Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2408.13197 · The Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters

Feshbach Resonances in Cold Collisions: Benchmarking State-of-the-Art Ab Initio Potential Energy Surfaces

Karl P. Horn, Meenu Upadhyay, Baruch Margulis, Daniel M. Reich, Edvardas Narevicius, Markus Meuwly, Christiane P. Koch

Published Jul 28, 2025• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

High Resolution Image Download MS PowerPoint Slide High-quality potential energy surfaces (PESs) are prerequisites for quantitative atomistic simulations with both quantum and classical dynamics approaches. The ultimate test for the validity of a PES entails comparisons with judiciously chosen experimental observables. Here we ask whether cold collision measurements are sufficiently informative to validate and distinguish between high-level, state-of-the art PESs for the strongly interacting Ne–H 2 + system. We show that measurement of the final state distributions for a process that involves several metastable intermediate states is sufficient to identify the PES that captures the long-range interactions properly. Furthermore, we show that a modest increase in the experimental energy resolution will allow for resolving individual Feshbach resonances and enable a quantitative probe of the interactions in the short and intermediate ranges.

DOI
10.1021/acs.jpclett.5c01581

Related papers

Improving potential energy surfaces using measured Feshbach resonance states

Karl P. Horn, Luis Itza Vazquez-Salazar, Christiane P. Koch +1 more

The structure and dynamics of a molecular system is governed by its potential energy surface (PES), representing the total energy as a function of the nuclear coordinates. Obtaining accurate potential energy surfaces is limited by the exponential scaling of Hilbert space, restricting quantitative predictions of experimental observables from first principles to small molecules with just a few electrons. Here, we present an explicitly physics-informed approach for improving and assessing the quality of families of PESs by modifying them through linear coordinate transformations based on experimental data. We demonstrate this “morphing” of the PES for the He ‐ H 2 + complex using recent comprehensive Feshbach resonance (FR) measurements for reference PESs at three different levels of quantum chemistry. In all cases, the positions and intensities of peaks in the energy distributions are improved. We find these observables to be mainly sensitive to the long-range part of the PES.

arXiv:2309.16491•Science Advances•Mar 1, 2024•19 citations

Tomography of Feshbach resonance states

Baruch Margulis, Karl P. Horn, Daniel M. Reich +8 more

Feshbach resonances are fundamental to interparticle interactions and become particularly important in cold collisions with atoms, ions, and molecules. In this work, we present the detection of Feshbach resonances in a benchmark system for strongly interacting and highly anisotropic collisions: molecular hydrogen ions colliding with noble gas atoms. The collisions are launched by cold Penning ionization, which exclusively populates Feshbach resonances that span both short- and long-range parts of the interaction potential. We resolved all final molecular channels in a tomographic manner using ion-electron coincidence detection. We demonstrate the nonstatistical nature of the final-state distribution. By performing quantum scattering calculations on ab initio potential energy surfaces, we show that the isolation of the Feshbach resonance pathways reveals their distinctive fingerprints in the collision outcome.

Science•Apr 6, 2023•40 citations

Tomography of Feshbach Resonance States

Baruch Margulis, Karl P. Horn, Daniel M. Reich +8 more

Feshbach resonances are fundamental to interparticle interactions and become particularly important in cold collisions with atoms, ions, and molecules. Here we present the detection of Feshbach resonances in a benchmark system for strongly interacting and highly anisotropic collisions -- molecular hydrogen ions colliding with noble gas atoms. The collisions are launched by cold Penning ionization exclusively populating Feshbach resonances that span both short- and long-range parts of the interaction potential. We resolved all final molecular channels in a tomographic manner using ion-electron coincidence detection and demonstrated the non-statistical nature of the final state distribution. By performing quantum scattering calculations on ab initio potential energy surfaces, we show that the isolation of the Feshbach resonance pathways reveals their distinctive fingerprints in the collision outcome.

