Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2412.15889 · Quantum

Quantum particle in the wrong box (or: the perils of finite-dimensional approximations)

Felix Fischer, Daniel Klaus Burgarth, Davide Lonigro

Published Jan 27, 2026• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

When numerically simulating the unitary time evolution of an infinite-dimensional quantum system, one is usually led to treat the Hamiltonian H as an "infinite-dimensional matrix" by expressing it in some orthonormal basis of the Hilbert space, and then truncate it to some finite dimensions. However, the solutions of the Schrödinger equations generated by the truncated Hamiltonians need not converge, in general, to the solution of the Schrödinger equation corresponding to the actual Hamiltonian.In this paper we demonstrate that, under mild assumptions, they converge to the solution of the Schrödinger equation generated by a specific Hamiltonian which crucially depends on the particular choice of basis: the Friedrichs extension of the restriction of H to the space of finite linear combinations of elements of the basis. Importantly, this is generally different from H itself; in all such cases, numerical simulations will unavoidably reproduce the wrong dynamics in the limit, and yet there is no numerical test that can reveal this failure, unless one has the analytical solution to compare with.As a practical demonstration of such results, we consider the quantum particle in the box, and we show that, for a wide class of bases (which include associated Legendre polynomials as a concrete example) the dynamics generated by the truncated Hamiltonians will always converge to the one corresponding to the particle with Dirichlet boundary conditions, regardless the initial choice of boundary conditions. Other such examples are discussed.

DOI
10.22331/q-2026-01-27-1985

Related papers

Spatial Discretization Error for Quantum Chemistry Simulation

Di Fang, Jiaqi Zhang

Nonrelativistic quantum chemistry is based on the Schrödinger equation in continuous, unbounded space. Computational approaches on classical and quantum computers often truncate the spatial domain and introduce a finite-dimensional basis, reducing the continuum problem to a finite-dimensional one. There is therefore a fundamental question: to what extent does this approximation capture the original continuum problem? In this work, we develop a general Sobolev-Galerkin framework for estimating spatial discretization errors in quantum simulation with unbounded Hamiltonians. We apply this framework to many-body Coulomb systems and establish both periodization and Galerkin error estimates for wave-function dynamics and ground-state energies. For dynamics, the finite-basis projection error of the exact wave function does not capture the full basis-discretization error: an additional dynamical projection error enters our bound at a different rate, and we introduce an inner-product argument to control this contribution. Interestingly, the spatial convergence rates for wave-function dynamics and ground-state energies differ quantitatively. For ground-state energies, we establish a sharp $M^{-1}$ convergence rate at fixed cell size, where $M$ is the number of one-particle basis functions. We also show that a uniform $M^{-1}$ convergence rate is impossible for the corresponding real-time wave-function error with general $H^2$ initial data. The analysis relies on many-body Sobolev estimates with explicit polynomial dependence on system size. Combining these estimates with state-of-the-art quantum algorithms, we obtain, to our knowledge, the first rigorous end-to-end complexity bounds for quantum simulation of molecular and electronic dynamics with all spatial errors explicitly controlled. The number of basis functions is determined directly from the continuum problem, without regularization.

quant-pharXiv:2610.25260•Oct 20, 2026•1 citation

Infinite-dimensional Extension of the Linear Combination of Hamiltonian Simulation: Theorems and Applications

Lu, Rundi, Hao-En Li, Zhengwei Liu +1 more

We generalize the Linear Combination of Hamiltonian Simulation (LCHS) formula [An, Liu, Lin, Phys. Rev. Lett. 2023] to simulate time-evolution operators in infinite-dimensional spaces, including scenarios involving unbounded operators. This extension, named Inf-LCHS for short, bridges the gap between finite-dimensional quantum simulations and the broader class of infinite-dimensional quantum dynamics governed by partial differential equations (PDEs). Furthermore, we propose two sampling methods by integrating the infinite-dimensional LCHS with Gaussian quadrature schemes (Inf-LCHS-Gaussian) or Monte Carlo integration schemes (Inf-LCHS-MC). We demonstrate the applicability of the Inf-LCHS theorem to a wide range of non-Hermitian dynamics, including linear parabolic PDEs, queueing models (birth-or-death processes), Schrödinger equations with complex potentials, Lindblad equations, and black hole thermal field equations. Our analysis provides insights into simulating general linear dynamics using a finite number of quantum dynamics and includes cost estimates for the corresponding quantum algorithms.

