Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2410.07470

Quantum Knots that Never Come Untied

Michikazu Kobayashi, Yuta Nozaki, Yuya Koda, Muneto Nitta

Published Oct 9, 2024• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Lord Kelvin proposed that atoms form hydrodynamic vortex knots. However, they typically untie through reconnections, i. e., local cut-and-slice events, unlike stable vortex unknots such as smoke rings. The same holds in superfluids--quantum fluids with zero viscosity--where vortices have quantized circulation, making them topologically stable. For over 150 years, hydrodynamically stable vortex knots have been sought both experimentally and theoretically. Here, we present the first demonstration of hydrodynamically stable vortex knots and links in experimentally realizable Bose-Einstein condensates of ultracold atomic gases and confirm it through dynamic simulations. Our method creates stable knotted vortex structures in systems where reconnections are prohibited, with potential relevance to neutron star interiors. Additionally, we anticipate our mathematical framework could have applications in quantum computation, quantum turbulence, and DNA dynamics, particularly where reconnections are restricted.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2410.07470

Related papers

Topological transition from superfluid vortex rings to isolated knots and links

Wen-Kai Bai, Tao Yang, Wu‐Ming Liu

Knots and links are fundamental topological objects that play a key role in both classical and quantum fluids. In this paper, we propose a scheme to generate torus vortex knots and links through the reconnections of vortex rings perturbed by Kelvin waves in trapped Bose-Einstein condensates, which makes it possible to generate topologically complex structures from topologically trivial objects controllably. The transfer of helicity between knots, links, and coils occur with different pathways which can be controlled through designing specific initial states. The generation of a knot or link can be achieved by setting the parity of the Kelvin wave number. The stability of knots and links can be greatly improved with tunable parameters, including the ideal relative angle and the minimal distance between the initial vortex rings.

arXiv:2007.02239•Physical Review A•Dec 16, 2020•20 citations

Geometric quantum hydrodynamics and Bose-Einstein condensates: non-Hamiltonian evolution of vortex lines

