Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2412.11382 · Nature Communications

Angle-tuned Gross-Neveu quantum criticality in twisted bilayer graphene

Cheng Huang, Nikolaos Parthenios, Maksim Ulybyshev, Xu Zhang, Fakher F. Assaad, Laura Classen, Zi Yang Meng

Published Aug 4, 2025• 25 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The quantum many-body states in twisted bilayer graphene at magic angle have been well understood both experimentally and theoretically. However, the phase diagram and excitations versus twist angle and permittivity are still largely unknown. Here, via a state-of-the-art momentum-space continuous-field quantum Monte Carlo method fully taking into account long-ranged Coulomb interactions and flat bands’ quantum metrics with system sizes up to 15 × 15, we show that charge-neutral twisted bilayer graphene realizes an angle-tuned quantum phase transition from a Kramers intervalley-coherent insulator to a Dirac semimetal with critical angles around 1.2°. Single-particle spectra demonstrate the evolution of the gap at Γ to touching points at Brillouin zone corners as the angle increases. The free energy and order parameters show that the transition belongs to fermionic Gross-Neveu criticality, and is robust upon varying the permittivity or the interlayer hopping. The phase diagram of twisted bilayer graphene as a function of twist angle remains not fully understood. Here, the authors theoretically demonstrate that it exhibits an angle-tuned quantum critical point of Gross-Neveu type using quantum Monte Carlo.

DOI
10.1038/s41467-025-62461-y

Related papers

Gross-Neveu-XY quantum criticality in moiré Dirac materials

Bilal Hawashin, Michael M. Scherer, Lukas Janssen

Two-dimensional van der Waals materials offer a highly tunable platform for engineering electronic band structures and interactions. By employing techniques such as twisting, gating, or applying pressure, these systems enable precise control over the electronic excitation spectrum. In moir\'e bilayer graphene, the tunability facilitates the transition from a symmetric Dirac semimetal phase through a quantum critical point into an interaction-induced long-range ordered phase with a finite band gap. At charge neutrality, the ordered state proposed to emerge from twist-angle tuning is the Kramers intervalley-coherent insulator. In this case, the transition falls into the quantum universality class of the relativistic Gross-Neveu-XY model in $2+1$ dimensions. Here, we refine estimates for the critical exponents characterizing this universality class using an expansion around the lower critical space-time dimension of two. We compute the order-parameter anomalous dimension ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\ensuremath{\varphi}}$ and the correlation-length exponent $\ensuremath{\nu}$ at one-loop order, and the fermion anomalous dimension ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\ensuremath{\psi}}$ at two-loop order. Combining these results with previous findings from the expansion around the upper critical dimension, we obtain improved estimates for the universal exponents in $2+1$ dimensions via Pad\'e interpolation. For ${N}_{\text{f}}=4$ four-component Dirac fermions, relevant to moir\'e bilayer graphene, we estimate $1/\ensuremath{\nu}=0.916(5), {\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\ensuremath{\varphi}}=0.926(13)$, and ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\ensuremath{\psi}}=0.0404(13)$. For ${N}_{\text{f}}=2$, potentially relevant to recent tetralayer ${\mathrm{WSe}}_{2}$ experiments, the Gross-Neveu-XY fixed point may be unstable owing to a fixed-point collision at ${N}_{\text{f,c}}$, with ${N}_{\text{f,c}}=1+\sqrt{2}+\mathcal{O}(\ensuremath{\epsilon})$ in the expansion around the lower critical dimension.

arXiv:2503.19963•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 21, 2025•12 citations

Fermionic Monte Carlo Study of a Realistic Model of Twisted Bilayer Graphene

Johannes Stephan Hofmann, Eslam Khalaf, Ashvin Vishwanath +2 more

The rich phenomenology of twisted bilayer graphene (TBG) near the magic angle is believed to arise from electron correlations in topological flat bands.An unbiased approach to this problem is highly desirable, but also particularly challenging, given the multiple electron flavors, the topological obstruction to defining tight-binding models, and the long-ranged Coulomb interactions.While numerical simulations of realistic models have thus far been confined to zero temperature, typically excluding some spin or valley species, analytic progress has relied on fixed point models away from the realistic limit.Here, we present unbiased Monte Carlo simulations of realistic models of magic-angle TBG at charge neutrality.We establish the absence of a sign problem for this model in a momentumspace approach and describe a computationally tractable formulation that applies even on breaking chiral symmetry and including band dispersion.Our results include (i) the emergence of an insulating Kramers intervalley coherent ground state in competition with a correlated semimetal phase, (ii) detailed temperature evolution of order parameters and electronic spectral functions that reveal a "pseudogap" regime, in which gap features are established at a higher temperature than the onset of order, and (iii) predictions for electronic tunneling spectra and their evolution with temperature.Our results pave the way towards uncovering the physics of magic-angle graphene through exact simulations of over a hundred electrons across a wide temperature range.

