r})$, in quantum systems. A key issue is the kinetic energy since the well-known forms, $\frac{1}{2}{|\mathbf{\ensuremath{\nabla}}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Psi}}|}^{2}$ and $\ensuremath{-}\frac{1}{2}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Psi}}{\ensuremath{\nabla}}^{2}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Psi}}$, lead to different densities, and analogous issues arise for interaction energy terms. This paper considers the ground state of a system of many interacting particles in an external potential, and presents a resolution to the problems in steps. (1) For the kinetic energy all effects of exchange and correlation are shown to be unique functions defined at each point $\mathbf{r}$; all issues of nonuniqueness are relegated to terms that involve only the density $n(\mathbf{r})$ and are equivalent to an effective single-particle problem with ground state wave function $s(\mathbf{r})=\sqrt{n(\mathbf{r})/N}$. (2) Interactions can be considered in two ways: in terms of potentials acting on particles or in terms of the interaction fields, e.g., the Maxwell form in terms of electric fields. In each case, the problem reduces to a mean field part that is a function of the density and a part due to correlation that is uniquely defined; however, it is different for the two cases. (3) The final results follow from the nature of energy and stress. Because the energy determines the ground state itself through the variational principle, the energy density approach leads directly to kinetic energy in the form $\ensuremath{-}\frac{1}{2}s{\ensuremath{\nabla}}^{2}s$ and interactions in terms of potentials acting on the particles. This leads naturally to density functional theory and provides an interpretation in which the energy density $e(\mathbf{r})$ is equilibrated to minimize fluctuations with the same chemical potential at all points $\mathbf{r}$. On the other hand, stress is related to forces, and the only physically acceptable expressions for the stress field involve the combination $\frac{1}{2}[s{\ensuremath{\nabla}}^{2}s\ensuremath{-}{|\mathbf{\ensuremath{\nabla}}s|}^{2}]$, as derived by Schr\"odinger, Pauli, and others, and Coulomb interactions in terms of electric fields, not potentials. Together these results lead to well-defined formulations of energy density and stress fields that are physically motivated and based on a clear set of arguments.

DOI
10.1103/49lf-cbyk

Related papers

Energy of many-particle quantum states

Purnima Ghale, Harley T. Johnson

We derive a functional form for the energy of interacting many-particle systems from first principles. Our main contribution is that we define the effective zero-point energy of an interacting system in terms of fluctuations of momentum and the Coulomb electric field. An uncertainty equation can be derived, relating the interaction energy in terms of the kinetic energy and local charge density. The Lieb-Thirring bound is then applied to constrain the kinetic energy which takes particle (anti-)symmetry into account, and the resulting functional form applies to fermionic as well as bosonic systems; in the uniform density case, the functional form agrees with the entire range of available Quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) data of many-particle systems, to within chemical accuracy. Furthermore, the functional form shows promising agreement with QMC phase transition data found in the literature, and in the high density case, where QMC data is not as readily available for a BCC Wigner state, predicts the stability of a BCC Wigner crystal agreeing qualitatively with Unrestricted Hartree-Fock. Seen in this way, many-particle wavefunctions are minimum uncertainty states in coherence with the electromagnetic bath, where the coupling is a self-generated scalar potential.

arXiv:2010.01656•Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Oct 4, 2020•0 citations

Ground state energy in the external field and the problem of density functional approximations

Viktor Borisovich Bobrov, S. A. Trigger

Based on the Schrodinger equation, exact expressions for the non-relativistic particle energy in the local external field and the external field potential are derived as inhomogeneous density functionals. On this basis, it is shown that, when considering more than two noninteracting electrons, the energy of such a system cannot be an inhomogeneous density functional. The result is extended for the system of interacting electrons. This means that the Hohenberg-Kohn lemma which assert that in the ground state to each inhomogeneous density corresponds only one potential of the external field cannot be a justification of the existence of the universal density functional in the general case. At the same time, statements of the density functional theory remain valid when considering any number of noninteracting ground-state bosons due to the Bose condensation effect.

