Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2410.23958 · Leibniz international proceedings in informatics

Space-Bounded Quantum Interactive Proof Systems

Le Gall, François, Liu, Yupan, Nishimura, Harumichi, Wang, Qisheng

Published Oct 31, 2024• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We introduce two models of space-bounded quantum interactive proof systems, QIPL and QIP_{U}L. The QIP_{U}L model, a space-bounded variant of quantum interactive proofs (QIP) introduced by Watrous (CC 2003) and Kitaev and Watrous (STOC 2000), restricts verifier actions to unitary circuits. In contrast, QIPL allows logarithmically many pinching intermediate measurements per verifier action, making it the weakest model that encompasses the classical model of Condon and Ladner (JCSS 1995). We characterize the computational power of QIPL and QIP_{U}L. When the message number m is polynomially bounded, QIP_{U}L ⊊ QIPL unless P = NP: - QIPL^HC, a subclass of QIPL defined by a high-concentration condition on yes instances, exactly characterizes NP. - QIP_{U}L is contained in P and contains SAC¹ ∪ BQL, where SAC¹ denotes problems solvable by classical logarithmic-depth, semi-unbounded fan-in circuits. However, this distinction vanishes when m is constant. Our results further indicate that (pinching) intermediate measurements uniquely impact space-bounded quantum interactive proofs, unlike in space-bounded quantum computation, where BQL = BQ_{U}L. We also introduce space-bounded unitary quantum statistical zero-knowledge (QSZK_{U}L), a specific form of QIP_{U}L proof systems with statistical zero-knowledge against any verifier. This class is a space-bounded variant of quantum statistical zero-knowledge (QSZK) defined by Watrous (SICOMP 2009). We prove that QSZK_{U}L = BQL, implying that the statistical zero-knowledge property negates the computational advantage typically gained from the interaction.

DOI
10.4230/lipics.ccc.2025.17

Related papers

On quantum interactive proofs with a laconic prover

Zihan Hu, Yupan Liu

Interactive proof systems with a laconic prover, studied by Goldreich, Vadhan, and Wigderson (CC, 2002), capture problems verifiable with logarithmic prover communication in the classical setting. For two-message quantum analogs, even a single-bit prover response contains quantum statistical zero-knowledge ($\sf QSZK$), introduced by Watrous (FOCS 2002). However, restricting the verifier's question to classical public coins collapses the corresponding class to $\sf BQP$, as shown by Beigi, Shor, and Watrous (ToC, 2011). We further study two-message quantum interactive proof systems with a laconic prover. To this end, we introduce the class ${\sf QIP}_{\ell\text{-}{\rm bit}}(2)$, where $\ell$ is the length of the prover's response, and establish: 1. A natural complete characterization of ${\sf QIP}_{\ell\text{-}{\rm bit}}(2)$ by Multi-State Distinguishability. In particular, Quantum State Distinguishability (QSD) is ${\sf QIP}_{\rm bit}$-complete. Since QSD is $\sf QSZK$-hard, our result places ${\sf QIP}_{\ell\text{-}{\rm bit}}(2)$, for $\ell\geq 2$, in a landscape "just above" $\sf QSZK$. 2. Easy regimes for ${\sf QIP}_{\ell\text{-}{\rm bit}}(2)$ collapsing to $\sf QSZK$. We prove that QSD$[a,b]$ (and thus ${\sf QIP}_{\rm bit}[a,b]$) is in $\sf QSZK$ when $a(n)-b(n)\geq 1/O(\log n)$, and combine this with an answer compression from ${\sf QIP}_{\ell\text{-}{\rm bit}}[2,c,s]$ to ${\sf QIP}_{\rm bit}$ to obtain another easy regime when $2c>(1+2^{\ell/2})s$. Remarkably, our improved polarization applies to SD and $\sf SZK$, resolving an open problem in Sahai and Vadhan (JACM, 2003). 3. Quantum public coins also make the interaction useless: ${\sf qc}\text{-}{\sf QAM}[O(\sqrt{\log{n}})]$ with constant gap is in $\sf BQP$, where ${\sf qc}\text{-}{\sf QAM}[\ell]$ is a subclass of ${\sf QIP}_{\ell\text{-}{\rm bit}}(2)$ in which the verifier's question is exactly halves of EPR pairs.

