Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2411.04874

Hardness of approximation for ground state problems

Sevag Gharibian, Hecht, Carsten

Published Nov 7, 2024• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

After nearly two decades of research, the question of a quantum PCP theorem for quantum Constraint Satisfaction Problems (CSPs) remains wide open. As a result, proving QMA-hardness of approximation for ground state energy estimation has remained elusive. Recently, it was shown [Bittel, Gharibian, Kliesch, CCC 2023] that a natural problem involving variational quantum circuits is QCMA-hard to approximate within ratio N^(1-eps) for any eps > 0 and N the input size. Unfortunately, this problem was not related to quantum CSPs, leaving the question of hardness of approximation for quantum CSPs open. In this work, we show that if instead of focusing on ground state energies, one considers computing properties of the ground space, QCMA-hardness of computing ground space properties can be shown. In particular, we show that it is (1) QCMA-complete within ratio N^(1-eps) to approximate the Ground State Connectivity problem (GSCON), and (2) QCMA-hard within the same ratio to estimate the amount of entanglement of a local Hamiltonian's ground state, denoted Ground State Entanglement (GSE). As a bonus, a simplification of our construction yields NP-completeness of approximation for a natural k-SAT reconfiguration problem, to be contrasted with the recent PCP-based PSPACE hardness of approximation results for a different definition of k-SAT reconfiguration [Karthik C.S. and Manurangsi, 2023, and Hirahara, Ohsaka, STOC 2024].

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2411.04874

Related papers

Product-state approximations to quantum ground states

Fernando G. S. L. Brandão, Aram W. Harrow

The local Hamiltonian problem consists of estimating the ground-state energy (given by the minimum eigenvalue) of a local quantum Hamiltonian. It can be considered as a quantum generalization of constraint satisfaction problems (CSPs) and has a key role in quantum complexity theory, being the first and most natural QMA-complete problem known. An interesting regime for the local Hamiltonian problem is that of extensive error, where one is interested in estimating the mean ground-state energy to constant accuracy. The problem is NP-hard by the PCP theorem, but whether it is QMA-hard is an important open question in quantum complexity theory. A positive solution would represent a quantum analogue of the PCP theorem. A key feature that distinguishes quantum Hamiltonians from classical CSPs is that the solutions may involve complicated entangled states. In this paper, we demonstrate several large classes of Hamiltonians for which product (i.e. unentangled) states can approximate the ground state energy to within a small extensive error.

arXiv:1310.0017•ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing (STOC)•May 28, 2013•62 citations

QCMA hardness of ground space connectivity for commuting Hamiltonians

David Gosset, Jenish C. Mehta, Thomas Vidick

In this work we consider the ground space connectivity problem for commuting local Hamiltonians. The ground space connectivity problem asks whether it is possible to go from one (efficiently preparable) state to another by applying a polynomial length sequence of 2-qubit unitaries while remaining at all times in a state with low energy for a given Hamiltonian H . It was shown in [Gharibian and Sikora, ICALP15] that this problem is QCMA-complete for general local Hamiltonians, where QCMA is defined as QMA with a classical witness and BQP verifier. Here we show that the commuting version of the problem is also QCMA-complete. This provides one of the first examples where commuting local Hamiltonians exhibit complexity theoretic hardness equivalent to general local Hamiltonians.

arXiv:1610.03582•Quantum•Jul 14, 2017•16 citations

Quasi-quantum states and the quasi-quantum PCP theorem

Arad, Itai, Miklós Sántha

In this work we define a new classical constraint satisfaction problem that shares many of the properties of the quantum local Hamiltonian problem, distinguishing it from the usual classical k-SAT problem. The problem consists of minimizing the number of violated local constraints over a restricted set of distributions of assignments. We show that these distributions can be 1-to-1 mapped to a superset of the quantum states, which we call k-local quasi-quantum states. Nevertheless, we claim that our optimization problem is essentially classical, by proving that it is an NP-complete problem. Interestingly, the optimal distribution shares many of the properties of quantum states. In particular, it is not determined straightforwardly by its local marginals, and consequently, it can be used as a classical toy model to study several aspects of Hamiltonian complexity that are different from their classical counter parts. These include the complexity of 1D systems (which is in P for classical CSPs, but is QMA-hard for quantum systems), and the lack of an easy search-to-decision reduction. Finally, we believe that our model can be used to gain insights into the quantum PCP conjecture. Indeed, while we have shown that approximating the minimal number of unsatisfiable constraints to within an Θ(1) is NP-hard, it is not clear if the problem remains hard if we want to approximate the minimal fraction of unsatisfiable constraints to within an Θ(1); as in the quantum PCP conjecture, naive quantization of the classical proofs does not seem to work.