arXiv:1201.3222•Jan 16, 2012•0 citations

Fermi and Bose pressures in statistical mechanics

Loyal Durand

I show how the pressure in Fermi and Bose systems, identified in standard discussions of quantum statistical mechanics by the use of thermodynamic analogies, can be derived directly in terms of the flux of momentum across a surface by using the quantum mechanical stress tensor. In this approach, which is analogous to classical kinetic theory, the pressure is naturally defined locally. The approach leads to a simple interpretation of the pressure in terms of the momentum flow encoded in the wave functions. The stress-tensor and thermodynamic approaches are related by an interesting application of boundary perturbation theory for quantum systems. I investigate the properties of quasi-continuous systems, the relations for Fermi and Bose pressures, shape-dependent effects and anisotropies, and the treatment of particles in external fields, and note several interesting problems for graduate courses in statistical mechanics.

arXiv:physics/0307118•American Journal of Physics•Jul 14, 2004•5 citations

A General Minimum Principle for Correlated Densities in Quantum Many-Particle Systems

A. Gonis, T. C. Schulthess, Jan van Ek +1 more

It is shown that interacting many-particle quantum systems can be described in terms of fully correlated $n$-particle densities, which determine uniquely the potential acting on the system and satisfy a minimum principle with respect to the ground-state energy. This leads to a generalization of ordinary density functional theory in terms of $n$-particle densities which allows the direct and self-consistent treatment of correlation effects within electronic structure methods for atoms, molecules, and solids.

Physical Review Letters•Sep 30, 1996•66 citations

Quantum Bound and Classical Statistical Interactions and a Constant "Energy" in Space

Francesco R. Ruggeri

Both quantum bound state equilibrium and classical statistical mechanical equilibrium are characterized by d/dt partial density(x,t)=0. For a quantum particle, W(x,t)=exp(-iEt)W(x) and d(x,t)=W*W. Density is linked to fluid flow and arguments of pressure balance such that the overall average fluid flow is zero are made. This pressure-force balance is common in classical statistical mechanics and used to calculate the variation of density with x i.e. obtain a differential equation with d d(x,t) /dt partial. A similar balance equation is used in (1) as the authors try to derive the Schrodinger equation using a fluid dynamical approach. In this note, we try to argue that one may think of the two equilibria in terms of an energy quantity which remains constant throughout space. This energy quantity depends directly on the type of interactions in the system at any point x. For a classical ideal gas, balanced two body time reversal scattering represents the interaction. V(x), a potential, does not change this fundamental manner of interacting at any given point, although it does affect density. As a result the energy related constant at each x is T, related to average kinetic energy. We argue that this already points to the dominant type of interaction creating the statistical interaction i.e. one that depends only on p in interactions which conserve kinetic energy. This “happens” to be equivalent to maximizing Shannon’s entropy, but we argue this is particular to this scenario in the sense that not all interacting systems will have this equivalence. In other words, we argue that one must be careful with regards to the maximization of entropy as a fundamental rule. In particular, we consider the single particle bound quantum state. The interaction exists between the particle and the potential V(x), but one may consider a distribution of free particle momentum probabilities i.e W(x)=wavefunction = Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx). The form exp(ipx) comes from separate arguments as is discussed in the note, but the point is that there are no two body scattering reactions occurring at a given x, neither is there acceleration from on x to another (except for a vrms mathematical quantity). Nevertheless the “free particle” exp(ipx) interacts at each x with V(x). As a result of this interaction, one has free particles exp(ipx) which are no longer associated with pp/2m, but rather with an Eave which is a constant for every p. In other words the identity of exp(ipx) is unusual because it is linked to exp(ipx) and pp/2m, but also to Vk1 a(p-k1), Vk2 a(p-k2) etc where V(x)=Sum over k Vk exp(ikx). Thus each x point is associated with a constant Eave and this defines the equilibrium. (It is also equivalent to conservation of energy at each x.) In such a case, one does not maximize entropy to find a(p) values. In the two cases, the common point seems to be considering the interactions at each x and finding a constant “energy” type quantity which does not vary with x. This we argue appears to define equilibrium for both the classical statistical and quantum bound states. Instead of considering density which does not change in time at each x, there is constant energy which not only does not change in time, but has a constant value at each x which seems to be an alternative rule.