•Jan 1, 2023•1 citation

Tomography of Feshbach Resonance States

Baruch Margulis, Karl P. Horn, Daniel M. Reich +8 more

Feshbach resonances are fundamental to interparticle interactions and become particularly important in cold collisions with atoms, ions, and molecules. Here we present the detection of Feshbach resonances in a benchmark system for strongly interacting and highly anisotropic collisions -- molecular hydrogen ions colliding with noble gas atoms. The collisions are launched by cold Penning ionization exclusively populating Feshbach resonances that span both short- and long-range parts of the interaction potential. We resolved all final molecular channels in a tomographic manner using ion-electron coincidence detection. We demonstrate the non-statistical nature of the final state distribution. By performing quantum scattering calculations on ab initio potential energy surfaces, we show that the isolation of the Feshbach resonance pathways reveals their distinctive fingerprints in the collision outcome.

arXiv:2212.02828•Dec 6, 2022•1 citation

When experiment challenges theory: Scattering of vibrationally excited molecules in the cold collision energy regime

F. J. Aoiz

The last decade has seen substantial advances in the exploration of inelastic and reactive collisions at collision energies in the cold ( < $<$ 1 K) and ultracold ( < 1 $<1$ mK) regime.1-13 These advances ushered in an understanding of cold and ultracold collisions that is impacting research areas ranging from molecular spectroscopy to quantum simulation and computation to quantum control of chemical reaction dynamics. Cold collisions are dominated by resonances, as amply manifest in most of the systems studied.1, 14 Resonances are also present in the thermal ( > $>$ 100 K) and hyperthermal ( > $>$ 1000 K) collision energy regimes,15 but obscured by background (non-resonant) scattering and the presence of many partial waves pertaining to higher angular momenta that blur the partial waves' individual contributions. Moreover, the outcome of thermal and hyperthermal collisions is somewhat insensitive to the details of the interaction potential – the potential energy surface (PES) – especially to its attractive long-range region. Only in a handful of cases, such as the F+HD exchange reaction, resonances in the thermal regime have been experimentally detected and theoretically accounted for by quantum mechanical scattering calculations.16, 17 In contrast, in the cold regime, collisions are dominated by only a few partial waves whose effects on the integral and differential scattering cross-sections can be singled out and linked to particular resonances. The cold collision energy regime has been attained by making use of crossed molecular beams that were either Stark- or Zeeman-decelerated or whose intersection angle could be reduced all the way down to the merging-beams limit. A beam emerging from a Stark or Zeeman decelerator has a variable, well-defined laboratory velocity. When crossed with a secondary beam at small angles (5 ∘ $^{\circ }$ –10 ∘ $^{\circ }$ ), collision energies in the 0.3–15 K could be readily achieved, as demonstrated by the group of van de Meerakker.9, 11 The technique of merged beams makes use of the ability to bend one of the beams by a magnetic or electric field such that the crossing angle becomes zero, thereby affording collision energies in the range 0.1 K–10 K. Merging beams have been used in studies of Penning ionization by the groups of Narevicius5, 12 and Osterwalder18 and made it possible to unravel shape and Feshbach resonances arising in this process. The techniques mentioned so far require the reactants to be polar or paramagnetic. For reactants that are neither, collision energies as low as 5 K could be achieved by taking advantage of a favorable combination of low intersection angles and low reduced mass of the reactants. This approach has been demonstrated by Bergeat, Costes, Naulin, and coworkers in a series of reactive3, 19 and inelastic collision experiments8, 20 of H 2 $_2$ . Yet, another