Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2407.18339 · IEEE International Conference on Quantum Computing and Engineering (QCE)

Few-Shot, Robust Calibration of Single Qubit Gates Using Bayesian Robust Phase Estimation

Travis Hurant, Ke Sun, Zhubing Jia, Jungsang Kim, Kenneth R. Brown

Published Sep 15, 2024• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Accurate calibration of control parameters in quan-tum gates is crucial for high-fidelity operations, yet it represents a significant time and resource challenge, necessitating periods of downtime for quantum computers. Robust Phase Estimation (RPE) [8] has emerged as a practical and effective calibration technique aimed at tackling this challenge. It combines a provably efficient number of control pulses with a classical post-processing algorithm to estimate the phase accumulated by a quantum gate. We introduce Bayesian Robust Phase Estimation (BRPE), an in-novative approach that integrates Bayesian parameter estimation into the classical post-processing phase to reduce the sampling overhead. Our numerical analysis shows that BRPE markedly reduces phase estimation errors, requiring approximately 50% fewer samples than standard RPE. Specifically, in an ideal, noise-free setting, it achieves up to a 96% reduction in average absolute estimation error for a fixed sample cost of 88 shots when compared to RPE. Under a depolarizing noise model, it attains up to a 47% reduction for a fixed cost of 1 76 shots. Additionally, we adapt BRPE for Ramsey spectroscopy applications and successfully implement it experimentally in a trapped ion system.

DOI
10.1109/qce60285.2024.00147

Related papers

Robust calibration of a universal single-qubit gate set via robust phase estimation

Shelby Kimmel, Guang Hao Low, Theodore J. Yoder

An important step in building a quantum computer is calibrating experimentally implemented quantum gates to produce operations that are close to ideal unitaries. The calibration step involves estimating the systematic errors in gates and then using controls to correct the implementation. Quantum process tomography is a standard technique for estimating these errors but is both time consuming (when one wants to learn only a few key parameters) and usually inaccurate without resources such as perfect state preparation and measurement, which might not be available. With the goal of efficiently and accurately estimating specific errors using minimal resources, we develop a parameter estimation technique, which can gauge key systematic parameters (specifically, amplitude and off-resonance errors) in a universal single-qubit gate set with provable robustness and efficiency. In particular, our estimates achieve the optimal efficiency, Heisenberg scaling, and do so without entanglement and entirely within a single-qubit Hilbert space. Our main theorem making this possible is a robust version of the phase estimation procedure of Higgins et al. [B. L. Higgins et al., New J. Phys. 11, 073023 (2009)].

arXiv:1502.02677•Physical Review A•Dec 8, 2015•155 citations

Testing the robustness of robust phase estimation

Adam M. Meier, Jan‐Karl Burkhardt, Brian J. McMahon +1 more

The robust phase estimation (RPE) protocol was designed to be an efficient and robust way to calibrate quantum operations. The robustness of RPE refers to its ability to estimate a single parameter, usually gate amplitude, even when other parameters are poorly calibrated or when the gate experiences significant errors. Here we demonstrate the robustness of RPE to errors that affect initialization, measurement, and gates. In each case, the error threshold at which RPE begins to fail matches quantitatively with theoretical bounds. We conclude that RPE is an effective and reliable tool for calibration of one-qubit rotations and that it is particularly useful for automated calibration routines and sensor tasks.

arXiv:1907.11766•Physical Review A•Nov 11, 2019•10 citations

Fast quantum calibration using Bayesian optimization with state parameter estimator for non-Markovian environment

Anonymous, Shahid Qamar, Xiao Xiao +5 more

As quantum systems expand in size and complexity, manual qubit characterization and gate optimization will be a non-scalable and time-consuming venture. Physical qubits have to be carefully calibrated because quantum processors are very sensitive to the external environment, with control hardware parameters slowly drifting during operation, affecting gate fidelity. Currently, existing calibration techniques require complex and lengthy measurements to independently control the different parameters of each gate and are unscalable to large quantum systems. Therefore, fully automated protocols with the desired functionalities are required to speed up the calibration process. This paper aims to propose single-qubit calibration of superconducting qubits under continuous weak measurements from a real physical experimental settings point of view. We propose a real-time optimal estimator of qubit states, which utilizes weak measurements and Bayesian optimization to find the optimal control pulses for gate design. Our numerical results demonstrate a significant reduction in the calibration process, obtaining a high gate fidelity. Using the proposed estimator we estimated the qubit state with and without measurement noise and the estimation error between the qubit state and the estimator state is less than 0.02. With this setup, we drive an approximated pi pulse with final fidelity of 0.9928. This shows that our proposed strategy is robust against the presence of measurement and environmental noise and can also be applicable for the calibration of many other quantum computation technologies.