•Feb 14, 2022•0 citations

Quantum Embedding Theories

Qiming Sun, Garnet Kin-Lic Chan

In complex systems, it is often the case that the region of interest forms only one part of a much larger system. The idea of joining two different quantum simulations-a high level calculation on the active region of interest, and a low level calculation on its environment-formally defines a quantum embedding. While any combination of techniques constitutes an embedding, several rigorous formalisms have emerged that provide for exact feedback between the embedded system and its environment. These three formulations: density functional embedding, Green's function embedding, and density matrix embedding, respectively, use the single-particle density, single-particle Green's function, and single-particle density matrix as the quantum variables of interest. Many excellent reviews exist covering these methods individually. However, a unified presentation of the different formalisms is so far lacking. Indeed, the various languages commonly used, functional equations for density functional embedding, diagrammatics for Green's function embedding, and entanglement arguments for density matrix embedding, make the three formulations appear vastly different. In this Account, we introduce the basic equations of all three formulations in such a way as to highlight their many common intellectual strands. While we focus primarily on a straightforward theoretical perspective, we also give a brief overview of recent applications and possible future developments. The first section starts with density functional embedding, where we introduce the key embedding potential via the Euler equation. We then discuss recent work concerning the treatment of the nonadditive kinetic potential, before describing mean-field density functional embedding and wave function in density functional embedding. We finish the section with extensions to time-dependence and excited states. The second section is devoted to Green's function embedding. Here, we use the Dyson equation to obtain equations that parallel as closely as possible the density functional embedding equations, with the hybridization playing the role of the embedding potential. Embedding a high-level self-energy within a low-level self-energy is treated analogously to wave function in density functional embedding. The numerical computation of the high-level self-energy allows us to briefly introduce the bath representation in the quantum impurity problem. We then consider translationally invariant systems to bring in the important dynamical mean-field theory. Recent developments to incorporate screening and long-range interactions are discussed. The third section concerns density matrix embedding. Here, we first highlight some mathematical complications associated with a simple Euler equation derivation, arising from the open nature of fragments. This motivates the density matrix embedding theory, where we use the Schmidt decomposition to represent the entanglement through bath orbitals. The resulting impurity plus bath formulation resembles that of dynamical mean-field theory. We discuss the numerical self-consistency associated with using a high-level correlated wave function with a mean-field low-level treatment, and connect the resulting numerical inversion to that used in density functional embedding. We finish with perspectives on the future of all three methods.

