Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2406.12280 · Physical Review A

Uncertainty relations based on a state-dependent norm of a commutator

Aina Mayumi, Gen Kimura, Hiromichi Ohno, Dariusz Chruściński

Published Dec 16, 2024• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this paper, we propose two uncertainty relations that reveal a previously unnoticed complementarity in quantum uncertainty not captured by the conventional Robertson and Schr\"odinger relations, particularly in the case of mixed quantum states. These relations are formulated based on the state-dependent norm of the commutator, generalizing the B\"ottcher-Wenzel inequality. Furthermore, we compare our results with the Luo-Park uncertainty relation and demonstrate that our bound outperforms their bound for mutually unbiased observables.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.110.062215

Related papers

Beyond Robertson–Schrödinger: a general uncertainty relation unveiling hidden noncommutative trade-offs

Gen Kimura, Aina Mayumi, Hiromichi Ohno +2 more

Abstract We report a universal improvement to the standard Robertson–Schrödinger uncertainty relation. Our result shows that the Robertson–Schrödinger lower bound can be supplemented by a new noncommutativity-induced term. This term represents a previously overlooked quantum contribution and becomes more pronounced as the state becomes more mixed. Moreover, it is expressed as the expectation value of a positive observable, namely the squared modulus of the commutator, and therefore preserves the direct, experimentally accessible character of the Robertson–Schrödinger relation. For two-level quantum systems, our relation becomes an exact equality for any state and any pair of observables, thereby ensuring the tightness of the bound in the strongest possible sense. The relation also yields, as a corollary, a complete proof of a general uncertainty bound that had previously been supported only by numerical evidence.

arXiv:2504.20404•npj Quantum Information•Sep 21, 2026•8 citations

Tighter uncertainty and reverse uncertainty relations

Debasis Mondal, Shrobona Bagchi, Arun Kumar Pati

We prove a few state-dependent uncertainty relations for the product as well as the sum of variances of two incompatible observables. These uncertainty relations are shown to be tighter than the Robertson-Schr\"odinger uncertainty relation and other ones existing in the current literature. Also, we derive a state-dependent upper bound to the sum and the product of variances using the reverse Cauchy-Schwarz inequality and the Dunkl-Williams inequality. Our results suggest that not only can we not prepare quantum states for which two incompatible observables can have sharp values, but also we have both the lower and the upper limits on the variances of quantum mechanical observables at a fundamental level.

arXiv:1607.06712•Physical Review A•May 18, 2017•58 citations

Uncertainty, entropy, and non-Gaussianity for mixed states

Aikaterini Mandilara, Evgueni Karpov, Nicolas J. Cerf

In the space of mixed states the Schrödinger-Robertson uncertainty relation holds though it can never be saturated. Two tight extensions of this relation in the space of mixed states exist; one proposed by Dodonov and Man'ko, where the lower limit on the uncertainty depends on the purity of the state, and another where the uncertainty is bounded by the von Neumann entropy of the state proposed by Bastiaans. Driven by the needs that have emerged in the field of quantum information, in a recent work we have extended the puritybounded uncertainty relation by adding an additional parameter characterizing the state, namely its degree of non-Gaussianity. In this work we alternatively present a extension of the entropy-bounded uncertainty relation. The common points and differences between the two extensions of the uncertainty relation help us to draw more general conclusions concerning the bounds on the non-Gaussianity of mixed states.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Apr 30, 2010•2 citations

Tight Generalization of Robertson-Type Uncertainty Relations

Gen Kimura, Aina Mayumi, Yamashita, Haruki

We establish the tightest possible Robertson-type preparation uncertainty relation, which explicitly depends on the eigenvalues of the quantum state. The conventional constant $ \tfrac{1}{4} $ is replaced by the state-dependent coefficient \[ \frac{(λ_{\max} + λ_{\min})^2}{4(λ_{\max} - λ_{\min})^2}, \] where $ λ_{\max} $ and $λ_{\min}$ denote the largest and smallest eigenvalues of the density operator $ ρ$, respectively. We prove that this coefficient is optimal among all Robertson-type generalizations and does not admit further improvement. We also obtain a complete characterization of all nontrivial equality cases. Our relation becomes more pronounced as the quantum state becomes more mixed, capturing a trade-off in quantum uncertainty that the conventional Robertson's relation fails to detect. In addition, our result also provides a strict generalization of the Schrödinger's uncertainty relation, showing that the uncertainty trade-off is governed by the sum of the covariance term and a state-dependent improvement over the Robertson bound. As applications, we also refine error-disturbance trade-offs by incorporating spectral information of both the system and the measuring apparatus, thereby generalizing the Arthurs-Goodman and Ozawa inequalities.

arXiv:2505.19861•May 26, 2025•4 citations

Variance uncertainty relations without covariances for three and four observables

V. V. Dodonov

Sum and product uncertainty relations, containing variances of three or four observables, but not containing explicitly their covariances, are derived. Their consequences are, in particular, inequalities, giving nonzero lower bounds for the products of two variances in the case of zero mean value of the commutator between the related operators. Explicit examples show that the bounds can be better than the known Robertson-Schr\"odinger one.

