Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2408.16406

Improved Circuit Lower Bounds and Quantum-Classical Separations

Sabee Grewal, Vinayak M. Kumar

Published Aug 29, 2024• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We continue the study of the circuit class GC^0, which augments AC^0 with unbounded-fan-in gates that compute arbitrary functions inside a sufficiently small Hamming ball but must be constant outside it. While GC^0 can compute functions requiring exponential-size circuits, Kumar (CCC 2023) showed that switching-lemma lower bounds for AC^0 extend to GC^0 with no loss in parameters. We prove a parallel result for the polynomial method: any lower bound for AC^0[p] obtained via the polynomial method extends to GC^0[p] without loss in parameters. As a consequence, we show that the majority function MAJ requires depth-$d$ GC^0[p] circuits of size $2^{Ω(n^{1/2(d-1)})}$, matching the best-known lower bounds for AC^0[p]. This yields the most expressive class of non-monotone circuits for which exponential-size lower bounds are known for an explicit function. We also prove a similar result for the algorithmic method, showing that E^NP requires exponential-size GCC^0 circuits, extending a result of Williams (JACM 2014). Finally, leveraging our improved classical lower bounds, we establish the strongest known unconditional separations between quantum and classical circuit classes. We separate QNC^0 from GC^0 and GC^0[p] in various settings and show that BQLOGTIME is not contained in GC^0. As a consequence, we construct an oracle relative to which BQP lies outside uniform GC^0, extending the Raz-Tal oracle separation between BQP and PH (STOC 2019).

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2408.16406

Related papers

Improved Lower Bounds for QAC0

Malvika Raj Joshi, Avishay Tal, Francisca Vasconcelos +1 more

In this work, we prove the strongest known lower bounds for QAC$^0$, allowing polynomially many gates and ancillae. Our main results show that: (1) Depth-3 QAC$^0$ circuits cannot compute PARITY, and require $Ω(\exp(\sqrt{n}))$ gates to compute MAJORITY. (2) Depth-2 circuits cannot approximate high-influence Boolean functions (e.g., PARITY) with non-negligible advantage, regardless of size. We develop new classical simulation techniques for QAC$^0$ to obtain our depth-3 bounds. In these results, we relax the output requirement of the quantum circuit to a single bit, making our depth $2$ approximation bound stronger than the previous best bound of Rosenthal (2021). This also enables us to draw natural comparisons with classical AC$^0$ circuits, which can compute PARITY exactly in depth $2$ (exp size). Our techniques further suggest that, for boolean total functions, constant-depth quantum circuits do not necessarily provide more power than their classical counterparts. Our third result shows that depth $2$ QAC$^0$ circuits, regardless of size, cannot exactly synthesize an $n$-target nekomata state (a state whose synthesis is directly related to the computation of PARITY). This complements the depth $2$ exponential size upper bound of Rosenthal (2021) for approximating nekomatas (which is used as a sub-circuit in the only known constant depth PARITY upper bound). Finally, we argue that approximating PARITY in QAC0, with significantly better than 1/poly(n) advantage on average, is just as hard as computing it exactly. Thus, extending our techniques to higher depths would also rule out approximate circuits for PARITY and related problems

quant-pharXiv:2512.14643•ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing (STOC)•Dec 17, 2025•6 citations

The Large-Error Approximate Degree of AC^0

Mark Bun, Justin Thaler

We prove two new results about the inability of low-degree polynomials to uniformly approximate constant-depth circuits, even to slightly-better-than-trivial error. First, we prove a tight Omega~(n^{1/2}) lower bound on the threshold degree of the SURJECTIVITY function on n variables. This matches the best known threshold degree bound for any AC^0 function, previously exhibited by a much more complicated circuit of larger depth (Sherstov, FOCS 2015). Our result also extends to a 2^{Omega~(n^{1/2})} lower bound on the sign-rank of an AC^0 function, improving on the previous best bound of 2^{Omega(n^{2/5})} (Bun and Thaler, ICALP 2016). Second, for any delta>0, we exhibit a function f : {-1,1}^n -> {-1,1} that is computed by a circuit of depth O(1/delta) and is hard to approximate by polynomials in the following sense: f cannot be uniformly approximated to error epsilon=1-2^{-Omega(n^{1-delta})}, even by polynomials of degree n^{1-delta}. Our recent prior work (Bun and Thaler, FOCS 2017) proved a similar lower bound, but which held only for error epsilon=1/3. Our result implies 2^{Omega(n^{1-delta})} lower bounds on the complexity of AC^0 under a variety of basic measures such as discrepancy, margin complexity, and threshold weight. This nearly matches the trivial upper bound of 2^{O(n)} that holds for every function. The previous best lower bound on AC^0 for these measures was 2^{Omega(n^{1/2})} (Sherstov, FOCS 2015). Additional applications in learning theory, communication complexity, and cryptography are described.

Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•Jan 1, 2019•3 citations

$\mathsf{QAC}^0$ Contains $\mathsf{TC}^0$ (with Many Copies of the Input)

Daniel Grier, Jackson Morris, Kewen Wu

$\mathsf{QAC}^0$ is the class of constant-depth polynomial-size quantum circuits constructed from arbitrary single-qubit gates and generalized Toffoli gates. It is arguably the smallest natural class of constant-depth quantum computation which has not been shown useful for computing any non-trivial Boolean function. Despite this, many attempts to port classical $\mathsf{AC}^0$ lower bounds to $\mathsf{QAC}^0$ have failed. We give one possible explanation of this: $\mathsf{QAC}^0$ circuits are significantly more powerful than their classical counterparts. We show the unconditional separation $\mathsf{QAC}^0\not\subset\mathsf{AC}^0[p]$ for decision problems, which also resolves for the first time whether $\mathsf{AC}^0$ could be more powerful than $\mathsf{QAC}^0$. Moreover, we prove that $\mathsf{QAC}^0$ circuits can compute a wide range of Boolean functions if given multiple copies of the input: $\mathsf{TC}^0 \subseteq \mathsf{QAC}^0 \circ \mathsf{NC}^0$. Along the way, we introduce an amplitude amplification technique that makes several approximate constant-depth constructions exact.

cs.CCCross-listedarXiv:2601.03243•Jan 7, 2026•10 citations

The Power of Shallow-depth Toffoli and Qudit Quantum Circuits

Alex B. Grilo, Elham Kashefi, Damian Markham +1 more

The relevance of shallow-depth quantum circuits has recently increased, mainly due to their applicability to near-term devices. In this context, one of the main goals of quantum circuit complexity is to find problems that can be solved by quantum shallow circuits but require more computational resources classically. Our first contribution in this work is to prove new separations between classical and quantum constant-depth circuits. Firstly, we show a separation between constant-depth quantum circuits with quantum advice \(\mathsf {QNC}^0/\mathsf {qpoly} \) , and \(\mathsf {AC}^0[p] \) , which is the class of classical constant-depth circuits with unbounded-fan in and \(\mathsf {MOD}_{p} \) gates. Additionally, we show a separation between \(\mathsf {QAC}^0 \) , the circuit class containing Toffoli gates with unbounded control, and \(\mathsf {AC}^0[p] \) , when \(\mathsf {QAC}^0 \) is augmented with additional mid-circuit measurements and classical fanout. This establishes the first such separation for a shallow-depth quantum class that does not involve quantum fanout gates, while relying solely on finite quantum gate sets. Equivalently, this yields a separation between \(\mathsf {AC}^0[p] \) and \([\mathsf {QNC}^0, \mathsf {AC}^0]^2 \) , i.e., shallow quantum circuits interleaved with simple classical computation. Secondly, we consider \(\mathsf {QNC}^0 \) circuits with infinite-size gate sets. We show that these circuits, along with quantum prime modular gates or classical prime modular gates in combination with classical fanout, can implement threshold gates, showing that \(\mathsf {QNC}^0[p]=\mathsf {QTC}^0 \) . Finally, we also show that in the infinite-size gate set case, these quantum circuit classes for higher-dimensional Hilbert spaces do not offer any advantage to standard qubit implementations.

arXiv:2404.18104•ACM Transactions on Quantum Computing•May 18, 2026•9 citations

Oracle Separation between Noisy Quantum Polynomial Time and the Polynomial Hierarchy

