Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2409.13008 · Machine Learning Science and Technology

Quantum resources of quantum and classical variational methods

Thomas Spriggs, Arash Ahmadi, Bokai Chen, Eliška Greplová

Published Jan 21, 2025• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract Variational techniques have long been at the heart of atomic, solid-state, and many-body physics. They have recently extended to quantum and classical machine learning, providing a basis for representing quantum states via neural networks. These methods generally aim to minimize the energy of a given ansatz, though open questions remain about the expressivity of quantum and classical variational ansätze. The connection between variational techniques and quantum computing, through variational quantum algorithms, offers opportunities to explore the quantum complexity of classical methods. We demonstrate how the concept of non-stabilizerness, or magic, can create a bridge between quantum information and variational techniques and we show that energy accuracy is a necessary but not always sufficient condition for accuracy in non-stabilizerness. Through systematic benchmarking of neural network quantum states, matrix product states, and variational quantum methods, we show that while classical techniques are more accurate in non-stabilizerness, not accounting for the symmetries of the system can have a severe impact on this accuracy. Our findings form a basis for a universal expressivity characterization of both quantum and classical variational methods.

DOI
10.1088/2632-2153/adaca2

Related papers

Advancements in numerical methods for quantum resources

Sven Benjamin Kožić, Gianpaolo Torre, S. M. Giampaolo

Abstract The evolution of statistical physics from its mid-twentieth-century roots to its modern interplay with quantum information (QI) has reshaped how complex many-body systems are modeled and quantified. Classical tools now coexist with quantum-mechanical concepts like entanglement, coherence, and non-stabilizerness, which function as resources in the operational framework of quantum resource theories. As a case study, we present a recent numerical approach based on tensor cross interpolation (TCI) for computing resource measures that conceptually consolidates ideas that underlie modern computational techniques. Motivated by this, we survey numerical methods for evaluating quantum resources in many-body systems, emphasizing what scales to large sizes in practice. We organize the discussion around three families: subspace decomposition (Krylov methods, tensor networks (TNs)), stochastic sampling (Monte Carlo), and learning-based models (neural quantum states), and outline how each supports the evaluation of entanglement, non-stabilizerness (magic), and coherence. We provide a concise comparison that summarizes available measures and highlights current open problems and perspectives.

Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Classical Quantum Optimization with Neural Network Quantum States

Joseph Gomes, Keri A. McKiernan, Peter K. Eastman +1 more

The classical simulation of quantum systems typically requires exponential resources. Recently, the introduction of a machine learning-based wavefunction ansatz has led to the ability to solve the quantum many-body problem in regimes that had previously been intractable for existing exact numerical methods. Here, we demonstrate the utility of the variational representation of quantum states based on artificial neural networks for performing quantum optimization. We show empirically that this methodology achieves high approximation ratio solutions with polynomial classical computing resources for a range of instances of the Maximum Cut (MaxCut) problem whose solutions have been encoded into the ground state of quantum many-body systems up to and including 256 qubits.

arXiv:1910.10675•Oct 23, 2019•17 citations

Quantum-Classical Neural Networks for Solving Lindblad Master Equations

Rafael Florencio Díaz, Julio Guerrero García, Elvira Romera Gutiérrez

Variational quantum algorithms have emerged as a promising approach for simulating open quantum systems, yet their expressive power and trainability remain poorly understood. We propose a variational framework for solving Lindblad master equations by minimizing a residual cost function using a compositional ansatz obtained by combining a classical neural network with a parameterized quantum circuit. The density matrix is represented through a purification on an enlarged Hilbert space, ensuring positivity, Hermiticity, and unit trace by construction, while all gradients are evaluated exactly via the parameter-shift rule. Beyond the algorithmic formulation, we derive an upper bound for the covering number of the proposed compositional model and compare it with that of purely quantum neural networks. Our analysis shows that the classical parametrization enlarges the effective hypothesis class while providing finer control over its complexity, thereby establishing a theoretical connection between expressivity, covering numbers, effective dimension, and the barren plateau phenomenon. Numerical experiments validate both the accuracy of the proposed method for representative Lindblad master equations and the theoretical predictions regarding gradient concentration. These results provide a unified variational and theoretical framework for the simulation of dissipative quantum dynamics using compositional quantum machine learning models.

