Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2408.03984 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Fractionalization as an alternate to charge ordering in electronic insulators

Seth Musser, Meng Cheng, T. Senthil

Published Jun 2, 2025• 12 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Who ordered anyons? Though exotic, anyons can be required by a system's fractional symmetry response. For example, in gapped systems with U(1) and unbroken translation symmetry, fractional lattice filling leads to anyons via the LSM constraint. The authors analyze here this setting and, for a given filling, determine the minimal number of required anyons. They prove this minimal topological order is unique and dub it a ``quantum charge liquid'' (QCL). The authors conclude by discussing the phenomenology of QCLs.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.111.235108

Related papers

Defect mediated quantum melting of charge ordered insulators

Abijith Krishnan, Ajesh Kumar, T. Senthil

Two-dimensional (2d) electronic systems on a lattice at fractional filling $ν= p/q$ exhibit a competition between charge ordered insulators, called Wigner-Mott insulators (WMIs), at large Coulomb repulsion and Fermi-liquid metals at large electronic kinetic energy. When those two energy scales are roughly equal, insulating states that restore the lattice translation symmetry, which we call quantum charge liquids (QCLs), may emerge. When gapped, these QCLs must exhibit topological order. In this work, we show that the allowed topological ordered phases that are proximate to the WMI strongly depend on the charge ordering in the WMI. In particular, we show that when $q$ is even, no direct transition exists between a WMI with the smallest allowed unit cell size from filling constraints, i.e., the "minimal" WMI, and the topological order with the smallest ground state degeneracy on a torus allowed by filling constraints, i.e., the "minimal" TO. Furthermore, we describe the quantum melting transition of the WMIs to the proximate QCLs in terms of the proliferation of the topological defects of the WMIs. The field theory of this transition in terms of the topological defects reveals their role as precursors to the anyon excitations in the QCLs.

arXiv:2510.00099•Sep 30, 2025•1 citation

Towards a microscopic model for an electronic quantum charge liquid

Jacob R. Taylor, Sankar Das Sarma, Seth Musser

We provide a route to constructing an electronic quantum charge liquid (QCL), a state made up of fermions at fractional filling of a lattice that does not break translation. Starting with spinless fermions at filling $ν=3/2$ we pair them to get bosons at filling $ν=3/4$ per unit cell. The tetramer model, a generalization of the dimer model, on the square lattice is evaluated as a candidate bosonic QCL at filling $ν= 3/4$. It is shown that these models exhibit a local $\mathbb{Z}_4$ symmetry. Upon numerical study of a family of tetramer wavefunctions it is found that while one is gapless due to $\mathrm{U}(1)^3$ symmetry at least one other can be definitively shown to be gapped. The gapped nature of this state, along with its $\mathbb{Z}_4$ symmetry, leads us to propose that it is an example of the elusive bosonic QCL displaying the minimal $\mathbb{Z}_4$ topological order. We conclude by discussing possible extensions to other lattice geometries, electronic QCLs, and to Rydberg atoms.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2604.25992•Apr 30, 2026•0 citations

Classifying fractionalization: Symmetry classification of gapped Z 2 spin liquids in two dimensions

