Abstract We re-use some original ideas of de Broglie, Schrödiger, Dirac and Feynman to revise the ensemble interpretation of wave function in quantum mechanics. To this end we introduce coherence (auto-concordance) of ensembles of quantum trajectories in the space-time. The coherence condition accounts phases proportional to classical action, which are in foundation of the Feynman path integral technique. Therefore, our interpretation is entirely based on well-known and tested concepts and methods of wave mechanics. Similarly to other ensemble interpretations our approach allows us to avoid all problems and paradoxes related to wave function collapse during a measurement process. Another consequence is that no quantum computation or quantum cryptography method will ever work if it assumes that a particular q-bit represents the entire wave function.
Abstract We re-use some original ideas of de Broglie, Schrödiger, Dirac and Feynman to revise the ensemble interpretation of wave function in quantum mechanics. To this end we introduce coherence (auto-concordance) of ensembles of quantum trajectories in the space-time. The coherence condition accounts phases proportional to classical action, which are in foundation of the Feynman path integral technique. Therefore, our interpretation is entirely based on well-known and tested concepts and methods of wave mechanics. Similarly to other ensemble interpretations our approach allows us to avoid all problems and paradoxes related to wave function collapse during a measurement process. Another consequence is that no quantum computation or quantum cryptography method will ever work if it assumes that a particular q-bit represents the entire wave function.
In Feynman's space-time approach to nonrelativistic quantum mechanics, the wave function may be considered to be the sum of path integrals over Brownian-motion trajectories. This formalism is entirely equivalent to the Schr\"odinger-equation treatment with its intrinsic indeterminacy. Pursuing the analogy with Brownian motion further, one may introduce a hidden variable corresponding to particle velocity in order to represent the wave function as a sum of path integrals taken over phase-space trajectories. By means of a hidden parameter corresponding to the time scale of fictitious interactions of the particle with the vacuum, one can define generalized propagators which over very short times produce wave functions which are localizable in phase space and hence are deterministic. For long times the conventional Feynman formalism is recovered. This short-time causality does not violate the von Neumann injunction against hidden variables since the new velocity variable turns out to be non-Hermitian over the long time scales normally considered. In contrast to the models proposed by Bohm and others, the present Brownian model is linear and preserves the usual statistical interpretation of the wave function for sufficiently long times.
In this paper the quantised version of Newton Second Law is derived assuming merely the existence of de Broglie matter-waves and their basic properties. At the same time we keep an eye towards interpretations of quantum mechanics and will realise that the two most different interpretations (Copenhagen interpretation and the de Broglie-Bohm theory) owe their difference to two fundamentally different approaches to `Harmonisation'. In this regard we shall see that the guiding equation of the de Broglie-Bohm theory currently found in literature is not the most complete equation possible; as a result we answer one of the important questions in interpreting quantum mechanics, namely that `when does the concept of classical path (trajectory) makes sense in quantum mechanics?' Moreover, in light of special-relativistic considerations we shall easily see that in the Number-Division approach, i.e. that of de Broglie-Bohm, the wave operator no longer appears, making it in turn impossible the application of Clifford algebras (Dirac's `square root' of the wave operator).
Chapter 4 shows that, just as Heisenberg’s matrix mechanics represented a break with classical physics and the beginning of a new physics, Schrödinger’s wave mechanics represented another, no less radical, break with classical physics and at the same time opened up another path to the quantum world. Schrödinger’s theory is shown to make substantial use of de Broglie’s waves and related phenomena. The Schrödinger equation, being wave-like, constitutes mathematically an eigenvalue problem for bounded systems, and thus naturally leads to quantization, as is illustrated with a couple of simple examples. The chapter ends with Dirac’s abstract formulation, which has the advantage of being suitable for any description, be it Heisenberg’s, Schrödinger’s or any other.
First, we show that there exists in classical mechanics three actions corresponding to different boundary conditions: two well-known actions, the Euler-Lagrange classical action S_cl(x,t;x_0), which links the initial position x_0 and its position x at time t, the Hamilton-Jacobi action S(x,t), which links a family of particles of initial action S_0(x) to their various positions x at time t, and a new action, the deterministic action S(x,t;x_0,v_0), which links a particle in initial position x_0 and initial velocity v_0 to its position x at time t. We study, in the semi-classical approximation, the convergence of the quantum density and the quantum action, solutions to the Madelung equations, when the Planck constant h tends to 0. We find two different solutions which depend on the initial density. In the first case, where the initial quantum density is a classical density, the quantum density and the quantum action converge to a classical action and a classical density which satisfy the statistical Hamilton-Jacobi equations. These are the equations of a set of classical particles whose initial positions are known only by the initial density. In the second case where initial density converges to a Dirac density, the density converges to the Dirac function and the quantum action converges to a deterministic action. Therefore we introduce into classical mechanics non-discerned particles, which satisfy the statistical Hamilton-Jacobi-equations and explain the Gibbs paradox, and discerned particles, which satisfy the deterministic Hamilton-Jacobi equations. Finally, we propose an interpretation of the Schrodinger wave function that depends on the initial conditions (preparation). This double interpretation seems to be the interpretation of Louis de Broglie's "double solution" idea.