arXiv:2502.19688•Feb 27, 2025•14 citations

Reliability of one-dimensional Dirichlet wave functions

Marco A. Núñez

It has been recently proven that the bound states of the one-dimensional Schr\"odinger equation H${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}^{(\mathit{i})}$=${\mathit{E}}^{(\mathit{i})}$${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}^{(\mathit{i})}$ in [0,\ensuremath{\infty}) can be approximated by those of the corresponding Dirichlet eigenproblem ${\mathit{H}}_{\mathit{R}}$${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}_{\mathit{R}}^{(\mathit{i})}$=${\mathit{E}}_{\mathit{R}}^{(\mathit{i})}$${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}_{\mathit{R}}^{(\mathit{i})}$ in a finite box [0,R] when R\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}. In this paper, we use a set of mathematical criteria that guarantee the correct calculation of expectation values in the frame of Hilbert spaces, to show that correct expectation values of most physical operators S are obtained by using the equation ${\mathrm{lim}}_{\mathit{R}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\infty}}}$〈${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}_{\mathit{R}}^{(\mathit{i})}$,S${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}_{\mathit{R}}^{(\mathit{j})}$〉= 〈${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}^{(\mathit{i})}$,S${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}^{(\mathit{j})}$〉, which includes operators not relatively form bounded by the Hamiltonian H. It is shown that standard numerical methods supply approximate wave functions ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}_{\mathit{R}\mathit{m}}^{(\mathit{i})}$ for which the equation ${\mathrm{lim}}_{\mathit{m}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\infty}}}$〈${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}_{\mathit{R}\mathit{m}}^{(\mathit{i})}$,S${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}_{\mathit{R}\mathit{m}}^{(\mathit{j})}$〉= 〈${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}_{\mathit{R}}^{(\mathit{i})}$,S${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}_{\mathit{R}}^{(\mathit{j})}$〉 holds true. Thus, combining the previous limits we obtain a general approach to compute correct expectation values. It is shown how this approach agrees with the results found by other authors in special cases. In the particular case of computing approximate wave functions ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}_{\mathit{R}\mathit{m}}^{(\mathit{i})}$ with the Ritz method, we show, analytically and numerically, that correct convergence toward the expectation values of high power of moment operators ${\mathit{r}}^{\mathit{k}}$ holds even when the basis functions have an analytic structure that substantially differs from that of the exact wave function.

Physical Review A•Jun 1, 1995•4 citations

Quantum system compression: A Hamiltonian guided walk through Hilbert space

Robert L. Kosut, Tak‐San Ho, HERSCHEL A. RABITZ

We present a systematic study of quantum system compression for the evolution of generic many-body problems. The necessary numerical simulations of such systems are seriously hindered by the exponential growth of the Hilbert-space dimension with the number of particles. For a constant Hamiltonian system of Hilbert-space dimension $n$ with frequencies ranging from ${f}_{min}$ to ${f}_{max}$, we show via a proper orthogonal decomposition that for a run time $T$ the dominant dynamics are compressed in the neighborhood of a subspace whose dimension is the smallest integer larger than the time-bandwidth product $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}=({f}_{max}\ensuremath{-}{f}_{min})T$. We also show how the distribution of initial states can further compress the system dimension. Under the stated conditions, the time-bandwidth estimate reveals the existence of an effective compressed model whose dimension is derived solely from system properties and not dependent on the particular implementation of a variational simulator, such as a machine learning system, or quantum device, or possibly even specially adapting traditional methods of solving the time-dependent Schr\"odinger equation. However, finding an efficient solution procedure $\mathit{is}$ dependent on the simulator implementation, which is not discussed in this paper. In addition, we show that the compression rendered by the proper orthogonal decomposition encoding method can be further strengthened via a multilayer autoencoder. Finally, we present numerical illustrations to affirm the compression behavior in time-varying Hamiltonian dynamics in the presence of external fields. The essential time-bandwidth product is also simply estimated for a wide class of physical systems, where typically localized high-frequency motion occurs at or around each of the many particles, and with low-frequency dynamics associated with globally distributed characteristic degrees of freedom. This estimate for the bandwidth has a generic character indicating the wide significance of expected quantum system dynamics compression. We also discuss the potential implications of the findings for machine learning tools to efficiently solve the many-body or other high-dimensional Schr\"odinger equations.