Scott A. Strong

Geometric quantum hydrodynamics merges geometric hydrodynamics with quantum hydrodynamics to study the geometric properties of vortex structures in superfluid states of matter. Here the vortex line acts as the fundamental building block and is a topological defect of the fluid medium about which the otherwise irrotational fluid circulates. In this thesis, we show that except for the simplest fluid flows, a vortex line seeks to decompose localized regions of curvature into helical configurations. The simplest flow, known as the local induction approximation, is also an integrable one. Integrability makes the transfer of energy into helical modes impossible. In the following, we demonstrate that any arclength conserving correction to this approximation defines a non-Hamiltonian evolution of the vortex geometry, which is capable of supporting dissipative solitons and helical wavefronts. Quantum turbulence in ultracold vortex tangles relies on energy transfer between helical or Kelvin modes to decay. Thus, models of vortex lines beyond the lowest order integrable cases are vitally important to our mathematical description of free decay of turbulent tangles. To motivate the results of this thesis we connect our theory of vortex line dynamics to continuum fluid mechanics. The Navier-Stokes equations are a statement of momentum balance for a fluid whose response to shear stress is proportional to the fluid's velocity gradients. Building off of Onsager's rather obscure work in fluid turbulence, others have shown that solutions to Navier-Stokes limit to Euler evolutions of distributional velocity profiles for large Reynolds number. Using this as our context, we show that the Euler equation can be transformed, in an inverse Madelung sense, to the Gross-Pitaevskii equation associated with the mean-field quantum dynamics of a dilute Bose gas. This theory predicts that an irrotational fluid is capable of circulating around regions of density depletion known as vortex lines. Furthermore, if a vortex line is used as the ansatz for the Gross-Pitaevskii equation then it is possible to show that the Biot-Savart integral over the vortex source results. This connection between the vortex line geometry and the induced velocity field provides the basis for the application of geometric quantum hydrodynamics to Bose-Einstein condensates. If the Biot-Savart integral is the basis of geometric quantum hydrodynamics, then Hasimoto's transformation is the structure built on top. The fundamental theorem of space curves states that up to rotations and translations, a curve is defined by its curvature and torsion. Through the Hasimoto transformation, it is possible to map flows defined by the Biot-Savart integral to scalar partial differential equations evolving the curvature and torsion of a vortex line. In this thesis, we conduct an asymptotic expansion of the Biot-Savart integral and apply the Hasimoto transformation to show that vortex lines prefer to relax curved abnormalities through the excitation of helical waves along the vortex. Thus, our model predicts a geometric mechanism for the generation of Kelvin waves and corrects a nearly 50 year old result to include the dynamics expected in our most primitive states of fluid matter. Our derivation begins with the Biot-Savart integral representation of the velocity field induced by a vortex line. We derive an exact representation of the velocity field in terms of the incomplete elliptic integrals by approximating local regions of vorticity with plane circular arcs. The velocity field is shown to be a combination of three fields defining axial flow, circulation and a binormal flow that appears in the presence of non-trivial curvature. The latter flow explains why vortex rings of smaller diameter travel faster than larger rings. Using known asymptotic formulae for the elliptic integrals allows us to move past the lowest order local induction approximation. The asymptotic representations are valid for the regime where the local curvature is small relative to the inverse of the vortex core size and are applicable to vortex lines in Bose-Einstein condensates. To understand the predictions stemming from our asymptotic representation of the local velocity field, we compute two key quantities. First, we consider the expansion of the local field in powers of curvature to define corrections to the flow when curvature becomes large. Second, we consider the Hasimoto transformation of the general induced binormal flow. The result is a scalar evolution of the curvature and torsion for configurations of vortex lines with significant bending. Moving past the local induction approximation causes Hasimoto's transformation to map the local flow onto a nonlinear integro-differential equation. Through the use of our asymptotic expansion, this evolution reduces to a nonlinear partial differential equation amenable to both symbolic and numerical analysis. Our symbolic analysis shows that a specific nonlinear term in the partial differential equation prohibits a Hamiltonian formulation of the problem. Using conservation laws associated with the local induction approximation, we consider how the non-Hamiltonian term gives rise to a dissipative mechanism allowing gain and loss of curvature in the vortex medium. Additionally, we derive a nonlinear dispersion relation predicting that low wavenumber helical modes jettison from locally curved regions. Consequently, curved regions seek to relax their bending through the production of helical structures. If the curvature is created through a vortex reconnection, then helical Kelvin waves couple the vortex to the Bose-Einstein condensate for the purposes of phonon generation and are expected to be the route to decay in free quantum turbulence. We corroborate these predictions with simulations of corrections to initial states predicted by the local induction approximation. Specifically, we simulate out of plane perturbations of a vortex ring, along with soliton and breathing states. A detailed analysis of the soliton state shows a transition to a log normal distribution where curvature disperses ahead of the traveling wave. On the vortex, this appears as a helical wavefront propagating into an otherwise straight line. The non-Hamiltonian gain mechanism acts to support Kelvin modes as they travel and keeps the initial peak profile from completely eroding, a feature indicative of a dissipative soliton. These dynamics were also seen in both the breathing and ring states. Thus, geometric quantum hydrodynamics predicts that the simplest flow of curved regions on a vortex line generates Kelvin waves providing a route to the anomalous dissipation first predicted by Onsager.

•Jan 1, 2018•0 citations

Helicity, topology, and Kelvin waves in reconnecting quantum knots

Patricio Clark Di Leoni, Pablo D. Mininni, Marc Brächet

Helicity is a topological invariant that measures the linkage and knottedness of lines, tubes, and ribbons. As such, it has found myriads of applications in astrophysics, fluid dynamics, atmospheric sciences, and biology. In quantum flows, where topology-changing reconnection events are a staple, helicity appears as a key quantity to study. However, the usual definition of helicity is not well posed in quantum vortices, and its computation based on counting links and crossings of centerline vorticity can be downright impossible to apply in complex and turbulent scenarios. We present a definition of helicity which overcomes these problems and which gives the expected result in the large-scale limit. With it, we show that certain reconnection events can excite Kelvin waves and other complex motions of the centerline vorticity, which slowly deplete helicity as they interact nonlinearly, thus linking the theory of vortex knots with observations of quantum fluids. This process also results in the depletion of helicity in a fully turbulent quantum flow, in a way reminiscent of the decay of helicity in classical fluids.

