Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2406.14501 · Physical Review Applied

Quantum limits of superconducting-photonic links and their extension to millimeter waves

Kevin Multani, Wentao Jiang, Emilio Alessandro Nanni, Amir H. Safavi‐Naeini

Published Nov 15, 2024• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Photonic addressing of superconducting circuits has been proposed to overcome wiring complexity and heat-load challenges. However, such superconducting-photonic links suffer from an efficiency-noise trade-off that limits scalability. This trade-off arises because increasing power conversion efficiency entails reducing optical power, which makes the converted signal susceptible to shot noise. We analyze this trade-off and find that the laser-driven qubit gate infidelity scales inversely with the number of photons used. While methods such as nonlinear detection or squeezed light could mitigate this effect, we consider generating higher-frequency electrical signals, such as millimeter waves (100 GHz), using laser light. At these higher frequencies, circuits have higher operating temperatures and cooling power budgets and alleviate constraints posed by the trade-off. Therefore, we demonstrate an optically driven cryogenic millimeter-wave source with a maximum power efficiency of 8 × 10 − 5 that can generate a maximum of 0.7 μ W of 80 GHz power, with a 1200 -thermal-photon equivalent of added noise at 4 K . Using this source, we perform frequency-domain spectroscopy of superconducting Nb Ti N resonators at 80–90 GHz. Our results show a promising approach to lessen the efficiency-noise constraints on superconducting-photonic links, while leveraging the benefits of photonic signal delivery. Further optimization of power efficiency and noise at high frequencies could make scalable photonic control of superconducting qubits viable at temperatures exceeding 1 K . Published by the American Physical Society 2024

DOI
10.1103/physrevapplied.22.054043

Related papers

Millimeter-wave interconnects for microwave-frequency quantum machines

Marek Pechal, Amir H. Safavi‐Naeini

Superconducting microwave circuits form a versatile platform for storing and manipulating quantum information. A major challenge to further scalability is to find approaches for connecting these systems over long distances and at high rates. One approach is to convert the quantum state of a microwave circuit to optical photons that can be transmitted over kilometers at room temperature with little loss. Many proposals for electro-optic conversion between microwave and optics use optical driving of a weak three-wave mixing nonlinearity to convert the frequency of an excitation. Residual absorption of this optical pump leads to heating, which is problematic at cryogenic temperatures. Here we propose an alternative approach where a nonlinear superconducting circuit is driven to interconvert between microwave-frequency ($7\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{9}$ Hz) and millimeter-wave-frequency photons ($3\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{11}$ Hz). To understand the potential for quantum state conversion between microwave and millimeter-wave photons, we consider the driven four-wave mixing quantum dynamics of nonlinear circuits. In contrast to the linear dynamics of the driven three-wave mixing converters, the proposed four-wave mixing converter has nonlinear decoherence channels that lead to a more complex parameter space of couplings and pump powers that we map out. We consider physical realizations of such converter circuits by deriving theoretically the upper bound on the maximum obtainable nonlinear coupling between any two modes in a lossless circuit, and synthesizing an optimal circuit based on realistic materials that saturates this bound. Our proposed circuit dissipates less than ${10}^{\ensuremath{-}9}$ times the energy of current electro-optic converters per qubit. Finally, we outline the quantum link budget for optical, microwave, and millimeter-wave connections, showing that our approach is viable for realizing interconnected quantum processors for intracity or quantum data center environments.