arXiv:2410.13549•Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•Oct 17, 2024•3 citations

On the complexity of estimating ground state entanglement and free energy

Sevag Gharibian, Jonas Kamminga

Understanding the entanglement structure of local Hamiltonian ground spaces is a physically motivated problem, with applications ranging from tensor network design to quantum error-correcting codes. To this end, we study the complexity of estimating ground state entanglement, and more generally entropy estimation for low energy states and Gibbs states. We find, in particular, that the classes qq-QAM [Kobayashi, le Gall, Nishimura, SICOMP 2019] (a quantum analogue of public-coin AM) and QMA(2) (QMA with unentangled proofs) play a crucial role for such problems, showing: (1) Detecting a high-entanglement ground state is qq-QAM-complete, (2) computing an additive error approximation to the Helmholtz free energy (equivalently, a multiplicative error approximation to the partition function) is in qq-QAM, (3) detecting a low-entanglement ground state is QMA(2)-hard, and (4) detecting low energy states which are close to product states can range from QMA-complete to QMA(2)-complete. Our results make progress on an open question of [Bravyi, Chowdhury, Gosset and Wocjan, Nature Physics 2022] on free energy, and yield the first QMA(2)-complete Hamiltonian problem using local Hamiltonians (cf. the sparse QMA(2)-complete Hamiltonian problem of [Chailloux, Sattath, CCC 2012]).

arXiv:2510.06796•Oct 8, 2025•3 citations

Ground State Connectivity of Local Hamiltonians

Sevag Gharibian, Jamie Sikora

The study of ground state energies of local Hamiltonians has played a fundamental role in quantum complexity theory. In this article, we take a new direction by introducing the physically motivated notion of “ground state connectivity” of local Hamiltonians, which captures problems in areas ranging from quantum stabilizer codes to quantum memories. Roughly, “ground state connectivity” corresponds to the natural question: Given two ground states |Ψ〉 and |ϕ〉 of a local Hamiltonian H , is there an “energy barrier” (with respect to H ) along any sequence of local operations mapping |Ψ〉 to |ϕ〉? We show that the complexity of this question can range from QCMA-complete to PSPACE-complete, as well as NEXP-complete for an appropriately defined “succinct” version of the problem. As a result, we obtain a natural QCMA-complete problem, a goal which has generally proven difficult since the conception of QCMA over a decade ago. Our proofs rely on a new technical tool, the Traversal Lemma, which analyzes the Hilbert space a local unitary evolution must traverse under certain conditions. We show that this lemma is essentially tight with respect to the length of the unitary evolution in question.

ACM Transactions on Computation Theory•Apr 14, 2018•15 citations

The Complexity of Translationally Invariant Problems Beyond Ground State Energies

James D. Watson, Johannes Bausch, Sevag Gharibian

It is known that three fundamental questions regarding local Hamiltonians -- approximating the ground state energy (the Local Hamiltonian problem), simulating local measurements on the ground space (APX-SIM), and deciding if the low energy space has an energy barrier (GSCON) -- are $\mathsf{QMA}$-hard, $\mathsf{P}^{\mathsf{QMA}[log]}$-hard and $\mathsf{QCMA}$-hard, respectively, meaning they are likely intractable even on a quantum computer. Yet while hardness for the Local Hamiltonian problem is known to hold even for translationally-invariant systems, it is not yet known whether APX-SIM and GSCON remain hard in such "simple" systems. In this work, we show that the translationally invariant versions of both APX-SIM and GSCON remain intractable, namely are $\mathsf{P}^{\mathsf{QMA}_{\mathsf{EXP}}}$- and $\mathsf{QCMA}_{\mathsf{EXP}}$-complete, respectively. Each of these results is attained by giving a respective generic "lifting theorem" for producing hardness results. For APX-SIM, for example, we give a framework for "lifting" any abstract local circuit-to-Hamiltonian mapping $H$ (satisfying mild assumptions) to hardness of APX-SIM on the family of Hamiltonians produced by $H$, while preserving the structural and geometric properties of $H$ (e.g. translation invariance, geometry, locality, etc). Each result also leverages counterintuitive properties of our constructions: for APX-SIM, we "compress" the answers to polynomially many parallel queries to a QMA oracle into a single qubit. For GSCON, we give a hardness construction robust against highly non-local unitaries, i.e. even if the adversary acts on all but one qudit in the system in each step.