arXiv:2006.13498•Physical Review A•Jan 12, 2021•5 citations

On the Exact Solution for the Schrödinger Equation

Yair Mulian

For almost 75 years, the general solution for the Schrödinger equation was assumed to be generated by an exponential or a time-ordered exponential known as the Dyson series. We study the unitarity of a solution in the case of a singular Hamiltonian and provide a new methodology that is not based on the assumption that the underlying space is L2(R). Then, an alternative operator for generating the time evolution that is manifestly unitary is suggested, regardless of the choice of Hamiltonian. The new construction involves an additional positive operator that normalizes the wave function locally and allows us to preserve unitarity, even when dealing with infinite dimensional or non-normed spaces. Our considerations show that Schrödinger and Liouville equations are, in fact, two sides of the same coin and together they provide a unified description for unbounded quantum systems.

arXiv:2402.18499•Particles•Dec 12, 2024•2 citations

Extended weak coupling limit for Friedrichs Hamiltonians

Jan Dereziński, Wojciech De Roeck

We study a class of self-adjoint operators defined on the direct sum of two Hilbert spaces: a finite dimensional one called sometimes a “small subsystem” and an infinite dimensional one called a “reservoir.” The operator, which we call a “Friedrichs Hamiltonian,” has a small coupling constant in front of its off-diagonal term. It is well known that under some conditions in the weak coupling limit the appropriately rescaled evolution in the interaction picture converges to a contractive semigroup when restricted to the subsystem. We show that in this model, the properly renormalized and rescaled evolution converges on the whole space to a new unitary evolution, which is a dilation of the above mentioned semigroup. Similar results have been studied before (Accardi et al., 1990) in more complicated models under the name of “stochastic limit.”