arXiv:1706.05368•Physical Review A•Oct 6, 2017•38 citations

Scaling up Superconducting Quantum Computers With Cryogenic RF-Photonics

Sanskriti Joshi, Sajjad Moazeni

Today's hundred-qubit quantum computers require a dramatic scale up to millions of qubits to become practical for solving real-world problems. Although a variety of qubit technologies have been demonstrated, scalability remains a major hurdle. Superconducting (SC) qubits are one of the most mature and promising technologies to overcome this challenge. However, these qubits reside in a millikelvin cryogenic dilution fridge, isolating them from thermal and electrical noise. They are controlled by a rack-full of external electronics through extremely complex wiring and cables. Although thousands of qubits can be fabricated on a single chip and cooled down to millikelvin temperatures, scaling up the control and readout electronics remains an elusive goal. This is mainly due to the limited available cooling power in cryogenic systems constraining the wiring capacity and cabling heat load management. In this article, we focus on scaling up the number of XY-control lines by using cryogenic RF-photonic links. This is one of the major roadblocks to build a thousand qubit superconducting QC. We will first review and study the challenges of state-of-the-art proposed approaches, including cryogenic CMOS and deep-cryogenic photonic methods, to scale up the control interface for SC qubit systems. We will discuss their limitations due to the active power dissipation and passive heat leakage in detail. By analytically modeling the noise sources and thermal budget limits, we will show that our solution can achieve a scale up to a thousand of qubits. Our proposed method can be seamlessly implemented using advanced silicon photonic processes, and the number of required optical fibers can be further reduced by using wavelength division multiplexing (WDM).

arXiv:2210.15756•Journal of Lightwave Technology•Sep 5, 2023•32 citations

Electro-optic Links for Cryogenic Radio Frequency Systems

Hana Kei Warner

Radio frequency (RF) radiation is a powerful tool in computing, communication, and sensing due to the ability to engineer strong electrical interactions. Within cryogenic systems, in particular, microwave (MW) frequency superconducting qubits have demonstrated promise as a platform for quantum computing, and MW and millimeter-wave (mmW) systems have been valuable tools in sensing. However, owing to their low energy, the weak, single-photon level signals employed by these systems suffer high sensitivity to thermal noise when they exit the thermal bath, as well as short attenuation lengths due to absorption and scattering in cables. Telecommunication frequency optical photons, meanwhile, have long propagation lengths and can be supported by low-loss optical fibers. The high photon energy makes signals insensitive to thermal noise, and the high frequency can allow many RF signals to be multiplexed onto a single optical carrier. Interfacing RF and optical radiation to leverage both strong interactions with macroscopic systems characteristic of electrical interactions and low-loss propagation characteristic of optical photons has been critical to realizing our global communication system. Leveraging the infrastructure developed to support this industry, such as single photon detectors, is attractive for scaling cryogenic RF systems. Coherent conversion processes, especially, can benefit a wide range of applications, especially in computing and sensing, by preserving quantum states, and retaining phase information necessary for quantum gates, and enable the use of measurement techniques that can increase detection sensitivity. This dissertation focuses on using the electro-optic effect in thin-film lithium niobate to form an efficient, coherent interface between radio- and telecommunication-frequency photons. Lithium niobate is an attractive platform due to its high electro-optic coefficient (approx. 30 pm/V), wide transparency window (DC to 400 THz), and ability to support low-loss optical waveguides (.2 dB/m), all of which deviate little from room temperature down to near-zero Kelvin environments. First, I explore the development of low-loss lithium niobate optical cavities and operation of lithium niobate waveguides at low temperatures. While lithium niobate is an electro-optic material with a DC response, using the electro-optic response at room temperature for stable biasing and low-frequency operation has remained a challenge. A temperature- and frequency-dependent study is conducted to identify lithium charge migration as a potential screening mechanism suppressed at low temperatures. Next, I explore the use of RF-cavity enhanced, triply resonant photonic molecules (created from two coupled low-loss optical cavities) for forming efficient electro-optic interfaces with microwave (3-10 GHz) and millimeter wave (100 GHz) radiation. In the microwave regime, I explore microwave-optical transduction for forming optical interfaces with microwave qubits, specifically focusing on superconducting qubits. The characterization of one such transducer is demonstrated, and the device is used to optically synthesize microwave signals at low temperatures, bypassing the need for input microwave control lines. Outlook for other interfaces, including optical photon mediated quantum information transfer, is discussed. At mmW frequencies, the triply resonant photonic molecule is explored for low-power ( mW) optical-frequency shifting.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Thermal noise in electro-optic devices at cryogenic temperatures

Sonia Mobassem, N. J. Lambert, Alfredo Rueda +3 more

Abstract The quantum bits (qubits) on which superconducting quantum computers are based have energy scales corresponding to photons with GHz frequencies. The energy of photons in the gigahertz domain is too low to allow transmission through the noisy room-temperature environment, where the signal would be lost in thermal noise. Optical photons, on the other hand, have much higher energies, and signals can be detected using highly efficient single-photon detectors. Transduction from microwave to optical frequencies is therefore a potential enabling technology for quantum devices. However, in such a device the optical pump can be a source of thermal noise and thus degrade the fidelity; the similarity of input microwave state to the output optical state. In order to investigate the magnitude of this effect we model the sub-Kelvin thermal behavior of an electro-optic transducer based on a lithium niobate whispering gallery mode resonator. We find that there is an optimum power level for a continuous pump, whilst pulsed operation of the pump increases the fidelity of the conversion.

