Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2410.09535

Tensorial Quantum Mechanics: Back to Heisenberg and Beyond

Christian DE RONDE, Raimundo Fernández Mouján, César Massri

Published Oct 12, 2024• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this work we discuss the establishment of Standard Quantum Mechanics (SQM) developed through Schrödinger's and Dirac's wave-vectorial reformulations of Heisenberg's original matrix mechanics. We will argue that while Heisenberg's approach was consistently developed -- taking as a standpoint the intensive patterns that were observed in the lab -- as an invariant-operational formalism, Dirac's axiomatic re-formulation was, instead, developed -- taking as a standpoint Schrödinger's wave mechanics and the methodological guide of Bohr and logical positivists -- as an essentially inconsistent "recipe" intended (but unable) to predict (binary) measurement outcomes. Leaving SQM behind and attempting to restore the consistent and coherent account of a real state of affairs, we will present a new tensorial proposal which -- taking as a standpoint Heisenberg's original approach -- will prove capable not only to extend the matrix formalism to a tensorial representation but also to account for new experimental phenomena.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2410.09535

Related papers

Tensorial quantum mechanics

Christian DE RONDE, Raimundo Fernández Mouján, César Massri

In July 1925, exactly one century ago, Werner Heisenberg created Quantum Mechanics (QM) as an invariant-operational formalism by taking as a standpoint the intensive patterns that had been already observed by experimentalists in the lab. One of the few drawbacks of this proposal was the impossibility to conceptualize it in classical terms. Attempting to restore a somewhat classical spatiotemporal representation, six months later, Erwin Schrödinger would present a formalism grounded on a wave equation in configuration space. Taking as a standpoint Schrödinger’s wave mechanics together with the methodological guide of Bohr and logical positivists, Dirac would present in 1930 an axiomatic re-formulation of the theory of quanta that would become known as the “standard” version of QM (SQM). This new version of the theory, that is still today taught in physics classrooms all around the world, would become accepted regardless of its inconsistent narrative as a “recipe” intended (but unable) to predict (binary) measurement outcomes. After pointing out some of the many problems of SQM, in this work we propose to go back to Heisenberg’s matrix mechanics (and also to his understanding of physical theories). We will argue that his matrix mechanics, as an operationally-invariant standpoint, opens the door to a tensorial enlargement of the mathematical formalism capable to account for new phenomena.

Scientific Reports•Apr 2, 2026•0 citations

Understanding Quantum Mechanics (Beyond Metaphysical Dogmatism and Naive Empiricism)

Christian DE RONDE

Quantum Mechanics (QM) has faced deep controversies and debates since its origin when Werner Heisenberg proposed the first mathematical formalism capable to operationally account for what had been recently discovered as the new field of quantum phenomena. Today, even though we have reached a standardized version of QM which is taught in Universities all around the world, there is still no consensus regarding the conceptual reference of the theory and, if or if not, it can refer to something beyond measurement outcomes. In this work we will argue that the reason behind the impossibility to reach a meaningful answer to this question is strictly related to the 20th Century Bohrian-positivist re-foundation of physics which is responsible for having introduced within the theory of quanta a harmful combination of metaphysical dogmatism and naive empiricism. We will also argue that the possibility of understanding QM is at plain sight, given we return to the original framework of physics in which the meaning of understanding has always been clear.

arXiv:2009.00487•Sep 1, 2020•2 citations

On the Physical Untenability of the Standard Notion of Quantum State

Christian DE RONDE

The notion of quantum state plays a fundamental role within the Standard account of Quantum Mechanics (SQM) as established by Dirac and von Neumann during 1930s and up to the present. In this work we expose the deep inconsistencies that exist within the multiple definitions of the notion of quantum state that are provided within this axiomatic formulation. As we will argue, these different inconsistent definitions continue to be -- even today -- uncritically confused within the mainstream physical and philosophical literature leading to self-contradictory statements and wrong conclusions. We end with a discussion regarding the untenability of this concept for any rational understanding of theoretical physics.

arXiv:2505.23989•May 29, 2025•0 citations

Mathematical Realization of Quantum Mechanics

Any physical phenomenon is described by a state vector and an operator in the quantum world. We present mathematical methods which connect the microscopic physical world to the quantum mechanics. Two different representations will be discussed in this chapter. One is the matrix mechanics formulated by W. Heisenberg. Another one is Schrödinger wave mechanics. At first two models appear very different each other, but it was proved that two theories are completely equivalent and lead to the same physical predictions. Both models have been quite useful not only in the formulation of quantum mechanics, but also in the development of quantum information theory.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Sep 24, 2020•0 citations

Formal Structure of Quantum Mechanics

In the preceding chapters we have introduced some important ideas in quantum mechanics and used them to study a number of physical systems. The formulation of the theory we used is known as wave mechanics and is due largely to Schrödinger. We are now going to take a more formal approach and will see that quantum mechanics can be formulated in different ways that are equivalent to wave mechanics, such as Heisenberg’s matrix mechanics. We will also introduce the very useful Dirac notation, which is widely used by researchers and can simplify calculations a lot. But first, let us introduce the important ideas of states and ensembles.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Mar 27, 2018•0 citations

Quantum mechanics

Valia Allori

This is a brief review of the history and development of quantum theories. Starting from the experimental findings and theoretical results which marked the crisis of the classical framework, I overview the rise of axiomatic quantum mechanics through matrix and wave mechanics. I discuss conceptual problems such as the measurement problem that led scientific realists to explore other, more satisfactory, quantum theories, as well as Bell’s theorem and quantum nonlocality, concluding with a short review of relativistic theories.