approach to achieving low relative collision velocities relies on the coexpansion of the collision partners in a single molecular beam.21 If their masses are similar, both partners will end up with nearly the same velocities, within a few ms − 1 $^{-1}$ . Using this technique, Zare, Mukherjee, and coworkers carried out a series of experiments in which rotational quenching of HD by H 2 $_2$ , D 2 $_2$ , and He was investigated. Moreover, in these experiments, the HD molecule was prepared in v $v$ =1 and j $j$ =2 using Stark-field-induced adiabatic Raman passage that allowed, in addition, to align the rotational angular momentum of the HD reactant molecule with respect to the initial relative velocity of the HD + He reactants.22-24 Collisional energy transfer between rotation and translation, in which a molecule is excited or relaxed via scattering by an atom or another molecule, has been of particular significance for developing our understanding of inelastic collisions. Most notably, the scattering of NO molecules by rare gas (Rg) atoms has served as a benchmark system for both experimentalists and theorists for decades. In its ground electronic state, NO is a 2 Π $^2\Pi$ molecule with a single unpaired electron in an antibonding π ∗ $\pi ^*$ orbital. In this state, the rotational levels are split into two spin–orbit manifolds, defined by the projection | Ω | $|\Omega |$ ( = 1 2 $=\frac{1}{2}$ or 3 2 $\frac{3}{2}$ ) of the electronic angular momentum (orbital and spin) on the internuclear axis. The rotational levels with the same j $j$ in the two manifolds are separated by approximately 123 cm − 1 $^{-1}$ for v $v$ =0 (117 cm − 1 $^{-1}$ for v $v$ =10). In addition, each rotational level within each manifold is further split into two Λ $\Lambda$ -doublet states ( ε = ± 1 $\epsilon = \pm 1$ , e/f), which are nearly degenerate, but differ in parity, p = ( − 1 ) j − ε / 2 $p = (-1)^{j-\epsilon /2}$ . As the Rg atom approaches the NO molecule, the degeneracy of the Λ $\Lambda$ doublets is lifted, giving rise to two PESs, A ′ $A^{\prime }$ and A ′ ′ $A^{\prime \prime }$ , in which the orbital of the unpaired electron lies, respectively, in the plane of the three atoms or perpendicular to it. In computational practice, it is more convenient to use linear combinations (sums and differences) of the A ′ ′ $A^{\prime \prime }$ and A ′ $A^{\prime }$ PESs. Using hexapole focusing or Stark deceleration combined with detection via velocity ion imaging, fully state-to-state-resolved integral and differential cross sections for rotationally elastic and inelastic collisions could be measured with high resolution.9, 11, 25, 26 More than that, the orientation and alignment of the scattered (outgoing) NO molecules could be measured as a function of the scattering angle27-30 and, quite recently, the effects of orientation of the reactant (incoming) NO molecules on the differential cross section in collisions with Rg, mostly Ar, could be established.31-35 On the theory side, quantum mechanical close coupling (QMCC) scattering calculations on accurate two-dimensional ab initio PESs using the benchmark coupled-cluster, CCSD(T), method with the NO internuclear distance fixed at its equilibrium value36 were performed and found to account for all the details revealed by the experiments. Although state of the art, most of these experiments except for those described in Refs. 9, 11 were carried out at thermal energies for NO molecules in their lowest level, | v = 0 , j = 1 2 , Ω = 1 2 , f ⟩ $|v=0, j=\frac{1}{2}, \Omega =\frac{1}{2}, f\rangle$ . Scattering of highly vibrationally excited molecules in the cold energy regime remained an unexplored frontier until the recent work by the groups of Arthur Suits, Ad van der Avoird, Gerrit Groenenboom, and Hua Guo who added spin–orbit and rotational state selection and looked for spin- and rotational-state changing collisions to boot. Published in the current issue of Natural Sciences,37 this work is a culmination of a 3-year collaboration that included both implementation of new experimental