arXiv:1602.06880•Physical Review A•Oct 3, 2016•39 citations

STABILITY AND DYNAMICS OF QUANTIZED VORTICES IN GASEOUS BOSE-EINSTEIN CONDENSATES

Jukka Huhtamäki

Bose-Einstein condensation is a quantum statistical phase transition which was theoretically predicted almost a hundred years ago. After years of seminal research, physicists realized the first almost ideal Bose-Einstein condensates in ultracold dilute atomic gases in 1995. Since then, the theoretical and experimental methods concerning such systems have been developing rapidly, and many fascinating phenomena have been found in these novel quantum systems.\n\nBose-Einstein condensation occurs in a system consisting of massive bosons when a single quantum state becomes macroscopically occupied as the temperature is lowered below the transition temperature. In general, condensates consisting of repulsively interacting bosons exhibit superfluidity: Particle currents can flow in the system without dissipation and viscosity. Moreover, the velocity fields of condensates have to be irrotational, which severely restricts the rotational characteristics of these systems. Apart from the center of mass motion, the system may carry angular momentum in the form of elementary excitations or so-called quantized vortices.\n\nThis Thesis is a theoretical study of subjects related to stability and dynamics of quantized vortices in dilute atomic Bose-Einstein condensates. The precession and instability of off-centered vortices in trapped condensates is investigated both in the zero-temperature limit and at finite temperatures. Dynamical stability of multiply quantized vortices and vortex clusters is studied in axisymmetric trap geometries. Splitting of energetically and dynamically unstable multiply quantized vortices into singly quantized vortices is also studied. Finally, as a separate subject, tunneling of a condensate through a potential barrier is investigated. Majority of this work relies on numerical methods for solving the Gross-Pitaevskii and Bogoliubov equations, which are of central importance in the study of dilute atomic Bose-Einstein condensates.

•Mar 7, 2008•0 citations

Vortex reconnections and rebounds in trapped atomic Bose-Einstein condensates

Simone Serafini, Luca Galantucci, Elena Iseni +6 more

Reconnections and interactions of filamentary coherent structures play a fundamental role in the dynamics of fluids,redistributing energy and helicity among the length scales and inducing fine-scale turbulent mixing. Unlike ordinary fluids, where vorticity is a continuous field, in quantum fluids vorticity is concentrated into discrete (quantized) vortex lines turning vortex reconnections into isolated events, conceptually easier to study. Here we report experimental and numerical observations of three-dimensional quantum vortex interactions in a cigar-shaped atomic Bose--Einstein Condensate. In addition to standard reconnections, already numerically and experimentally observed in homogeneous systems away from boundaries, we show that double reconnections, rebounds and ejections can also occur as a consequence of the non-homogeneous, confined nature of the system.

•May 25, 2017•0 citations

Vorticity Knot in Two-component Bose-Einstein Condensates

Y. M. Cho

We demonstrate the existence of the helical vortex solution in two-component Bose-Einstein condensates which can be identified as a twisted vorticity flux. Based on this we argue that the recently proposed knot in two-component Bose-Einstein condensates can be interpreted as a vorticity knot, a vortex ring made of the helical vortex. This picture shows that the knot is made of two quantized vorticity fluxes linked together, whose topology $π_3(S^2)$ is fixed by the linking number of two vorticity fluxes. Due to the helical structure the knot has both topological and dynamical stability. We estimate the energy of the lightest knot to be about $3\times 10^{-3} eV$.

