Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2411.00946

Classical versus quantum queries in quantum PCPs with classical proofs

Harry Buhrman, François Le Gall, Jordi R. Weggemans

Published Nov 1, 2024• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We generalize quantum-classical PCPs, first introduced by Weggemans, Folkertsma and Cade (TQC 2024), to allow for $q$ quantum queries to a polynomially-sized classical proof ($\mathsf{QCPCP}_{Q,c,s}[q]$). Exploiting a connection with the polynomial method, we prove that for any constant $q$, promise gap $c-s = Ω(1/\text{poly}(n))$ and $δ>0$, we have $\mathsf{QCPCP}_{Q,c,s}[q] \subseteq \mathsf{QCPCP}_{1-δ,1/2+δ}[3] \subseteq \mathsf{BQ} \cdot \mathsf{NP}$, where $\mathsf{BQ} \cdot \mathsf{NP}$ is the class of promise problems with quantum reductions to an $\mathsf{NP}$-complete problem. Surprisingly, this shows that we can amplify the promise gap from inverse polynomial to constant for constant query quantum-classical PCPs, and that any quantum-classical PCP making any constant number of quantum queries can be simulated by one that makes only three classical queries. Nevertheless, even though we can achieve promise gap amplification, our result also gives strong evidence that there exists no constant query quantum-classical PCP for $\mathsf{QCMA}$, as it is unlikely that $\mathsf{QCMA} \subseteq \mathsf{BQ} \cdot \mathsf{NP}$, which we support by giving oracular evidence. In the (poly-)logarithmic query regime, we show for any positive integer $c$, there exists an oracle relative to which $\mathsf{QCPCP}[\mathcal{O}(\log^c n)] \subsetneq \mathsf{QCPCP}_Q[\mathcal{O}(\log^c n)]$, contrasting the constant query case where the equivalence of both query models holds relative to any oracle. Finally, we connect our results to more general quantum-classical interactive proof systems.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2411.00946

Related papers

Quantum PCPs: on Adaptivity, Multiple Provers and Reductions to Local Hamiltonians

Harry Buhrman, Jonas Helsen, Jordi R. Weggemans

We define a general formulation of quantum PCPs, which captures adaptivity and multiple unentangled provers, and give a detailed construction of the quantum reduction to a local Hamiltonian with a constant promise gap. The reduction turns out to be a versatile subroutine to prove properties of quantum PCPs, allowing us to show: (i) Non-adaptive quantum PCPs can simulate adaptive quantum PCPs when the number of proof queries is constant. In fact, this can even be shown to hold when the non-adaptive quantum PCP picks the proof indices simply uniformly at random from a subset of all possible index combinations, answering an open question by Aharonov, Arad, Landau and Vazirani (STOC '09). (ii) If the q -local Hamiltonian problem with constant promise gap can be solved in QCMA , then QPCP[q]⊆QCMA for any q∈O(1) . (iii) If QMA(k) has a quantum PCP for any k≤poly(n) , then QMA(2)=QMA , connecting two of the longest-standing open problems in quantum complexity theory. Moreover, we also show that there exist (quantum) oracles relative to which certain quantum PCP statements are false. Hence, any attempt to prove the quantum PCP conjecture requires, just as was the case for the classical PCP theorem, (quantumly) non-relativizing techniques.

arXiv:2403.04841•Quantum•Jul 11, 2025•14 citations

A Relativizing MIP for BQP

Scott Aaronson, Anand Natarajan, Avishay Tal +1 more

Complexity class containments involving interactive proof classes are famously nonrelativizing: although $\mathsf{IP} = \mathsf{PSPACE}$, Fortnow and Sipser showed that that there exists an oracle relative to which $\mathsf{coNP} \not\subseteq \mathsf{IP}$. In contrast, the question of whether the containment $\mathsf{BQP} \subseteq \mathsf{IP}$ is relativizing remains wide open. In this work we make progress towards resolving this question by showing that the containment $\mathsf{BQP} \subseteq \mathsf{MIP}$ holds with respect to any classical oracle. We obtain this result by constructing, for any classical oracle $O$, a $\mathsf{PCP}$ proof system for $\mathsf{BQP}^{O}$ where the verifier makes polynomially many classical queries to an exponentially-long proof, and to the oracle $O$. Our construction is inspired by the state synthesis algorithm of Grover and Rudolph, and serves as a complement to the "exponential PCP" constructed by Aharonov, Arad, and Vidick, which achieves similar parameters but which is based on different ideas and does not relativize. We propose relativization as a proxy for prover efficiency, and hope that progress towards an $\mathsf{IP}$ for $\mathsf{BQP}$ in the oracle world will lead to a non-cryptographic interactive protocol for proving any quantum computation to a classical skeptic in the unrelativized world, which is a longstanding open problem in quantum complexity theory.

