Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2406.09336 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Hidden order and Z 2 confinement transition in a fully packed monopole liquid

Attila Szabó, S. A. Grigera, P. C. W. Holdsworth, Ludovic D. C. Jaubert, Roderich Moessner, D. Slobinsky, Mauricio Sturla, R. A. Borzi

Published Jul 14, 2025• 8 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We investigate a variant of spin ice whose degenerate ground states are densely packed monopole configurations. An applied field drives this model through a Z2 confinement transition. This phase change is a variant of the U(1) Kasteleyn transition, but instead of saturated order the system has fluctuations in the confined phase, and shows critical scaling on both sides of the transition. Remarkably, the magnetic response scales with the critical exponent of the specific heat in the 3D Ising universality class. We prove this universality using a Kramers--Wannier duality to map to an Ising model. The dual order parameter maps back to a non-local string order parameter in the original model, invisible to any local probe. Further, we describe the transition in terms of a bosonic field theory including a pairing term.

DOI
10.1103/m7ck-5bz2

Related papers

Confinement-deconfinement transitions in the dimer-loop models on two-dimensional non-bipartite lattices

Jay Pandey, Souvik Kundu, Kedar Damle

Recent work [Kundu, Damle, Phys. Rev. X 15, 011018 (2025)] has demonstrated that a class of $S=1$ kagome lattice antiferromagnets with competing anisotropies can exhibit unusual low-temperature behavior that is best described in terms of the statistical mechanics of an interesting interpolation between the fully-packed dimer model and the fully-packed loop model on the bipartite honeycomb lattice. On this and other bipartite lattices in two and three dimension, such fully-packed dimer-loop models generically have two distinct power-law correlated Coulomb phases, both of which admit a low-energy description in terms of a fluctuating divergence-free polarization vector field [Phys. Rev. X 15, 011018 (2025); arXiv:2510.11607]. The transition between these phases corresponds to a confinement transition for the $Z_2$ part of the corresponding $U(1)$ flux [Phys. Rev. X 15, 011018 (2025); arXiv:2510.11607]. Here we demonstrate that a variant of such a topological confinement transition can also exist in dimer-loop models on non-bipartite lattices such as the kagome and triangular lattices although the low-energy description does not feature any conserved $U(1)$ flux. In these non-bipartite dimer-loop models, both phases are short-range correlated liquids, and the topological distinction between them is in terms of a $Z_2$-valued winding number instead of the flux of a divergence-free polarization field. In spite of this key difference, this transition appears to be in the same Ising universality class as the analogous transition of the bipartite dimer-loop models. These kagome and triangular lattice dimer-loop models correspond respectively to the low-energy limit of a class of $S=1$ antiferromagnets with competing anisotropies on the ruby lattice comprising a corner-sharing arrangement of fully-frustrated squares and a lattice of corner-sharing fully-frustrated hexagons.

arXiv:2610.16676•Oct 12, 2026•0 citations

Emergent Coulombic criticality and Kibble-Zurek scaling in a topological magnet

James Hamp, Anushya Chandran, Roderich Moessner +1 more

When a classical system is driven through a continuous phase transition, its nonequilibrium response is universal and exhibits Kibble-Zurek scaling. We explore this dynamical scaling in the context of a three-dimensional topological magnet with fractionalized excitations, namely, the liquid-gas transition of the emergent mobile magnetic monopoles in dipolar spin ice. Using field-mixing and finite-size scaling techniques, we place the critical point of the liquid-gas line in the three-dimensional Ising universality class. We then demonstrate Kibble-Zurek scaling for sweeps of the magnetic field through the critical point. Unusually slow microscopic time scales in spin ice offer a unique opportunity to detect this universal nonequilibrium physics in current experimental setups.

arXiv:1506.03472•Physical Review B•Aug 28, 2015•19 citations

Universal Monopole Scaling near Transitions from the Coulomb Phase

Stephen Powell

Certain frustrated systems, including spin ice and dimer models, exhibit a Coulomb phase at low temperatures, with power-law correlations and fractionalized monopole excitations. Transitions out of this phase, at which the effective gauge theory becomes confining, provide examples of unconventional criticality. This Letter studies the behavior at nonzero monopole density near such transitions, using scaling theory to arrive at universal expressions for the crossover phenomena. For a particular transition in spin ice, quantitative predictions are made by mapping to the XY model and confirmed using Monte Carlo simulations.

