Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2406.11771 · Entropy

Simon’s Algorithm in the NISQ Cloud

Reece Robertson, Emery Doucet, Ernest Spicer, Sebastian Deffner

Published Jun 20, 2025• 10 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Simon's algorithm was one of the first to demonstrate a genuine quantum advantage in solving a problem. The algorithm, however, assumes access to fault-tolerant qubits. In our work, we use Simon's algorithm to benchmark the error rates of devices currently available in the "quantum cloud". As a main result, we objectively compare the different physical platforms made available by IBM and IonQ. Our study highlights the importance of understanding the device architectures and topologies when transpiling quantum algorithms onto hardware. For instance, we demonstrate that two-qubit operations on spatially separated qubits on superconducting chips should be avoided.

DOI
10.3390/e27070658

Related papers

Early IBM quantum computers: architectural analysis and performance benchmarks

M. AbuGhanem

Abstract The emergence of noisy intermediate-scale quantum processors marked a pivotal stage in quantum computing, enabling the first demonstrations of quantum computational advantage despite limitations in qubit count, connectivity, and gate fidelity. Among the earliest and most accessible NISQ platforms were the IBM Quantum $$^\texttt {TM}$$ TM computers, which provided an open testbed for algorithm development, benchmarking, and error mitigation. Crucially, many of these pioneering quantum computers have since been retired, rendering their performance records fragmented and at risk of permanent loss. This work presents a comprehensive benchmarking study of these early IBM quantum computers, documenting their architectural layouts, qubit connectivity, native gate sets, coherence properties, effective Hamiltonians, control mechanisms, error rates, and operational performance. We reconstruct the operational profiles of these quantum computers and highlight the trends, trade-offs, and limitations that characterized superconducting quantum hardware in the NISQ era. This study establishes a historical baseline for assessing progress in quantum hardware development, offering essential guidance on error scaling, coherence limitations, and architectural trade-offs for designing next-generation quantum hardware. These insights directly inform superconducting quantum architecture design, compilation strategies, and error-resilient algorithms on the path toward fault-tolerant quantum computation.

The Journal of Supercomputing•May 18, 2026•1 citation

Investigation of Hardware Architecture Effects on Quantum Algorithm Performance: A Comparative Hardware Study

Askar Oralkhan, Temirlan Zhaxalykov

Cloud-accessible quantum processors enable direct execution of quantum algorithms on heterogeneous hardware platforms. Unlike classical systems, however, identical quantum circuits may exhibit substantially different behavior across devices due to architectural variations in qubit connectivity, gate fidelity, and coherence times. In this work, we systematically benchmark five representative quantum algorithms - Bell state preparation, GHZ state generation, Quantum Fourier Transform (QFT), Grover's Search, and the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) - across trapped-ion, superconducting, and simulator backends using Amazon Braket. Performance metrics including fidelity, CHSH violation, success probability, circuit depth, and gate counts are evaluated. Our results demonstrate a strong dependence of algorithmic performance on hardware topology and noise characteristics. For example, 10-qubit GHZ states achieved fidelities above 0.8 on trapped-ion hardware, while superconducting platforms dropped below 0.15 due to routing overhead and accumulated two-qubit gate errors. These findings highlight the importance of hardware-aware algorithm selection and provide practical guidance for benchmarking in the NISQ era.

quant-pharXiv:2601.05286•Jan 8, 2026•1 citation

Application Performance Benchmarks for Quantum Computers

Krzysztof Kurowski, Piotr Rydlichowski, Wojciechowski, Konrad +2 more

Current technological advancements of quantum computers highlight the need for application-driven, practical and well-defined methods of benchmarking their performance. As the existing NISQ device's quality of two-qubit gate errors rate is even around one percent and the number of qubits is still limited to a few or several dozen, naturally, we need to propose rather small algorithms instances taken from key promising application areas, such as quantum chemistry, combinatorial optimisation or machine learning. While many techniques for assessing the performance of logical components, such as gate fidelity and qubit coherence exist, it is still challenging to extrapolate those values onto the performance of different quantum algorithms and subroutines. This work aims to introduce a series of initial quantum application benchmarks together with a methodology of execution for measuring the performance and fidelity of the results. The proposed suite refers to several variational algorithms widely used on available NISQ devices but also includes examples of quantum circuits designed for a fault-tolerant quantum computer.

arXiv:2310.13637•Oct 20, 2023•4 citations

A study of qubit modalities in contemporary quantum computing

Arun Govindankutty

The pursuit of a universal, fault-tolerant quantum computer has transformed quantum computing from a predominantly theoretical discipline into a rapidly diversifying hardware ecosystem. This review presents a comprehensive and technically grounded analysis of the principal physical qubit modalities: superconducting circuits, trapped ions, photonic platforms, neutral atoms, semiconductor spin qubits, and topological approaches, focusing on their underlying operating principles, performance characteristics, and system-level constraints. We examine how these qubit technologies are embedded within scalable quantum processor architectures, including control and readout infrastructures, connectivity topologies, and quantum error correction strategies. The review provides a comparative study of key performance metrics, such as coherence times, gate fidelities, error rates, and scalability, reveals fundamental trade-offs between speed, robustness, and operational complexity that shape distinct technological roadmaps and target applications. We further highlight the ongoing transition from noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices toward architectures centred on logical qubits, driven by advances in materials engineering, precision control, and quantum information theory. Together, these developments sketch the emerging routes toward fault-tolerant quantum computing and practical quantum advantage, while offering readers a coherent entry point and reference guide to the current quantum hardware landscape.