arXiv:1612.02576•Accounts of Chemical Research•Nov 7, 2016•340 citations
There has been an enduring interest and controversy about whether or not one can define physically meaningful energy density and stress fields, e(r)e(\mathbf{r})e(r) and \ensuremathσ\ensuremathα\ensuremathβ(r){\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\beta}}(\mathbf{r})\ensuremathσ\ensuremathα\ensuremathβ​(r), in quantum systems. A key issue is the kinetic energy since the well-known forms, 12∣\ensuremath∇\ensuremathΨ∣2\frac{1}{2}{|\mathbf{\ensuremath{\nabla}}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Psi}}|}^{2}21​∣\ensuremath∇\ensuremathΨ∣2 and \ensuremath−12\ensuremathΨ\ensuremath∇2\ensuremathΨ\ensuremath{-}\frac{1}{2}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Psi}}{\ensuremath{\nabla}}^{2}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Psi}}\ensuremath−21​\ensuremathΨ\ensuremath∇2\ensuremathΨ, lead to different densities, and analogous issues arise for interaction energy terms. This paper considers the ground state of a system of many interacting particles in an external potential, and presents a resolution to the problems in steps. (1) For the kinetic energy all effects of exchange and correlation are shown to be unique functions defined at each point r\mathbf{r}r; all issues of nonuniqueness are relegated to terms that involve only the density n(r)n(\mathbf{r})n(r) and are equivalent to an effective single-particle problem with ground state wave function s(r)=n(r)/Ns(\mathbf{r})=\sqrt{n(\mathbf{r})/N}s(r)=n(r)/N​. (2) Interactions can be considered in two ways: in terms of potentials acting on particles or in terms of the interaction fields, e.g., the Maxwell form in terms of electric fields. In each case, the problem reduces to a mean field part that is a function of the density and a part due to correlation that is uniquely defined; however, it is different for the two cases. (3) The final results follow from the nature of energy and stress. Because the energy determines the ground state itself through the variational principle, the energy density approach leads directly to kinetic energy in the form \ensuremath−12s\ensuremath∇2s\ensuremath{-}\frac{1}{2}s{\ensuremath{\nabla}}^{2}s\ensuremath−21​s\ensuremath∇2s and interactions in terms of potentials acting on the particles. This leads naturally to density functional theory and provides an interpretation in which the energy density e(r)e(\mathbf{r})e(r) is equilibrated to minimize fluctuations with the same chemical potential at all points r\mathbf{r}r. On the other hand, stress is related to forces, and the only physically acceptable expressions for the stress field involve the combination 12[s\ensuremath∇2s\ensuremath−∣\ensuremath∇s∣2]\frac{1}{2}[s{\ensuremath{\nabla}}^{2}s\ensuremath{-}{|\mathbf{\ensuremath{\nabla}}s|}^{2}]21​[s\ensuremath∇2s\ensuremath−∣\ensuremath∇s∣2], as derived by Schr"odinger, Pauli, and others, and Coulomb interactions in terms of electric fields, not potentials. Together these results lead to well-defined formulations of energy density and stress fields that are physically motivated and based on a clear set of arguments.
We derive a functional form for the energy of interacting many-particle systems from first principles. Our main contribution is that we define the effective zero-point energy of an interacting system in terms of fluctuations of momentum and the Coulomb electric field. An uncertainty equation can be derived, relating the interaction energy in terms of the kinetic energy and local charge density. The Lieb-Thirring bound is then applied to constrain the kinetic energy which takes particle (anti-)symmetry into account, and the resulting functional form applies to fermionic as well as bosonic systems; in the uniform density case, the functional form agrees with the entire range of available Quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) data of many-particle systems, to within chemical accuracy. Furthermore, the functional form shows promising agreement with QMC phase transition data found in the literature, and in the high density case, where QMC data is not as readily available for a BCC Wigner state, predicts the stability of a BCC Wigner crystal agreeing qualitatively with Unrestricted Hartree-Fock. Seen in this way, many-particle wavefunctions are minimum uncertainty states in coherence with the electromagnetic bath, where the coupling is a self-generated scalar potential.
Based on the Schrodinger equation, exact expressions for the non-relativistic particle energy in the local external field and the external field potential are derived as inhomogeneous density functionals. On this basis, it is shown that, when considering more than two noninteracting electrons, the energy of such a system cannot be an inhomogeneous density functional. The result is extended for the system of interacting electrons. This means that the Hohenberg-Kohn lemma which assert that in the ground state to each inhomogeneous density corresponds only one potential of the external field cannot be a justification of the existence of the universal density functional in the general case. At the same time, statements of the density functional theory remain valid when considering any number of noninteracting ground-state bosons due to the Bose condensation effect.
I show how the pressure in Fermi and Bose systems, identified in standard discussions of quantum statistical mechanics by the use of thermodynamic analogies, can be derived directly in terms of the flux of momentum across a surface by using the quantum mechanical stress tensor. In this approach, which is analogous to classical kinetic theory, the pressure is naturally defined locally. The approach leads to a simple interpretation of the pressure in terms of the momentum flow encoded in the wave functions. The stress-tensor and thermodynamic approaches are related by an interesting application of boundary perturbation theory for quantum systems. I investigate the properties of quasi-continuous systems, the relations for Fermi and Bose pressures, shape-dependent effects and anisotropies, and the treatment of particles in external fields, and note several interesting problems for graduate courses in statistical mechanics.
It is shown that interacting many-particle quantum systems can be described in terms of fully correlated nnn-particle densities, which determine uniquely the potential acting on the system and satisfy a minimum principle with respect to the ground-state energy. This leads to a generalization of ordinary density functional theory in terms of nnn-particle densities which allows the direct and self-consistent treatment of correlation effects within electronic structure methods for atoms, molecules, and solids.