quant-pharXiv:2604.11952•Apr 15, 2026•2 citations

Pointer Quantum PCPs and Multi-Prover Games

Alex B. Grilo, Iordanis Kerenidis, Attila Pereszlényi

The quantum PCP (QPCP) conjecture states that all problems in QMA, the quantum analogue of NP, admit quantum verifiers that only act on a constant number of qubits of a polynomial size quantum proof and have a constant gap between completeness and soundness. Despite an impressive body of work trying to prove or disprove the quantum PCP conjecture, it still remains widely open. The above-mentioned proof verification statement has also been shown equivalent to the QMA-completeness of the Local Hamiltonian problem with constant relative gap. Nevertheless, unlike in the classical case, no equivalent formulation in the language of multi-prover games is known. In this work, we propose a new type of quantum proof systems, the Pointer QPCP, where a verifier first accesses a classical proof that he can use as a pointer to which qubits from the quantum part of the proof to access. We define the Pointer QPCP conjecture, that states that all problems in QMA admit quantum verifiers that first access a logarithmic number of bits from the classical part of a polynomial size proof, then act on a constant number of qubits from the quantum part of the proof, and have a constant gap between completeness and soundness. We define a new QMA-complete problem, the Set Local Hamiltonian problem, and a new restricted class of quantum multi-prover games, called CRESP games. We use them to provide two other equivalent statements to the Pointer QPCP conjecture: the Set Local Hamiltonian problem with constant relative gap is QMA-complete; and the approximation of the maximum acceptance probability of CRESP games up to a constant additive factor is as hard as QMA. This is the first equivalence between a quantum PCP statement and the inapproximability of quantum multi-prover games.

arXiv:1603.00903•Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•Jan 1, 2016•4 citations

Quantum Interactive Oracle Proofs

Baocheng Sun, Thomas Vidick

We initiate the study of quantum Interactive Oracle Proofs (qIOPs), a generalization of both quantum Probabilistically Checkable Proofs and quantum Interactive Proofs, as well as a quantum analogue of classical Interactive Oracle Proofs. In the model of quantum Interactive Oracle Proofs, we allow multiple rounds of quantum interaction between the quantum prover and the quantum verifier, but the verifier has limited access to quantum resources. This includes both queries to the prover's messages and the complexity of the quantum circuits applied by the verifier. The question of whether QMA admits a quantum interactive oracle proof system is a relaxation of the quantum PCP Conjecture. We show the following two main constructions of qIOPs, both of which are unconditional: - We construct a qIOP for QMA in which the verifier shares polynomially many EPR pairs with the prover at the start of the protocol and reads only a constant number of qubits from the prover's messages. - We provide a stronger construction of qIOP for QMA in which the verifier not only reads a constant number of qubits but also operates on a constant number of qubits overall, including those in their private registers. However, in this stronger setting, the communication complexity becomes exponential. This leaves open the question of whether strong qIOPs for QMA, with polynomial communication complexity, exist. As a key component of our construction, we introduce a novel single prover many-qubits test, which may be of independent interest.