arXiv:math-ph/0604058•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jan 1, 2007•6 citations
When numerically simulating the unitary time evolution of an infinite-dimensional quantum system, one is usually led to treat the Hamiltonian H as an "infinite-dimensional matrix" by expressing it in some orthonormal basis of the Hilbert space, and then truncate it to some finite dimensions. However, the solutions of the Schrödinger equations generated by the truncated Hamiltonians need not converge, in general, to the solution of the Schrödinger equation corresponding to the actual Hamiltonian.In this paper we demonstrate that, under mild assumptions, they converge to the solution of the Schrödinger equation generated by a specific Hamiltonian which crucially depends on the particular choice of basis: the Friedrichs extension of the restriction of H to the space of finite linear combinations of elements of the basis. Importantly, this is generally different from H itself; in all such cases, numerical simulations will unavoidably reproduce the wrong dynamics in the limit, and yet there is no numerical test that can reveal this failure, unless one has the analytical solution to compare with.As a practical demonstration of such results, we consider the quantum particle in the box, and we show that, for a wide class of bases (which include associated Legendre polynomials as a concrete example) the dynamics generated by the truncated Hamiltonians will always converge to the one corresponding to the particle with Dirichlet boundary conditions, regardless the initial choice of boundary conditions. Other such examples are discussed.
Nonrelativistic quantum chemistry is based on the Schrödinger equation in continuous, unbounded space. Computational approaches on classical and quantum computers often truncate the spatial domain and introduce a finite-dimensional basis, reducing the continuum problem to a finite-dimensional one. There is therefore a fundamental question: to what extent does this approximation capture the original continuum problem? In this work, we develop a general Sobolev-Galerkin framework for estimating spatial discretization errors in quantum simulation with unbounded Hamiltonians. We apply this framework to many-body Coulomb systems and establish both periodization and Galerkin error estimates for wave-function dynamics and ground-state energies. For dynamics, the finite-basis projection error of the exact wave function does not capture the full basis-discretization error: an additional dynamical projection error enters our bound at a different rate, and we introduce an inner-product argument to control this contribution. Interestingly, the spatial convergence rates for wave-function dynamics and ground-state energies differ quantitatively. For ground-state energies, we establish a sharp M−1M^{-1}M−1 convergence rate at fixed cell size, where MMM is the number of one-particle basis functions. We also show that a uniform M−1M^{-1}M−1 convergence rate is impossible for the corresponding real-time wave-function error with general H2H^2H2 initial data. The analysis relies on many-body Sobolev estimates with explicit polynomial dependence on system size. Combining these estimates with state-of-the-art quantum algorithms, we obtain, to our knowledge, the first rigorous end-to-end complexity bounds for quantum simulation of molecular and electronic dynamics with all spatial errors explicitly controlled. The number of basis functions is determined directly from the continuum problem, without regularization.
We generalize the Linear Combination of Hamiltonian Simulation (LCHS) formula [An, Liu, Lin, Phys. Rev. Lett. 2023] to simulate time-evolution operators in infinite-dimensional spaces, including scenarios involving unbounded operators. This extension, named Inf-LCHS for short, bridges the gap between finite-dimensional quantum simulations and the broader class of infinite-dimensional quantum dynamics governed by partial differential equations (PDEs). Furthermore, we propose two sampling methods by integrating the infinite-dimensional LCHS with Gaussian quadrature schemes (Inf-LCHS-Gaussian) or Monte Carlo integration schemes (Inf-LCHS-MC). We demonstrate the applicability of the Inf-LCHS theorem to a wide range of non-Hermitian dynamics, including linear parabolic PDEs, queueing models (birth-or-death processes), Schrödinger equations with complex potentials, Lindblad equations, and black hole thermal field equations. Our analysis provides insights into simulating general linear dynamics using a finite number of quantum dynamics and includes cost estimates for the corresponding quantum algorithms.
It has been recently proven that the bound states of the one-dimensional Schr\"odinger equation H${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}^{(\mathit{i})}$=E(i){\mathit{E}}^{(\mathit{i})}E(i)${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}^{(\mathit{i})}$ in [0,\ensuremath{\infty}) can be approximated by those of the corresponding Dirichlet eigenproblem HR{\mathit{H}}_{\mathit{R}}HR​${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}_{\mathit{R}}^{(\mathit{i})}$=ER(i){\mathit{E}}_{\mathit{R}}^{(\mathit{i})}ER(i)​${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}_{\mathit{R}}^{(\mathit{i})}$ in a finite box [0,R] when R\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}. In this paper, we use a set of mathematical criteria that guarantee the correct calculation of expectation values in the frame of Hilbert spaces, to show that correct expectation values of most physical operators S are obtained by using the equation ${\mathrm{lim}}_{\mathit{R}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\infty}}}$〈${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}_{\mathit{R}}^{(\mathit{i})}$,S${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}_{\mathit{R}}^{(\mathit{j})}$〉= 〈${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}^{(\mathit{i})}$,S${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}^{(\mathit{j})}$〉, which includes operators not relatively form bounded by the Hamiltonian H. It is shown that standard numerical methods supply approximate wave functions ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}_{\mathit{R}\mathit{m}}^{(\mathit{i})}$ for which the equation ${\mathrm{lim}}_{\mathit{m}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\mathrm{\ensuremath{\infty}}}$〈${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}_{\mathit{R}\mathit{m}}^{(\mathit{i})}$,S${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}_{\mathit{R}\mathit{m}}^{(\mathit{j})}$〉= 〈${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}_{\mathit{R}}^{(\mathit{i})}$,S${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}_{\mathit{R}}^{(\mathit{j})}$〉 holds true. Thus, combining the previous limits we obtain a general approach to compute correct expectation values. It is shown how this approach agrees with the results found by other authors in special cases. In the particular case of computing approximate wave functions ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\psi}}}_{\mathit{R}\mathit{m}}^{(\mathit{i})}$ with the Ritz method, we show, analytically and numerically, that correct convergence toward the expectation values of high power of moment operators rk{\mathit{r}}^{\mathit{k}}rk holds even when the basis functions have an analytic structure that substantially differs from that of the exact wave function.
We present a systematic study of quantum system compression for the evolution of generic many-body problems. The necessary numerical simulations of such systems are seriously hindered by the exponential growth of the Hilbert-space dimension with the number of particles. For a constant Hamiltonian system of Hilbert-space dimension nnn with frequencies ranging from fmin{f}_{min}fmin​ to fmax{f}_{max}fmax​, we show via a proper orthogonal decomposition that for a run time TTT the dominant dynamics are compressed in the neighborhood of a subspace whose dimension is the smallest integer larger than the time-bandwidth product $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}=({f}_{max}\ensuremath{-}{f}_{min})T$. We also show how the distribution of initial states can further compress the system dimension. Under the stated conditions, the time-bandwidth estimate reveals the existence of an effective compressed model whose dimension is derived solely from system properties and not dependent on the particular implementation of a variational simulator, such as a machine learning system, or quantum device, or possibly even specially adapting traditional methods of solving the time-dependent Schr\"odinger equation. However, finding an efficient solution procedure is\mathit{is}is dependent on the simulator implementation, which is not discussed in this paper. In addition, we show that the compression rendered by the proper orthogonal decomposition encoding method can be further strengthened via a multilayer autoencoder. Finally, we present numerical illustrations to affirm the compression behavior in time-varying Hamiltonian dynamics in the presence of external fields. The essential time-bandwidth product is also simply estimated for a wide class of physical systems, where typically localized high-frequency motion occurs at or around each of the many particles, and with low-frequency dynamics associated with globally distributed characteristic degrees of freedom. This estimate for the bandwidth has a generic character indicating the wide significance of expected quantum system dynamics compression. We also discuss the potential implications of the findings for machine learning tools to efficiently solve the many-body or other high-dimensional Schr\"odinger equations.
For almost 75 years, the general solution for the Schrödinger equation was assumed to be generated by an exponential or a time-ordered exponential known as the Dyson series. We study the unitarity of a solution in the case of a singular Hamiltonian and provide a new methodology that is not based on the assumption that the underlying space is L2(R). Then, an alternative operator for generating the time evolution that is manifestly unitary is suggested, regardless of the choice of Hamiltonian. The new construction involves an additional positive operator that normalizes the wave function locally and allows us to preserve unitarity, even when dealing with infinite dimensional or non-normed spaces. Our considerations show that Schrödinger and Liouville equations are, in fact, two sides of the same coin and together they provide a unified description for unbounded quantum systems.
We study a class of self-adjoint operators defined on the direct sum of two Hilbert spaces: a finite dimensional one called sometimes a “small subsystem” and an infinite dimensional one called a “reservoir.” The operator, which we call a “Friedrichs Hamiltonian,” has a small coupling constant in front of its off-diagonal term. It is well known that under some conditions in the weak coupling limit the appropriately rescaled evolution in the interaction picture converges to a contractive semigroup when restricted to the subsystem. We show that in this model, the properly renormalized and rescaled evolution converges on the whole space to a new unitary evolution, which is a dilation of the above mentioned semigroup. Similar results have been studied before (Accardi et al., 1990) in more complicated models under the name of “stochastic limit.”