Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2405.13405 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Exotic d -wave Cooper pair Bose metal in two dimensions

Zhangkai Cao, Jiahao Su, Jianyu Li, Tao Ying, Wansheng Wang, Jin-Hua Sun, Ho-Kin Tang, Hai-Qing Lin

Published Dec 26, 2024• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The study of non-Fermi liquids sheds light on unconventional phenomena in condensed matter systems that lie beyond the scope of Landau Fermi liquid theory. One intriguing example is the Bose metal, characterized by an uncondensed bosonic ground state. However, constructing a Bose metal phase in two dimensions (2D) remains a significant challenge. Utilizing constraint path quantum Monte Carlo and functional renormalization group methods on a fermionic system with spin anisotropy in a 2D lattice, we reveal the emergence of a Cooper pair Bose metal (CPBM) phase in a highly anisotropic regime ($\ensuremath{\alpha}<0.30$) with wide range of filling, as proposed in [A. E. Feiguin et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 025303 (2009)]. Our findings exhibit a visible nonzero momentum Bose surface in the Cooper-pair distribution function, accompanied by a distinct signal of ${d}_{xy}$ correlation between pairs. Our results highlight that spin-dependent anisotropy in the Fermi surface leads to versatile pairing forms. Platforms such as ultracold atoms in optical lattices and recently proposed altermagnets hold promise for realizing this intriguing phase.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.110.224522

Related papers

Variation of the Bose surface by filling a Cooper-pair Bose metal

Jiahao Su, Ji Liu, Jianyu Li +3 more

The Cooper pair Bose metal (CPBM) is a nonsuperfluid quantum phase in which uncondensed fermion pairs form a ``Bose surface'' in momentum space. We investigate the CPBM in the two-dimensional spin-anisotropic attractive Hubbard model by tuning the next-nearest-neighbor (NNN) hopping ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}$, carrier filling $n$, and spin anisotropy $\ensuremath{\alpha}$, using large-scale constrained-path quantum Monte Carlo simulations. A moderate NNN hopping ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}/t=0.2$ substantially enlarges the CPBM region: the phase extends into weaker anisotropy regimes and coexists with a commensurate charge-density wave (CDW) near half-filling $(n>0.95)$, where CDW order would otherwise dominate at ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}=0$. Interestingly, ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ suppresses the overall CDW peak amplitude and introduces a geometric correlation between the orientations of the Fermi and Bose surfaces: for weak Fermi-surface rotations, the Bose surface remains aligned with the lattice axes, while larger distortions drive both surfaces to rotate in tandem. Momentum-resolved pairing distributions reveal that the bosonic pairing channels are jointly controlled by ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ and carrier filling $n$. For small ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}$, ${d}_{xy}$-wave correlations dominate across the entire filling range. In contrast, for larger ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}$, the dominant pairing symmetry varies with $n$, reflecting a nontrivial interplay between frustration and density. These findings establish carrier filling and NNN hopping as complementary levers for manipulating CPBM stability and provide concrete criteria for identifying nonsuperfluid bosonic matter in cold-atom and correlated-electron systems.

arXiv:2505.24405•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Nov 21, 2025•0 citations

d x 2 − y 2 -wave Bose metal induced by next-nearest-neighbor hopping anisotropy

Zhangkai Cao, Jianyu Li, Jiahao Su +2 more

Superconductivity arises when electrons form Cooper pairs with phase coherence. In contrast, a lack of phase coherence in Cooper pairs can lead to an uncondensed metallic ground state known as the Bose metal state. In this paper, we investigate an attractively interacting fermionic system with nearest-neighbor hopping (t) and next-nearest-neighbor hopping (${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}$) anisotropy between two species of spins in a two-dimensional lattice. Utilizing the constrained path quantum Monte Carlo method, we demonstrate the existence of a ${d}_{{x}^{2}\ensuremath{-}{y}^{2}}$-wave Cooper pair Bose metal (CPBM) phase with ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}/t>0.7$. The CPBM phase exhibits a domelike structure in the phase diagram of filling $n\ensuremath{\sim}0.65$, with the maximal region around an optimal ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}/t\ensuremath{\sim}0.2$, suggesting that an appropriate value of ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ facilitates the formation of the Bose metal. Furthermore, we find that a Bose metal formed by fermions with a closed Fermi surface confirms that the crucial condition for this exotic phenomenon is primarily the anisotropy of the Fermi surface rather than its topology. Our finding of the ${d}_{{x}^{2}\ensuremath{-}{y}^{2}}$-wave CPBM demonstrates the same pairing symmetry as the pseudogap behavior in cuprates, and its experimental realization in ultracold atom systems is also feasible.