arXiv:2105.12112•Physical Review X•Mar 30, 2022•90 citations

Trion Excitations in Twisted Bilayer Graphene: A Quantum Monte Carlo Study

Shibo Shan, Cheng Huang, Patrick Ledwith +1 more

Determining the nature of charge carriers is a fundamental goal in the study of strongly correlated electron systems. Here, we employ the continuous-field momentum-space quantum Monte Carlo method to reveal exotic "Dirac trion" excitations in the finite-temperature normal state of twisted bilayer graphene. While the ground state is a symmetry-breaking insulator with gapped ($\sim$ 20 meV) electron-like excitations, we show that a small temperature ($\sim$ 3 meV), well below the interaction scale, drives the system into a strongly fluctuating symmetric normal state. We demonstrate that this normal state hosts gapless excitations consisting of three-particle bound states, two electrons and one hole, that are exactly orthogonal to the higher-energy electrons at the zero-momentum gapless point. These Dirac trions have the remarkable property of being arbitrarily light despite being composed of heavy constituents, and their spectra can be easily tuned by varying the twist angle and interlayer hopping strength. Our unbiased quantum many-body computation sheds light on the Dirac trions in a projected correlated flat-band setting and opens the door for further investigation of many-body excitations in strongly correlated topological bands beyond Landau levels.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2607.27745•Jul 31, 2026

Valence Bond Orders at Charge Neutrality in a Possible Two-Orbital Extended Hubbard Model for Twisted Bilayer Graphene

Yuan Da Liao, Zi Yang Meng, Xiao Yan Xu

An extended Hubbard model on a honeycomb lattice with two orbitals per site at charge neutrality is investigated with unbiased large-scale quantum Monte Carlo simulations. The Fermi velocity of the Dirac fermions is renormalized as the cluster charge interaction increases, until a mass term emerges and a quantum phase transition from Dirac semimetal to valence bond solid (VBS) insulator is established. The quantum critical point is discovered to belong to the 3D N=4 Gross-Neveu chiral XY universality with the critical exponents obtained at high precision. Further enhancement of the interaction drives the system into two different VBS phases, the properties and transition between them are also revealed. Since the model is related to magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene, our results may have relevance towards the symmetry breaking order at the charge neutrality point of the material, and associate the wide range of universal strange metal behavior around it with quantum critical fluctuations.

arXiv:1901.11424•Physical Review Letters•Oct 8, 2019•90 citations

Correlation effects in magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene: An auxiliary-field quantum Monte Carlo study

Zhi-Yu Xiao, Shiwei Zhang

Magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene (MATBG) presents a fascinating platform for investigating the effects of electron interactions in topological flat bands. The Bistritzer-MacDonald (BM) model provides a simplified quantitative description of the flat bands. Introducing long-range Coulomb interactions leads to an interacting BM (IBM) Hamiltonian, a momentum-space continuum description which offers a very natural starting point for many-body studies of MATBG. Accurate and reliable many-body computations in the IBM model are challenging, however, and have been limited mostly to special fillings or smaller lattice sizes. We employ a state-of-the-art auxiliary-field quantum Monte Carlo (AFQMC) method to study the IBM model, which constrains the sign problem to enable accurate treatment of large system sizes. We determine ground-state properties and quantify errors compared to mean-field theory calculations. Our calculations identify correlated metal states and their competition with the insulating Kramers intervalley-coherent state at both half-filling and charge neutrality. Additionally, we investigate one- and three-quarter fillings, and examine the effect of many-body corrections beyond single Slater determinant solutions. We discuss the effect that details of the IBM Hamiltonian have on the results, including different forms of double-counting corrections, and the need to establish and precisely specify many-body Hamiltonians to allow more direct and quantitative comparisons with experiments in MATBG.

