Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2410.19152 · Leibniz international proceedings in informatics

Quantum Merlin-Arthur with an Internally Separable Proof

Roozbeh Bassirian, Bill Fefferman, Itai Leigh, Kunal Marwaha, Pei Wu

Published Oct 24, 2024• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We find a modification to QMA where having one quantum proof is strictly less powerful than having two unentangled proofs, assuming EXP $\ne$ NEXP. This gives a new route to prove QMA(2) = NEXP that overcomes the primary drawback of a recent approach [arXiv:2402.18790 , arXiv:2306.13247] (QIP 2024). Our modification endows each proof with a form of *multipartite* unentanglement: after tracing out one register, a small number of qubits are separable from the rest of the state.

DOI
10.4230/lipics.tqc.2026.5

Related papers

Quantum Merlin-Arthur and Proofs Without Relative Phase

Roozbeh Bassirian, Bill Fefferman, Kunal Marwaha

We study a variant of QMA where quantum proofs have no relative phase (i.e. non-negative amplitudes, up to a global phase). If only completeness is modified, this class is equal to QMA [arXiv:1410.2882]; but if both completeness and soundness are modified, the class (named QMA+ by Jeronimo and Wu) can be much more powerful. We show that QMA+ with some constant gap is equal to NEXP, yet QMA+ with some *other* constant gap is equal to QMA. One interpretation is that Merlin's ability to "deceive" originates from relative phase at least as much as from entanglement, since QMA(2) $\subseteq$ NEXP.

arXiv:2306.13247•Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•Jun 23, 2023•13 citations

An exponential time upper bound for Quantum Merlin-Arthur games with unentangled provers

Schwarz, Martin

We prove a deterministic exponential time upper bound for Quantum Merlin-Arthur games with k unentangled provers. This is the first non-trivial upper bound of QMA(k) better than NEXP and can be considered an exponential improvement, unless EXP=NEXP. The key ideas of our proof are to use perturbation theory to reduce the QMA(2)-complete Separable Sparse Hamiltonian problem to a variant of the Separable Local Hamiltonian problem with an exponentially small promise gap, and then to decide this instance using epsilon-net methods. Our results imply an exponential time algorithm for the Pure State N-Representability problem in quantum chemistry, which is in QMA(2), but is not known to be in QMA. We also discuss the implications of our results on the Best Separable State problem.

arXiv:1510.08447•Oct 28, 2015•2 citations

The Power of Unentanglement

Scott Aaronson, Salman Beigi, Andrew Drucker +2 more

The class QMA(k), introduced by Kobayashi et al., consists of all languages that can be verified using k unentangled quantum proofs. Many of the simplest questions about this class have remained embarrassingly open: for example, can we give any evidence that k quantum proofs are more powerful than one? Can we show any upper bound on QMA(k), besides the trivial NEXP? Does QMA(k)=QMA(2) for kges2? Can QMA(k) protocols be amplified to exponentially small error? In this paper, we make progress on all of the above questions. *We give a protocol by which a verifier can be convinced that a 3SAT formula of size n is satisfiable, with constant soundness, given O tilde(radicn) unentangled quantum witnesses with O(log n) qubits each. Our protocol relies on Dinur's version of the PCP Theorem and is inherently non-relativizing. *We show that assuming the famous Additivity Conjecture from quantum information theory, any QMA(2) protocol can be amplified to exponentially small error, and QMA(k)=QMA(2) for all kges=2. *We give evidence that QMA(2) sube PSPACE, by showing that this would follow from "strong amplification" of QMA(2) protocols. *We prove the nonexistence of "perfect disentanglers" for simulating multiple Merlins with one.

IEEE Conference on Computational Complexity (CCC)•Jun 1, 2008•31 citations

QMA has perfect completeness

Sabee Grewal, Dorian Rudolph

We prove $\mathsf{QMA} = \mathsf{QMA_1}$, i.e., every quantum Merlin-Arthur proof system can be made perfectly complete. Our construction uses only Hadamard, Toffoli, and $X$ gates, yielding a universal gate set for $\mathsf{QMA_1}$. As a consequence, quantum $3$-SAT is $\mathsf{QMA}$-complete. The construction relativizes to classical oracles, so known classical-oracle separations of $\mathsf{QMA}$ from $\mathsf{QCMA}$ extend to $\mathsf{QMA_1}$.