arXiv:2012.12717•Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•Dec 23, 2020•14 citations
After nearly two decades of research, the question of a quantum PCP theorem for quantum Constraint Satisfaction Problems (CSPs) remains wide open. As a result, proving QMA-hardness of approximation for ground state energy estimation has remained elusive. Recently, it was shown [Bittel, Gharibian, Kliesch, CCC 2023] that a natural problem involving variational quantum circuits is QCMA-hard to approximate within ratio N^(1-eps) for any eps > 0 and N the input size. Unfortunately, this problem was not related to quantum CSPs, leaving the question of hardness of approximation for quantum CSPs open. In this work, we show that if instead of focusing on ground state energies, one considers computing properties of the ground space, QCMA-hardness of computing ground space properties can be shown. In particular, we show that it is (1) QCMA-complete within ratio N^(1-eps) to approximate the Ground State Connectivity problem (GSCON), and (2) QCMA-hard within the same ratio to estimate the amount of entanglement of a local Hamiltonian's ground state, denoted Ground State Entanglement (GSE). As a bonus, a simplification of our construction yields NP-completeness of approximation for a natural k-SAT reconfiguration problem, to be contrasted with the recent PCP-based PSPACE hardness of approximation results for a different definition of k-SAT reconfiguration [Karthik C.S. and Manurangsi, 2023, and Hirahara, Ohsaka, STOC 2024].
The local Hamiltonian problem consists of estimating the ground-state energy (given by the minimum eigenvalue) of a local quantum Hamiltonian. It can be considered as a quantum generalization of constraint satisfaction problems (CSPs) and has a key role in quantum complexity theory, being the first and most natural QMA-complete problem known. An interesting regime for the local Hamiltonian problem is that of extensive error, where one is interested in estimating the mean ground-state energy to constant accuracy. The problem is NP-hard by the PCP theorem, but whether it is QMA-hard is an important open question in quantum complexity theory. A positive solution would represent a quantum analogue of the PCP theorem. A key feature that distinguishes quantum Hamiltonians from classical CSPs is that the solutions may involve complicated entangled states. In this paper, we demonstrate several large classes of Hamiltonians for which product (i.e. unentangled) states can approximate the ground state energy to within a small extensive error.
In this work we consider the ground space connectivity problem for commuting local Hamiltonians. The ground space connectivity problem asks whether it is possible to go from one (efficiently preparable) state to another by applying a polynomial length sequence of 2-qubit unitaries while remaining at all times in a state with low energy for a given Hamiltonian H . It was shown in [Gharibian and Sikora, ICALP15] that this problem is QCMA-complete for general local Hamiltonians, where QCMA is defined as QMA with a classical witness and BQP verifier. Here we show that the commuting version of the problem is also QCMA-complete. This provides one of the first examples where commuting local Hamiltonians exhibit complexity theoretic hardness equivalent to general local Hamiltonians.
In this work we define a new classical constraint satisfaction problem that shares many of the properties of the quantum local Hamiltonian problem, distinguishing it from the usual classical k-SAT problem. The problem consists of minimizing the number of violated local constraints over a restricted set of distributions of assignments. We show that these distributions can be 1-to-1 mapped to a superset of the quantum states, which we call k-local quasi-quantum states. Nevertheless, we claim that our optimization problem is essentially classical, by proving that it is an NP-complete problem. Interestingly, the optimal distribution shares many of the properties of quantum states. In particular, it is not determined straightforwardly by its local marginals, and consequently, it can be used as a classical toy model to study several aspects of Hamiltonian complexity that are different from their classical counter parts. These include the complexity of 1D systems (which is in P for classical CSPs, but is QMA-hard for quantum systems), and the lack of an easy search-to-decision reduction. Finally, we believe that our model can be used to gain insights into the quantum PCP conjecture. Indeed, while we have shown that approximating the minimal number of unsatisfiable constraints to within an Θ(1) is NP-hard, it is not clear if the problem remains hard if we want to approximate the minimal fraction of unsatisfiable constraints to within an Θ(1); as in the quantum PCP conjecture, naive quantization of the classical proofs does not seem to work.
