Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2409.13214 · Quantum Science and Technology

Detecting unfaithful entanglement by multiple fidelities

Ruiqi Zhang, Zhaohui Wei

Published Dec 23, 2024• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract Certifying entanglement for unknown quantum states experimentally is a fundamental problem in quantum computing and quantum physics. Because of being easy to implement, a most popular approach for this problem in modern quantum experiments is detecting target quantum states with fidelity-based entanglement witnesses. Specifically, if the fidelity between a target state and an entangled pure state exceeds a certain value, the target state can be guaranteed to be entangled. Recently, however, it has been realized that there exist so-called unfaithful quantum states, which can be entangled, but their entanglement cannot be certified by any fidelity-based entanglement witnesses. In this paper, by specific examples, we show that if one makes a slight modification to fidelity-based entanglement witnesses by combining multiple fidelities together, it is still possible to certify entanglement for unfaithful quantum states with this popular technique. Particularly, we will analyze the mathematical structure of the modified entanglement witnesses, and propose an algorithm that can search for the optimal designs for them.

DOI
10.1088/2058-9565/ada2b7

Related papers

Detecting Entanglement in Unfaithful States

Yongtao Zhan, Hoi‐Kwong Lo

Entanglement witness is an effective method to detect entanglement in unknown states without doing full tomography. One of the most widespread schemes of witnessing entanglement is measuring its fidelity with respect to a pure entangled state. Recently, a large class of states whose entanglement can not be detected with the fidelity witness has been discovered in Phys.Rev.Lett \textbf{124},200502(2020). They are called unfaithful states. In this paper we propose a new way to detect entanglement by calculating the lower bound of entanglement using measurement results. Numerical simulation shows our method can detect entanglement in unfaithful states with a small number of measurements. Moreover, we generalize our scheme to multipartite states and show that it can tolerate higher noise than previous entanglement witness operators with same number of measurement settings.

arXiv:2010.06054•Oct 12, 2020•6 citations

Entanglement Detection beyond Measuring Fidelities

Mirjam Weilenmann, Benjamin Dive, David Trillo +2 more

One of the most widespread methods to determine if a quantum state is entangled, or to quantify its entanglement dimensionality, is by measuring its fidelity with respect to a pure state. In this Letter, we find a large class of states whose entanglement cannot be detected in this manner; we call them unfaithful. We find that unfaithful states are ubiquitous in information theory. For small dimensions, we check numerically that most bipartite states are both entangled and unfaithful. Similarly, numerical searches in low dimensions show that most pure entangled states remain entangled but become unfaithful when a certain amount of white noise is added. We also find that faithfulness can be self-activated, i.e., there exist instances of unfaithful states whose tensor powers are faithful. To explore how the fidelity approach limits the quantification of entanglement dimensionality, we generalize the notion of an unfaithful state to that of a D unfaithful state, one that cannot be certified as D-dimensionally entangled by measuring its fidelity with respect to a pure state. For describing such states, we additionally introduce a hierarchy of semidefinite programming relaxations that fully characterizes the set of states of Schmidt rank at most D.

arXiv:1912.10056•Physical Review Letters•May 20, 2020•52 citations

Optimized Detection of High-Dimensional Entanglement

Xiao-Min Hu, Wen-Bo Xing, Yu Guo +9 more

Entanglement detection is one of the most conventional tasks in quantum information processing. While most experimental demonstrations of high-dimensional entanglement rely on fidelity-based witnesses, these are powerless to detect entanglement within a large class of entangled quantum states, the so-called unfaithful states. In this Letter, we introduce a highly flexible automated method to construct optimal tests for entanglement detection given a bipartite target state of arbitrary dimension, faithful or unfaithful, and a set of local measurement operators. By restricting the number or complexity of the considered measurement settings, our method outputs the most convenient protocol which can be implemented using a wide range of experimental techniques such as photons, superconducting qudits, cold atoms, or trapped ions. With an experimental quantum optics setup that can prepare and measure arbitrary high-dimensional mixed states, we implement some three-setting protocols generated by our method. These protocols allow us to experimentally certify two- and three-unfaithful entanglement in four-dimensional photonic states, some of which contain well above 50% of noise.