quant-pharXiv:2609.39495•Oct 1, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Proofs

Thomas Vidick, John Watrous

Quantum information and computation provide a fascinating twist on the notion of proofs in computational complexity theory. For instance, one may consider a quantum computational analogue of the complexity class NP, known as QMA, in which a quantum state plays the role of a proof (also called a certificate or witness), and is checked by a polynomial-time quantum computation. For some problems, the fact that a quantum proof state could be a superposition over exponentially many classical states appears to offer computational advantages over classical proof strings. In the interactive proof system setting, one may consider a verifier and one or more provers that exchange and process quantum information rather than classical information during an interaction for a given input string, giving rise to quantum complexity classes such as QIP, QSZK, and QMIP* that represent natural quantum analogues of IP, SZK, and MIP. While quantum interactive proof systems inherit some properties from their classical counterparts, they also possess distinct and uniquely quantum features that lead to an interesting landscape of complexity classes based on variants of this model. In this survey we provide an overview of many of the known results concerning quantum proofs, computational models based on this concept, and properties of the complexity classes they define. In particular, we discuss non-interactive proofs and the complexity class QMA, single-prover quantum interactive proof systems and the complexity class QIP, statistical zero-knowledge quantum interactive proof systems and the complexity class QSZK, and multiprover interactive proof systems and the complexity classes QMIP, QMIP*, and MIP*.

arXiv:1610.01664•Foundations and Trends® in Theoretical Computer Science•Mar 31, 2016•56 citations

Limits on the power of quantum statistical zero-knowledge

John Watrous

In this paper we propose a definition for (honest verifier) quantum statistical zero-knowledge interactive proof systems and study the resulting complexity class, which we denote QSZK/sub HV/. We prove several facts regarding this class, including: the following problem is a complete promise problem for QSZKHV: given instructions for preparing two mixed quantum states, are the states close together or far apart in the trace norm metric? This problem is a quantum generalization of the complete promise problem of Sahai and Vadhan (1997) for (classical) statistical zero-knowledge; QSZK/sub HV/ is closed under complement; QSZK/sub HV//spl sube/PSPACE. (At present it is not known if arbitrary quantum interactive proof systems can be simulated in PSPACE even for one-round proof systems); any polynomial-round honest verifier quantum statistical zero-knowledge proof system can be simulated by a two-message (i.e., one-round) honest verifier quantum statistical zero-knowledge proof system. Similarly, any polynomial-round honest verifier quantum statistical zero-knowledge proof system can be simulated by a three-message public-coin honest verifier quantum statistical zero-knowledge proof system. These facts establish close connections between classical statistical zero-knowledge and our definition for quantum statistical zero-knowledge, and give some insight regarding the effect of this zero-knowledge restriction on quantum interactive proof systems. The relationship between our definition and possible definitions of general (i.e., not necessarily honest) quantum statistical zero-knowledge are also discussed.

Annual Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science•Jun 26, 2003•141 citations

A slightly improved upper bound for quantum statistical zero-knowledge

François Le Gall, Yupan Liu, Qisheng Wang

The complexity class Quantum Statistical Zero-Knowledge ($\mathsf{QSZK}$), introduced by Watrous (FOCS 2002) and later refined in Watrous (SICOMP, 2009), has the best known upper bound $\mathsf{QIP(2)} \cap \text{co-}\mathsf{QIP(2)}$, which was simplified following the inclusion $\mathsf{QIP(2)} \subseteq \mathsf{PSPACE}$ established in Jain, Upadhyay, and Watrous (FOCS 2009). Here, $\mathsf{QIP(2)}$ denotes the class of promise problems that admit two-message quantum interactive proof systems in which the honest prover is typically computationally unbounded, and $\text{co-}\mathsf{QIP(2)}$ denotes the complement of $\mathsf{QIP(2)}$. We slightly improve this upper bound to $\mathsf{QIP(2)} \cap \text{co-}\mathsf{QIP(2)}$ with a quantum linear-space honest prover. Specifically, the honest prover uses space linear in the size of the transcript of the original $\mathsf{QSZK}$ proof system. A similar improvement also applies to the upper bound for the non-interactive variant $\mathsf{NIQSZK}$. Our main techniques are algorithmic versions of the Holevo-Helstrom measurement and the Uhlmann transform, both implementable in quantum linear space, implying polynomial-time complexity in the state dimension, using the recent space-efficient quantum singular value transformation of Le Gall, Liu, and Wang (CC, to appear).