Andrew M. Essin, Michael Hermele

We classify distinct types of quantum number fractionalization occurring in two-dimensional topologically ordered phases, focusing in particular on phases with ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ topological order, that is, on gapped ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ spin liquids. We find that the fractionalization class of each anyon is an equivalence class of projective representations of the symmetry group, corresponding to elements of the cohomology group ${H}^{2}(G,{\mathbb{Z}}_{2})$. This result leads us to a symmetry classification of gapped ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ spin liquids, such that two phases in different symmetry classes cannot be connected without breaking symmetry or crossing a phase transition. Symmetry classes are defined by specifying a fractionalization class for each type of anyon. The fusion rules of anyons play a crucial role in determining the symmetry classes. For translation and internal symmetries, braiding statistics plays no role, but can affect the classification when point group symmetries are present. For square lattice space group, time-reversal, and $\mathrm{SO}(3)$ spin rotation symmetries, we find $2\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}098\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}176\ensuremath{\approx}{2}^{21}$ distinct symmetry classes. Our symmetry classification is not complete, as we exclude, by assumption, permutation of the different types of anyons by symmetry operations. We give an explicit construction of symmetry classes for square lattice space group symmetry in the toric code model. Via simple examples, we illustrate how information about fractionalization classes can, in principle, be obtained from the spectrum and quantum numbers of excited states. Moreover, the symmetry class can be partially determined from the quantum numbers of the four degenerate ground states on the torus. We also extend our results to arbitrary Abelian topological orders (limited, though, to translations and internal symmetries), and compare our classification with the related projective symmetry group classification of parton mean-field theories. Our results provide a framework for understanding and probing the sharp distinctions among symmetric ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ spin liquids and are a first step toward a full classification of symmetric topologically ordered phases.

arXiv:1212.0593•Physical Review B•Mar 14, 2013•265 citations

Symmetry-induced anyon breeding in fractional quantum Hall states

Yuan-Ming Lu, Lukasz Fidkowski

An exotic feature of the fractional quantum Hall effect is the emergence of anyons, which are quasiparticle excitations with fractional statistics. In the presence of a symmetry, such as $U(1)$ charge conservation, it is well known that anyons can carry fractional symmetry quantum numbers. In this paper we reveal a different class of symmetry realizations, i.e., anyons can ``breed'' in multiples under symmetry operation. We focus on the global Ising (${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$) symmetry and show examples of these unconventional symmetry realizations in Laughlin-type fractional quantum Hall states. One remarkable consequence of such an Ising symmetry is the emergence of anyons on the Ising symmetry domain walls. We also provide a mathematical framework which generalizes this phenomenon to any Abelian topological orders.

arXiv:1311.6481•Physical Review B•Mar 28, 2014•11 citations

Fractional S -duality, classification of fractional topological insulators, and surface topological order

Peng Ye, Meng Cheng, Eduardo Fradkin

In this paper, we propose a generalization of the $S$-duality of four-dimensional quantum electrodynamics (${\text{QED}}_{4}$) to ${\text{QED}}_{4}$ with fractionally charged excitations, the fractional $S$-duality. Such ${\text{QED}}_{4}$ can be obtained by gauging the $\text{U(1)}$ symmetry of a topologically ordered state with fractional charges. When time-reversal symmetry is imposed, the axion angle ($\ensuremath{\theta}$) can take a nontrivial but still time-reversal-invariant value $\ensuremath{\pi}/{t}^{2}$ ($t\ensuremath{\in}\mathbb{Z}$). Here, $1/t$ specifies the minimal electric charge carried by bulk excitations. Such states with time-reversal and $\text{U(1)}$ global symmetry (fermion number conservation) are fractional topological insulators (FTIs). We propose a topological quantum field theory description, which microscopically justifies the fractional $S$-duality. Then, we consider stacking operations (i.e., a direct sum of Hamiltonians) among FTIs. We find that there are two topologically distinct classes of FTIs: type I and type II. Type I ($t\ensuremath{\in}{\mathbb{Z}}_{\mathrm{odd}}$) can be obtained by directly stacking a noninteracting topological insulator and a fractionalized gapped fermionic state with minimal charge $1/t$ and vanishing $\ensuremath{\theta}$. But type II ($t\ensuremath{\in}{\mathbb{Z}}_{\mathrm{even}}$) cannot be realized through any stacking. Finally, we study the surface topological order of fractional topological insulators.

arXiv:1701.05559•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Aug 18, 2017•33 citations

Anomalous Crystal Symmetry Fractionalization on the Surface of Topological Crystalline Insulators