arXiv:2011.02217•Physical Review Letters•Nov 22, 2021•21 citations

Exploring the relationship between the faithfulness and entanglement of two qubits

Gabriele Riccardi, Daniel E. Jones, Xiao‐Dong Yu +2 more

A conceptually simple and experimentally prevalent class of entanglement witnesses, known as fidelity witnesses, detects entanglement via a state's fidelity with a pure reference state. While existence proofs guarantee that a suitable witness can be constructed for every entangled state, such assurances do not apply to fidelity witnesses. Recent results have found that entangled states that cannot be detected by a fidelity witness, known as unfaithful states, are exceedingly common among bipartite states. In this paper, we show that even among two-qubit states, which are the simplest of all entangled states, unfaithful states can be created through a suitable application of decoherence and filtering to a Bell state. We also show that the faithfulness is not monotonic to entanglement, as measured by the concurrence. Finally, we experimentally verify our predictions using polarization-entangled photons, and specifically we demonstrate a situation in which an unfaithful state is brought to faithfulness at the expense of further reducing the entanglement of the state.

arXiv:2102.10121•Physical Review A•Apr 19, 2021•14 citations

Theory on detection of multipartite entanglement

宏二 長田

Since the 1980s, there has been a physical problem relating to the detection of multipartite entangled states that helps us to investigate fundamental point of view on interpretations of quantum mechanics. On the other hand, information theories based on the mathematical structure of quantum mechanics, for example, quantum cryptography and quantum computation, have been investigated by researchers whose number has been increasing day by day in the world. This field became to be called quantum information theories. A practical experimental realization of quantum information processing needs that we detect experimentally multipartite entangled states. The number of researchers for multipartite entangled states is increasing rapidly. Especially, Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) states are useful for quantum information processing information processing using quantum mechanics, which improves the conventional information processing ability which had been based on classical theories. However, practical experimental realization of the theories and controlling quantum states have inevitable difficulties due to the interaction with environments. The requirement in maintaining multipartite entangled states in relation to the time that takes to make a practical experiment is also a problem. Many experimentalists are tackling this problem, and recently, several groups have reported that multipartite entangled states have been physically detected in their laboratories. The main difficulty is how to judge whether or not the observed quantum state is indeed a multipartite entangled state. For this purpose, it is necessary to construct theoretical models to analyze such experimental data. In this thesis, we apply a mathematical structure as to density operators described in a high-dimensional Hilbert space, and we employ mathematical theories to prove if the corresponding density operator represents a multipartite entangled state or not. The main aim for constructing such models is to analyze the raw experimental data. Moreover, this model helps experimentalists in the sense that it allows them to see how to confirm that observed states are indeed the desired state. With mathematical theories developed before this thesis, only limited applications for this purpose were allowed. Some theories cover two-dimensional Hilbert space only. It has not been even discussed how to analyze the fidelity to GHZ states of the observed state. This has led to some doubt of that experimental data might not always confirm three-partite entangled states. However, by using the method of this thesis, statistical check based on such experimental data of the existence of three particle-entangled states is possible under appropriate assumptions. This example symbolizes that our analytical knowledge has improved very much in the last few years. This thesis gives us an advanced mathematical model for analyzing experimental data.