arXiv:2405.17808•Physical Review Research•Jan 27, 2025•6 citations

Momentum Space Quantum Monte Carlo on Twisted Bilayer Graphene

Xu Zhang, Gaopei Pan, Yi Zhang +2 more

We report an implementation of the momentum space quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) method on the interaction model for the twisted bilayer graphene (TBG). The long-range Coulomb repulsion is treated exactly with the flat bands, spin and valley degrees of freedom of electrons taking into account. We prove the absence of the minus sign problem for QMC simulation when either the two valleys or the two spin degrees of freedom are considered. By taking the realistic parameters of the twist angle and interlayer tunnelings into the simulation, we benchmark the QMC data with the exact band gap obtained at the chiral limit, to reveal the insulating ground states at the charge neutrality point (CNP). Then, with the exact Green’s functions from QMC, we perform stochastic analytic continuation to obtain the first set of single-particle spectral function for the TBG model at CNP. Our momentum space QMC scheme therefore offers the controlled computation pathway for systematic investigation of the electronic states in realistic TBG model at various electron fillings.

arXiv:2105.07010•Chinese Physics Letters•Jul 1, 2021•72 citations
The quantum many-body states in twisted bilayer graphene at magic angle have been well understood both experimentally and theoretically. However, the phase diagram and excitations versus twist angle and permittivity are still largely unknown. Here, via a state-of-the-art momentum-space continuous-field quantum Monte Carlo method fully taking into account long-ranged Coulomb interactions and flat bands’ quantum metrics with system sizes up to 15 × 15, we show that charge-neutral twisted bilayer graphene realizes an angle-tuned quantum phase transition from a Kramers intervalley-coherent insulator to a Dirac semimetal with critical angles around 1.2°. Single-particle spectra demonstrate the evolution of the gap at Γ to touching points at Brillouin zone corners as the angle increases. The free energy and order parameters show that the transition belongs to fermionic Gross-Neveu criticality, and is robust upon varying the permittivity or the interlayer hopping. The phase diagram of twisted bilayer graphene as a function of twist angle remains not fully understood. Here, the authors theoretically demonstrate that it exhibits an angle-tuned quantum critical point of Gross-Neveu type using quantum Monte Carlo.
Two-dimensional van der Waals materials offer a highly tunable platform for engineering electronic band structures and interactions. By employing techniques such as twisting, gating, or applying pressure, these systems enable precise control over the electronic excitation spectrum. In moir\'e bilayer graphene, the tunability facilitates the transition from a symmetric Dirac semimetal phase through a quantum critical point into an interaction-induced long-range ordered phase with a finite band gap. At charge neutrality, the ordered state proposed to emerge from twist-angle tuning is the Kramers intervalley-coherent insulator. In this case, the transition falls into the quantum universality class of the relativistic Gross-Neveu-XY model in 2+12+12+1 dimensions. Here, we refine estimates for the critical exponents characterizing this universality class using an expansion around the lower critical space-time dimension of two. We compute the order-parameter anomalous dimension ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\ensuremath{\varphi}}$ and the correlation-length exponent $\ensuremath{\nu}$ at one-loop order, and the fermion anomalous dimension ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\ensuremath{\psi}}$ at two-loop order. Combining these results with previous findings from the expansion around the upper critical dimension, we obtain improved estimates for the universal exponents in 2+12+12+1 dimensions via Pad\'e interpolation. For Nf=4{N}_{\text{f}}=4Nf​=4 four-component Dirac fermions, relevant to moir\'e bilayer graphene, we estimate $1/\ensuremath{\nu}=0.916(5), {\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\ensuremath{\varphi}}=0.926(13)$, and ${\ensuremath{\eta}}_{\ensuremath{\psi}}=0.0404(13)$. For Nf=2{N}_{\text{f}}=2Nf​=2, potentially relevant to recent tetralayer WSe2{\mathrm{WSe}}_{2}WSe2​ experiments, the Gross-Neveu-XY fixed point may be unstable owing to a fixed-point collision at Nf,c{N}_{\text{f,c}}Nf,c​, with ${N}_{\text{f,c}}=1+\sqrt{2}+\mathcal{O}(\ensuremath{\epsilon})$ in the expansion around the lower critical dimension.
The rich phenomenology of twisted bilayer graphene (TBG) near the magic angle is believed to arise from electron correlations in topological flat bands.An unbiased approach to this problem is highly desirable, but also particularly challenging, given the multiple electron flavors, the topological obstruction to defining tight-binding models, and the long-ranged Coulomb interactions.While numerical simulations of realistic models have thus far been confined to zero temperature, typically excluding some spin or valley species, analytic progress has relied on fixed point models away from the realistic limit.Here, we present unbiased Monte Carlo simulations of realistic models of magic-angle TBG at charge neutrality.We establish the absence of a sign problem for this model in a momentumspace approach and describe a computationally tractable formulation that applies even on breaking chiral symmetry and including band dispersion.Our results include (i) the emergence of an insulating Kramers intervalley coherent ground state in competition with a correlated semimetal phase, (ii) detailed temperature evolution of order parameters and electronic spectral functions that reveal a "pseudogap" regime, in which gap features are established at a higher temperature than the onset of order, and (iii) predictions for electronic tunneling spectra and their evolution with temperature.Our results pave the way towards uncovering the physics of magic-angle graphene through exact simulations of over a hundred electrons across a wide temperature range.