quant-pharXiv:2609.13032•Sep 14, 2026•5 citations

The Power of Unentanglement (Extended Abstract)

Scott Aaronson, Salman Beigi, Andrew Drucker +2 more

The class QMA(k), introduced by Kobayashi et al., consists of all languages that can be verified using k unentangled quantum proofs. Many of the simplest questions about this class have remained embarrassingly open: for example, can we give any evidence that k quantum proofs are more powerful than one? Can we show any upper bound on QMA(k), besides the trivial NEXP? Does QMA(k) = QMA(2) for k ≥ 2? Can QMA(k) protocols be amplified to exponentially small error? In this paper, we make progress on all of the above questions. • We give a protocol by which a verifier can be convinced that a 3SAT formula of size n is satisfiable, with constant soundness, given Õ (√n) unentangled quantum witnesses with O (log n) qubits each. Our protocol relies on Dinur’s version of the PCP Theorem and is inherently non-relativizing. • We show that assuming the famous Additivity Conjecture from quantum information theory, any QMA(2) protocol can be amplified to exponentially small error, and QMA(k) = QMA(2) for all k ≥ 2. • We give evidence that QMA(2) ⊆ PSPACE, by showing that this would follow from “strong amplification” of QMA(2) protocols. • We prove the nonexistence of “perfect disentanglers” for simulating multiple Merlins with one.

•Jan 1, 2008•0 citations

The Power of Unentanglement

Scott Aaronson, Salman Beigi, Andrew Drucker +2 more

The class $\mathsf{QMA}( k) $, introduced by Kobayashi et al., consists of all languages that can be verified using $k$ unentangled quantum proofs. Many of the simplest questions about this class have remained embarrassingly open: for example, can we give any evidence that $k$ quantum proofs are more powerful than one? Does $\mathsf{QMA}( k) =\mathsf{QMA}( 2) $ for $k\geq2$? Can $\mathsf{QMA}( k) $ protocols be amplified to exponentially small error? In this paper, we make progress on all of the above questions. We give a protocol by which a verifier can be convinced that a 3SAT formula of size $m$ is satisfiable, with constant soundness, given $\widetilde{O}(\sqrt{m}) $ unentangled quantum witnesses with $O( \log m) $ qubits each. Our protocol relies on the existence of very short PCPs. We show that assuming a weak version of the Additivity Conjecture from quantum information theory, any $\mathsf{QMA}( 2) $ protocol can be amplified to exponentially small error, and $\mathsf{QMA}( k) =\mathsf{QMA}( 2) $ for all $k\geq2$. We prove the nonexistence of “perfect disentanglers” for simulating multiple Merlins with one.