Understanding the entanglement structure of local Hamiltonian ground spaces is a physically motivated problem, with applications ranging from tensor network design to quantum error-correcting codes. To this end, we study the complexity of estimating ground state entanglement, and more generally entropy estimation for low energy states and Gibbs states. We find, in particular, that the classes qq-QAM [Kobayashi, le Gall, Nishimura, SICOMP 2019] (a quantum analogue of public-coin AM) and QMA(2) (QMA with unentangled proofs) play a crucial role for such problems, showing: (1) Detecting a high-entanglement ground state is qq-QAM-complete, (2) computing an additive error approximation to the Helmholtz free energy (equivalently, a multiplicative error approximation to the partition function) is in qq-QAM, (3) detecting a low-entanglement ground state is QMA(2)-hard, and (4) detecting low energy states which are close to product states can range from QMA-complete to QMA(2)-complete. Our results make progress on an open question of [Bravyi, Chowdhury, Gosset and Wocjan, Nature Physics 2022] on free energy, and yield the first QMA(2)-complete Hamiltonian problem using local Hamiltonians (cf. the sparse QMA(2)-complete Hamiltonian problem of [Chailloux, Sattath, CCC 2012]).
The study of ground state energies of local Hamiltonians has played a fundamental role in quantum complexity theory. In this article, we take a new direction by introducing the physically motivated notion of “ground state connectivity” of local Hamiltonians, which captures problems in areas ranging from quantum stabilizer codes to quantum memories. Roughly, “ground state connectivity” corresponds to the natural question: Given two ground states |Ψ〉 and |ϕ〉 of a local Hamiltonian H , is there an “energy barrier” (with respect to H ) along any sequence of local operations mapping |Ψ〉 to |ϕ〉? We show that the complexity of this question can range from QCMA-complete to PSPACE-complete, as well as NEXP-complete for an appropriately defined “succinct” version of the problem. As a result, we obtain a natural QCMA-complete problem, a goal which has generally proven difficult since the conception of QCMA over a decade ago. Our proofs rely on a new technical tool, the Traversal Lemma, which analyzes the Hilbert space a local unitary evolution must traverse under certain conditions. We show that this lemma is essentially tight with respect to the length of the unitary evolution in question.
It is known that three fundamental questions regarding local Hamiltonians -- approximating the ground state energy (the Local Hamiltonian problem), simulating local measurements on the ground space (APX-SIM), and deciding if the low energy space has an energy barrier (GSCON) -- are QMA\mathsf{QMA}QMA-hard, PQMA[log]\mathsf{P}^{\mathsf{QMA}[log]}PQMA[log]-hard and QCMA\mathsf{QCMA}QCMA-hard, respectively, meaning they are likely intractable even on a quantum computer. Yet while hardness for the Local Hamiltonian problem is known to hold even for translationally-invariant systems, it is not yet known whether APX-SIM and GSCON remain hard in such "simple" systems. In this work, we show that the translationally invariant versions of both APX-SIM and GSCON remain intractable, namely are PQMAEXP\mathsf{P}^{\mathsf{QMA}_{\mathsf{EXP}}}PQMAEXP​- and QCMAEXP\mathsf{QCMA}_{\mathsf{EXP}}QCMAEXP​-complete, respectively. Each of these results is attained by giving a respective generic "lifting theorem" for producing hardness results. For APX-SIM, for example, we give a framework for "lifting" any abstract local circuit-to-Hamiltonian mapping HHH (satisfying mild assumptions) to hardness of APX-SIM on the family of Hamiltonians produced by HHH, while preserving the structural and geometric properties of HHH (e.g. translation invariance, geometry, locality, etc). Each result also leverages counterintuitive properties of our constructions: for APX-SIM, we "compress" the answers to polynomially many parallel queries to a QMA oracle into a single qubit. For GSCON, we give a hardness construction robust against highly non-local unitaries, i.e. even if the adversary acts on all but one qudit in the system in each step.