Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2407.07782 · Physical Review Letters

Universal and Nonuniversal Signatures in the Scaling Functions of Critical Variables

Gianluca Teza, Attilio L. Stella

Published Mar 28, 2025• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

At criticality, the magnetization M of a d-dimensional Ising system with N spins is distributed such that the probability density function of m=M/N^{y_{H}/d}, with y_{H} universal exponent, converges to a limit f(m). The expectation that f should furnish a hallmark of universal behavior contrasts with its sensible dependence on nonuniversal features. We show that both nonuniversal amplitudes and universal exponents of leading power law singularities in all large deviation functions are determined by the fact that, due to extensivity, f(m)∼_{|m|≫1}exp(-c|m|^{δ+1}), with δ=y_{H}/(d-y_{H}) and c a nonuniversal coefficient. This unexplored scenario implies a universal form of central limit theorem at criticality and is confirmed by exact calculations for mean field Ising models in equilibrium and for anomalous diffusion models, with M replaced by displacement and N by time.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.134.127102

Related papers

Hidden universality of rare fluctuations and a central-limit structure at criticality

Nikolaos G. Fytas, Víctor Martín-Mayor, Attilio L. Stella +3 more

The central limit theorem is among the most fundamental principles in the natural sciences, governing the fluctuations of sums of weakly correlated random variables through Gaussian statistics. At critical points, however, long-range correlations invalidate this paradigm, raising a fundamental question: does any general limit theorem survive at criticality? Although scale invariance has long been recognised as the defining feature of typical critical fluctuations, the behaviour of rare fluctuations has remained largely unexplored, as their extraordinarily small probabilities place them beyond the reach of conventional numerical methods. Recent theoretical advances suggest that universal asymptotic laws {may govern large deviations in systems at criticality}, yet direct numerical evidence has been lacking. Here we provide the first such evidence in the two-dimensional Ising universality class. Using large-scale Tethered Monte Carlo simulations, we probe order-parameter fluctuations with probabilities as small as $10^{-200}$ and show that, once normalised by their characteristic width, the far tails collapse onto a single asymptotic law shared by distinct microscopic models in the same universality class. This collapse is governed by a universal amplitude, whose numerical extraction is compatible with the conjectured exact result we derive from conformal field theory, and points towards a generalised central limit theorem for critical fluctuations.

arXiv:2611.14621•Nov 10, 2026•0 citations

Large-deviation tails of critical order-parameter distributions

Jinhong Zhu, Yihao Xu, Abbas Ali Saberi +1 more

Large-deviation tails of critical probability distributions provide a sensitive probe of universality beyond standard finite-size scaling. We study these tails for critical percolation and Fortuin--Kasteleyn Ising models on two-dimensional lattices, three-dimensional lattices, and complete graphs. We consider two rescaled order parameters: the magnetization-like variable $x_m=|M|/\langle |M|\rangle$, including a signed cluster-mass analogue for percolation, and the largest-cluster variable $x_C=C_1/\langle C_1\rangle$. For $x_m$, we test the expected stretched-exponential large-deviation tail and show that the same form applies to the percolation analogue. For $x_C$, guided by the exact complete-graph result and scaling arguments, we propose universal scaling forms for both tails of the cumulative distribution and test them by extensive Monte Carlo simulations. In the complete-graph FK-Ising model, the left tail is governed by rare configurations with percolation-like scaling rather than by the typical Ising scaling. Our results show that the tails of order-parameter distributions reveal universal features of critical fluctuations that are not captured by averaged observables alone.

arXiv:2606.19030•Jun 17, 2026•1 citation

Finite-size calculations for the kinetic Ising model

Rahul Anil Pandit, Gabor Forgács, Pál Ruján

Using a Hamiltonian formulation of the master equation, we carry out finite-size calculations for the dynamical critical exponent $z$ of the kinetic Ising model in one and two dimensions. In one dimension, different appropriately normalized transition probabilities give different values for $z$; this result is based on both exact and finite-size calculations. We show that this "nonuniversal" behavior is due to the fact that the critical temperature for the one-dimensional Ising model is zero. In two dimensions we combine our finite-size calculations with finite-size scaling theory to calculate $z$. Even in this case we find that $z$ depends on the form of the transition probability---a result that contradicts the universality hypothesis for dynamical critical behavior. We discuss the possible reasons for this contradiction.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Aug 1, 1981•9 citations

Two-dimensional Ising model and local nonuniversality of critical exponents

R. Z. Bariev

We obtain the local magnetization of a planar Ising model with defects of different types. It is shown that near the critical point the local magnetization has a nonuniversal behavior that manifests itself in the fact that its critical exponent is a continuous function of the microscopic parameters of the system.