quant-pharXiv:2512.11597•Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•Dec 15, 2025•3 citations

Quantum statistical zero-knowledge

John Watrous

In this paper we propose a definition for (honest verifier) quantum statistical zero-knowledge interactive proof systems and study the resulting complexity class, which we denote QSZK. We prove several facts regarding this class that establish close connections between classical statistical zero-knowledge and our definition for quantum statistical zero-knowledge, and give some insight regarding the effect of this zero-knowledge restriction on quantum interactive proof systems.

arXiv:quant-ph/0202111•Feb 20, 2002•34 citations

QIP = PSPACE

Rahul Jain, Zhengfeng Ji, Sarvagya Upadhyay +1 more

This work considers the quantum interactive proof system model of computation, which is the (classical) interactive proof system model’s natural quantum computational analogue. An exact characterization of the expressive power of quantum interactive proof systems is obtained: the collection of computational problems having quantum interactive proof systems consists precisely of those problems solvable by deterministic Turing machines that use at most a polynomial amount of space (or, more succinctly, QIP = PSPACE). This characterization is proved through the use of a parallelized form of the matrix multiplicative weights update method, applied to a class of semidefinite programs that captures the computational power of quantum interactive proof systems. One striking implication of this characterization is that quantum computing provides no increase in computational power whatsoever over classical computing in the context of interactive proof systems, for it is well known that the collection of computational problems having classical interactive proof systems coincides with those problems solvable by polynomial-space computations.