Nai-Hui Chia, Min-Hsiu Hsieh, Hung, Shih-Han +1 more

This work investigates the oracle separation between the physically motivated complexity class of noisy quantum circuits, inspired by definitions such as those presented by Chen, Cotler, Huang, and Li (2022). We establish that with a constant error rate, separation can be achieved in terms of NP. When the error rate is $Ω(\log n/n)$, we can extend this result to the separation of PH. Notably, our oracles, in all separations, do not necessitate error correction schemes or fault tolerance, as all quantum circuits are of constant depth. This indicates that even quantum computers with minor errors, without error correction, may surpass classical complexity classes under various scenarios and assumptions. We also explore various common noise settings and present new classical hardness results, generalizing those found in studies by Raz and Tal (2022) and Bassirian, Bouland, Fefferman, Gunn, and Tal (2021), which are of independent interest.

arXiv:2405.07137•May 12, 2024•5 citations

Oracle separations of hybrid quantum-classical circuits

Atul Singh Arora, Alexandru Gheorghiu, Singh, Uttam

An important theoretical problem in the study of quantum computation, that is also practically relevant in the context of near-term quantum devices, is to understand the computational power of hybrid models, that combine poly-time classical computation with short-depth quantum computation. Here, we consider two such models: CQ_d which captures the scenario of a polynomial-time classical algorithm that queries a d-depth quantum computer many times; and QC_d which is more analogous to measurement-based quantum computation and captures the scenario of a d-depth quantum computer with the ability to change the sequence of gates being applied depending on measurement outcomes processed by a classical computation. Chia, Chung & Lai (STOC 2020) and Coudron & Menda (STOC 2020) showed that these models (with d=log^O(1) (n)) are strictly weaker than BQP (the class of problems solvable by poly-time quantum computation), relative to an oracle, disproving a conjecture of Jozsa in the relativised world. We show that, despite the similarities between CQ_d and QC_d, the two models are incomparable, i.e. CQ_d $\nsubseteq$ QC_d and QC_d $\nsubseteq$ CQ_d relative to an oracle. In other words, there exist problems that one model can solve but not the other and vice versa. We do this by considering new oracle problems that capture the distinctions between the two models and by introducing the notion of an intrinsically stochastic oracle, an oracle whose responses are inherently randomised, which is used for our second result. While we leave showing the second separation relative to a standard oracle as an open problem, we believe the notion of stochastic oracles could be of independent interest for studying complexity classes which have resisted separation in the standard oracle model. Our constructions also yield simpler oracle separations between the hybrid models and BQP, compared to earlier works.

