Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2405.11152 · Dissertationes Mathematicae

Operator systems, contextuality and non-locality

M. Anoussis, Alexandros Chatzinikolaou, Ivan G. Todorov

Published Oct 28, 2026• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We introduce an operator system, universal for the probabilistic models of a contextuality scenario, and identify its maximal C∗-cover via the right C∗-algebra of a canonical ternary ring of operators, arising from a hypergraph version of stochastic operator matrices. We study dilating contextuality scenarios, which have the property that each positive operator representation thereof admits a dilation to a projective representation on a larger Hilbert space, and characterise them via the equality of the aforementioned universal operator system and the operator system arising from the canonical generators of the respective hypergraph C∗-algebra. We characterise the no-signalling probabilistic models over a pair of contextuality scenarios of different types, which arise from either the positive operator representations or from the projective representations of these scenarios, in terms of states on operator system tensor products. Generalising the notion of a synchronous no-signalling correlation to the hypergraph framework, we define coherent probabilistic models associated with a given contextuality scenario and characterise various classes thereof via different types of traces of the hypergraph C∗-algebra, associated with the scenario. We establish several equivalent formulations of the Connes Embedding Problem in terms of no-signalling probabilistic models and hypergraph operator systems.

DOI
10.4064/dm240830-4-11

Related papers

Non-local game homomorphisms

Gage Hoefer

In the past few decades, the connections between non-local games arising in quantum information theory and the theory of operator algebras have undergone a phase of significant development. Operator algebras provide a particularly fruitful framework for approaching questions of non-locality in quantum systems, as the input-output behavior of measurements on bipartite quantum systems can be encoded through noncommutative operator algebras and their state spaces. This thesis is the compilation of a series of papers, written by the author in collaboration with Ivan G. Todorov, utilizing this framework by using the theory of operator algebras and completely positive maps to study questions involving non-local games. ☐ Using the simulation paradigm from information theory, we define a quantized version of homomorphisms and isomorphisms between classical hypergraphs, generalizing quantum homomorphisms and isomorphisms of graphs from the literature. We show that these quantum homomorphisms and isomorphisms constitute pre-orders and equivalence relations, respectively. We use quantum homomorphisms of hypergraphs to provide multiple examples of strict separation between correlation classes of varying types. Specializing to the case when our underlying hypergraphs arise from classical non-local games, we define quantum non-local game homomorphisms and isomorphisms. We also show how the existence of a homomorphism or isomorphism of some fixed type between games is reflected in a comparison of optimal and asymptotic game values with respect to this type. These non-local game homomorphisms are defined via a new class of non-signalling correlations which we introduce here. We develop the multivariate tensor product theory in the category of operator systems, which we then use to provide a characterization of game homomorphisms in terms of state spaces for various tensor products of canonically associated operator systems. We then apply these results to the study of synchronous non-local games, defining jointly synchronous correlations and showing how they correspond to tracial states of tensor products of C*-algebras canonically associated to each game party. ☐ We then move to a second level of quantization by proposing a "quantized" notion of hypergraphs (where "quantum" here is in the sense of a non-commutative analogue for a discrete combinatorial object), and introduce quantum homomorphisms between these quantum objects. We provide an initial foray into the properties quantum morphisms between quantum hypergraphs display, showing they satisfy analogous properties to quantum homomorphisms between classical hypergraphs. We also indicate initial connections these quantum homomorphisms between quantum hypergraphs have to the study of quantum input-output games. We end the thesis showing that homomorphisms of a local type between quantum hypergraphs is closely related, and in some cases identical, to the TRO equivalence of finite-dimensionally acting operator spaces canonically associated with each hypergraph. This suggests a quantum information theoretic approach to Morita equivalence in the category of operator spaces.