arXiv:2406.08131•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Apr 16, 2025•4 citations

Exotic paired phases in ladders with spin-dependent hopping

Adrian E. Feiguin, Matthew P. A. Fisher

Fermions in two dimensions, when subject to anisotropic spin-dependent hopping, can potentially give rise to unusual paired states in unpolarized mixtures that can behave as non-Fermi liquids. One possibility is a fully paired state with a gap for fermion excitations in which the Cooper pairs remain uncondensed. Such a ``Cooper-pair Bose-metal'' phase would be expected to have a singular Bose surface in momentum space. As demonstrated in the context of two-dimensional bosons hopping with a frustrating ring-exchange interaction, an analogous Bose-metal phase has a set of quasi-one-dimensional descendant states when put on a ladder geometry. Here we present a density matrix renormalization group study of the attractive Hubbard model with spin-dependent hopping on a two-leg ladder geometry. In our setup, one spin species moves preferentially along the leg direction, while the other does so along the rung direction. We find compelling evidence for the existence of a novel Cooper-pair Bose-metal phase in a region of the phase diagram at intermediate coupling. We further explore the phase diagram of this model as a function of hopping anisotropy, density, and interaction strength, finding a conventional superfluid phase as well as a phase of paired Cooper pairs with $d$-wave symmetry, similar to the one found in models of hard-core bosons with ring exchange. We argue that simulating this model with cold Fermi gases on spin-dependent optical lattices is a promising direction for realizing exotic quantum states.

arXiv:1007.5251•Physical Review B•Mar 4, 2011•17 citations

Exotic Paired States with Anisotropic Spin-Dependent Fermi Surfaces

Adrian E. Feiguin, Matthew P. A. Fisher

We propose a model for realizing exotic paired states in cold Fermi gases by using a spin-dependent optical lattice to engineer mismatched Fermi surfaces for each hyperfine species. The BCS phase diagram shows a stable paired superfluid state with coexisting pockets of momentum space with gapless unpaired carriers, similar to the Sarma state in polarized mixtures, but in our case the system is unpolarized. We propose the possible existence of an exotic "Cooper-pair Bose-metal" phase, which has a gap for single fermion excitations but gapless and uncondensed "Cooper-pair" excitations residing on a "Bose surface" in momentum space.

arXiv:0903.2656•Physical Review Letters•Jul 10, 2009•33 citations

Non-Fermi liquid induced by Bose metal with protected subsystem symmetries

SangEun Han, Yong Baek Kim

Understanding non-Fermi liquids in dimensions higher than one has been a subject of great interest. Such phases may serve as parent states for other unconventional phases of quantum matter, in a similar manner that conventional broken symmetry states can be understood as instabilities of the Fermi liquid. In this work, we investigate the emergence of an exotic non-Fermi liquid in two dimensions, where the fermions with quadratic band-touching dispersion interact with Bose metal. The bosonic excitations in Bose metal possess an extended nodal-line spectrum in momentum space, which arises due to the subsystem symmetry or the restricted motion of bosons. Using renormalization group analysis and direct computations, we show that the extended infrared singularity of Bose metal leads to a line of interacting fixed points of an exotic non-Fermi liquids, where the anomalous dimension of the fermions varies continuously, akin to the Luttinger liquid in one dimension. Further, the generalization of the model with multiple low-energy excitations is used to explore other unusual features of the resulting ground state.

arXiv:2102.05052•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Aug 8, 2022•10 citations

d -wave correlated critical Bose liquids in two dimensions

Olexei I. Motrunich, Matthew P. A. Fisher

We develop a description of a quantum liquid phase of interacting bosons confined in two dimensions that possesses relative $d$-wave two-body correlations. We refer to this stable quantum phase as a $d$-wave Bose liquid (DBL). The DBL has no broken symmetries, supports gapless boson excitations that reside on ``Bose surfaces'' in momentum space, and exhibits power-law correlation functions characterized by a manifold of continuously variable exponents. While the DBL can be constructed for bosons moving in the two-dimensional continuum, the state only respects the point group symmetries of the square lattice. On the square lattice, the DBL respects all symmetries and does not require a particular lattice filling. However, lattice effects do allow for the possibility of a second distinct phase, a quasilocal variant we refer to as a $d$-wave local Bose liquid (DLBL). Remarkably, the DLBL has short-range boson correlations and hence no Bose surfaces, despite sharing gapless excitations and other critical signatures with the DBL. Moreover, both phases are metals with a resistance that vanishes as a power of the temperature. We establish these results by constructing a class of many-particle wave functions for the DBL, which are time reversal invariant analogs of Laughlin's quantum Hall wave function for bosons in a half-filled Landau level. A gauge theory formulation leads to a simple mean field theory, and a suitable $N$-flavor generalization enables incorporation of gauge field fluctuations to deduce the properties of the DBL/DLBL in a controlled and systematic fashion. Various equal-time correlation functions thereby obtained are in qualitative accord with the properties inferred from the variational wave functions. We also identify a promising microscopic Hamiltonian that might manifest the DBL or DLBL, and perform a variational energetics study comparing other competing phases, including the superfluid. We suggest how the $d$-wave Bose liquid wave function can be suitably generalized to describe an itinerant non-Fermi-liquid phase of electrons on the square lattice with a no-double-occupancy constraint, a $d$-wave metal phase.