arXiv:0804.0802•Theory of Computing•Jan 1, 2009•70 citations
We find a modification to QMA where having one quantum proof is strictly less powerful than having two unentangled proofs, assuming EXP ≠\ne= NEXP. This gives a new route to prove QMA(2) = NEXP that overcomes the primary drawback of a recent approach [arXiv:2402.18790 , arXiv:2306.13247] (QIP 2024). Our modification endows each proof with a form of multipartite unentanglement: after tracing out one register, a small number of qubits are separable from the rest of the state.
We study a variant of QMA where quantum proofs have no relative phase (i.e. non-negative amplitudes, up to a global phase). If only completeness is modified, this class is equal to QMA [arXiv:1410.2882]; but if both completeness and soundness are modified, the class (named QMA+ by Jeronimo and Wu) can be much more powerful. We show that QMA+ with some constant gap is equal to NEXP, yet QMA+ with some *other* constant gap is equal to QMA. One interpretation is that Merlin's ability to "deceive" originates from relative phase at least as much as from entanglement, since QMA(2) ⊆\subseteq⊆ NEXP.
We prove a deterministic exponential time upper bound for Quantum Merlin-Arthur games with k unentangled provers. This is the first non-trivial upper bound of QMA(k) better than NEXP and can be considered an exponential improvement, unless EXP=NEXP. The key ideas of our proof are to use perturbation theory to reduce the QMA(2)-complete Separable Sparse Hamiltonian problem to a variant of the Separable Local Hamiltonian problem with an exponentially small promise gap, and then to decide this instance using epsilon-net methods. Our results imply an exponential time algorithm for the Pure State N-Representability problem in quantum chemistry, which is in QMA(2), but is not known to be in QMA. We also discuss the implications of our results on the Best Separable State problem.
The class QMA(k), introduced by Kobayashi et al., consists of all languages that can be verified using k unentangled quantum proofs. Many of the simplest questions about this class have remained embarrassingly open: for example, can we give any evidence that k quantum proofs are more powerful than one? Can we show any upper bound on QMA(k), besides the trivial NEXP? Does QMA(k)=QMA(2) for kges2? Can QMA(k) protocols be amplified to exponentially small error? In this paper, we make progress on all of the above questions. *We give a protocol by which a verifier can be convinced that a 3SAT formula of size n is satisfiable, with constant soundness, given O tilde(radicn) unentangled quantum witnesses with O(log n) qubits each. Our protocol relies on Dinur's version of the PCP Theorem and is inherently non-relativizing. *We show that assuming the famous Additivity Conjecture from quantum information theory, any QMA(2) protocol can be amplified to exponentially small error, and QMA(k)=QMA(2) for all kges=2. *We give evidence that QMA(2) sube PSPACE, by showing that this would follow from "strong amplification" of QMA(2) protocols. *We prove the nonexistence of "perfect disentanglers" for simulating multiple Merlins with one.
We prove QMA=QMA1\mathsf{QMA} = \mathsf{QMA_1}QMA=QMA1​, i.e., every quantum Merlin-Arthur proof system can be made perfectly complete. Our construction uses only Hadamard, Toffoli, and XXX gates, yielding a universal gate set for QMA1\mathsf{QMA_1}QMA1​. As a consequence, quantum 333-SAT is QMA\mathsf{QMA}QMA-complete. The construction relativizes to classical oracles, so known classical-oracle separations of QMA\mathsf{QMA}QMA from QCMA\mathsf{QCMA}QCMA extend to QMA1\mathsf{QMA_1}QMA1​.
The class QMA(k), introduced by Kobayashi et al., consists of all languages that can be verified using k unentangled quantum proofs. Many of the simplest questions about this class have remained embarrassingly open: for example, can we give any evidence that k quantum proofs are more powerful than one? Can we show any upper bound on QMA(k), besides the trivial NEXP? Does QMA(k) = QMA(2) for k ≥ 2? Can QMA(k) protocols be amplified to exponentially small error? In this paper, we make progress on all of the above questions. • We give a protocol by which a verifier can be convinced that a 3SAT formula of size n is satisfiable, with constant soundness, given Õ (√n) unentangled quantum witnesses with O (log n) qubits each. Our protocol relies on Dinur’s version of the PCP Theorem and is inherently non-relativizing. • We show that assuming the famous Additivity Conjecture from quantum information theory, any QMA(2) protocol can be amplified to exponentially small error, and QMA(k) = QMA(2) for all k ≥ 2. • We give evidence that QMA(2) ⊆ PSPACE, by showing that this would follow from “strong amplification” of QMA(2) protocols. • We prove the nonexistence of “perfect disentanglers” for simulating multiple Merlins with one.
The class $\mathsf{QMA}( k) $, introduced by Kobayashi et al., consists of all languages that can be verified using kkk unentangled quantum proofs. Many of the simplest questions about this class have remained embarrassingly open: for example, can we give any evidence that kkk quantum proofs are more powerful than one? Does $\mathsf{QMA}( k) =\mathsf{QMA}( 2) $ for k≥2k\geq2k≥2? Can $\mathsf{QMA}( k) $ protocols be amplified to exponentially small error? In this paper, we make progress on all of the above questions. We give a protocol by which a verifier can be convinced that a 3SAT formula of size mmm is satisfiable, with constant soundness, given $\widetilde{O}(\sqrt{m}) $ unentangled quantum witnesses with $O( \log m) $ qubits each. Our protocol relies on the existence of very short PCPs. We show that assuming a weak version of the Additivity Conjecture from quantum information theory, any $\mathsf{QMA}( 2) $ protocol can be amplified to exponentially small error, and $\mathsf{QMA}( k) =\mathsf{QMA}( 2) $ for all k≥2k\geq2k≥2. We prove the nonexistence of “perfect disentanglers” for simulating multiple Merlins with one.