techniques and boosting of theoretical methods. Working with the NO+Ar system, the authors made use of stimulated emission pumping via the electronically excited A 2 Σ + $A^2\Sigma ^+$ state to promote NO( 2 Π 1 2 $^2\Pi _{\frac{1}{2}}$ ) molecules to the vibrationally excited state with v = 10 $v=10$ and a selected spin–orbit state | Ω | $|\Omega |$ and rotational state j $j$ , | v = 10 , j , Ω , f ⟩ $|v=10, j,\Omega , f\rangle$ .38, 39 Low (cold) collision energies were achieved in a novel experimental setup of two beams (dual-beam arrangement) crossing at 4 ∘ $^{\circ }$ and intersected by the pump and dump laser beams of the stimulated-emission pumping scheme. Downstream, the collision products were probed using 1+1 ′ $^{\prime }$ REMPI with the ionization laser tuned just above the ionization threshold. Fully state-resolved angular distributions of the scattered NO molecules were measured by velocity ion slice imaging and detected by a charge-coupled device (CCD). In order to be able to detect the product (outgoing) molecules resulting from the cold NO + Ar collisions, some excess energy had to be made available to the products. This came in the form of the initial spin–orbit and/or rotational state energy. In the study highlighted herein,37 angular distributions leading to the spin–orbit changing transition | v = 10 , Ω = 3 2 , j = 3 2 f ⟩ → | v ′ = 10 , Ω ′ = 1 2 , j ′ = 9 2 , e ⟩ $|v=10, \Omega =\frac{3}{2}, j=\frac{3}{2} f\rangle \rightarrow |v^{\prime }=10, \Omega ^{\prime }=\frac{1}{2}, j^{\prime }=\frac{9}{2}, e \rangle$ were measured at energies in the 2 K–5 K range. Although intrabeam scattering could have been used as an alternative as it had been in previous work,21 the authors demonstrated that a dual-beam setup provides a superior angular and energy resolution. The highlighted experiment challenged the existing theoretical treatments of the NO+ Rg systems: first, the approximation of fixing NO at its equilibrium distance was bound to fail for NO in v = 10 $v=10$ due to the concomitant elongation of the NO bond. Second, for such a highly excited vibrational state, both the long- and short-range interactions are affected, triggering nonadiabatic effects involving rotational and spin–orbit degrees of freedom. The above rendered the single-reference coupled-cluster method used in previous treatments of NO( 2 Π 1 2 , v = 0 $^2\Pi _{\frac{1}{2}},v=0$ ) inadequate. Therefore, the authors of the highlighted paper37 constructed a new coupled-cluster PES as well as a multireference configuration-interaction (MRCI) PES and carried out full-fledged (3D) QMCC calculations on both PESs. These tour-de-force calculations reproduced quite well the experimental differential cross sections and defined a new state of the art in scattering calculations. However, some discrepancies remain as at low collision energies, and the accuracy of the long-range potential needed is a challenge for any ab initio method. Moreover, treating spin-changing collisions that are dominated by the essentially attractive difference potential, V A ′ ′ − V A ′ $V_{A^{\prime \prime }}-V_{A^{\prime }}$ , puts additional demands on the accuracy of the A ′ ′ $A^{\prime \prime }$ and A ′ $A^{\prime }$ PESs. The calculated integral cross section in the 3–4 cm − 1 $^{-1}$ energy interval exhibits a bump that may indicate the presence of resonances that show up as backscattering in the measured differential cross section. A partial-wave analysis points to overlapping resonances associated with contributions from several of the highest partial waves involved. In any case, tracing the resonances may require additional improvements of the existing PESs. All in all, the highlighted combined experimental and theoretical study sets a new standard for our understanding of cold collisions. There is no conflict of interest. The peer review history for this article is available at https://publons.com/publon/10.1002/ntls.20210088. This Highlight has been internally reviewed and edited by Bretislav Friedrich and Gerard Meijer. No data available.

