Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2405.04247 · Physical Review Research

Quantum-enhanced Markov chain Monte Carlo for systems larger than a quantum computer

Stuart Ferguson, Petros Wallden

Published Mar 3, 2025• 10 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum computers theoretically promise computational advantages in many tasks, but it is much less clear how such advantages can be maintained when using existing and near-term hardware that has limitations in the number and quality of its qubits. Layden [] proposed a promising application by introducing a quantum-enhanced Markov chain Monte Carlo (QeMCMC) approach to reduce the thermalization time required when sampling from hard probability distributions. In QeMCMC, the size of the required quantum computer scales linearly with the problem, placing limitations on the sizes of systems that can be considered. In this paper we introduce a framework to coarse grain the algorithm in such a way that the quantum computation can be performed using considerably smaller quantum computers and we term the method the coarse grained quantum-enhanced Markov chain Monte Carlo (CGQeMCMC). Example strategies within this framework are put to the test, with the quantum speedup persisting while using only n simulated qubits where n is the number of qubits required in the original QeMCMC—a quadratic reduction in resources. The coarse graining framework has the potential to be practically applicable in the near term as it requires very few qubits to approach classically intractable problem instances; in this case, only six simulated qubits suffice to gain an advantage compared with standard classical approaches when investigating the magnetization of a 36-spin system. Our method can be easily combined with other classical and quantum techniques and is adaptable to various quantum hardware specifications—in particular those with limited connectivity.

DOI
10.1103/physrevresearch.7.013231

Related papers

Quantum-enhanced Markov Chain Monte Carlo for Combinatorial Optimization

Kate V. Marshall, Daniel J. Egger, Michael Garn +4 more

Quantum computing offers an alternative paradigm for addressing combinatorial optimization problems compared to classical computing. Despite recent hardware improvements, the execution of empirical quantum optimization experiments at scales known to be hard for state-of-the-art classical solvers is not yet in reach. In this work, we offer a different way to approach combinatorial optimization with near-term quantum computing. Motivated by the promising results observed in using quantum-enhanced Markov chain Monte Carlo (QeMCMC) for approximating complicated probability distributions, we combine ideas of sampling from the device with QeMCMC together with warm-starting and parallel tempering, in the context of combinatorial optimization. We demonstrate empirically that our algorithm recovers the global optima for instances of the Maximum Independent Set problem (MIS) up to 117 decision variables using 117 qubits on IBM quantum hardware. We show early evidence of a scaling advantage of our algorithm compared to similar classical methods for the chosen instances of MIS. MIS is practically relevant across domains like financial services and molecular biology, and, in some cases, already difficult to solve to optimality classically with only a few hundred decision variables.

quant-pharXiv:2602.06171•Feb 9, 2026•9 citations

Bounding the speedup of the quantum-enhanced Markov-chain Monte Carlo algorithm

Alev Orfi, Dries Sels

Sampling tasks are a natural class of problems for quantum computers due to the probabilistic nature of the Born rule. Sampling from useful distributions on noisy quantum hardware remains a challenging problem. A recent paper [D. Layden et al., Nature (London) 619, 282 (2023).] proposed a quantum-enhanced Markov-chain Monte Carlo algorithm where moves are generated by a quantum device and accepted or rejected by a classical algorithm. While this procedure is robust to noise and control imperfections, its potential for quantum advantage is unclear. Here we show that there is no speedup over classical sampling on a worst-case unstructured sampling problem. We present an upper bound to the Markov gap that rules out a speedup for any unital quantum proposal.

arXiv:2403.03087•Physical Review A•Nov 12, 2024•17 citations

Experimental Realization of the Markov Chain Monte Carlo Algorithm on a Quantum Computer