cs.CCCross-listedarXiv:2601.12874•Jan 20, 2026•1 citation

Quantum Information and the PCP Theorem

Ran Raz

We show how to encode $2^n$ (classical) bits $a_1,...,a_{2^n}$ by a single quantum state $|Ψ>$ of size O(n) qubits, such that: for any constant $k$ and any $i_1,...,i_k \in \{1,...,2^n\}$, the values of the bits $a_{i_1},...,a_{i_k}$ can be retrieved from $|Ψ>$ by a one-round Arthur-Merlin interactive protocol of size polynomial in $n$. This shows how to go around Holevo-Nayak's Theorem, using Arthur-Merlin proofs. We use the new representation to prove the following results: 1) Interactive proofs with quantum advice: We show that the class $QIP/qpoly$ contains ALL languages. That is, for any language $L$ (even non-recursive), the membership $x \in L$ (for $x$ of length $n$) can be proved by a polynomial-size quantum interactive proof, where the verifier is a polynomial-size quantum circuit with working space initiated with some quantum state $|Ψ_{L,n} >$ (depending only on $L$ and $n$). Moreover, the interactive proof that we give is of only one round, and the messages communicated are classical. 2) PCP with only one query: We show that the membership $x \in SAT$ (for $x$ of length $n$) can be proved by a logarithmic-size quantum state $|Ψ>$, together with a polynomial-size classical proof consisting of blocks of length $polylog(n)$ bits each, such that after measuring the state $|Ψ>$ the verifier only needs to read {\bf one} block of the classical proof. While the first result is a straight forward consequence of the new representation, the second requires an additional machinery of quantum low-degree-test that may be interesting in its own right.

arXiv:quant-ph/0504075•Apr 10, 2005•6 citations

Quantum Information and the PCP Theorem

Ran Raz

Our main result is that the membership x ∈ SAT (for x of length n) can be proved by a logarithmic-size quantum state |Ψ〉, together with a polynomial-size classical proof consisting of blocks of length polylog(n) bits each, such that after measuring the state |Ψ 〉 the verifier only needs to read one block of the classical proof. This shows that if a short quantum witness is available then a (classical) PCP with only one query is possible. Our second result is that the class QIP/qpoly contains all languages. That is, for any language L (even non-recursive), the membership x ∈ L (for x of length n) can be proved by a polynomial-size quantum interactive proof, where the verifier is a polynomial-size quantum circuit with working space initiated with some quantum state |ΨL,n 〉 (depending only on L and n). Moreover, the interactive proof that we give is of only one round, and the messages communicated are classical. The advice |ΨL,n 〉 given to the verifier can also be replaced by a classical probabilistic advice, as long as this advice is kept as a secret from the prover. Our result can hence be interpreted as: the class IP/rpoly contains all languages. For the proof of the second result, we introduce the quantum low-degree-extension of a string of bits. The main result requires an additional machinery of quantum lowdegree-test.