Natural Sciences•Nov 11, 2021•0 citations

Long-Range Interaction between Molecules with Electronic Degeneracy: Beyond the Born–Oppenheimer Approximation

Yipeng Yu, Xixi Hu, Hua Guo +1 more

High Resolution Image Download MS PowerPoint Slide Long-range intermolecular interaction plays an essential role in (ultra)cold collisions. For monomers with degenerate electronic states, an accurate description of the long-range interaction can be challenging due to the potential breakdown of the Born–Oppenheimer approximation. In this work, we developed a general method to construct long-range interaction potential energy surfaces (IPESs) between arbitrary molecules using the degenerate perturbation theory of Schrödinger. To further simplify the application of this method, a group-theoretical method is introduced to identify nonzero components of electrostatic properties of monomers, especially for the nonlinear molecules. To demonstrate this approach, we report the long-range IPESs of the O( 3 P)–OH( 2 Π) and OH( 2 Π)–OH( 2 Π) systems. The excellent agreement with ab initio calculations in large separations, even near electronic degeneracies, confirms the accuracy of our approach. The method is expected to lay the groundwork for the accurate investigation of (ultra)cold collisional dynamics involving open-shell species.

JACS Au•Sep 25, 2025•5 citations
High Resolution Image Download MS PowerPoint Slide High-quality potential energy surfaces (PESs) are prerequisites for quantitative atomistic simulations with both quantum and classical dynamics approaches. The ultimate test for the validity of a PES entails comparisons with judiciously chosen experimental observables. Here we ask whether cold collision measurements are sufficiently informative to validate and distinguish between high-level, state-of-the art PESs for the strongly interacting Ne–H 2 + system. We show that measurement of the final state distributions for a process that involves several metastable intermediate states is sufficient to identify the PES that captures the long-range interactions properly. Furthermore, we show that a modest increase in the experimental energy resolution will allow for resolving individual Feshbach resonances and enable a quantitative probe of the interactions in the short and intermediate ranges.
The structure and dynamics of a molecular system is governed by its potential energy surface (PES), representing the total energy as a function of the nuclear coordinates. Obtaining accurate potential energy surfaces is limited by the exponential scaling of Hilbert space, restricting quantitative predictions of experimental observables from first principles to small molecules with just a few electrons. Here, we present an explicitly physics-informed approach for improving and assessing the quality of families of PESs by modifying them through linear coordinate transformations based on experimental data. We demonstrate this “morphing” of the PES for the He ‐ H 2 + complex using recent comprehensive Feshbach resonance (FR) measurements for reference PESs at three different levels of quantum chemistry. In all cases, the positions and intensities of peaks in the energy distributions are improved. We find these observables to be mainly sensitive to the long-range part of the PES.
Feshbach resonances are fundamental to interparticle interactions and become particularly important in cold collisions with atoms, ions, and molecules. In this work, we present the detection of Feshbach resonances in a benchmark system for strongly interacting and highly anisotropic collisions: molecular hydrogen ions colliding with noble gas atoms. The collisions are launched by cold Penning ionization, which exclusively populates Feshbach resonances that span both short- and long-range parts of the interaction potential. We resolved all final molecular channels in a tomographic manner using ion-electron coincidence detection. We demonstrate the nonstatistical nature of the final-state distribution. By performing quantum scattering calculations on ab initio potential energy surfaces, we show that the isolation of the Feshbach resonance pathways reveals their distinctive fingerprints in the collision outcome.