•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

Quantum No-signalling Correlations and Non-local Games

Ivan G. Todorov, Lyudmila B. Turowska

Abstract We introduce and examine three subclasses of the family of quantum no-signalling (QNS) correlations introduced by Duan and Winter: quantum commuting, quantum and local. We formalise the notion of a universal TRO of a block operator isometry, define an operator system, universal for stochastic operator matrices, and realise it as a quotient of a matrix algebra. We describe the classes of QNS correlations in terms of states on the tensor products of two copies of the universal operator system and specialise the correlation classes and their representations to classical-to-quantum correlations. We study various quantum versions of synchronous no-signalling correlations and show that they possess invariance properties for suitable sets of states. We introduce quantum non-local games as a generalisation of non-local games. We define the operation of quantum game composition and show that the perfect strategies belonging to a certain class are closed under channel composition. We specialise to the case of graph colourings, where we exhibit quantum versions of the orthogonal rank of a graph as the optimal output dimension for which perfect classical-to-quantum strategies of the graph colouring game exist, as well as to non-commutative graph homomorphisms, where we identify quantum versions of non-commutative graph homomorphisms introduced by Stahlke.

arXiv:2009.07016•Communications in Mathematical Physics•May 28, 2024•30 citations

Probabilistic models on contextuality scenarios

Tobias Fritz, Anthony Leverrier, Ana Belén Sainz

We introduce a framework to describe probabilistic models in Bell experiments, and more generally in contextuality scenarios. Such a scenario is a hypergraph whose vertices represent elementary events and hyperedges correspond to measurements. A probabilistic model on such a scenario associates to each event a probability, in such a way that events in a given measurement have a total probability equal to one. We discuss the advantages of this framework, like the unification of the notions of contexuality and nonlocality, and give a short overview of results obtained elsewhere.

arXiv:1307.0145•Electronic Proceedings in Theoretical Computer Science•Dec 26, 2014•10 citations

Contextuality under weak assumptions

Andrew W. Simmons, Joel J. Wallman, Hakop Pashayan +2 more

The presence of contextuality in quantum theory was first highlighted by Bell, Kochen and Specker, who discovered that for quantum systems of three or more dimensions, measurements could not be viewed as deterministically revealing pre-existing properties of the system. More precisely, no model can assign deterministic outcomes to the projectors of a quantum measurement in a way that depends only on the projector and not the context (the full set of projectors) in which it appeared, despite the fact that the Born rule probabilities associated with projectors are independent of the context. A more general, operational definition of contextuality introduced by Spekkens, which we will term 'probabilistic contextuality', drops the assumption of determinism and allows for operations other than measurements to be considered contextual. Even two-dimensional quantum mechanics can be shown to be contextual under this generalised notion. Probabilistic noncontextuality represents the postulate that elements of an operational theory that cannot be distinguished from each other based on the statistics of arbitrarily many repeated experiments (they give rise to the same operational probabilities) are ontologically identical. In this paper, we introduce a framework that enables us to distinguish between different noncontextuality assumptions in terms of the relationships between the ontological representations of objects in the theory given a certain relation between their operational representations. This framework can be used to motivate and define a 'possibilistic' analogue, encapsulating the idea that elements of an operational theory that cannot be unambiguously distinguished operationally can also not be unambiguously distinguished ontologically. We then prove that possibilistic noncontextuality is equivalent to an alternative notion of noncontextuality proposed by Hardy. Finally, we demonstrate that these weaker noncontextuality assumptions are sufficient to prove alternative versions of known 'no-go' theorems that constrain ψ -epistemic models for quantum mechanics.