We choose to examine a phenomenon which is impossible, absolutely impossible, to explain in any classical way, and which has in it the heart of quantum mechanics. In reality, it contains the only mystery. —Richard P. Feynman In this chapter we show that a reformulation of quantum mechanics, namely Feynman's path integral approach, is equivalent to the earlier ones, due to Schrödinger and Heisenberg. We shall introduce and apply it in this chapter to interpret the Aharonov–Bohm effect, which is considered to be a “quantum wonder.” It underscores the importance of electromagnetic potentials. We shall find that in addition to the dynamical phase introduced in Chapter 1, another angle, namely the geometric phase (Pancharatnam–Berry phase), is an important physical property of the wavefunction whose consequences are measurable. 2.1 Propagator: Propagation of a Quantum of Knowledge Notwithstanding the equivalence of wave mechanics and matrix mechanics, Schrödinger and Heisenberg did not appreciate each other's methodologies [1]. In 1926, Schrödinger said: “ I knew of [Heisenberg’s] theory, of course, but I felt discouraged, not to say repelled, by the methods of transcendental algebra, which appeared difficult to me, and by the lack of visualizability. ” Heisenberg's dislike for Schrödinger's wave mechanics was equally intense. In the same year, in a letter to Pauli, he wrote “ The more I think about the physical portion of Schrödinger's theory, the more repulsive I find it…. What Schrödinger writes about the visualizability of his theory ‘is probably not quite right,’ in other words it's crap .” In the mean time, Paul A. M. Dirac, who had made path-breaking contributions [2] in that eventful year (1926) to the formulation of quantum mechanics, had drawn a penetrating analogy [3] between classical and quantum mechanics. Dirac's remark drew the attention of Richard P. Feynman, who used it to build the path integral approach to quantum mechanics based on the variational principle. Feynman was introduced to the principle of extremum action [4] rather early, while in high school. He reveals in his book [5] that “ my Physics teacher … Mr. Bader … told me something … absolutely fascinating…. Every time the subject comes up, I work on it … the principle of least (rather, ‘extremum’) action. ”
The phase corresponding to a certain path in the Feynman path integral is derived with the help of the de Broglie hypothesis. Zusammenfassung. Die einem bestimmten Pfad entsprechende Phase im Feynman-Pfadintegral wird mit Hilfe der de Broglie-Hypothese abgeleitet. In the beginning quantum mechanics was built up by analogy with the formulation of classical mechanics in terms of the Hamilton function. In 1933, Dirac [2] announced the idea of formulating quantum mechanics on the basis of the Lagrange function. He started from the analogy between the treatment of classical motion as a canonical transformation and the transformational properties of operators with respect to a time translation. This idea of Dirac was developed further by Feynman [3], who regarded a quantum-mechanical motion from one space-time point to another as a superposition of motions along all possible paths connecting the two points. Each path contributes to the total probability amplitude a term proportional to where is the classical action corresponding to this path and is Planck's constant. Feynman [3] adopted the form of the phase in the expression (1) as a postulate. Another way, however, of deriving the phase is to use the de Broglie hypothesis [1], as shown below. According to this hypothesis, it is possible to associate any particle with a certain frequency proportional to its energy (Hamiltonian function), i.e., and a wave vector proportional to the particle's momentum as Now consider, in the sense of Feynman's formulation, a particle moving along a certain path from point 1 to point 2. During the motion, let and be the radius vectors of the particle at the times t, t+ dt respectively. According to the de Broglie hypothesis, we can associate a plane wave with the particle in the neighbourhood of these points. The phase change of this wave along the particle's path during the motion between the points and consists of space and time phase changes: The term in the parentheses is precisely the value of the Lagrange function at the point . The phase change of the wavefunction corresponding to the whole path can be obtained by integration of the term expressing the infinitesimal phase change: In this way, on the basis of the de Broglie hypothesis, we have reached full agreement with Feynman's postulate: the phase of the probability amplitude corresponding to a certain path is equal to , where is the classical action corresponding to this path. References [1] de Broglie L 1923 Comptes rendus 177 548 - 550 [2] Dirac P A M 1933 Phys. Z. der Sowjetunion 3 64 [3] Feynman R 1948 Rev. Mod. Phys. 2 367