Determining the nature of charge carriers is a fundamental goal in the study of strongly correlated electron systems. Here, we employ the continuous-field momentum-space quantum Monte Carlo method to reveal exotic "Dirac trion" excitations in the finite-temperature normal state of twisted bilayer graphene. While the ground state is a symmetry-breaking insulator with gapped (∼\sim∼ 20 meV) electron-like excitations, we show that a small temperature (∼\sim∼ 3 meV), well below the interaction scale, drives the system into a strongly fluctuating symmetric normal state. We demonstrate that this normal state hosts gapless excitations consisting of three-particle bound states, two electrons and one hole, that are exactly orthogonal to the higher-energy electrons at the zero-momentum gapless point. These Dirac trions have the remarkable property of being arbitrarily light despite being composed of heavy constituents, and their spectra can be easily tuned by varying the twist angle and interlayer hopping strength. Our unbiased quantum many-body computation sheds light on the Dirac trions in a projected correlated flat-band setting and opens the door for further investigation of many-body excitations in strongly correlated topological bands beyond Landau levels.
An extended Hubbard model on a honeycomb lattice with two orbitals per site at charge neutrality is investigated with unbiased large-scale quantum Monte Carlo simulations. The Fermi velocity of the Dirac fermions is renormalized as the cluster charge interaction increases, until a mass term emerges and a quantum phase transition from Dirac semimetal to valence bond solid (VBS) insulator is established. The quantum critical point is discovered to belong to the 3D N=4 Gross-Neveu chiral XY universality with the critical exponents obtained at high precision. Further enhancement of the interaction drives the system into two different VBS phases, the properties and transition between them are also revealed. Since the model is related to magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene, our results may have relevance towards the symmetry breaking order at the charge neutrality point of the material, and associate the wide range of universal strange metal behavior around it with quantum critical fluctuations.
Magic-angle twisted bilayer graphene (MATBG) presents a fascinating platform for investigating the effects of electron interactions in topological flat bands. The Bistritzer-MacDonald (BM) model provides a simplified quantitative description of the flat bands. Introducing long-range Coulomb interactions leads to an interacting BM (IBM) Hamiltonian, a momentum-space continuum description which offers a very natural starting point for many-body studies of MATBG. Accurate and reliable many-body computations in the IBM model are challenging, however, and have been limited mostly to special fillings or smaller lattice sizes. We employ a state-of-the-art auxiliary-field quantum Monte Carlo (AFQMC) method to study the IBM model, which constrains the sign problem to enable accurate treatment of large system sizes. We determine ground-state properties and quantify errors compared to mean-field theory calculations. Our calculations identify correlated metal states and their competition with the insulating Kramers intervalley-coherent state at both half-filling and charge neutrality. Additionally, we investigate one- and three-quarter fillings, and examine the effect of many-body corrections beyond single Slater determinant solutions. We discuss the effect that details of the IBM Hamiltonian have on the results, including different forms of double-counting corrections, and the need to establish and precisely specify many-body Hamiltonians to allow more direct and quantitative comparisons with experiments in MATBG.
We report an implementation of the momentum space quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) method on the interaction model for the twisted bilayer graphene (TBG). The long-range Coulomb repulsion is treated exactly with the flat bands, spin and valley degrees of freedom of electrons taking into account. We prove the absence of the minus sign problem for QMC simulation when either the two valleys or the two spin degrees of freedom are considered. By taking the realistic parameters of the twist angle and interlayer tunnelings into the simulation, we benchmark the QMC data with the exact band gap obtained at the chiral limit, to reveal the insulating ground states at the charge neutrality point (CNP). Then, with the exact Green’s functions from QMC, we perform stochastic analytic continuation to obtain the first set of single-particle spectral function for the TBG model at CNP. Our momentum space QMC scheme therefore offers the controlled computation pathway for systematic investigation of the electronic states in realistic TBG model at various electron fillings.