Contextuality and assessment of guilt
Bartosz W. Wojciechowski
According to the axioms of classical probability theory, a person is in a certain state with respect to certain judgement and cognition at each given instant, and it is possible to assign a probability to a cognitive response with a specific value at each moment. It is established and quantifiable, and its existence may be disclosed. However, there has been evidence of so-called constructive influences in decision-making, whereby a decision appears to alter the underlying mental state. Quantum accounting, unlike classical theory, permits a person to exist in an indeterminate condition, known as a superposition state, at all times. This implies that one cannot assume that psychological states are characterized by specific values that can be recorded by a psychological measurement at every moment. The act of choosing one choice over another, for instance, produces a preference for the selected option. In this chapter, we will discuss the findings of a study conducted on a group of 60 lawyers (judges, prosecutors and attorneys at law) and 30 non-lawyers. We will investigate the positive effect of expressing an intermediate judgement on the suspect’s guilt on the total rating of guilt. With the application of the quantum probability theory, we present a cognitive model that formalizes such a constructive process.
Routledge eBooks•Aug 1, 2023•0 citations