Yang Qi, Liang Fu

The surface of a three-dimensional topological electron system often hosts symmetry-protected gapless surface states. With the effect of electron interactions, these surface states can be gapped out without symmetry breaking by a surface topological order, in which the anyon excitations carry anomalous symmetry fractionalization that cannot be realized in a genuine two-dimensional system. We show that for a mirror-symmetry-protected topological crystalline insulator with mirror Chern number n=4, its surface can be gapped out by an anomalous Z_{2} topological order, where all anyons carry mirror-symmetry fractionalization M^{2}=-1. The identification of such anomalous crystalline symmetry fractionalization implies that in a two-dimensional Z_{2} spin liquid, the vison excitation cannot carry M^{2}=-1 if the spinon carries M^{2}=-1 or a half-integer spin.

arXiv:1505.06201•Physical Review Letters•Dec 2, 2015•50 citations
Who ordered anyons? Though exotic, anyons can be required by a system's fractional symmetry response. For example, in gapped systems with U(1) and unbroken translation symmetry, fractional lattice filling leads to anyons via the LSM constraint. The authors analyze here this setting and, for a given filling, determine the minimal number of required anyons. They prove this minimal topological order is unique and dub it a ``quantum charge liquid'' (QCL). The authors conclude by discussing the phenomenology of QCLs.
Two-dimensional (2d) electronic systems on a lattice at fractional filling ν=p/qν= p/qν=p/q exhibit a competition between charge ordered insulators, called Wigner-Mott insulators (WMIs), at large Coulomb repulsion and Fermi-liquid metals at large electronic kinetic energy. When those two energy scales are roughly equal, insulating states that restore the lattice translation symmetry, which we call quantum charge liquids (QCLs), may emerge. When gapped, these QCLs must exhibit topological order. In this work, we show that the allowed topological ordered phases that are proximate to the WMI strongly depend on the charge ordering in the WMI. In particular, we show that when qqq is even, no direct transition exists between a WMI with the smallest allowed unit cell size from filling constraints, i.e., the "minimal" WMI, and the topological order with the smallest ground state degeneracy on a torus allowed by filling constraints, i.e., the "minimal" TO. Furthermore, we describe the quantum melting transition of the WMIs to the proximate QCLs in terms of the proliferation of the topological defects of the WMIs. The field theory of this transition in terms of the topological defects reveals their role as precursors to the anyon excitations in the QCLs.
We provide a route to constructing an electronic quantum charge liquid (QCL), a state made up of fermions at fractional filling of a lattice that does not break translation. Starting with spinless fermions at filling ν=3/2ν=3/2ν=3/2 we pair them to get bosons at filling ν=3/4ν=3/4ν=3/4 per unit cell. The tetramer model, a generalization of the dimer model, on the square lattice is evaluated as a candidate bosonic QCL at filling ν=3/4ν= 3/4ν=3/4. It is shown that these models exhibit a local Z4\mathbb{Z}_4Z4​ symmetry. Upon numerical study of a family of tetramer wavefunctions it is found that while one is gapless due to U(1)3\mathrm{U}(1)^3U(1)3 symmetry at least one other can be definitively shown to be gapped. The gapped nature of this state, along with its Z4\mathbb{Z}_4Z4​ symmetry, leads us to propose that it is an example of the elusive bosonic QCL displaying the minimal Z4\mathbb{Z}_4Z4​ topological order. We conclude by discussing possible extensions to other lattice geometries, electronic QCLs, and to Rydberg atoms.
We classify distinct types of quantum number fractionalization occurring in two-dimensional topologically ordered phases, focusing in particular on phases with Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ topological order, that is, on gapped Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ spin liquids. We find that the fractionalization class of each anyon is an equivalence class of projective representations of the symmetry group, corresponding to elements of the cohomology group H2(G,Z2){H}^{2}(G,{\mathbb{Z}}_{2})H2(G,Z2​). This result leads us to a symmetry classification of gapped Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ spin liquids, such that two phases in different symmetry classes cannot be connected without breaking symmetry or crossing a phase transition. Symmetry classes are defined by specifying a fractionalization class for each type of anyon. The fusion rules of anyons play a crucial role in determining the symmetry classes. For