Discover Quantum Science•Jul 28, 2026•1 citation

Quantum Computing: Current Advances And Near-Term Applications

Win Mathew John

Quantum computing has transitioned from a theoretical curiosity to an emerging technological paradigm with demonstrable computational advantages in specific problem domains. This paper presents a comprehensive review of current advances in quantum computing hardware, software, and near-term applications within the Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) era. We examine the architectural evolution of leading quantum platforms, including superconducting, trapped-ion, and photonic systems, analyzing their qubit counts, gate fidelities, and coherence times. The paper evaluates key quantum algorithms Shor's factoring algorithm [1], Grover's search algorithm [2], the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) [3], and the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) [4] in the context of their practical applicability to real-world problems. We further discuss the milestone of quantum computational advantage demonstrated by Google's Sycamore processor [5] and IBM's ambitious hardware roadmap toward fault-tolerant quantum computing [6]. Our analysis reveals that while universal fault-tolerant quantum computing remains a long-term objective, NISQ-era devices are already yielding valuable results in quantum chemistry simulation, combinatorial optimization, and quantum machine learning. We conclude by identifying the critical challenges—error correction, scalability, and algorithm design that must be addressed to realize the full potential of quantum computing.

•Apr 29, 2026•0 citations

Comparative Analysis of Contemporary Quantum Computer Processors: Architectures, Performance, and Perspectives

Marko Vukšić, Jasmin Ćelić, Aleksandar Cuculić

Quantum computing promises to revolutionize several scientific and industrial domains by tackling problems that are intractable for classical supercomputers. At the centre of this effort is the quantum processor unit (QPU), implemented today across multiple physical qubit platforms. This review provides a comparative analysis of the state of quantum processors as of late 2024/early 2025, focusing on superconducting qubits, trapped ions, photonic systems, neutral atoms, silicon spin qubits, and emerging topological approaches. We compile and compare recent processor generations such as IBM’s Heron family, Google’s updated Sycamore-class devices, Quantinuum’s H-series, IonQ’s Aria and Forte, neutral-atom platforms with more than 1,000 trapped atoms, and silicon spin prototypes like Tunnel Falls. Key performance metrics, including qubit count, gate and readout fidelity, coherence time, operation speed, and holistic benchmarks such as Quantum Volume (QV) and Algorithmic Qubits (#AQ) are examined with reference to concrete experimental milestones. We discuss algorithmic capabilities demonstrated on current hardware, early realizations of logical qubits and fault-tolerant primitives, and the distinction between feasibility-oriented “quantum advantage” experiments and emerging signs of practical “quantum utility”. Finally, we outline the main technical bottlenecks for each platform on the path from today’s NISQ devices toward universal fault-tolerant quantum computers.