arXiv:1610.06897•New Journal of Physics•Feb 9, 2017•10 citations

Macroscopic noncontextuality as a principle for almost-quantum correlations

Joe Henson C, Ana Belén Sainz

Quantum mechanics allows only certain sets of experimental results (or ``probabilistic models'') for Bell-type quantum nonlocality experiments. A derivation of this set from simple physical or information theoretic principles would represent an important step forward in our understanding of quantum mechanics, and this problem has been intensely investigated in recent years. ``Macroscopic locality,'' which requires the recovery of locality in the limit of large numbers of trials, is one of several principles discussed in the literature that place a bound on the set of quantum probabilistic models. A similar question can also be asked about probabilistic models for the more general class of quantum contextuality experiments. Here, we extend the macroscopic locality principle to this more general setting, using the hypergraph approach of Ac\'{\i}n, Fritz, Leverrier, and Sainz [Comm. Math. Phys. 334(2), 533--628 (2015)], which provides a framework to study both phenomena of nonlocality and contextuality in a unified manner. We find that the set of probabilistic models allowed by our macroscopic noncontextuality principle is equivalent to an important and previously studied set in this formalism, which is slightly larger than the quantum set. In the particular case of Bell scenarios, this set is equivalent to the set of ``almost-quantum'' models, which is of particular interest since the latter was recently shown to satisfy all but one of the principles that have been proposed to bound quantum probabilistic models, without being implied by any of them (or even their conjunction). Our condition is the first characterization of the almost-quantum set from a simple physical principle.

arXiv:1501.06052•Physical Review A•Apr 13, 2015•20 citations

Quantumness via Discrete Structures

Ravi Kunjwal

Quantum theory departs from classical probabilistic theories in foundational ways. These departures--termed quantumness here--power quantum information and computation. This thesis charts the role of discrete structures in assessing quantumness, synthesizing elements of my postdoctoral research through this lens. After an introduction to the necessary background concepts, I present my work under three broad categories. First, I present work on contextuality that extensively relies on (undirected) graphs and hypergraphs as the discrete structures of interest; more specifically, it relies on invariants associated with them. This work includes Kochen-Specker (KS) contextuality and its operationalization to generalized contextuality, expressed via (hyper)graph-theoretic frameworks. I also present work on KS-contextuality in multiqubit systems and an application of generalized contextuality to a one-shot communication task, both of which rely on hypergraphs. Second, I present work on causality, where the discrete structures of interest are directed graphs. This includes work on indefinite causal order, specifically its connections to the gap between local operations and classical communication (LOCC) and separable operations (SEP), and a device-independent notion of nonclassicality--termed antinomicity--that generalizes Bell nonlocality without global causal assumptions. Finally, I present work on the incompatibility of quantum measurements, its connection to Bell nonlocality, and its role in discriminating between quantum and almost quantum correlations in the single-system setting. The discrete structures of interest here are hypergraphs that model joint measurability relations between quantum measurements. I conclude with a summary and an overview of work that is not covered in this thesis.