translation and internal symmetries, braiding statistics plays no role, but can affect the classification when point group symmetries are present. For square lattice space group, time-reversal, and SO(3)\mathrm{SO}(3)SO(3) spin rotation symmetries, we find $2\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}098\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}176\ensuremath{\approx}{2}^{21}$ distinct symmetry classes. Our symmetry classification is not complete, as we exclude, by assumption, permutation of the different types of anyons by symmetry operations. We give an explicit construction of symmetry classes for square lattice space group symmetry in the toric code model. Via simple examples, we illustrate how information about fractionalization classes can, in principle, be obtained from the spectrum and quantum numbers of excited states. Moreover, the symmetry class can be partially determined from the quantum numbers of the four degenerate ground states on the torus. We also extend our results to arbitrary Abelian topological orders (limited, though, to translations and internal symmetries), and compare our classification with the related projective symmetry group classification of parton mean-field theories. Our results provide a framework for understanding and probing the sharp distinctions among symmetric Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ spin liquids and are a first step toward a full classification of symmetric topologically ordered phases.
An exotic feature of the fractional quantum Hall effect is the emergence of anyons, which are quasiparticle excitations with fractional statistics. In the presence of a symmetry, such as U(1)U(1)U(1) charge conservation, it is well known that anyons can carry fractional symmetry quantum numbers. In this paper we reveal a different class of symmetry realizations, i.e., anyons can ``breed'' in multiples under symmetry operation. We focus on the global Ising (Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​) symmetry and show examples of these unconventional symmetry realizations in Laughlin-type fractional quantum Hall states. One remarkable consequence of such an Ising symmetry is the emergence of anyons on the Ising symmetry domain walls. We also provide a mathematical framework which generalizes this phenomenon to any Abelian topological orders.
In this paper, we propose a generalization of the SSS-duality of four-dimensional quantum electrodynamics (QED4{\text{QED}}_{4}QED4​) to QED4{\text{QED}}_{4}QED4​ with fractionally charged excitations, the fractional SSS-duality. Such QED4{\text{QED}}_{4}QED4​ can be obtained by gauging the U(1)\text{U(1)}U(1) symmetry of a topologically ordered state with fractional charges. When time-reversal symmetry is imposed, the axion angle ($\ensuremath{\theta}$) can take a nontrivial but still time-reversal-invariant value $\ensuremath{\pi}/{t}^{2}$ ($t\ensuremath{\in}\mathbb{Z}$). Here, 1/t1/t1/t specifies the minimal electric charge carried by bulk excitations. Such states with time-reversal and U(1)\text{U(1)}U(1) global symmetry (fermion number conservation) are fractional topological insulators (FTIs). We propose a topological quantum field theory description, which microscopically justifies the fractional SSS-duality. Then, we consider stacking operations (i.e., a direct sum of Hamiltonians) among FTIs. We find that there are two topologically distinct classes of FTIs: type I and type II. Type I ($t\ensuremath{\in}{\mathbb{Z}}_{\mathrm{odd}}$) can be obtained by directly stacking a noninteracting topological insulator and a fractionalized gapped fermionic state with minimal charge 1/t1/t1/t and vanishing $\ensuremath{\theta}$. But type II ($t\ensuremath{\in}{\mathbb{Z}}_{\mathrm{even}}$) cannot be realized through any stacking. Finally, we study the surface topological order of fractional topological insulators.
The surface of a three-dimensional topological electron system often hosts symmetry-protected gapless surface states. With the effect of electron interactions, these surface states can be gapped out without symmetry breaking by a surface topological order, in which the anyon excitations carry anomalous symmetry fractionalization that cannot be realized in a genuine two-dimensional system. We show that for a mirror-symmetry-protected topological crystalline insulator with mirror Chern number n=4, its surface can be gapped out by an anomalous Z_{2} topological order, where all anyons carry mirror-symmetry fractionalization M^{2}=-1. The identification of such anomalous crystalline symmetry fractionalization implies that in a two-dimensional Z_{2} spin liquid, the vison excitation cannot carry M^{2}=-1 if the spinon carries M^{2}=-1 or a half-integer spin.