IEEE Access•Jan 1, 2026•2 citations
Simon's algorithm was one of the first to demonstrate a genuine quantum advantage in solving a problem. The algorithm, however, assumes access to fault-tolerant qubits. In our work, we use Simon's algorithm to benchmark the error rates of devices currently available in the "quantum cloud". As a main result, we objectively compare the different physical platforms made available by IBM and IonQ. Our study highlights the importance of understanding the device architectures and topologies when transpiling quantum algorithms onto hardware. For instance, we demonstrate that two-qubit operations on spatially separated qubits on superconducting chips should be avoided.
Abstract The emergence of noisy intermediate-scale quantum processors marked a pivotal stage in quantum computing, enabling the first demonstrations of quantum computational advantage despite limitations in qubit count, connectivity, and gate fidelity. Among the earliest and most accessible NISQ platforms were the IBM Quantum TM^\texttt {TM}TM TM computers, which provided an open testbed for algorithm development, benchmarking, and error mitigation. Crucially, many of these pioneering quantum computers have since been retired, rendering their performance records fragmented and at risk of permanent loss. This work presents a comprehensive benchmarking study of these early IBM quantum computers, documenting their architectural layouts, qubit connectivity, native gate sets, coherence properties, effective Hamiltonians, control mechanisms, error rates, and operational performance. We reconstruct the operational profiles of these quantum computers and highlight the trends, trade-offs, and limitations that characterized superconducting quantum hardware in the NISQ era. This study establishes a historical baseline for assessing progress in quantum hardware development, offering essential guidance on error scaling, coherence limitations, and architectural trade-offs for designing next-generation quantum hardware. These insights directly inform superconducting quantum architecture design, compilation strategies, and error-resilient algorithms on the path toward fault-tolerant quantum computation.
Cloud-accessible quantum processors enable direct execution of quantum algorithms on heterogeneous hardware platforms. Unlike classical systems, however, identical quantum circuits may exhibit substantially different behavior across devices due to architectural variations in qubit connectivity, gate fidelity, and coherence times. In this work, we systematically benchmark five representative quantum algorithms - Bell state preparation, GHZ state generation, Quantum Fourier Transform (QFT), Grover's Search, and the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) - across trapped-ion, superconducting, and simulator backends using Amazon Braket. Performance metrics including fidelity, CHSH violation, success probability, circuit depth, and gate counts are evaluated. Our results demonstrate a strong dependence of algorithmic performance on hardware topology and noise characteristics. For example, 10-qubit GHZ states achieved fidelities above 0.8 on trapped-ion hardware, while superconducting platforms dropped below 0.15 due to routing overhead and accumulated two-qubit gate errors. These findings highlight the importance of hardware-aware algorithm selection and provide practical guidance for benchmarking in the NISQ era.
Current technological advancements of quantum computers highlight the need for application-driven, practical and well-defined methods of benchmarking their performance. As the existing NISQ device's quality of two-qubit gate errors rate is even around one percent and the number of qubits is still limited to a few or several dozen, naturally, we need to propose rather small algorithms instances taken from key promising application areas, such as quantum chemistry, combinatorial optimisation or machine learning. While many techniques for assessing the performance of logical components, such as gate fidelity and qubit coherence exist, it is still challenging to extrapolate those values onto the performance of different quantum algorithms and subroutines. This work aims to introduce a series of initial quantum application benchmarks together with a methodology of execution for measuring the performance and fidelity of the results. The proposed suite refers to several variational algorithms widely used on available NISQ devices but also includes examples of quantum circuits designed for a fault-tolerant quantum computer.
The pursuit of a universal, fault-tolerant quantum computer has transformed quantum computing from a predominantly theoretical discipline into a rapidly diversifying hardware ecosystem. This review presents a comprehensive and technically grounded analysis of the principal physical qubit modalities: superconducting circuits, trapped ions, photonic platforms, neutral atoms, semiconductor spin qubits, and topological approaches, focusing on their underlying operating principles, performance characteristics, and system-level constraints. We examine how these qubit technologies are embedded within scalable quantum processor architectures, including control and readout infrastructures, connectivity topologies, and quantum error correction strategies. The review provides a comparative study of key performance metrics, such as coherence times, gate fidelities, error rates, and scalability, reveals fundamental trade-offs between speed, robustness, and operational complexity that shape distinct technological roadmaps and target applications. We further highlight the ongoing transition from noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices toward architectures centred on logical qubits, driven by advances in materials engineering, precision control, and quantum information theory. Together, these developments sketch the emerging routes toward fault-tolerant quantum computing and practical quantum advantage, while offering readers a coherent entry point and reference guide to the current quantum hardware landscape.
Quantum computing has transitioned from a theoretical curiosity to an emerging technological paradigm with demonstrable computational advantages in specific problem domains. This paper presents a comprehensive review of current advances in quantum computing hardware, software, and near-term applications within the Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) era. We examine the architectural evolution of leading quantum platforms, including superconducting, trapped-ion, and photonic systems, analyzing their qubit counts, gate fidelities, and coherence times. The paper evaluates key quantum algorithms Shor's factoring algorithm [1], Grover's search algorithm [2], the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) [3], and the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) [4] in the context of their practical applicability to real-world problems. We further discuss the milestone of quantum computational advantage demonstrated by Google's Sycamore processor [5] and IBM's ambitious hardware roadmap toward fault-tolerant quantum computing [6]. Our analysis reveals that while universal fault-tolerant quantum computing remains a long-term objective, NISQ-era devices are already yielding valuable results in quantum chemistry simulation, combinatorial optimization, and quantum machine learning. We conclude by identifying the critical challenges—error correction, scalability, and algorithm design that must be addressed to realize the full potential of quantum computing.
Quantum computing promises to revolutionize several scientific and industrial domains by tackling problems that are intractable for classical supercomputers. At the centre of this effort is the quantum processor unit (QPU), implemented today across multiple physical qubit platforms. This review provides a comparative analysis of the state of quantum processors as of late 2024/early 2025, focusing on superconducting qubits, trapped ions, photonic systems, neutral atoms, silicon spin qubits, and emerging topological approaches. We compile and compare recent processor generations such as IBM’s Heron family, Google’s updated Sycamore-class devices, Quantinuum’s H-series, IonQ’s Aria and Forte, neutral-atom platforms with more than 1,000 trapped atoms, and silicon spin prototypes like Tunnel Falls. Key performance metrics, including qubit count, gate and readout fidelity, coherence time, operation speed, and holistic benchmarks such as Quantum Volume (QV) and Algorithmic Qubits (#AQ) are examined with reference to concrete experimental milestones. We discuss algorithmic capabilities demonstrated on current hardware, early realizations of logical qubits and fault-tolerant primitives, and the distinction between feasibility-oriented “quantum advantage” experiments and emerging signs of practical “quantum utility”. Finally, we outline the main technical bottlenecks for each platform on the path from today’s NISQ devices toward universal fault-tolerant quantum computers.