Feshbach resonances are fundamental to interparticle interactions and become particularly important in cold collisions with atoms, ions, and molecules. Here we present the detection of Feshbach resonances in a benchmark system for strongly interacting and highly anisotropic collisions -- molecular hydrogen ions colliding with noble gas atoms. The collisions are launched by cold Penning ionization exclusively populating Feshbach resonances that span both short- and long-range parts of the interaction potential. We resolved all final molecular channels in a tomographic manner using ion-electron coincidence detection and demonstrated the non-statistical nature of the final state distribution. By performing quantum scattering calculations on ab initio potential energy surfaces, we show that the isolation of the Feshbach resonance pathways reveals their distinctive fingerprints in the collision outcome.
Feshbach resonances are fundamental to interparticle interactions and become particularly important in cold collisions with atoms, ions, and molecules. Here we present the detection of Feshbach resonances in a benchmark system for strongly interacting and highly anisotropic collisions -- molecular hydrogen ions colliding with noble gas atoms. The collisions are launched by cold Penning ionization exclusively populating Feshbach resonances that span both short- and long-range parts of the interaction potential. We resolved all final molecular channels in a tomographic manner using ion-electron coincidence detection. We demonstrate the non-statistical nature of the final state distribution. By performing quantum scattering calculations on ab initio potential energy surfaces, we show that the isolation of the Feshbach resonance pathways reveals their distinctive fingerprints in the collision outcome.
The last decade has seen substantial advances in the exploration of inelastic and reactive collisions at collision energies in the cold ( < <<< 1 K) and ultracold ( < 1 <1<1<1 mK) regime.1-13 These advances ushered in an understanding of cold and ultracold collisions that is impacting research areas ranging from molecular spectroscopy to quantum simulation and computation to quantum control of chemical reaction dynamics. Cold collisions are dominated by resonances, as amply manifest in most of the systems studied.1, 14 Resonances are also present in the thermal ( > >>> 100 K) and hyperthermal ( > >>> 1000 K) collision energy regimes,15 but obscured by background (non-resonant) scattering and the presence of many partial waves pertaining to higher angular momenta that blur the partial waves' individual contributions. Moreover, the outcome of thermal and hyperthermal collisions is somewhat insensitive to the details of the interaction potential – the potential energy surface (PES) – especially to its attractive long-range region. Only in a handful of cases, such as the F+HD exchange reaction, resonances in the thermal regime have been experimentally detected and theoretically accounted for by quantum mechanical scattering calculations.16, 17 In contrast, in the cold regime, collisions are dominated by only a few partial waves whose effects on the integral and differential scattering cross-sections can be singled out and linked to particular resonances. The cold collision energy regime has been attained by making use of crossed molecular beams that were either Stark- or Zeeman-decelerated or whose intersection angle could be reduced all the way down to the merging-beams limit. A beam emerging from a Stark or Zeeman decelerator has a variable, well-defined laboratory velocity. When crossed with a secondary beam at small angles (5 ∘ ∘^{\circ }∘ –10 ∘ ∘^{\circ }∘ ), collision energies in the 0.3–15 K could be readily achieved, as demonstrated by the group of van de Meerakker.9, 11 The technique of merged beams makes use of the ability to bend one of the beams by a magnetic or electric field such that the crossing angle becomes zero, thereby affording collision energies in the range 0.1 K–10 K. Merging beams have been used in studies of Penning ionization by the groups of Narevicius5, 12 and Osterwalder18 and made it possible to unravel shape and Feshbach resonances arising in this process. The techniques mentioned so far require the reactants to be polar or paramagnetic. For reactants that are neither, collision energies as low as 5 K could be achieved by taking advantage of a favorable combination of low intersection angles and low reduced mass of the reactants. This approach has been demonstrated by Bergeat, Costes, Naulin, and coworkers in a series of reactive3, 19 and inelastic collision experiments8, 20 of H 2 2_22​ . Yet, another approach to achieving low relative collision velocities relies on the coexpansion of the collision partners in a single molecular beam.21 If their masses are similar, both partners will end up with nearly the same velocities, within a few ms − 1 −1^{-1}−1 . Using this technique, Zare, Mukherjee, and coworkers