arXiv:1203.4564•Physical Review Letters•Aug 8, 2012•10 citations

Geometric Phase Transition of the Three-Dimensional Z 2 Lattice Gauge Model

Ramgopal Agrawal, Leticia F. Cugliandolo, Lara Faoro +2 more

After fifty years of lattice gauge theories (LGTs), the nature of the transition between their topological phases (confinement or deconfinement) remains challenging due to the absence of a local order parameter. In this work, we conduct a percolation analysis of Wegner's three-dimensional Z_{2} lattice gauge model using intensive Monte Carlo simulations and finite-size scaling, offering fresh insights into the topological phase transitions of gauge-invariant systems. We demonstrate that, regardless of the connection rules, geometrical loops, constructed by piercing excited plaquettes percolate precisely at the thermal critical point T_{c}, with critical exponents coinciding with those of the loop representation of the dual 3D Ising model. Further, we construct Fortuin-Kasteleyn (FK) clusters in a random-cluster representation, showing that they also percolate at T_{c}, enabling access to all thermal critical exponents. Strikingly, the Binder cumulants of the percolation order parameters for both loops and FK clusters reveal a pseudo-first-order transition. This work sheds new light on the critical behavior of pure LGTs, with potential implications for condensed matter systems and quantum error correction.

arXiv:2409.15123•Physical Review Letters•Aug 15, 2025•6 citations

Anomalous Dimensions of Monopole Operators at the Transitions between Dirac and Topological Spin Liquids

Éric Dupuis, Rufus Boyack, William Witczak‐Krempa

Monopole operators are studied in a large family of quantum critical points between Dirac spin liquids and topological quantum spin liquids (QSLs): chiral and Z 2 QSLs.These quantum phase transitions are described by conformal field theories (CFTs): quantum electrodynamics in 2 þ 1 dimensions with 2N flavors of two-component massless Dirac fermions and a four-fermion interaction term.For the transition to a chiral spin liquid, it is the Gross-Neveu interaction (QED 3 -GN), while for the transitions to Z 2 QSLs, it is a superconducting pairing term with general spin and valley structure (generalized QED 3 -Z 2 GN).Using the state-operator correspondence, we obtain monopole scaling dimensions to subleading order in 1=N.For monopoles with a minimal topological charge q ¼ 1=2, the scaling dimension is 2N × 0.26510 at leading order, with the quantum correction being 0.118911(7) for the chiral spin liquid, and 0.102846(9) for the simplest Z 2 case (the expression is also given for a general pairing term).Although these two anomalous dimensions are nearly equal, the underlying quantum fluctuations possess distinct origins.The analogous result in QED 3 is also obtained, and we find a subleading contribution of -0.038138ð5Þ, which is slightly different from the value -0.0383 first obtained in the literature.The scaling dimension of a QED 3 -GN monopole with minimal charge is very close to the scaling dimensions of other operators predicted to be equal by a conjectured duality between QED 3 -GN with 2N ¼ 2 flavors and the CP 1 model.Additionally, nonminimally charged monopoles with equal charges on both sides of the duality have similar scaling dimensions.By studying the large-q asymptotics of the scaling dimensions in QED 3 , QED 3 -GN, and QED 3 -Z 2 GN, we verify that the constant Oðq 0 Þ coefficient precisely matches the universal nonperturbative prediction for CFTs with a global U(1) symmetry.Finally, we identify numerous open questions regarding the fate of monopoles and their hierarchies at transitions to spin liquids and ordered phases.