•Jan 1, 2003•0 citations

Universal entanglement detection with geometrically optimal witnesses

Xuanran Zhu, Keyi Huang, Chao Zhang +3 more

Constructing optimal entanglement witnesses for arbitrary quantum systems remains a formidable challenge, hindered by the structural complexity of high-dimensional quantum state spaces. In this work, we overcome this barrier by introducing a unified framework for constructing geometrically optimal witnesses capable of identifying arbitrary entanglement structures. By leveraging the geometric properties of a target quantum state relative to a specific entanglement structure in Hilbert-Schmidt space, these witnesses are constructed in an efficient and effective manner. Among all nontrivial witnesses, they provide maximal distinguishability between the target state and the set of states without the desired entanglement structure. As a result, our approach enables the universal detection of bipartite, multipartite, and high-dimensional entanglement. To demonstrate its experimental feasibility, we apply the framework to a four-qubit nuclear spin quantum system. Compared to existing methods, our approach offers enhanced noise robustness, broader detection universality, and improved construction efficiency, providing a powerful and versatile tool for advancing the characterization and understanding of entanglement in quantum systems.

quant-pharXiv:2610.17592•Physical Review A•Oct 14, 2026•0 citations
Abstract Certifying entanglement for unknown quantum states experimentally is a fundamental problem in quantum computing and quantum physics. Because of being easy to implement, a most popular approach for this problem in modern quantum experiments is detecting target quantum states with fidelity-based entanglement witnesses. Specifically, if the fidelity between a target state and an entangled pure state exceeds a certain value, the target state can be guaranteed to be entangled. Recently, however, it has been realized that there exist so-called unfaithful quantum states, which can be entangled, but their entanglement cannot be certified by any fidelity-based entanglement witnesses. In this paper, by specific examples, we show that if one makes a slight modification to fidelity-based entanglement witnesses by combining multiple fidelities together, it is still possible to certify entanglement for unfaithful quantum states with this popular technique. Particularly, we will analyze the mathematical structure of the modified entanglement witnesses, and propose an algorithm that can search for the optimal designs for them.
Entanglement witness is an effective method to detect entanglement in unknown states without doing full tomography. One of the most widespread schemes of witnessing entanglement is measuring its fidelity with respect to a pure entangled state. Recently, a large class of states whose entanglement can not be detected with the fidelity witness has been discovered in Phys.Rev.Lett \textbf{124},200502(2020). They are called unfaithful states. In this paper we propose a new way to detect entanglement by calculating the lower bound of entanglement using measurement results. Numerical simulation shows our method can detect entanglement in unfaithful states with a small number of measurements. Moreover, we generalize our scheme to multipartite states and show that it can tolerate higher noise than previous entanglement witness operators with same number of measurement settings.
One of the most widespread methods to determine if a quantum state is entangled, or to quantify its entanglement dimensionality, is by measuring its fidelity with respect to a pure state. In this Letter, we find a large class of states whose entanglement cannot be detected in this manner; we call them unfaithful. We find that unfaithful states are ubiquitous in information theory. For small dimensions, we check numerically that most bipartite states are both entangled and unfaithful. Similarly, numerical searches in low dimensions show that most pure entangled states remain entangled but become unfaithful when a certain amount of white noise is added. We also find that faithfulness can be self-activated, i.e., there exist instances of unfaithful states whose tensor powers are faithful. To explore how the fidelity approach limits the quantification of entanglement dimensionality, we generalize the notion of an unfaithful state to that of a D unfaithful state, one that cannot be certified as D-dimensionally entangled by measuring its fidelity with respect to a pure state. For describing such states, we additionally introduce a hierarchy of semidefinite programming relaxations that fully characterizes the set of states of Schmidt rank at most D.
Entanglement detection is one of the most conventional tasks in quantum information processing. While most experimental demonstrations of high-dimensional entanglement rely on fidelity-based witnesses, these are powerless to detect entanglement within a large class of entangled quantum states, the so-called unfaithful states. In this Letter, we introduce a highly flexible automated method to construct optimal tests for entanglement detection given a bipartite target state of arbitrary dimension, faithful or unfaithful, and a set of local measurement operators. By restricting the number or complexity of the considered measurement settings, our method outputs the most convenient protocol which can be implemented using a wide range of experimental techniques such as photons, superconducting qudits, cold atoms, or trapped ions. With an experimental quantum optics setup that can prepare and measure arbitrary high-dimensional mixed states, we implement some three-setting protocols generated by our method. These protocols allow us to experimentally certify two- and three-unfaithful entanglement in four-dimensional photonic states, some of which contain well above 50% of noise.