carried out a series of experiments in which rotational quenching of HD by H 2 2_22​ , D 2 2_22​ , and He was investigated. Moreover, in these experiments, the HD molecule was prepared in v vvv =1 and j jjj =2 using Stark-field-induced adiabatic Raman passage that allowed, in addition, to align the rotational angular momentum of the HD reactant molecule with respect to the initial relative velocity of the HD + He reactants.22-24 Collisional energy transfer between rotation and translation, in which a molecule is excited or relaxed via scattering by an atom or another molecule, has been of particular significance for developing our understanding of inelastic collisions. Most notably, the scattering of NO molecules by rare gas (Rg) atoms has served as a benchmark system for both experimentalists and theorists for decades. In its ground electronic state, NO is a 2 Π 2Π^2\Pi2Π molecule with a single unpaired electron in an antibonding π ∗ π∗\pi ^*π∗ orbital. In this state, the rotational levels are split into two spin–orbit manifolds, defined by the projection | Ω | ∣Ω∣|\Omega |∣Ω∣ ( = 1 2 =12=\frac{1}{2}=21​ or 3 2 32\frac{3}{2}23​ ) of the electronic angular momentum (orbital and spin) on the internuclear axis. The rotational levels with the same j jjj in the two manifolds are separated by approximately 123 cm − 1 −1^{-1}−1 for v vvv =0 (117 cm − 1 −1^{-1}−1 for v vvv =10). In addition, each rotational level within each manifold is further split into two Λ Λ\LambdaΛ -doublet states ( ε = ± 1 ϵ=±1\epsilon = \pm 1ϵ=±1 , e/f), which are nearly degenerate, but differ in parity, p = ( − 1 ) j − ε / 2 p=(−1)j−ϵ/2p = (-1)^{j-\epsilon /2}p=(−1)j−ϵ/2 . As the Rg atom approaches the NO molecule, the degeneracy of the Λ Λ\LambdaΛ doublets is lifted, giving rise to two PESs, A ′ A′A^{\prime }A′ and A ′ ′ A′′A^{\prime \prime }A′′ , in which the orbital of the unpaired electron lies, respectively, in the plane of the three atoms or perpendicular to it. In computational practice, it is more convenient to use linear combinations (sums and differences) of the A ′ ′ A′′A^{\prime \prime }A′′ and A ′ A′A^{\prime }A′ PESs. Using hexapole focusing or Stark deceleration combined with detection via velocity ion imaging, fully state-to-state-resolved integral and differential cross sections for rotationally elastic and inelastic collisions could be measured with high resolution.9, 11, 25, 26 More than that, the orientation and alignment of the scattered (outgoing) NO molecules could be measured as a function of the scattering angle27-30 and, quite recently, the effects of orientation of the reactant (incoming) NO molecules on the differential cross section in collisions with Rg, mostly Ar, could be established.31-35 On the theory side, quantum mechanical close coupling (QMCC) scattering calculations on accurate two-dimensional ab initio PESs using the benchmark coupled-cluster, CCSD(T), method with the NO internuclear distance fixed at its equilibrium value36 were performed and found to account for all the details revealed by the experiments. Although state of the art, most of these experiments except for those described in Refs. 9, 11 were carried out at thermal energies for NO molecules in their lowest level, | v = 0 , j = 1 2 , Ω = 1 2 , f ⟩ ∣v=0,j=12,Ω=12,f⟩|v=0, j=\frac{1}{2}, \Omega =\frac{1}{2}, f\rangle∣v=0,j=21​,Ω=21​,f⟩ . Scattering of highly vibrationally excited molecules in the cold energy regime remained an unexplored frontier until the recent work by the groups of Arthur Suits, Ad van der Avoird, Gerrit Groenenboom, and Hua Guo who added spin–orbit and rotational state selection and looked for spin- and rotational-state changing collisions to boot. Published in the current issue of Natural Sciences,37 this work is a culmination of a 3-year collaboration that included both implementation of new experimental techniques and boosting of theoretical methods. Working with the NO+Ar system, the authors made use of stimulated emission pumping via the electronically excited A 2 Σ + A2Σ+A^2\Sigma ^+A2Σ+ state to promote NO( 2 Π 1 2 2Π12^2\Pi _{\frac{1}{2}}2Π21​​ ) molecules to the vibrationally excited state with v = 10 v=10v=10v=10 and a selected spin–orbit state | Ω | ∣Ω∣|\Omega |∣Ω∣ and rotational state j jjj , | v = 10 , j , Ω , f ⟩ ∣v=10,j,Ω,f⟩|v=10, j,\Omega , f\rangle∣v=10,j,Ω,f⟩ .38, 39 Low (cold) collision energies were achieved in a novel experimental setup of two beams (dual-beam arrangement) crossing at 4 ∘ ∘^{\circ }∘ and intersected by the pump and dump laser beams of the stimulated-emission pumping scheme. Downstream, the collision products were