quant-pharXiv:2512.10063•Dec 12, 2025•0 citations
We introduce an operator system, universal for the probabilistic models of a contextuality scenario, and identify its maximal C∗-cover via the right C∗-algebra of a canonical ternary ring of operators, arising from a hypergraph version of stochastic operator matrices. We study dilating contextuality scenarios, which have the property that each positive operator representation thereof admits a dilation to a projective representation on a larger Hilbert space, and characterise them via the equality of the aforementioned universal operator system and the operator system arising from the canonical generators of the respective hypergraph C∗-algebra. We characterise the no-signalling probabilistic models over a pair of contextuality scenarios of different types, which arise from either the positive operator representations or from the projective representations of these scenarios, in terms of states on operator system tensor products. Generalising the notion of a synchronous no-signalling correlation to the hypergraph framework, we define coherent probabilistic models associated with a given contextuality scenario and characterise various classes thereof via different types of traces of the hypergraph C∗-algebra, associated with the scenario. We establish several equivalent formulations of the Connes Embedding Problem in terms of no-signalling probabilistic models and hypergraph operator systems.
In the past few decades, the connections between non-local games arising in quantum information theory and the theory of operator algebras have undergone a phase of significant development. Operator algebras provide a particularly fruitful framework for approaching questions of non-locality in quantum systems, as the input-output behavior of measurements on bipartite quantum systems can be encoded through noncommutative operator algebras and their state spaces. This thesis is the compilation of a series of papers, written by the author in collaboration with Ivan G. Todorov, utilizing this framework by using the theory of operator algebras and completely positive maps to study questions involving non-local games. ☐ Using the simulation paradigm from information theory, we define a quantized version of homomorphisms and isomorphisms between classical hypergraphs, generalizing quantum homomorphisms and isomorphisms of graphs from the literature. We show that these quantum homomorphisms and isomorphisms constitute pre-orders and equivalence relations, respectively. We use quantum homomorphisms of hypergraphs to provide multiple examples of strict separation between correlation classes of varying types. Specializing to the case when our underlying hypergraphs arise from classical non-local games, we define quantum non-local game homomorphisms and isomorphisms. We also show how the existence of a homomorphism or isomorphism of some fixed type between games is reflected in a comparison of optimal and asymptotic game values with respect to this type. These non-local game homomorphisms are defined via a new class of non-signalling correlations which we introduce here. We develop the multivariate tensor product theory in the category of operator systems, which we then use to provide a characterization of game homomorphisms in terms of state spaces for various tensor products of canonically associated operator systems. We then apply these results to the study of synchronous non-local games, defining jointly synchronous correlations and showing how they correspond to tracial states of tensor products of C*-algebras canonically associated to each game party. ☐ We then move to a second level of quantization by proposing a "quantized" notion of hypergraphs (where "quantum" here is in the sense of a non-commutative analogue for a discrete combinatorial object), and introduce quantum homomorphisms between these quantum objects. We provide an initial foray into the properties quantum morphisms between quantum hypergraphs display, showing they satisfy analogous properties to quantum homomorphisms between classical hypergraphs. We also indicate initial connections these quantum homomorphisms between quantum hypergraphs have to the study of quantum input-output games. We end the thesis showing that homomorphisms of a local type between quantum hypergraphs is closely related, and in some cases identical, to the TRO equivalence of finite-dimensionally acting operator spaces canonically associated with each hypergraph. This suggests a quantum information theoretic approach to Morita equivalence in the category of operator spaces.
Abstract We introduce and examine three subclasses of the family of quantum no-signalling (QNS) correlations introduced by Duan and Winter: quantum commuting, quantum and local. We formalise the notion of a universal TRO of a block operator isometry, define an operator system, universal for stochastic operator matrices, and realise it as a quotient of a matrix algebra. We describe the classes of QNS correlations in terms of states on the tensor products of two copies of the universal operator system and specialise the correlation classes and their representations to classical-to-quantum correlations. We study various quantum versions of synchronous no-signalling correlations and show that they possess invariance properties for suitable sets of states. We introduce quantum non-local games as a generalisation of non-local games. We define the operation of quantum game composition and show that the perfect strategies belonging to a certain class are closed under channel composition. We specialise to the case of graph colourings, where we exhibit quantum versions of the orthogonal rank of a graph as the optimal output dimension for which perfect classical-to-quantum strategies of the graph colouring game exist, as well as to non-commutative graph homomorphisms, where we identify quantum versions of non-commutative graph homomorphisms introduced by Stahlke.