quant-pharXiv:2610.22691•Oct 19, 2026•0 citations

Quantum neural network quantum state

Xin Pang, Yanan Li, Zhimin Wang

Quantum many-body computation is a central challenge across multiple domains of scientific research, and Monte Carlo method has emerged as one of the most effective numerical techniques for investigating large-scale many-body systems. In recent years, the integration of Monte Carlo methods with machine learning has led to the development of neural quantum state approach. Quantum neural networks (QNNs) offer superior expressiveness compared to classical neural networks. In this paper, we propose a novel Quantum Neural Network Quantum State (QNNQS) method, based on the variational Monte Carlo framework. This approach leverages a quantum neural network to represent the many-body quantum state, and optimizes it iteratively through gradient descent to determine the ground-state energy. To assess the performance of this method, we conduct simulations of the one-dimensional transverse-field Ising model, investigating the influence of quantum circuit architecture on circuit expressibility, entangling capability, and computational accuracy. The results demonstrate that the QNNQS method achieves comparable simulation accuracy while utilizing significantly fewer parameters and requiring less training resources than classical network quantum state methods.

International Conference on Algorithms, Network, and Communication Technology (ICANCT)•Mar 3, 2025•2 citations

Hybrid Quantum-Classical Neural Networks and its Hyperparameter Optimization-A Study

R Adithya, Joyline Dsa, Adarsh Rag S +1 more

In recent years, the field of machine learning has witnessed a paradigm shift with the emergence of hybrid quantum-classical neural networks. These networks combine the power of classical neural networks with the computational advantages offered by quantum variational circuits. This study presents a comprehensive survey of hybrid quantum-classical machine learning algorithms, focusing on their architecture, performance, and hyperparameter optimization techniques. Introducing the concept of hybrid quantum-classical machine learning and its significance in contemporary image classification tasks. It explores the theoretical foundations of quantum variational circuits and their integration with classical neural network architectures. Special attention is given to prominent algorithms such as Quantum Convolutional Neural Networks, Quanvolutional Neural Networks, and Quantum ResNet, each offering unique advantages in image classification tasks. A major aspect covered in this study is the hyperparameter optimization techniques employed in hybrid quantum-classical machine learning. The chapter discusses quantum-inspired optimization methods tailored for efficiently tuning the hyperparameters of complex neural network models. Through comparative analysis, the effectiveness of these optimization techniques is demonstrated in reducing computational overhead and improving model performance. Moreover, the study also delves into experimental results obtained from benchmarking hybrid quantum-classical models against traditional classical approaches. It highlights the accuracy variations observed across different quantum architectures and explores the impact of architectural permutations on model convergence. Insights gained from these experiments provide valuable guidance for researchers and practitioners seeking to leverage hybrid quantum-classical neural networks in real-world applications.

International Conference on Computing, Semiconductor, Mechatronics, Intelligent Systems and Communications (COSMIC)•Nov 22, 2024•1 citation

Simulating quantum dynamics: neural-network quantum states, open quantum systems, and quantum devices