arXiv:cond-mat/0703261•Physical Review B•Jun 21, 2007•108 citations
The study of non-Fermi liquids sheds light on unconventional phenomena in condensed matter systems that lie beyond the scope of Landau Fermi liquid theory. One intriguing example is the Bose metal, characterized by an uncondensed bosonic ground state. However, constructing a Bose metal phase in two dimensions (2D) remains a significant challenge. Utilizing constraint path quantum Monte Carlo and functional renormalization group methods on a fermionic system with spin anisotropy in a 2D lattice, we reveal the emergence of a Cooper pair Bose metal (CPBM) phase in a highly anisotropic regime (\ensuremathα<0.30\ensuremath{\alpha}<0.30\ensuremathα<0.30) with wide range of filling, as proposed in [A. E. Feiguin et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 025303 (2009)]. Our findings exhibit a visible nonzero momentum Bose surface in the Cooper-pair distribution function, accompanied by a distinct signal of dxy{d}_{xy}dxy​ correlation between pairs. Our results highlight that spin-dependent anisotropy in the Fermi surface leads to versatile pairing forms. Platforms such as ultracold atoms in optical lattices and recently proposed altermagnets hold promise for realizing this intriguing phase.
The Cooper pair Bose metal (CPBM) is a nonsuperfluid quantum phase in which uncondensed fermion pairs form a ``Bose surface'' in momentum space. We investigate the CPBM in the two-dimensional spin-anisotropic attractive Hubbard model by tuning the next-nearest-neighbor (NNN) hopping ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}$, carrier filling nnn, and spin anisotropy $\ensuremath{\alpha}$, using large-scale constrained-path quantum Monte Carlo simulations. A moderate NNN hopping ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}/t=0.2$ substantially enlarges the CPBM region: the phase extends into weaker anisotropy regimes and coexists with a commensurate charge-density wave (CDW) near half-filling (n>0.95)(n>0.95)(n>0.95), where CDW order would otherwise dominate at ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}=0$. Interestingly, ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ suppresses the overall CDW peak amplitude and introduces a geometric correlation between the orientations of the Fermi and Bose surfaces: for weak Fermi-surface rotations, the Bose surface remains aligned with the lattice axes, while larger distortions drive both surfaces to rotate in tandem. Momentum-resolved pairing distributions reveal that the bosonic pairing channels are jointly controlled by ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ and carrier filling nnn. For small ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}$, dxy{d}_{xy}dxy​-wave correlations dominate across the entire filling range. In contrast, for larger ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}$, the dominant pairing symmetry varies with nnn, reflecting a nontrivial interplay between frustration and density. These findings establish carrier filling and NNN hopping as complementary levers for manipulating CPBM stability and provide concrete criteria for identifying nonsuperfluid bosonic matter in cold-atom and correlated-electron systems.
Superconductivity arises when electrons form Cooper pairs with phase coherence. In contrast, a lack of phase coherence in Cooper pairs can lead to an uncondensed metallic ground state known as the Bose metal state. In this paper, we investigate an attractively interacting fermionic system with nearest-neighbor hopping (t) and next-nearest-neighbor hopping (${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}$) anisotropy between two species of spins in a two-dimensional lattice. Utilizing the constrained path quantum Monte Carlo method, we demonstrate the existence of a ${d}_{{x}^{2}\ensuremath{-}{y}^{2}}$-wave Cooper pair Bose metal (CPBM) phase with ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}/t>0.7$. The CPBM phase exhibits a domelike structure in the phase diagram of filling $n\ensuremath{\sim}0.65$, with the maximal region around an optimal ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}/t\ensuremath{\sim}0.2$, suggesting that an appropriate value of ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ facilitates the formation of the Bose metal. Furthermore, we find that a Bose metal formed by fermions with a closed Fermi surface confirms that the crucial condition for this exotic phenomenon is primarily the anisotropy of the Fermi surface rather than its topology. Our finding of the ${d}_{{x}^{2}\ensuremath{-}{y}^{2}}$-wave CPBM demonstrates the same pairing symmetry as the pseudogap behavior in cuprates, and its experimental realization in ultracold atom systems is also feasible.