We introduce a framework to describe probabilistic models in Bell experiments, and more generally in contextuality scenarios. Such a scenario is a hypergraph whose vertices represent elementary events and hyperedges correspond to measurements. A probabilistic model on such a scenario associates to each event a probability, in such a way that events in a given measurement have a total probability equal to one. We discuss the advantages of this framework, like the unification of the notions of contexuality and nonlocality, and give a short overview of results obtained elsewhere.
The presence of contextuality in quantum theory was first highlighted by Bell, Kochen and Specker, who discovered that for quantum systems of three or more dimensions, measurements could not be viewed as deterministically revealing pre-existing properties of the system. More precisely, no model can assign deterministic outcomes to the projectors of a quantum measurement in a way that depends only on the projector and not the context (the full set of projectors) in which it appeared, despite the fact that the Born rule probabilities associated with projectors are independent of the context. A more general, operational definition of contextuality introduced by Spekkens, which we will term 'probabilistic contextuality', drops the assumption of determinism and allows for operations other than measurements to be considered contextual. Even two-dimensional quantum mechanics can be shown to be contextual under this generalised notion. Probabilistic noncontextuality represents the postulate that elements of an operational theory that cannot be distinguished from each other based on the statistics of arbitrarily many repeated experiments (they give rise to the same operational probabilities) are ontologically identical. In this paper, we introduce a framework that enables us to distinguish between different noncontextuality assumptions in terms of the relationships between the ontological representations of objects in the theory given a certain relation between their operational representations. This framework can be used to motivate and define a 'possibilistic' analogue, encapsulating the idea that elements of an operational theory that cannot be unambiguously distinguished operationally can also not be unambiguously distinguished ontologically. We then prove that possibilistic noncontextuality is equivalent to an alternative notion of noncontextuality proposed by Hardy. Finally, we demonstrate that these weaker noncontextuality assumptions are sufficient to prove alternative versions of known 'no-go' theorems that constrain ψ -epistemic models for quantum mechanics.
Quantum mechanics allows only certain sets of experimental results (or ``probabilistic models'') for Bell-type quantum nonlocality experiments. A derivation of this set from simple physical or information theoretic principles would represent an important step forward in our understanding of quantum mechanics, and this problem has been intensely investigated in recent years. ``Macroscopic locality,'' which requires the recovery of locality in the limit of large numbers of trials, is one of several principles discussed in the literature that place a bound on the set of quantum probabilistic models. A similar question can also be asked about probabilistic models for the more general class of quantum contextuality experiments. Here, we extend the macroscopic locality principle to this more general setting, using the hypergraph approach of Ac\'{\i}n, Fritz, Leverrier, and Sainz [Comm. Math. Phys. 334(2), 533--628 (2015)], which provides a framework to study both phenomena of nonlocality and contextuality in a unified manner. We find that the set of probabilistic models allowed by our macroscopic noncontextuality principle is equivalent to an important and previously studied set in this formalism, which is slightly larger than the quantum set. In the particular case of Bell scenarios, this set is equivalent to the set of ``almost-quantum'' models, which is of particular interest since the latter was recently shown to satisfy all but one of the principles that have been proposed to bound quantum probabilistic models, without being implied by any of them (or even their conjunction). Our condition is the first characterization of the almost-quantum set from a simple physical principle.
Quantum theory departs from classical probabilistic theories in foundational ways. These departures--termed quantumness here--power quantum information and computation. This thesis charts the role of discrete structures in assessing quantumness, synthesizing elements of my postdoctoral research through this lens. After an introduction to the necessary background concepts, I present my work under three broad categories. First, I present work on contextuality that extensively relies on (undirected) graphs and hypergraphs as the discrete structures of interest; more specifically, it relies on invariants associated with them. This work includes Kochen-Specker (KS) contextuality and its operationalization to generalized contextuality, expressed via (hyper)graph-theoretic frameworks. I also present work on KS-contextuality in multiqubit systems and an application of generalized contextuality to a one-shot communication task, both of which rely on hypergraphs. Second, I present work on causality, where the discrete structures of interest are directed graphs. This includes work on indefinite causal order, specifically its connections to the gap between local operations and classical communication (LOCC) and separable operations (SEP), and a device-independent notion of nonclassicality--termed antinomicity--that generalizes Bell nonlocality without global causal assumptions. Finally, I present work on the incompatibility of quantum measurements, its connection to Bell nonlocality, and its role in discriminating between quantum and almost quantum correlations in the single-system setting. The discrete structures of interest here are hypergraphs that model joint measurability relations between quantum measurements. I conclude with a summary and an overview of work that is not covered in this thesis.