Gravina, Luca

This thesis investigates quantum many-body systems in and out of equilibrium, with a dual focus on open-system theory and advanced computational methods. Taken together, the results articulate a unifying perspective: in both classical/analog simulations and digital algorithms for many-body quantum systems, the relevant physics often concentrates in small, dynamically selected pockets of the Liouville or Hilbert space. By exposing this structure - whether as noise-protected logical manifolds in bosonic modes, low-rank sectors of the density operator during open evolution, or expressive submanifolds learned by neural networks - and by designing algorithms that operate within these reduced subspaces, the thesis advances hardware-aware encoding strategies, scalable open-system simulation, and dependable neural-network-based variational Monte Carlo methods. The manuscript presents three original contributions: (i) a Liouville-space framework that leverages symmetries and spectral diagnostics to engineer dissipation as a resource for bosonic quantum information; (ii) a low-rank, time-dependent variational method for simulating Lindblad dynamics with adaptive error control; and (iii) methodological advances for Neural Quantum States that stabilize Monte-Carloâ driven optimization and enable reliable ground-state and dynamical calculations. These three directions structure the three main chapters of the thesis. Each chapter includes a focused, self-contained review of the necessary background, not as a textbook survey but as a coherent theoretical scaffold framing the proposed advances.

•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations
Abstract Variational techniques have long been at the heart of atomic, solid-state, and many-body physics. They have recently extended to quantum and classical machine learning, providing a basis for representing quantum states via neural networks. These methods generally aim to minimize the energy of a given ansatz, though open questions remain about the expressivity of quantum and classical variational ansätze. The connection between variational techniques and quantum computing, through variational quantum algorithms, offers opportunities to explore the quantum complexity of classical methods. We demonstrate how the concept of non-stabilizerness, or magic, can create a bridge between quantum information and variational techniques and we show that energy accuracy is a necessary but not always sufficient condition for accuracy in non-stabilizerness. Through systematic benchmarking of neural network quantum states, matrix product states, and variational quantum methods, we show that while classical techniques are more accurate in non-stabilizerness, not accounting for the symmetries of the system can have a severe impact on this accuracy. Our findings form a basis for a universal expressivity characterization of both quantum and classical variational methods.
Abstract The evolution of statistical physics from its mid-twentieth-century roots to its modern interplay with quantum information (QI) has reshaped how complex many-body systems are modeled and quantified. Classical tools now coexist with quantum-mechanical concepts like entanglement, coherence, and non-stabilizerness, which function as resources in the operational framework of quantum resource theories. As a case study, we present a recent numerical approach based on tensor cross interpolation (TCI) for computing resource measures that conceptually consolidates ideas that underlie modern computational techniques. Motivated by this, we survey numerical methods for evaluating quantum resources in many-body systems, emphasizing what scales to large sizes in practice. We organize the discussion around three families: subspace decomposition (Krylov methods, tensor networks (TNs)), stochastic sampling (Monte Carlo), and learning-based models (neural quantum states), and outline how each supports the evaluation of entanglement, non-stabilizerness (magic), and coherence. We provide a concise comparison that summarizes available measures and highlights current open problems and perspectives.
The classical simulation of quantum systems typically requires exponential resources. Recently, the introduction of a machine learning-based wavefunction ansatz has led to the ability to solve the quantum many-body problem in regimes that had previously been intractable for existing exact numerical methods. Here, we demonstrate the utility of the variational representation of quantum states based on artificial neural networks for performing quantum optimization. We show empirically that this methodology achieves high approximation ratio solutions with polynomial classical computing resources for a range of instances of the Maximum Cut (MaxCut) problem whose solutions have been encoded into the ground state of quantum many-body systems up to and including 256 qubits.