arXiv:2008.08764•Quantum Science and Technology•Jun 28, 2021•12 citations

Electro-optic conversion of itinerant Fock states

Thomas Werner, Erfan Riyazi, Samarth Hawaldar +10 more

Superconducting qubits are a leading candidate for utility-scale quantum computing due to their fast gate speeds and steadily decreasing error rates. The requirement for millikelvin operating temperatures, however, creates a significant scaling bottleneck. Modular architectures using optical fiber links could bridge separate cryogenic nodes, but superconducting circuits do not have coherent optical transitions and microwave-to-optical conversion has not been shown for any non-classical photon state. In this work, we demonstrate the on-demand generation and tomographic reconstruction of itinerant single microwave photons at 8.9 GHz from a superconducting qubit. We upconvert this non-Gaussian state with a transducer added noise below 0.012 quanta and count the converted telecom photons at 193.4 THz with a signal-to-noise ratio of up to 5.1$\pm$1.1. We characterize the trade-offs between throughput and noise, and establish a viable path toward heralded entanglement distribution and gate teleportation. Looking ahead, these results empower existing superconducting devices to take a key role in distributed quantum technologies and heterogeneous quantum systems.

quant-pharXiv:2602.00928•Feb 3, 2026•4 citations

Cryogenic photonic link using an extended-InGaAs photodiode and short pulse illumination toward high-fidelity drive of superconducting qubits

Takuma Nakamura, Dahyeon Lee, Jason Horng +3 more

We investigate short pulse illumination of a high-speed extended-InGaAs photodiode at cryogenic temperatures toward its use in control and readout of superconducting qubits. First, we demonstrate high detector responsivity at 1550 nm illumination at 20 mK, a wavelength band unavailable to cryogenic standard InGaAs detectors due to the temperature-dependent bandgap shift. Second, we demonstrate an improved signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) at the shot noise limit for cryogenic short optical pulse detection when compared with conventional modulated continuous-wave laser detection. At 40 μA of photocurrent and a detector temperature of 4 K, short pulse detection yields an SNR improvement of 20 dB and 3 dB for phase and amplitude quadratures, respectively. Last, we discuss how short pulse detection offers a path for signal multiplexing, with a demonstration of simultaneous production of microwave pulses at two different carrier frequencies. Together, these advancements establish a path toward low noise and power efficient multiplexed photonic links for quantum computing with a large number of superconducting qubits.