arXiv:2108.05922•Physical Review X•Jul 19, 2022•29 citations

Percolation as a confinement order parameter in Z 2 lattice gauge theories

Simon M. Linsel, Annabelle Bohrdt, Lukas Homeier +2 more

Lattice gauge theories (LGTs) were introduced in 1974 by Wilson to study quark confinement. These models have been shown to exhibit (de)confined phases, yet it remains challenging to define experimentally accessible order parameters. Here we propose percolation-inspired order parameters (POPs) to probe confinement of dynamical matter in ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ LGTs using electric field basis snapshots accessible to quantum simulators. We apply the POPs to study a classical ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ LGT and find a confining phase up to temperature $T=\ensuremath{\infty}$ in two dimensions (critical ${T}_{c}$, i.e., finite-$T$ phase transition, in three dimensions) for any nonzero density of ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ charges. Further, using quantum Monte Carlo we demonstrate that the POPs reproduce the square lattice Fradkin-Shenker phase diagram at $T=0$ and explore the phase diagram at $T>0$. The correlation length exponent coincides with the one of the three-dimensional Ising universality class and we determine the POP critical exponent characterizing percolation. Our proposed POPs provide a geometric perspective of confinement and are directly accessible to snapshots obtained in quantum simulators, making them suitable as a probe for quantum spin liquids.