arXiv:2201.01904•Jan 6, 2022•13 citations
We continue the study of the circuit class GC^0, which augments AC^0 with unbounded-fan-in gates that compute arbitrary functions inside a sufficiently small Hamming ball but must be constant outside it. While GC^0 can compute functions requiring exponential-size circuits, Kumar (CCC 2023) showed that switching-lemma lower bounds for AC^0 extend to GC^0 with no loss in parameters. We prove a parallel result for the polynomial method: any lower bound for AC^0[p] obtained via the polynomial method extends to GC^0[p] without loss in parameters. As a consequence, we show that the majority function MAJ requires depth-ddd GC^0[p] circuits of size 2Ω(n1/2(d−1))2^{Ω(n^{1/2(d-1)})}2Ω(n1/2(d−1)), matching the best-known lower bounds for AC^0[p]. This yields the most expressive class of non-monotone circuits for which exponential-size lower bounds are known for an explicit function. We also prove a similar result for the algorithmic method, showing that E^NP requires exponential-size GCC^0 circuits, extending a result of Williams (JACM 2014). Finally, leveraging our improved classical lower bounds, we establish the strongest known unconditional separations between quantum and classical circuit classes. We separate QNC^0 from GC^0 and GC^0[p] in various settings and show that BQLOGTIME is not contained in GC^0. As a consequence, we construct an oracle relative to which BQP lies outside uniform GC^0, extending the Raz-Tal oracle separation between BQP and PH (STOC 2019).
In this work, we prove the strongest known lower bounds for QAC0^00, allowing polynomially many gates and ancillae. Our main results show that: (1) Depth-3 QAC0^00 circuits cannot compute PARITY, and require Ω(exp⁡(n))Ω(\exp(\sqrt{n}))Ω(exp(n​)) gates to compute MAJORITY. (2) Depth-2 circuits cannot approximate high-influence Boolean functions (e.g., PARITY) with non-negligible advantage, regardless of size. We develop new classical simulation techniques for QAC0^00 to obtain our depth-3 bounds. In these results, we relax the output requirement of the quantum circuit to a single bit, making our depth 222 approximation bound stronger than the previous best bound of Rosenthal (2021). This also enables us to draw natural comparisons with classical AC0^00 circuits, which can compute PARITY exactly in depth 222 (exp size). Our techniques further suggest that, for boolean total functions, constant-depth quantum circuits do not necessarily provide more power than their classical counterparts. Our third result shows that depth 222 QAC0^00 circuits, regardless of size, cannot exactly synthesize an nnn-target nekomata state (a state whose synthesis is directly related to the computation of PARITY). This complements the depth 222 exponential size upper bound of Rosenthal (2021) for approximating nekomatas (which is used as a sub-circuit in the only known constant depth PARITY upper bound). Finally, we argue that approximating PARITY in QAC0, with significantly better than 1/poly(n) advantage on average, is just as hard as computing it exactly. Thus, extending our techniques to higher depths would also rule out approximate circuits for PARITY and related problems
We prove two new results about the inability of low-degree polynomials to uniformly approximate constant-depth circuits, even to slightly-better-than-trivial error. First, we prove a tight Omega~(n^{1/2}) lower bound on the threshold degree of the SURJECTIVITY function on n variables. This matches the best known threshold degree bound for any AC^0 function, previously exhibited by a much more complicated circuit of larger depth (Sherstov, FOCS 2015). Our result also extends to a 2^{Omega~(n^{1/2})} lower bound on the sign-rank of an AC^0 function, improving on the previous best bound of 2^{Omega(n^{2/5})} (Bun and Thaler, ICALP 2016). Second, for any delta>0, we exhibit a function f : {-1,1}^n -> {-1,1} that is computed by a circuit of depth O(1/delta) and is hard to approximate by polynomials in the following sense: f cannot be uniformly approximated to error epsilon=1-2^{-Omega(n^{1-delta})}, even by polynomials of degree n^{1-delta}. Our recent prior work (Bun and Thaler, FOCS 2017) proved a similar lower bound, but which held only for error epsilon=1/3. Our result implies 2^{Omega(n^{1-delta})} lower bounds on the complexity of AC^0 under a variety of basic measures such as discrepancy, margin complexity, and threshold weight. This nearly matches the trivial upper bound of 2^{O(n)} that holds for every function. The previous best lower bound on AC^0 for these measures was 2^{Omega(n^{1/2})} (Sherstov, FOCS 2015). Additional applications in learning theory, communication complexity, and cryptography are described.
QAC0\mathsf{QAC}^0QAC0 Contains TC0\mathsf{TC}^0TC0 (with Many Copies of the Input)