Both quantum bound state equilibrium and classical statistical mechanical equilibrium are characterized by d/dt partial density(x,t)=0. For a quantum particle, W(x,t)=exp(-iEt)W(x) and d(x,t)=W*W. Density is linked to fluid flow and arguments of pressure balance such that the overall average fluid flow is zero are made. This pressure-force balance is common in classical statistical mechanics and used to calculate the variation of density with x i.e. obtain a differential equation with d d(x,t) /dt partial. A similar balance equation is used in (1) as the authors try to derive the Schrodinger equation using a fluid dynamical approach. In this note, we try to argue that one may think of the two equilibria in terms of an energy quantity which remains constant throughout space. This energy quantity depends directly on the type of interactions in the system at any point x. For a classical ideal gas, balanced two body time reversal scattering represents the interaction. V(x), a potential, does not change this fundamental manner of interacting at any given point, although it does affect density. As a result the energy related constant at each x is T, related to average kinetic energy. We argue that this already points to the dominant type of interaction creating the statistical interaction i.e. one that depends only on p in interactions which conserve kinetic energy. This “happens” to be equivalent to maximizing Shannon’s entropy, but we argue this is particular to this scenario in the sense that not all interacting systems will have this equivalence. In other words, we argue that one must be careful with regards to the maximization of entropy as a fundamental rule. In particular, we consider the single particle bound quantum state. The interaction exists between the particle and the potential V(x), but one may consider a distribution of free particle momentum probabilities i.e W(x)=wavefunction = Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx). The form exp(ipx) comes from separate arguments as is discussed in the note, but the point is that there are no two body scattering reactions occurring at a given x, neither is there acceleration from on x to another (except for a vrms mathematical quantity). Nevertheless the “free particle” exp(ipx) interacts at each x with V(x). As a result of this interaction, one has free particles exp(ipx) which are no longer associated with pp/2m, but rather with an Eave which is a constant for every p. In other words the identity of exp(ipx) is unusual because it is linked to exp(ipx) and pp/2m, but also to Vk1 a(p-k1), Vk2 a(p-k2) etc where V(x)=Sum over k Vk exp(ikx). Thus each x point is associated with a constant Eave and this defines the equilibrium. (It is also equivalent to conservation of energy at each x.) In such a case, one does not maximize entropy to find a(p) values. In the two cases, the common point seems to be considering the interactions at each x and finding a constant “energy” type quantity which does not vary with x. This we argue appears to define equilibrium for both the classical statistical and quantum bound states. Instead of considering density which does not change in time at each x, there is constant energy which not only does not change in time, but has a constant value at each x which seems to be an alternative rule.
In complex systems, it is often the case that the region of interest forms only one part of a much larger system. The idea of joining two different quantum simulations-a high level calculation on the active region of interest, and a low level calculation on its environment-formally defines a quantum embedding. While any combination of techniques constitutes an embedding, several rigorous formalisms have emerged that provide for exact feedback between the embedded system and its environment. These three formulations: density functional embedding, Green's function embedding, and density matrix embedding, respectively, use the single-particle density, single-particle Green's function, and single-particle density matrix as the quantum variables of interest. Many excellent reviews exist covering these methods individually. However, a unified presentation of the different formalisms is so far lacking. Indeed, the various languages commonly used, functional equations for density functional embedding, diagrammatics for Green's function embedding, and entanglement arguments for density matrix embedding, make the three formulations appear vastly different. In this Account, we introduce the basic equations of all three formulations in such a way as to highlight their many common intellectual strands. While we focus primarily on a straightforward theoretical perspective, we also give a brief overview of recent applications and possible future developments. The first section starts with density functional embedding, where we introduce the key embedding potential via the Euler equation. We then discuss recent work concerning the treatment of the nonadditive kinetic potential, before describing mean-field density functional embedding and wave function in density functional embedding. We finish the section with extensions to time-dependence and excited states. The second section is devoted to Green's function embedding. Here, we use the Dyson equation to obtain equations that parallel as closely as possible the density functional embedding equations, with the hybridization playing the role of the embedding potential. Embedding a high-level self-energy within a low-level self-energy is treated analogously to wave function in density functional embedding. The numerical computation of the high-level self-energy allows us to briefly introduce the bath representation in the quantum impurity problem. We then consider translationally invariant systems to bring in the important dynamical mean-field theory. Recent developments to incorporate screening and long-range interactions are discussed. The third section concerns density matrix embedding. Here, we first highlight some mathematical complications associated with a simple Euler equation derivation, arising from the open nature of fragments. This motivates the density matrix embedding theory, where we use the Schmidt decomposition to represent the entanglement through bath orbitals. The resulting impurity plus bath formulation resembles that of dynamical mean-field theory. We discuss the numerical self-consistency associated with using a high-level correlated wave function with a mean-field low-level treatment, and connect the resulting numerical inversion to that used in density functional embedding. We finish with perspectives on the future of all three methods.