A conceptually simple and experimentally prevalent class of entanglement witnesses, known as fidelity witnesses, detects entanglement via a state's fidelity with a pure reference state. While existence proofs guarantee that a suitable witness can be constructed for every entangled state, such assurances do not apply to fidelity witnesses. Recent results have found that entangled states that cannot be detected by a fidelity witness, known as unfaithful states, are exceedingly common among bipartite states. In this paper, we show that even among two-qubit states, which are the simplest of all entangled states, unfaithful states can be created through a suitable application of decoherence and filtering to a Bell state. We also show that the faithfulness is not monotonic to entanglement, as measured by the concurrence. Finally, we experimentally verify our predictions using polarization-entangled photons, and specifically we demonstrate a situation in which an unfaithful state is brought to faithfulness at the expense of further reducing the entanglement of the state.
Since the 1980s, there has been a physical problem relating to the detection of multipartite entangled states that helps us to investigate fundamental point of view on interpretations of quantum mechanics. On the other hand, information theories based on the mathematical structure of quantum mechanics, for example, quantum cryptography and quantum computation, have been investigated by researchers whose number has been increasing day by day in the world. This field became to be called quantum information theories. A practical experimental realization of quantum information processing needs that we detect experimentally multipartite entangled states. The number of researchers for multipartite entangled states is increasing rapidly. Especially, Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) states are useful for quantum information processing information processing using quantum mechanics, which improves the conventional information processing ability which had been based on classical theories. However, practical experimental realization of the theories and controlling quantum states have inevitable difficulties due to the interaction with environments. The requirement in maintaining multipartite entangled states in relation to the time that takes to make a practical experiment is also a problem. Many experimentalists are tackling this problem, and recently, several groups have reported that multipartite entangled states have been physically detected in their laboratories. The main difficulty is how to judge whether or not the observed quantum state is indeed a multipartite entangled state. For this purpose, it is necessary to construct theoretical models to analyze such experimental data. In this thesis, we apply a mathematical structure as to density operators described in a high-dimensional Hilbert space, and we employ mathematical theories to prove if the corresponding density operator represents a multipartite entangled state or not. The main aim for constructing such models is to analyze the raw experimental data. Moreover, this model helps experimentalists in the sense that it allows them to see how to confirm that observed states are indeed the desired state. With mathematical theories developed before this thesis, only limited applications for this purpose were allowed. Some theories cover two-dimensional Hilbert space only. It has not been even discussed how to analyze the fidelity to GHZ states of the observed state. This has led to some doubt of that experimental data might not always confirm three-partite entangled states. However, by using the method of this thesis, statistical check based on such experimental data of the existence of three particle-entangled states is possible under appropriate assumptions. This example symbolizes that our analytical knowledge has improved very much in the last few years. This thesis gives us an advanced mathematical model for analyzing experimental data.
Constructing optimal entanglement witnesses for arbitrary quantum systems remains a formidable challenge, hindered by the structural complexity of high-dimensional quantum state spaces. In this work, we overcome this barrier by introducing a unified framework for constructing geometrically optimal witnesses capable of identifying arbitrary entanglement structures. By leveraging the geometric properties of a target quantum state relative to a specific entanglement structure in Hilbert-Schmidt space, these witnesses are constructed in an efficient and effective manner. Among all nontrivial witnesses, they provide maximal distinguishability between the target state and the set of states without the desired entanglement structure. As a result, our approach enables the universal detection of bipartite, multipartite, and high-dimensional entanglement. To demonstrate its experimental feasibility, we apply the framework to a four-qubit nuclear spin quantum system. Compared to existing methods, our approach offers enhanced noise robustness, broader detection universality, and improved construction efficiency, providing a powerful and versatile tool for advancing the characterization and understanding of entanglement in quantum systems.