Journal of the ACM•Dec 1, 2011•81 citations
We introduce two models of space-bounded quantum interactive proof systems, QIPL and QIP_{U}L. The QIP_{U}L model, a space-bounded variant of quantum interactive proofs (QIP) introduced by Watrous (CC 2003) and Kitaev and Watrous (STOC 2000), restricts verifier actions to unitary circuits. In contrast, QIPL allows logarithmically many pinching intermediate measurements per verifier action, making it the weakest model that encompasses the classical model of Condon and Ladner (JCSS 1995). We characterize the computational power of QIPL and QIP_{U}L. When the message number m is polynomially bounded, QIP_{U}L ⊊ QIPL unless P = NP: - QIPL^HC, a subclass of QIPL defined by a high-concentration condition on yes instances, exactly characterizes NP. - QIP_{U}L is contained in P and contains SAC¹ ∪ BQL, where SAC¹ denotes problems solvable by classical logarithmic-depth, semi-unbounded fan-in circuits. However, this distinction vanishes when m is constant. Our results further indicate that (pinching) intermediate measurements uniquely impact space-bounded quantum interactive proofs, unlike in space-bounded quantum computation, where BQL = BQ_{U}L. We also introduce space-bounded unitary quantum statistical zero-knowledge (QSZK_{U}L), a specific form of QIP_{U}L proof systems with statistical zero-knowledge against any verifier. This class is a space-bounded variant of quantum statistical zero-knowledge (QSZK) defined by Watrous (SICOMP 2009). We prove that QSZK_{U}L = BQL, implying that the statistical zero-knowledge property negates the computational advantage typically gained from the interaction.
Interactive proof systems with a laconic prover, studied by Goldreich, Vadhan, and Wigderson (CC, 2002), capture problems verifiable with logarithmic prover communication in the classical setting. For two-message quantum analogs, even a single-bit prover response contains quantum statistical zero-knowledge (QSZK\sf QSZKQSZK), introduced by Watrous (FOCS 2002). However, restricting the verifier's question to classical public coins collapses the corresponding class to BQP\sf BQPBQP, as shown by Beigi, Shor, and Watrous (ToC, 2011). We further study two-message quantum interactive proof systems with a laconic prover. To this end, we introduce the class QIPℓ-bit(2){\sf QIP}_{\ell\text{-}{\rm bit}}(2)QIPℓ-bit​(2), where ℓ\ellℓ is the length of the prover's response, and establish: 1. A natural complete characterization of QIPℓ-bit(2){\sf QIP}_{\ell\text{-}{\rm bit}}(2)QIPℓ-bit​(2) by Multi-State Distinguishability. In particular, Quantum State Distinguishability (QSD) is QIPbit{\sf QIP}_{\rm bit}QIPbit​-complete. Since QSD is QSZK\sf QSZKQSZK-hard, our result places QIPℓ-bit(2){\sf QIP}_{\ell\text{-}{\rm bit}}(2)QIPℓ-bit​(2), for ℓ≥2\ell\geq 2ℓ≥2, in a landscape "just above" QSZK\sf QSZKQSZK. 2. Easy regimes for QIPℓ-bit(2){\sf QIP}_{\ell\text{-}{\rm bit}}(2)QIPℓ-bit​(2) collapsing to QSZK\sf QSZKQSZK. We prove that QSD[a,b][a,b][a,b] (and thus QIPbit[a,b]{\sf QIP}_{\rm bit}[a,b]QIPbit​[a,b]) is in QSZK\sf QSZKQSZK when a(n)−b(n)≥1/O(log⁡n)a(n)-b(n)\geq 1/O(\log n)a(n)−b(n)≥1/O(logn), and combine this with an answer compression from QIPℓ-bit[2,c,s]{\sf QIP}_{\ell\text{-}{\rm bit}}[2,c,s]QIPℓ-bit​[2,c,s] to QIPbit{\sf QIP}_{\rm bit}QIPbit​ to obtain another easy regime when 2c>(1+2ℓ/2)s2c>(1+2^{\ell/2})s2c>(1+2ℓ/2)s. Remarkably, our improved polarization applies to SD and SZK\sf SZKSZK, resolving an open problem in Sahai and Vadhan (JACM, 2003). 3. Quantum public coins also make the interaction useless: qc-QAM[O(log⁡n)]{\sf qc}\text{-}{\sf QAM}[O(\sqrt{\log{n}})]qc-QAM[O(logn​)] with constant gap is in BQP\sf BQPBQP, where qc-QAM[ℓ]{\sf qc}\text{-}{\sf QAM}[\ell]qc-QAM[ℓ] is a subclass of QIPℓ-bit(2){\sf QIP}_{\ell\text{-}{\rm bit}}(2)QIPℓ-bit​(2) in which the verifier's question is exactly halves of EPR pairs.
Quantum information and computation provide a fascinating twist on the notion of proofs in computational complexity theory. For instance, one may consider a quantum computational analogue of the complexity class NP, known as QMA, in which a quantum state plays the role of a proof (also called a certificate or witness), and is checked by a polynomial-time quantum computation. For some problems, the fact that a quantum proof state could be a superposition over exponentially many classical states appears to offer computational advantages over classical proof strings. In the interactive proof system setting, one may consider a verifier and one or more provers that exchange and process quantum information rather than classical information during an interaction for a given input string, giving rise to quantum complexity classes such as QIP, QSZK, and QMIP* that represent natural quantum analogues of IP, SZK, and MIP. While quantum interactive proof systems inherit some properties from their classical counterparts, they also possess distinct and uniquely quantum features that lead to an interesting landscape of complexity classes based on variants of this model. In this survey we provide an overview of many of the known results concerning quantum proofs, computational models based on this concept, and properties of the complexity classes they define. In particular, we discuss non-interactive proofs and the complexity class QMA, single-prover quantum interactive proof systems and the complexity class QIP, statistical zero-knowledge quantum interactive proof systems and the complexity class QSZK, and multiprover interactive proof systems and the complexity classes QMIP, QMIP*, and MIP*.