arXiv:cond-mat/0409636•Sep 24, 2004•4 citations
Lord Kelvin proposed that atoms form hydrodynamic vortex knots. However, they typically untie through reconnections, i. e., local cut-and-slice events, unlike stable vortex unknots such as smoke rings. The same holds in superfluids--quantum fluids with zero viscosity--where vortices have quantized circulation, making them topologically stable. For over 150 years, hydrodynamically stable vortex knots have been sought both experimentally and theoretically. Here, we present the first demonstration of hydrodynamically stable vortex knots and links in experimentally realizable Bose-Einstein condensates of ultracold atomic gases and confirm it through dynamic simulations. Our method creates stable knotted vortex structures in systems where reconnections are prohibited, with potential relevance to neutron star interiors. Additionally, we anticipate our mathematical framework could have applications in quantum computation, quantum turbulence, and DNA dynamics, particularly where reconnections are restricted.
Knots and links are fundamental topological objects that play a key role in both classical and quantum fluids. In this paper, we propose a scheme to generate torus vortex knots and links through the reconnections of vortex rings perturbed by Kelvin waves in trapped Bose-Einstein condensates, which makes it possible to generate topologically complex structures from topologically trivial objects controllably. The transfer of helicity between knots, links, and coils occur with different pathways which can be controlled through designing specific initial states. The generation of a knot or link can be achieved by setting the parity of the Kelvin wave number. The stability of knots and links can be greatly improved with tunable parameters, including the ideal relative angle and the minimal distance between the initial vortex rings.
Geometric quantum hydrodynamics merges geometric hydrodynamics with quantum hydrodynamics to study the geometric properties of vortex structures in superfluid states of matter. Here the vortex line acts as the fundamental building block and is a topological defect of the fluid medium about which the otherwise irrotational fluid circulates. In this thesis, we show that except for the simplest fluid flows, a vortex line seeks to decompose localized regions of curvature into helical configurations. The simplest flow, known as the local induction approximation, is also an integrable one. Integrability makes the transfer of energy into helical modes impossible. In the following, we demonstrate that any arclength conserving correction to this approximation defines a non-Hamiltonian evolution of the vortex geometry, which is capable of supporting dissipative solitons and helical wavefronts. Quantum turbulence in ultracold vortex tangles relies on energy transfer between helical or Kelvin modes to decay. Thus, models of vortex lines beyond the lowest order integrable cases are vitally important to our mathematical description of free decay of turbulent tangles. To motivate the results of this thesis we connect our theory of vortex line dynamics to continuum fluid mechanics. The Navier-Stokes equations are a statement of momentum balance for a fluid whose response to shear stress is proportional to the fluid's velocity gradients. Building off of Onsager's rather obscure work in fluid turbulence, others have shown that solutions to Navier-Stokes limit to Euler evolutions of distributional velocity profiles for large Reynolds number. Using this as our context, we show that the Euler equation can be transformed, in an inverse Madelung sense, to the Gross-Pitaevskii equation associated with the mean-field quantum dynamics of a dilute Bose gas. This theory predicts that an irrotational fluid is capable of circulating around regions of density depletion known as vortex lines. Furthermore, if a vortex line is used as the ansatz for the Gross-Pitaevskii equation then it is possible to show that the Biot-Savart integral over the vortex source results. This connection between the vortex line geometry and the induced velocity field provides the basis for the application of geometric quantum hydrodynamics to Bose-Einstein condensates. If the Biot-Savart integral is the basis of geometric quantum hydrodynamics, then Hasimoto's transformation is the structure built on top. The fundamental theorem of space curves states that up to rotations and translations, a curve is defined by its curvature and torsion. Through the Hasimoto transformation, it is possible to map flows defined by the Biot-Savart integral to scalar partial differential equations evolving the curvature and torsion of a vortex line. In this thesis, we conduct an asymptotic expansion of the Biot-Savart integral and apply the Hasimoto transformation to show that vortex lines prefer to relax curved abnormalities through the excitation of helical waves along the vortex. Thus, our model predicts a geometric mechanism for the generation of Kelvin waves and corrects a nearly 50 year old result to include the dynamics expected in our most primitive states of fluid matter. Our derivation begins with the Biot-Savart integral representation of the velocity field induced by a vortex line. We derive an exact representation of the velocity field in terms of the incomplete elliptic integrals by approximating local regions of vorticity with plane circular arcs. The velocity field is shown to be a combination of three fields defining axial flow, circulation and a binormal flow that appears in the presence of non-trivial curvature. The latter flow explains why vortex rings of smaller diameter travel faster than larger rings. Using known asymptotic formulae for the elliptic integrals allows us to move past the lowest order local induction approximation. The asymptotic representations are valid for the regime where the local curvature is small relative to the inverse of the vortex core size and are applicable to vortex lines in Bose-Einstein condensates. To understand the predictions stemming from our asymptotic representation of the local velocity field, we compute two key quantities. First, we consider the expansion of the local field in powers of curvature to define corrections to the flow when curvature becomes large. Second, we consider the Hasimoto transformation of the general induced binormal flow. The result is a scalar evolution of the curvature and torsion for configurations of vortex lines with significant bending. Moving past the local induction approximation causes Hasimoto's transformation to map the local flow onto a nonlinear