Baptiste Claudon, Sergi Ramos-Calderer, Jean-Philip Piquemal

Quantum algorithms present a quadratically improved complexity over classical ones for certain sampling tasks. For instance, the Quantum Amplitude Estimation (QAE) algorithm promises to speed up the estimation of the mean of certain functions, given access to the quantum state corresponding to the probability distribution to be sampled from. Classically, samples are often obtained by simulating a Markov chain. In this work, we experimentally use encodings of Markov chains to prepare quantum states and run a quantum Markov Chain Monte Carlo (qMCMC) algorithm on Quantinuum System Model H2 and Quantinuum Helios quantum computers. We first demonstrate that it is possible to obtain accurate results by operating directly on the physical qubits. Crucially, to pave the way toward fault-tolerant execution, we also implement these algorithms using logical qubits protected by the Iceberg Quantum Error Detection (QED) code. By applying multiple rounds of mid-circuit QED during a random walk, we successfully catch and filter out hardware errors. These experiments demonstrate the feasibility of qMCMC on quantum hardware, bringing us closer to realizing quadratic quantum speedups with broad applications ranging from molecular modeling to machine learning and finance.

quant-pharXiv:2603.08395•Mar 10, 2026•1 citation

Quantum-Assisted Variational Monte Carlo

Longfei Chang, Zhendong Li, Wei‐Hai Fang

Solving the ground state of quantum many-body systems remains a fundamental challenge in physics and chemistry. Recent advancements in quantum hardware have opened new avenues for addressing this challenge. Inspired by the quantum-enhanced Markov chain Monte Carlo (QeMCMC) algorithm, which was originally designed for sampling the Boltzmann distribution of classical spin models using quantum computers, we introduce a quantum-assisted variational Monte Carlo (QA-VMC) algorithm for solving the ground state of quantum many-body systems by adapting QeMCMC to sample the distribution of a (neural-network) wave function in VMC. The central question is whether such a quantum-assisted proposal can potentially offer a computational advantage over classical methods. Through numerical investigations for the Fermi-Hubbard model and molecular systems, we demonstrate that the quantum-assisted proposal exhibits larger absolute spectral gaps and reduced autocorrelation times compared to conventional classical proposals, leading to more efficient sampling and faster convergence to the ground state in VMC as well as a more accurate and precise estimation of physical observables. This advantage is especially pronounced for specific parameter ranges, where the ground-state configurations are more concentrated in some configurations separated by large Hamming distances. Our results underscore the potential of quantum-assisted algorithms to enhance classical variational methods for solving the ground state of quantum many-body systems.

arXiv:2502.20799•Precision Chemistry•Jun 7, 2025•4 citations

Markov-chain Monte Carlo method enhanced by a quantum alternating operator ansatz

Yuichiro Nakano, Hideaki Hakoshima, Kosuke Mitarai +1 more

Quantum computation is expected to accelerate certain computational tasks over classical counterparts. Its most primitive advantage is its ability to sample from classically intractable probability distributions. A promising approach to make use of this fact is the so-called quantum-enhanced Markov-chain Monte Carlo (qe-MCMC) method [D. Layden , ], which uses outputs from quantum circuits as the proposal distributions. In this paper, we propose the use of a quantum alternating operator ansatz (QAOA) for qe-MCMC and provide a strategy to optimize its parameters to improve convergence speed while keeping its depth shallow. The proposed QAOA-type circuit is designed to satisfy the specific constraint which qe-MCMC requires with arbitrary parameters. Through our extensive numerical analysis, we find a correlation in a certain parameter range between an experimentally measurable value, acceptance rate of MCMC, and the spectral gap of the MCMC transition matrix, which determines the convergence speed. This allows us to optimize the parameter in the QAOA circuit and achieve quadratic speedup in convergence. Since MCMC is used in various areas such as statistical physics and machine learning, this paper represents an important step toward realizing practical quantum advantage with currently available quantum computers through qe-MCMC. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2305.08789•Physical Review Research•Jul 25, 2024•18 citations

Neural-Network-Assisted Monte Carlo Sampling Trained by Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm

Yuichiro Nakano, Ken N. Okada, Keisuke Fujii

Sampling problems are widely regarded as the task for which quantum computers can most readily provide a quantum advantage. Leveraging this feature, the quantum-enhanced Markov chain Monte Carlo [Layden , Nature 619, 282–287 (2023)] has been proposed recently, where sampling from a quantum computer is used as a proposal distribution and convergence to a target distribution is accelerated. However, guaranteeing convergence to the target distribution typically forces one to impose restrictive symmetry constraints on the quantum circuit, which makes it hard to design good proposal distributions and prevents making full use of the advantage of a quantum computer. We explore a hybrid quantum-classical Markov chain Monte Carlo framework that combines a quantum circuit with a generative neural sampler (GNS). The GNS is trained on quantum samples and acts as a classical surrogate to efficiently emulate quantum outputs, thereby lifting circuit constraints. We apply this method to Boltzmann sampling of spin glasses using proposals trained with a quantum approximate optimization algorithm circuit. This approach outperforms conventional methods, showing a polynomial speedup (over cubic) in spectral gap compared with uniform proposals. Notably, it maintains similar acceleration even without parameter optimization. These results establish the method as a viable sampling-based quantum algorithm for noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices and highlight its potential for solving practical problems with quantum computation.

arXiv:2506.01335•PRX Quantum•Jan 6, 2026•6 citations
Quantum computers theoretically promise computational advantages in many tasks, but it is much less clear how such advantages can be maintained when using existing and near-term hardware that has limitations in the number and quality of its qubits. Layden [] proposed a promising application by introducing a quantum-enhanced Markov chain Monte Carlo (QeMCMC) approach to reduce the thermalization time required when sampling from hard probability distributions. In QeMCMC, the size of the required quantum computer scales linearly with the problem, placing limitations on the sizes of systems that can be considered. In this paper we introduce a framework to coarse grain the algorithm in such a way that the quantum computation can be performed using considerably smaller quantum computers and we term the method the coarse grained quantum-enhanced Markov chain Monte Carlo (CGQeMCMC). Example strategies within this framework are put to the test, with the quantum speedup persisting while using only n simulated qubits where n is the number of qubits required in the original QeMCMC—a quadratic reduction in resources. The coarse graining framework has the potential to be practically applicable in the near term as it requires very few qubits to approach classically intractable problem instances; in this case, only six simulated qubits suffice to gain an advantage compared with standard classical approaches when investigating the magnetization of a 36-spin system. Our method can be easily combined with other classical and quantum techniques and is adaptable to various quantum hardware specifications—in particular those with limited connectivity.
Quantum computing offers an alternative paradigm for addressing combinatorial optimization problems compared to classical computing. Despite recent hardware improvements, the execution of empirical quantum optimization experiments at scales known to be hard for state-of-the-art classical solvers is not yet in reach. In this work, we offer a different way to approach combinatorial optimization with near-term quantum computing. Motivated by the promising results observed in using quantum-enhanced Markov chain Monte Carlo (QeMCMC) for approximating complicated probability distributions, we combine ideas of sampling from the device with QeMCMC together with warm-starting and parallel tempering, in the context of combinatorial optimization. We demonstrate empirically that our algorithm recovers the global optima for instances of the Maximum Independent Set problem (MIS) up to 117 decision variables using 117 qubits on IBM quantum hardware. We show early evidence of a scaling advantage of our algorithm compared to similar classical methods for the chosen instances of MIS. MIS is practically relevant across domains like financial services and molecular biology, and, in some cases, already difficult to solve to optimality classically with only a few hundred decision variables.
Sampling tasks are a natural class of problems for quantum computers due to the probabilistic nature of the Born rule. Sampling from useful distributions on noisy quantum hardware remains a challenging problem. A recent paper [D. Layden et al., Nature (London) 619, 282 (2023).] proposed a quantum-enhanced Markov-chain Monte Carlo algorithm where moves are generated by a quantum device and accepted or rejected by a classical algorithm. While this procedure is robust to noise and control imperfections, its potential for quantum advantage is unclear. Here we show that there is no speedup over classical sampling on a worst-case unstructured sampling problem. We present an upper bound to the Markov gap that rules out a speedup for any unital quantum proposal.