arXiv:2501.00545•Optica Quantum•May 2, 2025•7 citations
Photonic addressing of superconducting circuits has been proposed to overcome wiring complexity and heat-load challenges. However, such superconducting-photonic links suffer from an efficiency-noise trade-off that limits scalability. This trade-off arises because increasing power conversion efficiency entails reducing optical power, which makes the converted signal susceptible to shot noise. We analyze this trade-off and find that the laser-driven qubit gate infidelity scales inversely with the number of photons used. While methods such as nonlinear detection or squeezed light could mitigate this effect, we consider generating higher-frequency electrical signals, such as millimeter waves (100 GHz), using laser light. At these higher frequencies, circuits have higher operating temperatures and cooling power budgets and alleviate constraints posed by the trade-off. Therefore, we demonstrate an optically driven cryogenic millimeter-wave source with a maximum power efficiency of 8 × 10 − 5 that can generate a maximum of 0.7 μ W of 80 GHz power, with a 1200 -thermal-photon equivalent of added noise at 4 K . Using this source, we perform frequency-domain spectroscopy of superconducting Nb Ti N resonators at 80–90 GHz. Our results show a promising approach to lessen the efficiency-noise constraints on superconducting-photonic links, while leveraging the benefits of photonic signal delivery. Further optimization of power efficiency and noise at high frequencies could make scalable photonic control of superconducting qubits viable at temperatures exceeding 1 K . Published by the American Physical Society 2024
Superconducting microwave circuits form a versatile platform for storing and manipulating quantum information. A major challenge to further scalability is to find approaches for connecting these systems over long distances and at high rates. One approach is to convert the quantum state of a microwave circuit to optical photons that can be transmitted over kilometers at room temperature with little loss. Many proposals for electro-optic conversion between microwave and optics use optical driving of a weak three-wave mixing nonlinearity to convert the frequency of an excitation. Residual absorption of this optical pump leads to heating, which is problematic at cryogenic temperatures. Here we propose an alternative approach where a nonlinear superconducting circuit is driven to interconvert between microwave-frequency ($7\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{9}$ Hz) and millimeter-wave-frequency photons ($3\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{11}$ Hz). To understand the potential for quantum state conversion between microwave and millimeter-wave photons, we consider the driven four-wave mixing quantum dynamics of nonlinear circuits. In contrast to the linear dynamics of the driven three-wave mixing converters, the proposed four-wave mixing converter has nonlinear decoherence channels that lead to a more complex parameter space of couplings and pump powers that we map out. We consider physical realizations of such converter circuits by deriving theoretically the upper bound on the maximum obtainable nonlinear coupling between any two modes in a lossless circuit, and synthesizing an optimal circuit based on realistic materials that saturates this bound. Our proposed circuit dissipates less than ${10}^{\ensuremath{-}9}$ times the energy of current electro-optic converters per qubit. Finally, we outline the quantum link budget for optical, microwave, and millimeter-wave connections, showing that our approach is viable for realizing interconnected quantum processors for intracity or quantum data center environments.
Today's hundred-qubit quantum computers require a dramatic scale up to millions of qubits to become practical for solving real-world problems. Although a variety of qubit technologies have been demonstrated, scalability remains a major hurdle. Superconducting (SC) qubits are one of the most mature and promising technologies to overcome this challenge. However, these qubits reside in a millikelvin cryogenic dilution fridge, isolating them from thermal and electrical noise. They are controlled by a rack-full of external electronics through extremely complex wiring and cables. Although thousands of qubits can be fabricated on a single chip and cooled down to millikelvin temperatures, scaling up the control and readout electronics remains an elusive goal. This is mainly due to the limited available cooling power in cryogenic systems constraining the wiring capacity and cabling heat load management. In this article, we focus on scaling up the number of XY-control lines by using cryogenic RF-photonic links. This is one of the major roadblocks to build a thousand qubit superconducting QC. We will first review and study the challenges of state-of-the-art proposed approaches, including cryogenic CMOS and deep-cryogenic photonic methods, to scale up the control interface for SC qubit systems. We will discuss their limitations due to the active power dissipation and passive heat leakage in detail. By analytically modeling the noise sources and thermal budget limits, we will show that our solution can achieve a scale up to a thousand of qubits. Our proposed method can be seamlessly implemented using advanced silicon photonic processes, and the number of required optical fibers can be further reduced by using wavelength division multiplexing (WDM).