QAC0\mathsf{QAC}^0QAC0 is the class of constant-depth polynomial-size quantum circuits constructed from arbitrary single-qubit gates and generalized Toffoli gates. It is arguably the smallest natural class of constant-depth quantum computation which has not been shown useful for computing any non-trivial Boolean function. Despite this, many attempts to port classical AC0\mathsf{AC}^0AC0 lower bounds to QAC0\mathsf{QAC}^0QAC0 have failed. We give one possible explanation of this: QAC0\mathsf{QAC}^0QAC0 circuits are significantly more powerful than their classical counterparts. We show the unconditional separation QAC0⊄AC0[p]\mathsf{QAC}^0\not\subset\mathsf{AC}^0[p]QAC0⊂AC0[p] for decision problems, which also resolves for the first time whether AC0\mathsf{AC}^0AC0 could be more powerful than QAC0\mathsf{QAC}^0QAC0. Moreover, we prove that QAC0\mathsf{QAC}^0QAC0 circuits can compute a wide range of Boolean functions if given multiple copies of the input: TC0⊆QAC0∘NC0\mathsf{TC}^0 \subseteq \mathsf{QAC}^0 \circ \mathsf{NC}^0TC0⊆QAC0∘NC0. Along the way, we introduce an amplitude amplification technique that makes several approximate constant-depth constructions exact.
The relevance of shallow-depth quantum circuits has recently increased, mainly due to their applicability to near-term devices. In this context, one of the main goals of quantum circuit complexity is to find problems that can be solved by quantum shallow circuits but require more computational resources classically. Our first contribution in this work is to prove new separations between classical and quantum constant-depth circuits. Firstly, we show a separation between constant-depth quantum circuits with quantum advice QNC0/qpoly\mathsf {QNC}^0/\mathsf {qpoly} QNC0/qpoly , and AC0[p]\mathsf {AC}^0[p] AC0[p] , which is the class of classical constant-depth circuits with unbounded-fan in and MODp\mathsf {MOD}_{p} MODp​ gates. Additionally, we show a separation between QAC0\mathsf {QAC}^0 QAC0 , the circuit class containing Toffoli gates with unbounded control, and AC0[p]\mathsf {AC}^0[p] AC0[p] , when QAC0\mathsf {QAC}^0 QAC0 is augmented with additional mid-circuit measurements and classical fanout. This establishes the first such separation for a shallow-depth quantum class that does not involve quantum fanout gates, while relying solely on finite quantum gate sets. Equivalently, this yields a separation between AC0[p]\mathsf {AC}^0[p] AC0[p] and [QNC0,AC0]2[\mathsf {QNC}^0, \mathsf {AC}^0]^2 [QNC0,AC0]2 , i.e., shallow quantum circuits interleaved with simple classical computation. Secondly, we consider QNC0\mathsf {QNC}^0 QNC0 circuits with infinite-size gate sets. We show that these circuits, along with quantum prime modular gates or classical prime modular gates in combination with classical fanout, can implement threshold gates, showing that QNC0[p]=QTC0\mathsf {QNC}^0[p]=\mathsf {QTC}^0 QNC0[p]=QTC0 . Finally, we also show that in the infinite-size gate set case, these quantum circuit classes for higher-dimensional Hilbert spaces do not offer any advantage to standard qubit implementations.
This work investigates the oracle separation between the physically motivated complexity class of noisy quantum circuits, inspired by definitions such as those presented by Chen, Cotler, Huang, and Li (2022). We establish that with a constant error rate, separation can be achieved in terms of NP. When the error rate is Ω(log⁡n/n)Ω(\log n/n)Ω(logn/n), we can extend this result to the separation of PH. Notably, our oracles, in all separations, do not necessitate error correction schemes or fault tolerance, as all quantum circuits are of constant depth. This indicates that even quantum computers with minor errors, without error correction, may surpass classical complexity classes under various scenarios and assumptions. We also explore various common noise settings and present new classical hardness results, generalizing those found in studies by Raz and Tal (2022) and Bassirian, Bouland, Fefferman, Gunn, and Tal (2021), which are of independent interest.
An important theoretical problem in the study of quantum computation, that is also practically relevant in the context of near-term quantum devices, is to understand the computational power of hybrid models, that combine poly-time classical computation with short-depth quantum computation. Here, we consider two such models: CQ_d which captures the scenario of a polynomial-time classical algorithm that queries a d-depth quantum computer many times; and QC_d which is more analogous to measurement-based quantum computation and captures the scenario of a d-depth quantum computer with the ability to change the sequence of gates being applied depending on measurement outcomes processed by a classical computation. Chia, Chung & Lai (STOC 2020) and Coudron & Menda (STOC 2020) showed that these models (with d=log^O(1) (n)) are strictly weaker than BQP (the class of problems solvable by poly-time quantum computation), relative to an oracle, disproving a conjecture of Jozsa in the relativised world. We show that, despite the similarities between CQ_d and QC_d, the two models are incomparable, i.e. CQ_d ⊈\nsubseteq⊈ QC_d and QC_d ⊈\nsubseteq⊈ CQ_d relative to an oracle. In other words, there exist problems that one model can solve but not the other and vice versa. We do this by considering new oracle problems that capture the distinctions between the two models and by introducing the notion of an intrinsically stochastic oracle, an oracle whose responses are inherently randomised, which is used for our second result. While we leave showing the second separation relative to a standard oracle as an open problem, we believe the notion of stochastic oracles could be of independent interest for studying complexity classes which have resisted separation in the standard oracle model. Our constructions also yield simpler oracle separations between the hybrid models and BQP, compared to earlier works.