arXiv:2205.12929•Physical Review A•Jul 14, 2026•5 citations

Heisenberg-limited calibration of entangling gates with robust phase estimation

Kenneth Rudinger, J. P. Marceaux, Akel Hashim +3 more

The calibration of high-quality two-qubit entangling gates is an essential component in engineering large-scale, fault-tolerant quantum computers. However, many standard calibration techniques are based on randomized circuits that are only quadratically sensitive to calibration errors. As a result, these approaches are inefficient, requiring many experimental shots to achieve acceptable performance. In this work, we demonstrate that robust phase estimation can enable high-precision, Heisenberg-limited estimates of coherent errors in multi-qubit gates. Equipped with an efficient estimator, the calibration problem may be reduced to a simple optimization loop that minimizes the estimated coherent error. We experimentally demonstrate our calibration protocols by improving the operation of a two-qubit controlled-Z gate on a superconducting processor, and we validate the improved performance with gate set tomography. Our methods are applicable to gates in other quantum hardware platforms such as ion traps and neutral atoms, and on other multi-qubit gates, such as CNOT or iSWAP.

arXiv:2502.06698•Feb 10, 2025•4 citations

Experimental Demonstration of a Cheap and Accurate Phase Estimation

Kenneth Rudinger, Shelby Kimmel, Daniel Lobser +1 more

We demonstrate an experimental implementation of robust phase estimation (RPE) to learn the phase of a single-qubit rotation on a trapped Yb^{+} ion qubit. We show this phase can be estimated with an uncertainty below 4×10^{-4} rad using as few as 176 total experimental samples, and our estimates exhibit Heisenberg scaling. Unlike standard phase estimation protocols, RPE neither assumes perfect state preparation and measurement, nor requires access to ancillae. We crossvalidate the results of RPE with the more resource-intensive protocol of gate set tomography.

arXiv:1702.01763•Physical Review Letters•May 11, 2017•40 citations

Harnessing Bayesian Optimisation for Quantum Information Processing

Fernando Martínez-García

Achieving precise control over quantum systems has groundbreaking ap-plications, such as simulating complex quantum systems, or implementing quantum algorithms with an improved efficiency over classical algorithms. Quantum computing has been under development for the last decades, re-sulting in the so-called Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) devices with about 50 qubits. While these devices are built with the purpose of achieving practical advantages over classical processors, they are vulnerable to noise sources. In order to account for error sources, one needs to im-plement Quantum Error Correction (QEC) techniques. These techniques protect quantum information by encoding a logical qubit into several phys-ical ones. For the implementation of NISQ devices and QEC techniques, it is vital to keep improving the quantum operations and states involved. Here we develop calibration protocols based on the application of Bayesian inference. We show their advantages compared to the more traditional frequentist approaches, such as their ability to maximise the information gained with each measurement, or their straightforward automation. In our first line of research, we develop a Bayesian protocol for the correction of unwanted phases appearing in the experimental preparation of Steane code states. This protocol requires 13 times less measurements than the frequentist approach. In our second line of research, we develop a proto-col for locking a laser to the qubit transition frequency in a trapped-ion architecture. This calibration is vital, since the correct implementation of single-qubit gates depends on it. In our final line of research, we study the Mølmer-Sørensen entangling gate, used in trapped-ion systems. First we introduce the calibration parameters, and derive a semianalytical model of the effects of one of them, for which there was no previous analytical understanding. Finally, we develop a Bayesian protocol for the calibration of these parameters, which was successfully implemented and tested in an experimental trapped-ion quantum processor.