probed using 1+1 ′ ′^{\prime }′ REMPI with the ionization laser tuned just above the ionization threshold. Fully state-resolved angular distributions of the scattered NO molecules were measured by velocity ion slice imaging and detected by a charge-coupled device (CCD). In order to be able to detect the product (outgoing) molecules resulting from the cold NO + Ar collisions, some excess energy had to be made available to the products. This came in the form of the initial spin–orbit and/or rotational state energy. In the study highlighted herein,37 angular distributions leading to the spin–orbit changing transition | v = 10 , Ω = 3 2 , j = 3 2 f ⟩ → | v ′ = 10 , Ω ′ = 1 2 , j ′ = 9 2 , e ⟩ ∣v=10,Ω=32,j=32f⟩→∣v′=10,Ω′=12,j′=92,e⟩|v=10, \Omega =\frac{3}{2}, j=\frac{3}{2} f\rangle \rightarrow |v^{\prime }=10, \Omega ^{\prime }=\frac{1}{2}, j^{\prime }=\frac{9}{2}, e \rangle∣v=10,Ω=23​,j=23​f⟩→∣v′=10,Ω′=21​,j′=29​,e⟩ were measured at energies in the 2 K–5 K range. Although intrabeam scattering could have been used as an alternative as it had been in previous work,21 the authors demonstrated that a dual-beam setup provides a superior angular and energy resolution. The highlighted experiment challenged the existing theoretical treatments of the NO+ Rg systems: first, the approximation of fixing NO at its equilibrium distance was bound to fail for NO in v = 10 v=10v=10v=10 due to the concomitant elongation of the NO bond. Second, for such a highly excited vibrational state, both the long- and short-range interactions are affected, triggering nonadiabatic effects involving rotational and spin–orbit degrees of freedom. The above rendered the single-reference coupled-cluster method used in previous treatments of NO( 2 Π 1 2 , v = 0 2Π12,v=0^2\Pi _{\frac{1}{2}},v=02Π21​​,v=0 ) inadequate. Therefore, the authors of the highlighted paper37 constructed a new coupled-cluster PES as well as a multireference configuration-interaction (MRCI) PES and carried out full-fledged (3D) QMCC calculations on both PESs. These tour-de-force calculations reproduced quite well the experimental differential cross sections and defined a new state of the art in scattering calculations. However, some discrepancies remain as at low collision energies, and the accuracy of the long-range potential needed is a challenge for any ab initio method. Moreover, treating spin-changing collisions that are dominated by the essentially attractive difference potential, V A ′ ′ − V A ′ VA′′−VA′V_{A^{\prime \prime }}-V_{A^{\prime }}VA′′​−VA′​ , puts additional demands on the accuracy of the A ′ ′ A′′A^{\prime \prime }A′′ and A ′ A′A^{\prime }A′ PESs. The calculated integral cross section in the 3–4 cm − 1 −1^{-1}−1 energy interval exhibits a bump that may indicate the presence of resonances that show up as backscattering in the measured differential cross section. A partial-wave analysis points to overlapping resonances associated with contributions from several of the highest partial waves involved. In any case, tracing the resonances may require additional improvements of the existing PESs. All in all, the highlighted combined experimental and theoretical study sets a new standard for our understanding of cold collisions. There is no conflict of interest. The peer review history for this article is available at https://publons.com/publon/10.1002/ntls.20210088. This Highlight has been internally reviewed and edited by Bretislav Friedrich and Gerard Meijer. No data available.
High Resolution Image Download MS PowerPoint Slide Long-range intermolecular interaction plays an essential role in (ultra)cold collisions. For monomers with degenerate electronic states, an accurate description of the long-range interaction can be challenging due to the potential breakdown of the Born–Oppenheimer approximation. In this work, we developed a general method to construct long-range interaction potential energy surfaces (IPESs) between arbitrary molecules using the degenerate perturbation theory of Schrödinger. To further simplify the application of this method, a group-theoretical method is introduced to identify nonzero components of electrostatic properties of monomers, especially for the nonlinear molecules. To demonstrate this approach, we report the long-range IPESs of the O( 3 P)–OH( 2 Π) and OH( 2 Π)–OH( 2 Π) systems. The excellent agreement with ab initio calculations in large separations, even near electronic degeneracies, confirms the accuracy of our approach. The method is expected to lay the groundwork for the accurate investigation of (ultra)cold collisional dynamics involving open-shell species.