Quantum algorithms present a quadratically improved complexity over classical ones for certain sampling tasks. For instance, the Quantum Amplitude Estimation (QAE) algorithm promises to speed up the estimation of the mean of certain functions, given access to the quantum state corresponding to the probability distribution to be sampled from. Classically, samples are often obtained by simulating a Markov chain. In this work, we experimentally use encodings of Markov chains to prepare quantum states and run a quantum Markov Chain Monte Carlo (qMCMC) algorithm on Quantinuum System Model H2 and Quantinuum Helios quantum computers. We first demonstrate that it is possible to obtain accurate results by operating directly on the physical qubits. Crucially, to pave the way toward fault-tolerant execution, we also implement these algorithms using logical qubits protected by the Iceberg Quantum Error Detection (QED) code. By applying multiple rounds of mid-circuit QED during a random walk, we successfully catch and filter out hardware errors. These experiments demonstrate the feasibility of qMCMC on quantum hardware, bringing us closer to realizing quadratic quantum speedups with broad applications ranging from molecular modeling to machine learning and finance.
Solving the ground state of quantum many-body systems remains a fundamental challenge in physics and chemistry. Recent advancements in quantum hardware have opened new avenues for addressing this challenge. Inspired by the quantum-enhanced Markov chain Monte Carlo (QeMCMC) algorithm, which was originally designed for sampling the Boltzmann distribution of classical spin models using quantum computers, we introduce a quantum-assisted variational Monte Carlo (QA-VMC) algorithm for solving the ground state of quantum many-body systems by adapting QeMCMC to sample the distribution of a (neural-network) wave function in VMC. The central question is whether such a quantum-assisted proposal can potentially offer a computational advantage over classical methods. Through numerical investigations for the Fermi-Hubbard model and molecular systems, we demonstrate that the quantum-assisted proposal exhibits larger absolute spectral gaps and reduced autocorrelation times compared to conventional classical proposals, leading to more efficient sampling and faster convergence to the ground state in VMC as well as a more accurate and precise estimation of physical observables. This advantage is especially pronounced for specific parameter ranges, where the ground-state configurations are more concentrated in some configurations separated by large Hamming distances. Our results underscore the potential of quantum-assisted algorithms to enhance classical variational methods for solving the ground state of quantum many-body systems.
Quantum computation is expected to accelerate certain computational tasks over classical counterparts. Its most primitive advantage is its ability to sample from classically intractable probability distributions. A promising approach to make use of this fact is the so-called quantum-enhanced Markov-chain Monte Carlo (qe-MCMC) method [D. Layden , ], which uses outputs from quantum circuits as the proposal distributions. In this paper, we propose the use of a quantum alternating operator ansatz (QAOA) for qe-MCMC and provide a strategy to optimize its parameters to improve convergence speed while keeping its depth shallow. The proposed QAOA-type circuit is designed to satisfy the specific constraint which qe-MCMC requires with arbitrary parameters. Through our extensive numerical analysis, we find a correlation in a certain parameter range between an experimentally measurable value, acceptance rate of MCMC, and the spectral gap of the MCMC transition matrix, which determines the convergence speed. This allows us to optimize the parameter in the QAOA circuit and achieve quadratic speedup in convergence. Since MCMC is used in various areas such as statistical physics and machine learning, this paper represents an important step toward realizing practical quantum advantage with currently available quantum computers through qe-MCMC. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
Sampling problems are widely regarded as the task for which quantum computers can most readily provide a quantum advantage. Leveraging this feature, the quantum-enhanced Markov chain Monte Carlo [Layden , Nature 619, 282–287 (2023)] has been proposed recently, where sampling from a quantum computer is used as a proposal distribution and convergence to a target distribution is accelerated. However, guaranteeing convergence to the target distribution typically forces one to impose restrictive symmetry constraints on the quantum circuit, which makes it hard to design good proposal distributions and prevents making full use of the advantage of a quantum computer. We explore a hybrid quantum-classical Markov chain Monte Carlo framework that combines a quantum circuit with a generative neural sampler (GNS). The GNS is trained on quantum samples and acts as a classical surrogate to efficiently emulate quantum outputs, thereby lifting circuit constraints. We apply this method to Boltzmann sampling of spin glasses using proposals trained with a quantum approximate optimization algorithm circuit. This approach outperforms conventional methods, showing a polynomial speedup (over cubic) in spectral gap compared with uniform proposals. Notably, it maintains similar acceleration even without parameter optimization. These results establish the method as a viable sampling-based quantum algorithm for noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices and highlight its potential for solving practical problems with quantum computation.