In this paper we propose a definition for (honest verifier) quantum statistical zero-knowledge interactive proof systems and study the resulting complexity class, which we denote QSZK/sub HV/. We prove several facts regarding this class, including: the following problem is a complete promise problem for QSZKHV: given instructions for preparing two mixed quantum states, are the states close together or far apart in the trace norm metric? This problem is a quantum generalization of the complete promise problem of Sahai and Vadhan (1997) for (classical) statistical zero-knowledge; QSZK/sub HV/ is closed under complement; QSZK/sub HV//spl sube/PSPACE. (At present it is not known if arbitrary quantum interactive proof systems can be simulated in PSPACE even for one-round proof systems); any polynomial-round honest verifier quantum statistical zero-knowledge proof system can be simulated by a two-message (i.e., one-round) honest verifier quantum statistical zero-knowledge proof system. Similarly, any polynomial-round honest verifier quantum statistical zero-knowledge proof system can be simulated by a three-message public-coin honest verifier quantum statistical zero-knowledge proof system. These facts establish close connections between classical statistical zero-knowledge and our definition for quantum statistical zero-knowledge, and give some insight regarding the effect of this zero-knowledge restriction on quantum interactive proof systems. The relationship between our definition and possible definitions of general (i.e., not necessarily honest) quantum statistical zero-knowledge are also discussed.
The complexity class Quantum Statistical Zero-Knowledge (QSZK\mathsf{QSZK}QSZK), introduced by Watrous (FOCS 2002) and later refined in Watrous (SICOMP, 2009), has the best known upper bound QIP(2)∩co-QIP(2)\mathsf{QIP(2)} \cap \text{co-}\mathsf{QIP(2)}QIP(2)∩co-QIP(2), which was simplified following the inclusion QIP(2)⊆PSPACE\mathsf{QIP(2)} \subseteq \mathsf{PSPACE}QIP(2)⊆PSPACE established in Jain, Upadhyay, and Watrous (FOCS 2009). Here, QIP(2)\mathsf{QIP(2)}QIP(2) denotes the class of promise problems that admit two-message quantum interactive proof systems in which the honest prover is typically computationally unbounded, and co-QIP(2)\text{co-}\mathsf{QIP(2)}co-QIP(2) denotes the complement of QIP(2)\mathsf{QIP(2)}QIP(2). We slightly improve this upper bound to QIP(2)∩co-QIP(2)\mathsf{QIP(2)} \cap \text{co-}\mathsf{QIP(2)}QIP(2)∩co-QIP(2) with a quantum linear-space honest prover. Specifically, the honest prover uses space linear in the size of the transcript of the original QSZK\mathsf{QSZK}QSZK proof system. A similar improvement also applies to the upper bound for the non-interactive variant NIQSZK\mathsf{NIQSZK}NIQSZK. Our main techniques are algorithmic versions of the Holevo-Helstrom measurement and the Uhlmann transform, both implementable in quantum linear space, implying polynomial-time complexity in the state dimension, using the recent space-efficient quantum singular value transformation of Le Gall, Liu, and Wang (CC, to appear).
This work considers the quantum interactive proof system model of computation, which is the (classical) interactive proof system model’s natural quantum computational analogue. An exact characterization of the expressive power of quantum interactive proof systems is obtained: the collection of computational problems having quantum interactive proof systems consists precisely of those problems solvable by deterministic Turing machines that use at most a polynomial amount of space (or, more succinctly, QIP = PSPACE). This characterization is proved through the use of a parallelized form of the matrix multiplicative weights update method, applied to a class of semidefinite programs that captures the computational power of quantum interactive proof systems. One striking implication of this characterization is that quantum computing provides no increase in computational power whatsoever over classical computing in the context of interactive proof systems, for it is well known that the collection of computational problems having classical interactive proof systems coincides with those problems solvable by polynomial-space computations.