Brazilian Journal of Physics•Dec 1, 2000•1 citation

Generalization of the central limit theorem to critical systems: Revisiting perturbation theory

Sankarshan Sahu, Bertrand Delamotte, Adam Rançon

The central limit theorem does not hold for strongly correlated stochastic variables, as is the case for statistical systems close to criticality. Recently, the calculation of the probability distribution function (PDF) of the magnetization mode has been performed with the functional renormalization group in the case of the three-dimensional Ising model [Balog et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 129, 210602 (2022)10.1103/PhysRevLett.129.210602]. It has been shown in that article that there exists an entire family of universal PDFs parameterized by ζ=lim_{L,ξ_{∞}→∞}L/ξ_{∞} which is the ratio of the system size L to the bulk correlation length ξ_{∞} with both the thermodynamic limit and the critical limit being taken simultaneously. We show how these PDFs or, equivalently, the rate functions which are their logarithm, can be systematically computed perturbatively in the ε=4-d expansion. We determine the whole family of universal PDFs and show that they are in good qualitative agreement with Monte Carlo data. Finally, we conjecture on how to significantly improve the quantitative agreement between the one-loop and the numerical results.

arXiv:2407.12603•Physical review. E•Mar 26, 2025•9 citations

Mean-field behavior of the finite size Ising model near its critical point

Daniela Olascoaga-Rodríguez, Francisco Sastre, Víctor Romero-Rochín

Universality classes encompass the analogous thermodynamic behavior of unlike physical systems, at different spatial dimensions d , in the vicinity of their critical point. Critical exponents define these classes, with the Ising model being the outstanding prototype that elucidates the differences from the mean-field category, believed to be valid above a critical dimension only. Here, in apparent striking contradiction to the Ising universality class, we demonstrate that the critical behavior of a finite Ising system of N spins in d = 3 obeys mean-field Landau theory in the vicinity of its critical point, with classical critical exponents. Yet, when expressed in terms of the linear size L of the system, the free energy unveils its proper finite-size scaling form, from which the thermodynamic limit critical temperature T c and the Ising critical exponents ν , γ and β can be identified. We find that the larger the size L , the smaller the mean-field region, shrinking to zero in the thermodynamic limit. These conclusions are achieved via the use of an alternative data analysis of Monte Carlo simulations of a three-dimensional Ising model that allows for the evaluation of the free energy per spin f = f ( T , m ; L ) and of the coexistence curve, or spontaneous magnetization at zero magnetic field, m coex = m ( T ; L ) as functions of temperature T and magnetization per spin m = M / N . Our results suggest a revision of the role of mean-field theory in the elucidation of critical phenomena.