•Jan 1, 2022•0 citations
Accurate calibration of control parameters in quan-tum gates is crucial for high-fidelity operations, yet it represents a significant time and resource challenge, necessitating periods of downtime for quantum computers. Robust Phase Estimation (RPE) [8] has emerged as a practical and effective calibration technique aimed at tackling this challenge. It combines a provably efficient number of control pulses with a classical post-processing algorithm to estimate the phase accumulated by a quantum gate. We introduce Bayesian Robust Phase Estimation (BRPE), an in-novative approach that integrates Bayesian parameter estimation into the classical post-processing phase to reduce the sampling overhead. Our numerical analysis shows that BRPE markedly reduces phase estimation errors, requiring approximately 50% fewer samples than standard RPE. Specifically, in an ideal, noise-free setting, it achieves up to a 96% reduction in average absolute estimation error for a fixed sample cost of 88 shots when compared to RPE. Under a depolarizing noise model, it attains up to a 47% reduction for a fixed cost of 1 76 shots. Additionally, we adapt BRPE for Ramsey spectroscopy applications and successfully implement it experimentally in a trapped ion system.
An important step in building a quantum computer is calibrating experimentally implemented quantum gates to produce operations that are close to ideal unitaries. The calibration step involves estimating the systematic errors in gates and then using controls to correct the implementation. Quantum process tomography is a standard technique for estimating these errors but is both time consuming (when one wants to learn only a few key parameters) and usually inaccurate without resources such as perfect state preparation and measurement, which might not be available. With the goal of efficiently and accurately estimating specific errors using minimal resources, we develop a parameter estimation technique, which can gauge key systematic parameters (specifically, amplitude and off-resonance errors) in a universal single-qubit gate set with provable robustness and efficiency. In particular, our estimates achieve the optimal efficiency, Heisenberg scaling, and do so without entanglement and entirely within a single-qubit Hilbert space. Our main theorem making this possible is a robust version of the phase estimation procedure of Higgins et al. [B. L. Higgins et al., New J. Phys. 11, 073023 (2009)].
The robust phase estimation (RPE) protocol was designed to be an efficient and robust way to calibrate quantum operations. The robustness of RPE refers to its ability to estimate a single parameter, usually gate amplitude, even when other parameters are poorly calibrated or when the gate experiences significant errors. Here we demonstrate the robustness of RPE to errors that affect initialization, measurement, and gates. In each case, the error threshold at which RPE begins to fail matches quantitatively with theoretical bounds. We conclude that RPE is an effective and reliable tool for calibration of one-qubit rotations and that it is particularly useful for automated calibration routines and sensor tasks.
As quantum systems expand in size and complexity, manual qubit characterization and gate optimization will be a non-scalable and time-consuming venture. Physical qubits have to be carefully calibrated because quantum processors are very sensitive to the external environment, with control hardware parameters slowly drifting during operation, affecting gate fidelity. Currently, existing calibration techniques require complex and lengthy measurements to independently control the different parameters of each gate and are unscalable to large quantum systems. Therefore, fully automated protocols with the desired functionalities are required to speed up the calibration process. This paper aims to propose single-qubit calibration of superconducting qubits under continuous weak measurements from a real physical experimental settings point of view. We propose a real-time optimal estimator of qubit states, which utilizes weak measurements and Bayesian optimization to find the optimal control pulses for gate design. Our numerical results demonstrate a significant reduction in the calibration process, obtaining a high gate fidelity. Using the proposed estimator we estimated the qubit state with and without measurement noise and the estimation error between the qubit state and the estimator state is less than 0.02. With this setup, we drive an approximated pi pulse with final fidelity of 0.9928. This shows that our proposed strategy is robust against the presence of measurement and environmental noise and can also be applicable for the calibration of many other quantum computation technologies.
The calibration of high-quality two-qubit entangling gates is an essential component in engineering large-scale, fault-tolerant quantum computers. However, many standard calibration techniques are based on randomized circuits that are only quadratically sensitive to calibration errors. As a result, these approaches are inefficient, requiring many experimental shots to achieve acceptable performance. In this work, we demonstrate that robust phase estimation can enable high-precision, Heisenberg-limited estimates of coherent errors in multi-qubit gates. Equipped with an efficient estimator, the calibration problem may be reduced to a simple optimization loop that minimizes the estimated coherent error. We experimentally demonstrate our calibration protocols by improving the operation of a two-qubit controlled-Z gate on a superconducting processor, and we validate the improved performance with gate set tomography. Our methods are applicable to gates in other quantum hardware platforms such as ion traps and neutral atoms, and on other multi-qubit gates, such as CNOT or iSWAP.
We demonstrate an experimental implementation of robust phase estimation (RPE) to learn the phase of a single-qubit rotation on a trapped Yb^{+} ion qubit. We show this phase can be estimated with an uncertainty below 4×10^{-4} rad using as few as 176 total experimental samples, and our estimates exhibit Heisenberg scaling. Unlike standard phase estimation protocols, RPE neither assumes perfect state preparation and measurement, nor requires access to ancillae. We crossvalidate the results of RPE with the more resource-intensive protocol of gate set tomography.
Achieving precise control over quantum systems has groundbreaking ap-plications, such as simulating complex quantum systems, or implementing quantum algorithms with an improved efficiency over classical algorithms. Quantum computing has been under development for the last decades, re-sulting in the so-called Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) devices with about 50 qubits. While these devices are built with the purpose of achieving practical advantages over classical processors, they are vulnerable to noise sources. In order to account for error sources, one needs to im-plement Quantum Error Correction (QEC) techniques. These techniques protect quantum information by encoding a logical qubit into several phys-ical ones. For the implementation of NISQ devices and QEC techniques, it is vital to keep improving the quantum operations and states involved. Here we develop calibration protocols based on the application of Bayesian inference. We show their advantages compared to the more traditional frequentist approaches, such as their ability to maximise the information gained with each measurement, or their straightforward automation. In our first line of research, we develop a Bayesian protocol for the correction of unwanted phases appearing in the experimental preparation of Steane code states. This protocol requires 13 times less measurements than the frequentist approach. In our second line of research, we develop a proto-col for locking a laser to the qubit transition frequency in a trapped-ion architecture. This calibration is vital, since the correct implementation of single-qubit gates depends on it. In our final line of research, we study the Mølmer-Sørensen entangling gate, used in trapped-ion systems. First we introduce the calibration parameters, and derive a semianalytical model of the effects of one of them, for which there was no previous analytical understanding. Finally, we develop a Bayesian protocol for the calibration of these parameters, which was successfully implemented and tested in an experimental trapped-ion quantum processor.