integro-differential equation. Through the use of our asymptotic expansion, this evolution reduces to a nonlinear partial differential equation amenable to both symbolic and numerical analysis. Our symbolic analysis shows that a specific nonlinear term in the partial differential equation prohibits a Hamiltonian formulation of the problem. Using conservation laws associated with the local induction approximation, we consider how the non-Hamiltonian term gives rise to a dissipative mechanism allowing gain and loss of curvature in the vortex medium. Additionally, we derive a nonlinear dispersion relation predicting that low wavenumber helical modes jettison from locally curved regions. Consequently, curved regions seek to relax their bending through the production of helical structures. If the curvature is created through a vortex reconnection, then helical Kelvin waves couple the vortex to the Bose-Einstein condensate for the purposes of phonon generation and are expected to be the route to decay in free quantum turbulence. We corroborate these predictions with simulations of corrections to initial states predicted by the local induction approximation. Specifically, we simulate out of plane perturbations of a vortex ring, along with soliton and breathing states. A detailed analysis of the soliton state shows a transition to a log normal distribution where curvature disperses ahead of the traveling wave. On the vortex, this appears as a helical wavefront propagating into an otherwise straight line. The non-Hamiltonian gain mechanism acts to support Kelvin modes as they travel and keeps the initial peak profile from completely eroding, a feature indicative of a dissipative soliton. These dynamics were also seen in both the breathing and ring states. Thus, geometric quantum hydrodynamics predicts that the simplest flow of curved regions on a vortex line generates Kelvin waves providing a route to the anomalous dissipation first predicted by Onsager.
Helicity is a topological invariant that measures the linkage and knottedness of lines, tubes, and ribbons. As such, it has found myriads of applications in astrophysics, fluid dynamics, atmospheric sciences, and biology. In quantum flows, where topology-changing reconnection events are a staple, helicity appears as a key quantity to study. However, the usual definition of helicity is not well posed in quantum vortices, and its computation based on counting links and crossings of centerline vorticity can be downright impossible to apply in complex and turbulent scenarios. We present a definition of helicity which overcomes these problems and which gives the expected result in the large-scale limit. With it, we show that certain reconnection events can excite Kelvin waves and other complex motions of the centerline vorticity, which slowly deplete helicity as they interact nonlinearly, thus linking the theory of vortex knots with observations of quantum fluids. This process also results in the depletion of helicity in a fully turbulent quantum flow, in a way reminiscent of the decay of helicity in classical fluids.
Bose-Einstein condensation is a quantum statistical phase transition which was theoretically predicted almost a hundred years ago. After years of seminal research, physicists realized the first almost ideal Bose-Einstein condensates in ultracold dilute atomic gases in 1995. Since then, the theoretical and experimental methods concerning such systems have been developing rapidly, and many fascinating phenomena have been found in these novel quantum systems.\n\nBose-Einstein condensation occurs in a system consisting of massive bosons when a single quantum state becomes macroscopically occupied as the temperature is lowered below the transition temperature. In general, condensates consisting of repulsively interacting bosons exhibit superfluidity: Particle currents can flow in the system without dissipation and viscosity. Moreover, the velocity fields of condensates have to be irrotational, which severely restricts the rotational characteristics of these systems. Apart from the center of mass motion, the system may carry angular momentum in the form of elementary excitations or so-called quantized vortices.\n\nThis Thesis is a theoretical study of subjects related to stability and dynamics of quantized vortices in dilute atomic Bose-Einstein condensates. The precession and instability of off-centered vortices in trapped condensates is investigated both in the zero-temperature limit and at finite temperatures. Dynamical stability of multiply quantized vortices and vortex clusters is studied in axisymmetric trap geometries. Splitting of energetically and dynamically unstable multiply quantized vortices into singly quantized vortices is also studied. Finally, as a separate subject, tunneling of a condensate through a potential barrier is investigated. Majority of this work relies on numerical methods for solving the Gross-Pitaevskii and Bogoliubov equations, which are of central importance in the study of dilute atomic Bose-Einstein condensates.
Reconnections and interactions of filamentary coherent structures play a fundamental role in the dynamics of fluids,redistributing energy and helicity among the length scales and inducing fine-scale turbulent mixing. Unlike ordinary fluids, where vorticity is a continuous field, in quantum fluids vorticity is concentrated into discrete (quantized) vortex lines turning vortex reconnections into isolated events, conceptually easier to study. Here we report experimental and numerical observations of three-dimensional quantum vortex interactions in a cigar-shaped atomic Bose--Einstein Condensate. In addition to standard reconnections, already numerically and experimentally observed in homogeneous systems away from boundaries, we show that double reconnections, rebounds and ejections can also occur as a consequence of the non-homogeneous, confined nature of the system.
We demonstrate the existence of the helical vortex solution in two-component Bose-Einstein condensates which can be identified as a twisted vorticity flux. Based on this we argue that the recently proposed knot in two-component Bose-Einstein condensates can be interpreted as a vorticity knot, a vortex ring made of the helical vortex. This picture shows that the knot is made of two quantized vorticity fluxes linked together, whose topology π3(S2)π_3(S^2)π3​(S2) is fixed by the linking number of two vorticity fluxes. Due to the helical structure the knot has both topological and dynamical stability. We estimate the energy of the lightest knot to be about 3×10−3eV3\times 10^{-3} eV3×10−3eV.