Physica A Statistical Mechanics and its Applications•Jun 8, 2026•0 citations
At criticality, the magnetization M of a d-dimensional Ising system with N spins is distributed such that the probability density function of m=M/N^{y_{H}/d}, with y_{H} universal exponent, converges to a limit f(m). The expectation that f should furnish a hallmark of universal behavior contrasts with its sensible dependence on nonuniversal features. We show that both nonuniversal amplitudes and universal exponents of leading power law singularities in all large deviation functions are determined by the fact that, due to extensivity, f(m)∼{|m|≫1}exp(-c|m|^{δ+1}), with δ=y{H}/(d-y_{H}) and c a nonuniversal coefficient. This unexplored scenario implies a universal form of central limit theorem at criticality and is confirmed by exact calculations for mean field Ising models in equilibrium and for anomalous diffusion models, with M replaced by displacement and N by time.
The central limit theorem is among the most fundamental principles in the natural sciences, governing the fluctuations of sums of weakly correlated random variables through Gaussian statistics. At critical points, however, long-range correlations invalidate this paradigm, raising a fundamental question: does any general limit theorem survive at criticality? Although scale invariance has long been recognised as the defining feature of typical critical fluctuations, the behaviour of rare fluctuations has remained largely unexplored, as their extraordinarily small probabilities place them beyond the reach of conventional numerical methods. Recent theoretical advances suggest that universal asymptotic laws {may govern large deviations in systems at criticality}, yet direct numerical evidence has been lacking. Here we provide the first such evidence in the two-dimensional Ising universality class. Using large-scale Tethered Monte Carlo simulations, we probe order-parameter fluctuations with probabilities as small as 10−20010^{-200}10−200 and show that, once normalised by their characteristic width, the far tails collapse onto a single asymptotic law shared by distinct microscopic models in the same universality class. This collapse is governed by a universal amplitude, whose numerical extraction is compatible with the conjectured exact result we derive from conformal field theory, and points towards a generalised central limit theorem for critical fluctuations.
Large-deviation tails of critical probability distributions provide a sensitive probe of universality beyond standard finite-size scaling. We study these tails for critical percolation and Fortuin--Kasteleyn Ising models on two-dimensional lattices, three-dimensional lattices, and complete graphs. We consider two rescaled order parameters: the magnetization-like variable xm=∣M∣/⟨∣M∣⟩x_m=|M|/\langle |M|\ranglexm​=∣M∣/⟨∣M∣⟩, including a signed cluster-mass analogue for percolation, and the largest-cluster variable xC=C1/⟨C1⟩x_C=C_1/\langle C_1\ranglexC​=C1​/⟨C1​⟩. For xmx_mxm​, we test the expected stretched-exponential large-deviation tail and show that the same form applies to the percolation analogue. For xCx_CxC​, guided by the exact complete-graph result and scaling arguments, we propose universal scaling forms for both tails of the cumulative distribution and test them by extensive Monte Carlo simulations. In the complete-graph FK-Ising model, the left tail is governed by rare configurations with percolation-like scaling rather than by the typical Ising scaling. Our results show that the tails of order-parameter distributions reveal universal features of critical fluctuations that are not captured by averaged observables alone.
Using a Hamiltonian formulation of the master equation, we carry out finite-size calculations for the dynamical critical exponent zzz of the kinetic Ising model in one and two dimensions. In one dimension, different appropriately normalized transition probabilities give different values for zzz; this result is based on both exact and finite-size calculations. We show that this "nonuniversal" behavior is due to the fact that the critical temperature for the one-dimensional Ising model is zero. In two dimensions we combine our finite-size calculations with finite-size scaling theory to calculate zzz. Even in this case we find that zzz depends on the form of the transition probability---a result that contradicts the universality hypothesis for dynamical critical behavior. We discuss the possible reasons for this contradiction.
The central limit theorem does not hold for strongly correlated stochastic variables, as is the case for statistical systems close to criticality. Recently, the calculation of the probability distribution function (PDF) of the magnetization mode has been performed with the functional renormalization group in the case of the three-dimensional Ising model [Balog et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 129, 210602 (2022)10.1103/PhysRevLett.129.210602]. It has been shown in that article that there exists an entire family of universal PDFs parameterized by ζ=lim_{L,ξ_{∞}→∞}L/ξ_{∞} which is the ratio of the system size L to the bulk correlation length ξ_{∞} with both the thermodynamic limit and the critical limit being taken simultaneously. We show how these PDFs or, equivalently, the rate functions which are their logarithm, can be systematically computed perturbatively in the ε=4-d expansion. We determine the whole family of universal PDFs and show that they are in good qualitative agreement with Monte Carlo data. Finally, we conjecture on how to significantly improve the quantitative agreement between the one-loop and the numerical results.
Universality classes encompass the analogous thermodynamic behavior of unlike physical systems, at different spatial dimensions d , in the vicinity of their critical point. Critical exponents define these classes, with the Ising model being the outstanding prototype that elucidates the differences from the mean-field category, believed to be valid above a critical dimension only. Here, in apparent striking contradiction to the Ising universality class, we demonstrate that the critical behavior of a finite Ising system of N spins in d = 3 obeys mean-field Landau theory in the vicinity of its critical point, with classical critical exponents. Yet, when expressed in terms of the linear size L of the system, the free energy unveils its proper finite-size scaling form, from which the thermodynamic limit critical temperature T c and the Ising critical exponents ν , γ and β can be identified. We find that the larger the size L , the smaller the mean-field region, shrinking to zero in the thermodynamic limit. These conclusions are achieved via the use of an alternative data analysis of Monte Carlo simulations of a three-dimensional Ising model that allows for the evaluation of the free energy per spin f = f ( T , m ; L ) and of the coexistence curve, or spontaneous magnetization at zero magnetic field, m coex = m ( T ; L ) as functions of temperature T and magnetization per spin m = M / N . Our results suggest a revision of the role of mean-field theory in the elucidation of critical phenomena.