Radio frequency (RF) radiation is a powerful tool in computing, communication, and sensing due to the ability to engineer strong electrical interactions. Within cryogenic systems, in particular, microwave (MW) frequency superconducting qubits have demonstrated promise as a platform for quantum computing, and MW and millimeter-wave (mmW) systems have been valuable tools in sensing. However, owing to their low energy, the weak, single-photon level signals employed by these systems suffer high sensitivity to thermal noise when they exit the thermal bath, as well as short attenuation lengths due to absorption and scattering in cables. Telecommunication frequency optical photons, meanwhile, have long propagation lengths and can be supported by low-loss optical fibers. The high photon energy makes signals insensitive to thermal noise, and the high frequency can allow many RF signals to be multiplexed onto a single optical carrier. Interfacing RF and optical radiation to leverage both strong interactions with macroscopic systems characteristic of electrical interactions and low-loss propagation characteristic of optical photons has been critical to realizing our global communication system. Leveraging the infrastructure developed to support this industry, such as single photon detectors, is attractive for scaling cryogenic RF systems. Coherent conversion processes, especially, can benefit a wide range of applications, especially in computing and sensing, by preserving quantum states, and retaining phase information necessary for quantum gates, and enable the use of measurement techniques that can increase detection sensitivity. This dissertation focuses on using the electro-optic effect in thin-film lithium niobate to form an efficient, coherent interface between radio- and telecommunication-frequency photons. Lithium niobate is an attractive platform due to its high electro-optic coefficient (approx. 30 pm/V), wide transparency window (DC to 400 THz), and ability to support low-loss optical waveguides (.2 dB/m), all of which deviate little from room temperature down to near-zero Kelvin environments. First, I explore the development of low-loss lithium niobate optical cavities and operation of lithium niobate waveguides at low temperatures. While lithium niobate is an electro-optic material with a DC response, using the electro-optic response at room temperature for stable biasing and low-frequency operation has remained a challenge. A temperature- and frequency-dependent study is conducted to identify lithium charge migration as a potential screening mechanism suppressed at low temperatures. Next, I explore the use of RF-cavity enhanced, triply resonant photonic molecules (created from two coupled low-loss optical cavities) for forming efficient electro-optic interfaces with microwave (3-10 GHz) and millimeter wave (100 GHz) radiation. In the microwave regime, I explore microwave-optical transduction for forming optical interfaces with microwave qubits, specifically focusing on superconducting qubits. The characterization of one such transducer is demonstrated, and the device is used to optically synthesize microwave signals at low temperatures, bypassing the need for input microwave control lines. Outlook for other interfaces, including optical photon mediated quantum information transfer, is discussed. At mmW frequencies, the triply resonant photonic molecule is explored for low-power ( mW) optical-frequency shifting.
Abstract The quantum bits (qubits) on which superconducting quantum computers are based have energy scales corresponding to photons with GHz frequencies. The energy of photons in the gigahertz domain is too low to allow transmission through the noisy room-temperature environment, where the signal would be lost in thermal noise. Optical photons, on the other hand, have much higher energies, and signals can be detected using highly efficient single-photon detectors. Transduction from microwave to optical frequencies is therefore a potential enabling technology for quantum devices. However, in such a device the optical pump can be a source of thermal noise and thus degrade the fidelity; the similarity of input microwave state to the output optical state. In order to investigate the magnitude of this effect we model the sub-Kelvin thermal behavior of an electro-optic transducer based on a lithium niobate whispering gallery mode resonator. We find that there is an optimum power level for a continuous pump, whilst pulsed operation of the pump increases the fidelity of the conversion.
Superconducting qubits are a leading candidate for utility-scale quantum computing due to their fast gate speeds and steadily decreasing error rates. The requirement for millikelvin operating temperatures, however, creates a significant scaling bottleneck. Modular architectures using optical fiber links could bridge separate cryogenic nodes, but superconducting circuits do not have coherent optical transitions and microwave-to-optical conversion has not been shown for any non-classical photon state. In this work, we demonstrate the on-demand generation and tomographic reconstruction of itinerant single microwave photons at 8.9 GHz from a superconducting qubit. We upconvert this non-Gaussian state with a transducer added noise below 0.012 quanta and count the converted telecom photons at 193.4 THz with a signal-to-noise ratio of up to 5.1$\pm$1.1. We characterize the trade-offs between throughput and noise, and establish a viable path toward heralded entanglement distribution and gate teleportation. Looking ahead, these results empower existing superconducting devices to take a key role in distributed quantum technologies and heterogeneous quantum systems.
We investigate short pulse illumination of a high-speed extended-InGaAs photodiode at cryogenic temperatures toward its use in control and readout of superconducting qubits. First, we demonstrate high detector responsivity at 1550 nm illumination at 20 mK, a wavelength band unavailable to cryogenic standard InGaAs detectors due to the temperature-dependent bandgap shift. Second, we demonstrate an improved signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) at the shot noise limit for cryogenic short optical pulse detection when compared with conventional modulated continuous-wave laser detection. At 40 μA of photocurrent and a detector temperature of 4 K, short pulse detection yields an SNR improvement of 20 dB and 3 dB for phase and amplitude quadratures, respectively. Last, we discuss how short pulse detection offers a path for signal multiplexing, with a demonstration of simultaneous production of microwave pulses at two different carrier frequencies. Together, these advancements establish a path toward low noise and power efficient multiplexed photonic links for quantum computing with a large number of superconducting qubits.