arXiv:2401.08770•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Dec 2, 2024•12 citations
We investigate a variant of spin ice whose degenerate ground states are densely packed monopole configurations. An applied field drives this model through a Z2 confinement transition. This phase change is a variant of the U(1) Kasteleyn transition, but instead of saturated order the system has fluctuations in the confined phase, and shows critical scaling on both sides of the transition. Remarkably, the magnetic response scales with the critical exponent of the specific heat in the 3D Ising universality class. We prove this universality using a Kramers--Wannier duality to map to an Ising model. The dual order parameter maps back to a non-local string order parameter in the original model, invisible to any local probe. Further, we describe the transition in terms of a bosonic field theory including a pairing term.
Recent work [Kundu, Damle, Phys. Rev. X 15, 011018 (2025)] has demonstrated that a class of S=1S=1S=1 kagome lattice antiferromagnets with competing anisotropies can exhibit unusual low-temperature behavior that is best described in terms of the statistical mechanics of an interesting interpolation between the fully-packed dimer model and the fully-packed loop model on the bipartite honeycomb lattice. On this and other bipartite lattices in two and three dimension, such fully-packed dimer-loop models generically have two distinct power-law correlated Coulomb phases, both of which admit a low-energy description in terms of a fluctuating divergence-free polarization vector field [Phys. Rev. X 15, 011018 (2025); arXiv:2510.11607]. The transition between these phases corresponds to a confinement transition for the Z2Z_2Z2​ part of the corresponding U(1)U(1)U(1) flux [Phys. Rev. X 15, 011018 (2025); arXiv:2510.11607]. Here we demonstrate that a variant of such a topological confinement transition can also exist in dimer-loop models on non-bipartite lattices such as the kagome and triangular lattices although the low-energy description does not feature any conserved U(1)U(1)U(1) flux. In these non-bipartite dimer-loop models, both phases are short-range correlated liquids, and the topological distinction between them is in terms of a Z2Z_2Z2​-valued winding number instead of the flux of a divergence-free polarization field. In spite of this key difference, this transition appears to be in the same Ising universality class as the analogous transition of the bipartite dimer-loop models. These kagome and triangular lattice dimer-loop models correspond respectively to the low-energy limit of a class of S=1S=1S=1 antiferromagnets with competing anisotropies on the ruby lattice comprising a corner-sharing arrangement of fully-frustrated squares and a lattice of corner-sharing fully-frustrated hexagons.
When a classical system is driven through a continuous phase transition, its nonequilibrium response is universal and exhibits Kibble-Zurek scaling. We explore this dynamical scaling in the context of a three-dimensional topological magnet with fractionalized excitations, namely, the liquid-gas transition of the emergent mobile magnetic monopoles in dipolar spin ice. Using field-mixing and finite-size scaling techniques, we place the critical point of the liquid-gas line in the three-dimensional Ising universality class. We then demonstrate Kibble-Zurek scaling for sweeps of the magnetic field through the critical point. Unusually slow microscopic time scales in spin ice offer a unique opportunity to detect this universal nonequilibrium physics in current experimental setups.
Certain frustrated systems, including spin ice and dimer models, exhibit a Coulomb phase at low temperatures, with power-law correlations and fractionalized monopole excitations. Transitions out of this phase, at which the effective gauge theory becomes confining, provide examples of unconventional criticality. This Letter studies the behavior at nonzero monopole density near such transitions, using scaling theory to arrive at universal expressions for the crossover phenomena. For a particular transition in spin ice, quantitative predictions are made by mapping to the XY model and confirmed using Monte Carlo simulations.
After fifty years of lattice gauge theories (LGTs), the nature of the transition between their topological phases (confinement or deconfinement) remains challenging due to the absence of a local order parameter. In this work, we conduct a percolation analysis of Wegner's three-dimensional Z_{2} lattice gauge model using intensive Monte Carlo simulations and finite-size scaling, offering fresh insights into the topological phase transitions of gauge-invariant systems. We demonstrate that, regardless of the connection rules, geometrical loops, constructed by piercing excited plaquettes percolate precisely at the thermal critical point T_{c}, with critical exponents coinciding with those of the loop representation of the dual 3D Ising model. Further, we construct Fortuin-Kasteleyn (FK) clusters in a random-cluster representation, showing that they also percolate at T_{c}, enabling access to all thermal critical exponents. Strikingly, the Binder cumulants of the percolation order parameters for both loops and FK clusters reveal a pseudo-first-order transition. This work sheds new light on the critical behavior of pure LGTs, with potential implications for condensed matter systems and quantum error correction.
Monopole operators are studied in a large family of quantum critical points between Dirac spin liquids and topological quantum spin liquids (QSLs): chiral and Z 2 QSLs.These quantum phase transitions are described by conformal field theories (CFTs): quantum electrodynamics in 2 þ 1 dimensions with 2N flavors of two-component massless Dirac fermions and a four-fermion interaction term.For the transition to a chiral spin liquid, it is the Gross-Neveu interaction (QED 3 -GN), while for the transitions to Z 2 QSLs, it is a superconducting pairing term with general spin and valley structure (generalized QED 3 -Z 2 GN).Using the state-operator correspondence, we obtain monopole scaling dimensions to subleading order in 1=N.For monopoles with a minimal topological charge q ¼ 1=2, the scaling dimension is 2N × 0.26510 at leading order, with the quantum correction being 0.118911(7) for the chiral spin liquid, and 0.102846(9) for the simplest Z 2 case (the expression is also given for a general pairing term).Although these two anomalous dimensions are nearly equal, the underlying quantum fluctuations possess distinct origins.The analogous result in QED 3 is also obtained, and we find a subleading contribution of -0.038138ð5Þ, which is slightly different from the value -0.0383 first obtained in the literature.The scaling dimension of a QED 3 -GN monopole with minimal charge is very close to the scaling dimensions of other operators predicted to be equal by a conjectured duality between QED 3 -GN with 2N ¼ 2 flavors and the CP 1 model.Additionally, nonminimally charged monopoles with equal charges on both sides of the duality have similar scaling dimensions.By studying the large-q asymptotics of the scaling dimensions in QED 3 , QED 3 -GN, and QED 3 -Z 2 GN, we verify that the constant Oðq 0 Þ coefficient precisely matches the universal nonperturbative prediction for CFTs with a global U(1) symmetry.Finally, we identify numerous open questions regarding the fate of monopoles and their hierarchies at transitions to spin liquids and ordered phases.
Lattice gauge theories (LGTs) were introduced in 1974 by Wilson to study quark confinement. These models have been shown to exhibit (de)confined phases, yet it remains challenging to define experimentally accessible order parameters. Here we propose percolation-inspired order parameters (POPs) to probe confinement of dynamical matter in Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ LGTs using electric field basis snapshots accessible to quantum simulators. We apply the POPs to study a classical Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ LGT and find a confining phase up to temperature $T=\ensuremath{\infty}$ in two dimensions (critical Tc{T}_{c}Tc​, i.e., finite-TTT phase transition, in three dimensions) for any nonzero density of Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ charges. Further, using quantum Monte Carlo we demonstrate that the POPs reproduce the square lattice Fradkin-Shenker phase diagram at T=0T=0T=0 and explore the phase diagram at T>0T>0T>0. The correlation length exponent coincides with the one of the three-dimensional Ising universality class and we determine the POP critical exponent characterizing percolation. Our proposed POPs provide a geometric perspective of confinement and are directly accessible to snapshots obtained in quantum simulators, making them suitable as a probe for quantum spin liquids.