Fermions in two dimensions, when subject to anisotropic spin-dependent hopping, can potentially give rise to unusual paired states in unpolarized mixtures that can behave as non-Fermi liquids. One possibility is a fully paired state with a gap for fermion excitations in which the Cooper pairs remain uncondensed. Such a ``Cooper-pair Bose-metal'' phase would be expected to have a singular Bose surface in momentum space. As demonstrated in the context of two-dimensional bosons hopping with a frustrating ring-exchange interaction, an analogous Bose-metal phase has a set of quasi-one-dimensional descendant states when put on a ladder geometry. Here we present a density matrix renormalization group study of the attractive Hubbard model with spin-dependent hopping on a two-leg ladder geometry. In our setup, one spin species moves preferentially along the leg direction, while the other does so along the rung direction. We find compelling evidence for the existence of a novel Cooper-pair Bose-metal phase in a region of the phase diagram at intermediate coupling. We further explore the phase diagram of this model as a function of hopping anisotropy, density, and interaction strength, finding a conventional superfluid phase as well as a phase of paired Cooper pairs with ddd-wave symmetry, similar to the one found in models of hard-core bosons with ring exchange. We argue that simulating this model with cold Fermi gases on spin-dependent optical lattices is a promising direction for realizing exotic quantum states.
We propose a model for realizing exotic paired states in cold Fermi gases by using a spin-dependent optical lattice to engineer mismatched Fermi surfaces for each hyperfine species. The BCS phase diagram shows a stable paired superfluid state with coexisting pockets of momentum space with gapless unpaired carriers, similar to the Sarma state in polarized mixtures, but in our case the system is unpolarized. We propose the possible existence of an exotic "Cooper-pair Bose-metal" phase, which has a gap for single fermion excitations but gapless and uncondensed "Cooper-pair" excitations residing on a "Bose surface" in momentum space.
Understanding non-Fermi liquids in dimensions higher than one has been a subject of great interest. Such phases may serve as parent states for other unconventional phases of quantum matter, in a similar manner that conventional broken symmetry states can be understood as instabilities of the Fermi liquid. In this work, we investigate the emergence of an exotic non-Fermi liquid in two dimensions, where the fermions with quadratic band-touching dispersion interact with Bose metal. The bosonic excitations in Bose metal possess an extended nodal-line spectrum in momentum space, which arises due to the subsystem symmetry or the restricted motion of bosons. Using renormalization group analysis and direct computations, we show that the extended infrared singularity of Bose metal leads to a line of interacting fixed points of an exotic non-Fermi liquids, where the anomalous dimension of the fermions varies continuously, akin to the Luttinger liquid in one dimension. Further, the generalization of the model with multiple low-energy excitations is used to explore other unusual features of the resulting ground state.
We develop a description of a quantum liquid phase of interacting bosons confined in two dimensions that possesses relative ddd-wave two-body correlations. We refer to this stable quantum phase as a ddd-wave Bose liquid (DBL). The DBL has no broken symmetries, supports gapless boson excitations that reside on ``Bose surfaces'' in momentum space, and exhibits power-law correlation functions characterized by a manifold of continuously variable exponents. While the DBL can be constructed for bosons moving in the two-dimensional continuum, the state only respects the point group symmetries of the square lattice. On the square lattice, the DBL respects all symmetries and does not require a particular lattice filling. However, lattice effects do allow for the possibility of a second distinct phase, a quasilocal variant we refer to as a ddd-wave local Bose liquid (DLBL). Remarkably, the DLBL has short-range boson correlations and hence no Bose surfaces, despite sharing gapless excitations and other critical signatures with the DBL. Moreover, both phases are metals with a resistance that vanishes as a power of the temperature. We establish these results by constructing a class of many-particle wave functions for the DBL, which are time reversal invariant analogs of Laughlin's quantum Hall wave function for bosons in a half-filled Landau level. A gauge theory formulation leads to a simple mean field theory, and a suitable NNN-flavor generalization enables incorporation of gauge field fluctuations to deduce the properties of the DBL/DLBL in a controlled and systematic fashion. Various equal-time correlation functions thereby obtained are in qualitative accord with the properties inferred from the variational wave functions. We also identify a promising microscopic Hamiltonian that might manifest the DBL or DLBL, and perform a variational energetics study comparing other competing phases, including the superfluid. We suggest how the ddd-wave Bose liquid wave function can be suitably generalized to describe an itinerant non-Fermi-liquid phase of electrons on the square lattice with a no-double-occupancy constraint, a ddd-wave metal phase.