Variational quantum algorithms have emerged as a promising approach for simulating open quantum systems, yet their expressive power and trainability remain poorly understood. We propose a variational framework for solving Lindblad master equations by minimizing a residual cost function using a compositional ansatz obtained by combining a classical neural network with a parameterized quantum circuit. The density matrix is represented through a purification on an enlarged Hilbert space, ensuring positivity, Hermiticity, and unit trace by construction, while all gradients are evaluated exactly via the parameter-shift rule. Beyond the algorithmic formulation, we derive an upper bound for the covering number of the proposed compositional model and compare it with that of purely quantum neural networks. Our analysis shows that the classical parametrization enlarges the effective hypothesis class while providing finer control over its complexity, thereby establishing a theoretical connection between expressivity, covering numbers, effective dimension, and the barren plateau phenomenon. Numerical experiments validate both the accuracy of the proposed method for representative Lindblad master equations and the theoretical predictions regarding gradient concentration. These results provide a unified variational and theoretical framework for the simulation of dissipative quantum dynamics using compositional quantum machine learning models.
Quantum many-body computation is a central challenge across multiple domains of scientific research, and Monte Carlo method has emerged as one of the most effective numerical techniques for investigating large-scale many-body systems. In recent years, the integration of Monte Carlo methods with machine learning has led to the development of neural quantum state approach. Quantum neural networks (QNNs) offer superior expressiveness compared to classical neural networks. In this paper, we propose a novel Quantum Neural Network Quantum State (QNNQS) method, based on the variational Monte Carlo framework. This approach leverages a quantum neural network to represent the many-body quantum state, and optimizes it iteratively through gradient descent to determine the ground-state energy. To assess the performance of this method, we conduct simulations of the one-dimensional transverse-field Ising model, investigating the influence of quantum circuit architecture on circuit expressibility, entangling capability, and computational accuracy. The results demonstrate that the QNNQS method achieves comparable simulation accuracy while utilizing significantly fewer parameters and requiring less training resources than classical network quantum state methods.
In recent years, the field of machine learning has witnessed a paradigm shift with the emergence of hybrid quantum-classical neural networks. These networks combine the power of classical neural networks with the computational advantages offered by quantum variational circuits. This study presents a comprehensive survey of hybrid quantum-classical machine learning algorithms, focusing on their architecture, performance, and hyperparameter optimization techniques. Introducing the concept of hybrid quantum-classical machine learning and its significance in contemporary image classification tasks. It explores the theoretical foundations of quantum variational circuits and their integration with classical neural network architectures. Special attention is given to prominent algorithms such as Quantum Convolutional Neural Networks, Quanvolutional Neural Networks, and Quantum ResNet, each offering unique advantages in image classification tasks. A major aspect covered in this study is the hyperparameter optimization techniques employed in hybrid quantum-classical machine learning. The chapter discusses quantum-inspired optimization methods tailored for efficiently tuning the hyperparameters of complex neural network models. Through comparative analysis, the effectiveness of these optimization techniques is demonstrated in reducing computational overhead and improving model performance. Moreover, the study also delves into experimental results obtained from benchmarking hybrid quantum-classical models against traditional classical approaches. It highlights the accuracy variations observed across different quantum architectures and explores the impact of architectural permutations on model convergence. Insights gained from these experiments provide valuable guidance for researchers and practitioners seeking to leverage hybrid quantum-classical neural networks in real-world applications.
This thesis investigates quantum many-body systems in and out of equilibrium, with a dual focus on open-system theory and advanced computational methods. Taken together, the results articulate a unifying perspective: in both classical/analog simulations and digital algorithms for many-body quantum systems, the relevant physics often concentrates in small, dynamically selected pockets of the Liouville or Hilbert space. By exposing this structure - whether as noise-protected logical manifolds in bosonic modes, low-rank sectors of the density operator during open evolution, or expressive submanifolds learned by neural networks - and by designing algorithms that operate within these reduced subspaces, the thesis advances hardware-aware encoding strategies, scalable open-system simulation, and dependable neural-network-based variational Monte Carlo methods. The manuscript presents three original contributions: (i) a Liouville-space framework that leverages symmetries and spectral diagnostics to engineer dissipation as a resource for bosonic quantum information; (ii) a low-rank, time-dependent variational method for simulating Lindblad dynamics with adaptive error control; and (iii) methodological advances for Neural Quantum States that stabilize Monte-Carloâ driven optimization and enable reliable ground-state and dynamical calculations. These three directions structure the three main chapters of the thesis. Each chapter includes a focused, self-contained review of the necessary background, not as a textbook survey but as a coherent theoretical scaffold framing the proposed advances.