Abstract The transition from unitary, reversible von Neumann-Everett quantum processes to non-unitary, irreversible processes and measurements is explored through infinite tensor products interpreted as nested, chained, or iterated Wigner’s friend scenarios. Infinite tensor products can disrupt unitary equivalence through sectorization and factorization, drawing parallels to concepts from real analysis, recursive mathematics, and statistical physics.
Abstract The transition from unitary, reversible von Neumann-Everett quantum processes to non-unitary, irreversible processes and measurements is explored through infinite tensor products interpreted as nested, chained, or iterated Wigner’s friend scenarios. Infinite tensor products can disrupt unitary equivalence through sectorization and factorization, drawing parallels to concepts from real analysis, recursive mathematics, and statistical physics.
Infinity is central to deriving macroscopic irreversibility from reversible microscopic laws across mathematics, theoretical computer science and physics. In analysis, infinite processes—such as Dedekind cuts and Cauchy sequences—construct real numbers as equivalence classes of rational approximations, bridging discrete rationals to the continuous real line. In quantum mechanics, infinite tensor products model nested measurements, where sectorization partitions the Hilbert space into equivalence classes, reconciling unitary evolution with wavefunction collapse. In statistical mechanics, macrostates emerge as equivalence classes of microstates sharing identical macroscopic properties, providing the statistical basis for thermodynamic irreversibility despite reversible dynamics. Equivalence relations formalize For-All-Practical-Purposes (FAPP) indistinguishability, reflecting operational limits on precision and observation. Together, these examples reveal a unified framework where infinity and equivalence underpin emergent macroscopic behavior from microscopic reversibility.
Wigner-friend scenarios -- in which external agents describe a closed laboratory containing a friend making a measurement -- highlight the difficulties inherent to quantum theory when accounting for measurements. In non-relativistic scenarios, the difficulty is to accommodate unitary evolution for a closed system with a definite outcome obtained by the friend. In relativistic scenarios the tensions between quantum theory and relativity induce additional constraints. A generic property of relativistic scenarios is the frame-dependence of state update upon a measurement. Based on a definite example, we will show that this property leads to inconsistent accounts for outcomes obtained in different reference frames. We will further argue that these results point to some fundamental inadequacy when attempting to model actions taken by a complex agent as unitary operations made on simple wavefunctions.
Mathematical foundation of the novel concept of quantum tensor product by Zanardi et al is rigorously established. The concept of relative quantum entanglement is naturally introduced and its meaning is made clear both mathematically and physically. For a finite or an infinite dimensional vector space W the so called tensor product partition (TPP) is introduced on End(W), the set of endmorphisms of W, and a natural correspondence is constructed between the set of TPP's of End(W) and the set of tensor product structures (TPS's) of W. As a byproduct, it is shown that an arbitrarily given wave function belonging to an n-dimensional Hilbert space, n being not a prime number, can be interpreted as a separable state with respect to some man-made TPS, and thus a quantum entangled state of a many-body system with respect to the "God-given" TPS can be regarded as a quantum state without entanglement in some sense. The concept of standard set of observables is also introduced to probe the underlying structure of the object TPP and to establish its connection with practical physical measurement.
We revisit von Neumann's theory of infinite tensor products of Hilbert spaces. On the set Γ of equivalence classes of C0-sequences, which labels the incomplete tensor products inside the complete tensor product, we introduce a natural pseudo-ultrametric d: the distance between two classes is the convergence exponent of the series ∑j∣⟨φj,ψj⟩−1∣ formed from any pair of representatives. We show that d is well defined on equivalence classes, satisfies the strong triangle inequality, and is complete. Distinct classes may lie at distance zero, so d separates points only after passing to the quotient Γ of Γ by the relation d=0; the pair (Γ,d) is then a complete ultrametric space. As an application, we show that a product unitary ⨂jU whose factor U satisfies inf∥x∥=1∣⟨x,Ux⟩−1∣>0 (in particular, a unitary on a finite dimensional space with 1∈/σ(U)) displaces every class to the maximal distance 1. Guided by the intended application -- a caricature of Everettian branching, in which the sectors of the infinite tensor product play the role of worlds -- we also develop a gauge-invariant variant d~ of the metric, based on von Neumann's weak equivalence and matched to the quasi-equivalence of product states on the quasi-local algebra. The displacement of a class under a product unitary, measured by d~, is class dependent and realizes every value in [0,1]. We interpret d~ as a decoherence exponent: it measures the polynomial rate at which two branches of the universal state vector become operationally distinct as ever larger portions of the environment are monitored.
``The unambiguous account of proper quantum phenomena must, in principle, include a description of all relevant features of experimental arrangement'' (Bohr). The measurement process is composed of premeasurement (quantum correlation of the system with the pointer variable) and an irreversible decoherence via interaction with an environment. The system ends up in a probabilistic mixture of the eigenstates of the measured observable. For the premeasurement stage, any attempt to introduce an ``outcome'' leads, as we show, to a logical contradiction, 1=i. This nullifies claims that a modified concept of Wigner's friend, who just premeasures, can lead to valid results concerning quantum theory.
In Section 2.4 we learned that a composite quantum system, composed of two subsystems A and B , is associated with a tensor product space HA ? HB . Composite quantum systems have already played an important role in many instances in this text, especially in open systems and measurement models. In this chapter we dive deeper into tensor product spaces, discovering some strange implications of the quantum theory of composite quantum systems. As a result of its tensor product structure, quantum theory has embedded into it the phenomenon of entanglement , which is often seen as the foremost quantum feature. As early as in 1935 it puzzled Erwin Schrödinger, who introduced the German term Verschränkung [127] and Albert Einstein, who, together with Boris Podolski and Nathan Rosen, used the specific example of an entangled state to argue that quantum theory is incomplete [58]. In the 1960s John Bell demonstrated that the consequences of entanglement are incompatible with the Einstein– Podolsky–Rosen model of local realism [11], [12]. In recent years entanglement has been recognized as the resource for quantum information processing. Nowadays entanglement theory is a highly developed subject, and we can present only the mathematical basics. For the reader with a deeper interest in entanglement we recommend the recent reviews by Horodecki et al . [80] and Plenio et al . [118], which also cover the quantum information aspects of entanglement. To simplify our discussion we will assume that the Hilbert spaces are finite dimensional.