•Apr 10, 2005•0 citations
We generalize quantum-classical PCPs, first introduced by Weggemans, Folkertsma and Cade (TQC 2024), to allow for qqq quantum queries to a polynomially-sized classical proof (QCPCPQ,c,s[q]\mathsf{QCPCP}_{Q,c,s}[q]QCPCPQ,c,s​[q]). Exploiting a connection with the polynomial method, we prove that for any constant qqq, promise gap c−s=Ω(1/poly(n))c-s = Ω(1/\text{poly}(n))c−s=Ω(1/poly(n)) and δ>0δ>0δ>0, we have QCPCPQ,c,s[q]⊆QCPCP1−δ,1/2+δ[3]⊆BQ⋅NP\mathsf{QCPCP}_{Q,c,s}[q] \subseteq \mathsf{QCPCP}_{1-δ,1/2+δ}[3] \subseteq \mathsf{BQ} \cdot \mathsf{NP}QCPCPQ,c,s​[q]⊆QCPCP1−δ,1/2+δ​[3]⊆BQ⋅NP, where BQ⋅NP\mathsf{BQ} \cdot \mathsf{NP}BQ⋅NP is the class of promise problems with quantum reductions to an NP\mathsf{NP}NP-complete problem. Surprisingly, this shows that we can amplify the promise gap from inverse polynomial to constant for constant query quantum-classical PCPs, and that any quantum-classical PCP making any constant number of quantum queries can be simulated by one that makes only three classical queries. Nevertheless, even though we can achieve promise gap amplification, our result also gives strong evidence that there exists no constant query quantum-classical PCP for QCMA\mathsf{QCMA}QCMA, as it is unlikely that QCMA⊆BQ⋅NP\mathsf{QCMA} \subseteq \mathsf{BQ} \cdot \mathsf{NP}QCMA⊆BQ⋅NP, which we support by giving oracular evidence. In the (poly-)logarithmic query regime, we show for any positive integer ccc, there exists an oracle relative to which QCPCP[O(log⁡cn)]⊊QCPCPQ[O(log⁡cn)]\mathsf{QCPCP}[\mathcal{O}(\log^c n)] \subsetneq \mathsf{QCPCP}_Q[\mathcal{O}(\log^c n)]QCPCP[O(logcn)]⊊QCPCPQ​[O(logcn)], contrasting the constant query case where the equivalence of both query models holds relative to any oracle. Finally, we connect our results to more general quantum-classical interactive proof systems.
We define a general formulation of quantum PCPs, which captures adaptivity and multiple unentangled provers, and give a detailed construction of the quantum reduction to a local Hamiltonian with a constant promise gap. The reduction turns out to be a versatile subroutine to prove properties of quantum PCPs, allowing us to show: (i) Non-adaptive quantum PCPs can simulate adaptive quantum PCPs when the number of proof queries is constant. In fact, this can even be shown to hold when the non-adaptive quantum PCP picks the proof indices simply uniformly at random from a subset of all possible index combinations, answering an open question by Aharonov, Arad, Landau and Vazirani (STOC '09). (ii) If the q -local Hamiltonian problem with constant promise gap can be solved in QCMA , then QPCP[q]⊆QCMA for any q∈O(1) . (iii) If QMA(k) has a quantum PCP for any k≤poly(n) , then QMA(2)=QMA , connecting two of the longest-standing open problems in quantum complexity theory. Moreover, we also show that there exist (quantum) oracles relative to which certain quantum PCP statements are false. Hence, any attempt to prove the quantum PCP conjecture requires, just as was the case for the classical PCP theorem, (quantumly) non-relativizing techniques.
Complexity class containments involving interactive proof classes are famously nonrelativizing: although IP=PSPACE\mathsf{IP} = \mathsf{PSPACE}IP=PSPACE, Fortnow and Sipser showed that that there exists an oracle relative to which coNP⊈IP\mathsf{coNP} \not\subseteq \mathsf{IP}coNP⊆IP. In contrast, the question of whether the containment BQP⊆IP\mathsf{BQP} \subseteq \mathsf{IP}BQP⊆IP is relativizing remains wide open. In this work we make progress towards resolving this question by showing that the containment BQP⊆MIP\mathsf{BQP} \subseteq \mathsf{MIP}BQP⊆MIP holds with respect to any classical oracle. We obtain this result by constructing, for any classical oracle OOO, a PCP\mathsf{PCP}PCP proof system for BQPO\mathsf{BQP}^{O}BQPO where the verifier makes polynomially many classical queries to an exponentially-long proof, and to the oracle OOO. Our construction is inspired by the state synthesis algorithm of Grover and Rudolph, and serves as a complement to the "exponential PCP" constructed by Aharonov, Arad, and Vidick, which achieves similar parameters but which is based on different ideas and does not relativize. We propose relativization as a proxy for prover efficiency, and hope that progress towards an IP\mathsf{IP}IP for BQP\mathsf{BQP}BQP in the oracle world will lead to a non-cryptographic interactive protocol for proving any quantum computation to a classical skeptic in the unrelativized world, which is a longstanding open problem in quantum complexity theory.
The quantum PCP (QPCP) conjecture states that all problems in QMA, the quantum analogue of NP, admit quantum verifiers that only act on a constant number of qubits of a polynomial size quantum proof and have a constant gap between completeness and soundness. Despite an impressive body of work trying to prove or disprove the quantum PCP conjecture, it still remains widely open. The above-mentioned proof verification statement has also been shown equivalent to the QMA-completeness of the Local Hamiltonian problem with constant relative gap. Nevertheless, unlike in the classical case, no equivalent formulation in the language of multi-prover games is known. In this work, we propose a new type of quantum proof systems, the Pointer QPCP, where a verifier first accesses a classical proof that he can use as a pointer to which qubits from the quantum part of the proof to access. We define