arXiv:1711.04037•Physical Review A•Feb 7, 2018•32 citations

Stronger Uncertainty Relations for All Incompatible Observables

Lorenzo Maccone, Arun Kumar Pati

The Heisenberg-Robertson uncertainty relation expresses a limitation in the possible preparations of the system by giving a lower bound to the product of the variances of two observables in terms of their commutator. Notably, it does not capture the concept of incompatible observables because it can be trivial; i.e., the lower bound can be null even for two noncompatible observables. Here we give two stronger uncertainty relations, relating to the sum of variances, whose lower bound is guaranteed to be nontrivial whenever the two observables are incompatible on the state of the system.

arXiv:1407.0338•Physical Review Letters•Dec 31, 2014•293 citations
In this paper, we propose two uncertainty relations that reveal a previously unnoticed complementarity in quantum uncertainty not captured by the conventional Robertson and Schr"odinger relations, particularly in the case of mixed quantum states. These relations are formulated based on the state-dependent norm of the commutator, generalizing the B"ottcher-Wenzel inequality. Furthermore, we compare our results with the Luo-Park uncertainty relation and demonstrate that our bound outperforms their bound for mutually unbiased observables.
Abstract We report a universal improvement to the standard Robertson–Schrödinger uncertainty relation. Our result shows that the Robertson–Schrödinger lower bound can be supplemented by a new noncommutativity-induced term. This term represents a previously overlooked quantum contribution and becomes more pronounced as the state becomes more mixed. Moreover, it is expressed as the expectation value of a positive observable, namely the squared modulus of the commutator, and therefore preserves the direct, experimentally accessible character of the Robertson–Schrödinger relation. For two-level quantum systems, our relation becomes an exact equality for any state and any pair of observables, thereby ensuring the tightness of the bound in the strongest possible sense. The relation also yields, as a corollary, a complete proof of a general uncertainty bound that had previously been supported only by numerical evidence.
We prove a few state-dependent uncertainty relations for the product as well as the sum of variances of two incompatible observables. These uncertainty relations are shown to be tighter than the Robertson-Schr\"odinger uncertainty relation and other ones existing in the current literature. Also, we derive a state-dependent upper bound to the sum and the product of variances using the reverse Cauchy-Schwarz inequality and the Dunkl-Williams inequality. Our results suggest that not only can we not prepare quantum states for which two incompatible observables can have sharp values, but also we have both the lower and the upper limits on the variances of quantum mechanical observables at a fundamental level.
In the space of mixed states the Schrödinger-Robertson uncertainty relation holds though it can never be saturated. Two tight extensions of this relation in the space of mixed states exist; one proposed by Dodonov and Man'ko, where the lower limit on the uncertainty depends on the purity of the state, and another where the uncertainty is bounded by the von Neumann entropy of the state proposed by Bastiaans. Driven by the needs that have emerged in the field of quantum information, in a recent work we have extended the puritybounded uncertainty relation by adding an additional parameter characterizing the state, namely its degree of non-Gaussianity. In this work we alternatively present a extension of the entropy-bounded uncertainty relation. The common points and differences between the two extensions of the uncertainty relation help us to draw more general conclusions concerning the bounds on the non-Gaussianity of mixed states.
We establish the tightest possible Robertson-type preparation uncertainty relation, which explicitly depends on the eigenvalues of the quantum state. The conventional constant $ \tfrac{1}{4} $ is replaced by the state-dependent coefficient (λmax⁡+λmin⁡)24(λmax⁡−λmin⁡)2, \frac{(λ_{\max} + λ_{\min})^2}{4(λ_{\max} - λ_{\min})^2}, 4(λmax​−λmin​)2(λmax​+λmin​)2​, where $ λ_{\max} $ and λmin⁡λ_{\min}λmin​ denote the largest and smallest eigenvalues of the density operator $ ρ$, respectively. We prove that this coefficient is optimal among all Robertson-type generalizations and does not admit further improvement. We also obtain a complete characterization of all nontrivial equality cases. Our relation becomes more pronounced as the quantum state becomes more mixed, capturing a trade-off in quantum uncertainty that the conventional Robertson's relation fails to detect. In addition, our result also provides a strict generalization of the Schrödinger's uncertainty relation, showing that the uncertainty trade-off is governed by the sum of the covariance term and a state-dependent improvement over the Robertson bound. As applications, we also refine error-disturbance trade-offs by incorporating spectral information of both the system and the measuring apparatus, thereby generalizing the Arthurs-Goodman and Ozawa inequalities.
The Heisenberg-Robertson uncertainty relation expresses a limitation in the possible preparations of the system by giving a lower bound to the product of the variances of two observables in terms of their commutator. Notably, it does not capture the concept of incompatible observables because it can be trivial; i.e., the lower bound can be null even for two noncompatible observables. Here we give two stronger uncertainty relations, relating to the sum of variances, whose lower bound is guaranteed to be nontrivial whenever the two observables are incompatible on the state of the system.