Routledge eBooks•Dec 16, 2025•0 citations
In this work we discuss the establishment of Standard Quantum Mechanics (SQM) developed through Schrödinger's and Dirac's wave-vectorial reformulations of Heisenberg's original matrix mechanics. We will argue that while Heisenberg's approach was consistently developed -- taking as a standpoint the intensive patterns that were observed in the lab -- as an invariant-operational formalism, Dirac's axiomatic re-formulation was, instead, developed -- taking as a standpoint Schrödinger's wave mechanics and the methodological guide of Bohr and logical positivists -- as an essentially inconsistent "recipe" intended (but unable) to predict (binary) measurement outcomes. Leaving SQM behind and attempting to restore the consistent and coherent account of a real state of affairs, we will present a new tensorial proposal which -- taking as a standpoint Heisenberg's original approach -- will prove capable not only to extend the matrix formalism to a tensorial representation but also to account for new experimental phenomena.
In July 1925, exactly one century ago, Werner Heisenberg created Quantum Mechanics (QM) as an invariant-operational formalism by taking as a standpoint the intensive patterns that had been already observed by experimentalists in the lab. One of the few drawbacks of this proposal was the impossibility to conceptualize it in classical terms. Attempting to restore a somewhat classical spatiotemporal representation, six months later, Erwin Schrödinger would present a formalism grounded on a wave equation in configuration space. Taking as a standpoint Schrödinger’s wave mechanics together with the methodological guide of Bohr and logical positivists, Dirac would present in 1930 an axiomatic re-formulation of the theory of quanta that would become known as the “standard” version of QM (SQM). This new version of the theory, that is still today taught in physics classrooms all around the world, would become accepted regardless of its inconsistent narrative as a “recipe” intended (but unable) to predict (binary) measurement outcomes. After pointing out some of the many problems of SQM, in this work we propose to go back to Heisenberg’s matrix mechanics (and also to his understanding of physical theories). We will argue that his matrix mechanics, as an operationally-invariant standpoint, opens the door to a tensorial enlargement of the mathematical formalism capable to account for new phenomena.
Quantum Mechanics (QM) has faced deep controversies and debates since its origin when Werner Heisenberg proposed the first mathematical formalism capable to operationally account for what had been recently discovered as the new field of quantum phenomena. Today, even though we have reached a standardized version of QM which is taught in Universities all around the world, there is still no consensus regarding the conceptual reference of the theory and, if or if not, it can refer to something beyond measurement outcomes. In this work we will argue that the reason behind the impossibility to reach a meaningful answer to this question is strictly related to the 20th Century Bohrian-positivist re-foundation of physics which is responsible for having introduced within the theory of quanta a harmful combination of metaphysical dogmatism and naive empiricism. We will also argue that the possibility of understanding QM is at plain sight, given we return to the original framework of physics in which the meaning of understanding has always been clear.
The notion of quantum state plays a fundamental role within the Standard account of Quantum Mechanics (SQM) as established by Dirac and von Neumann during 1930s and up to the present. In this work we expose the deep inconsistencies that exist within the multiple definitions of the notion of quantum state that are provided within this axiomatic formulation. As we will argue, these different inconsistent definitions continue to be -- even today -- uncritically confused within the mainstream physical and philosophical literature leading to self-contradictory statements and wrong conclusions. We end with a discussion regarding the untenability of this concept for any rational understanding of theoretical physics.
Any physical phenomenon is described by a state vector and an operator in the quantum world. We present mathematical methods which connect the microscopic physical world to the quantum mechanics. Two different representations will be discussed in this chapter. One is the matrix mechanics formulated by W. Heisenberg. Another one is Schrödinger wave mechanics. At first two models appear very different each other, but it was proved that two theories are completely equivalent and lead to the same physical predictions. Both models have been quite useful not only in the formulation of quantum mechanics, but also in the development of quantum information theory.
In the preceding chapters we have introduced some important ideas in quantum mechanics and used them to study a number of physical systems. The formulation of the theory we used is known as wave mechanics and is due largely to Schrödinger. We are now going to take a more formal approach and will see that quantum mechanics can be formulated in different ways that are equivalent to wave mechanics, such as Heisenberg’s matrix mechanics. We will also introduce the very useful Dirac notation, which is widely used by researchers and can simplify calculations a lot. But first, let us introduce the important ideas of states and ensembles.
This is a brief review of the history and development of quantum theories. Starting from the experimental findings and theoretical results which marked the crisis of the classical framework, I overview the rise of axiomatic quantum mechanics through matrix and wave mechanics. I discuss conceptual problems such as the measurement problem that led scientific realists to explore other, more satisfactory, quantum theories, as well as Bell’s theorem and quantum nonlocality, concluding with a short review of relativistic theories.