the Pointer QPCP conjecture, that states that all problems in QMA admit quantum verifiers that first access a logarithmic number of bits from the classical part of a polynomial size proof, then act on a constant number of qubits from the quantum part of the proof, and have a constant gap between completeness and soundness. We define a new QMA-complete problem, the Set Local Hamiltonian problem, and a new restricted class of quantum multi-prover games, called CRESP games. We use them to provide two other equivalent statements to the Pointer QPCP conjecture: the Set Local Hamiltonian problem with constant relative gap is QMA-complete; and the approximation of the maximum acceptance probability of CRESP games up to a constant additive factor is as hard as QMA. This is the first equivalence between a quantum PCP statement and the inapproximability of quantum multi-prover games.
We initiate the study of quantum Interactive Oracle Proofs (qIOPs), a generalization of both quantum Probabilistically Checkable Proofs and quantum Interactive Proofs, as well as a quantum analogue of classical Interactive Oracle Proofs. In the model of quantum Interactive Oracle Proofs, we allow multiple rounds of quantum interaction between the quantum prover and the quantum verifier, but the verifier has limited access to quantum resources. This includes both queries to the prover's messages and the complexity of the quantum circuits applied by the verifier. The question of whether QMA admits a quantum interactive oracle proof system is a relaxation of the quantum PCP Conjecture. We show the following two main constructions of qIOPs, both of which are unconditional: - We construct a qIOP for QMA in which the verifier shares polynomially many EPR pairs with the prover at the start of the protocol and reads only a constant number of qubits from the prover's messages. - We provide a stronger construction of qIOP for QMA in which the verifier not only reads a constant number of qubits but also operates on a constant number of qubits overall, including those in their private registers. However, in this stronger setting, the communication complexity becomes exponential. This leaves open the question of whether strong qIOPs for QMA, with polynomial communication complexity, exist. As a key component of our construction, we introduce a novel single prover many-qubits test, which may be of independent interest.
We show how to encode 2n2^n2n (classical) bits a1,...,a2na_1,...,a_{2^n}a1​,...,a2n​ by a single quantum state ∣Ψ>|Ψ>∣Ψ> of size O(n) qubits, such that: for any constant kkk and any i1,...,ik∈{1,...,2n}i_1,...,i_k \in \{1,...,2^n\}i1​,...,ik​∈{1,...,2n}, the values of the bits ai1,...,aika_{i_1},...,a_{i_k}ai1​​,...,aik​​ can be retrieved from ∣Ψ>|Ψ>∣Ψ> by a one-round Arthur-Merlin interactive protocol of size polynomial in nnn. This shows how to go around Holevo-Nayak's Theorem, using Arthur-Merlin proofs. We use the new representation to prove the following results: 1) Interactive proofs with quantum advice: We show that the class QIP/qpolyQIP/qpolyQIP/qpoly contains ALL languages. That is, for any language LLL (even non-recursive), the membership x∈Lx \in Lx∈L (for xxx of length nnn) can be proved by a polynomial-size quantum interactive proof, where the verifier is a polynomial-size quantum circuit with working space initiated with some quantum state ∣ΨL,n>|Ψ_{L,n} >∣ΨL,n​> (depending only on LLL and nnn). Moreover, the interactive proof that we give is of only one round, and the messages communicated are classical. 2) PCP with only one query: We show that the membership x∈SATx \in SATx∈SAT (for xxx of length nnn) can be proved by a logarithmic-size quantum state ∣Ψ>|Ψ>∣Ψ>, together with a polynomial-size classical proof consisting of blocks of length polylog(n)polylog(n)polylog(n) bits each, such that after measuring the state ∣Ψ>|Ψ>∣Ψ> the verifier only needs to read {\bf one} block of the classical proof. While the first result is a straight forward consequence of the new representation, the second requires an additional machinery of quantum low-degree-test that may be interesting in its own right.
Our main result is that the membership x ∈ SAT (for x of length n) can be proved by a logarithmic-size quantum state |Ψ〉, together with a polynomial-size classical proof consisting of blocks of length polylog(n) bits each, such that after measuring the state |Ψ 〉 the verifier only needs to read one block of the classical proof. This shows that if a short quantum witness is available then a (classical) PCP with only one query is possible. Our second result is that the class QIP/qpoly contains all languages. That is, for any language L (even non-recursive), the membership x ∈ L (for x of length n) can be proved by a polynomial-size quantum interactive proof, where the verifier is a polynomial-size quantum circuit with working space initiated with some quantum state |ΨL,n 〉 (depending only on L and n). Moreover, the interactive proof that we give is of only one round, and the messages communicated are classical. The advice |ΨL,n 〉 given to the verifier can also be replaced by a classical probabilistic advice, as long as this advice is kept as a secret from the prover. Our result can hence be interpreted as: the class IP/rpoly contains all languages. For the proof of the second result, we introduce the quantum low-degree-extension of a string of bits. The main result requires an additional machinery of quantum lowdegree-test.