Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2404.16156 · International Symposium on Quality Electronic Design (ISQED)

Guardians of the Quantum GAN

Archisman Ghosh, Debarshi Kundu, Avimita Chatterjee, Swaroop Ghosh

Published Apr 23, 2025• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum Generative Adversarial Networks (qGANs) are leading image-generating quantum machine learning models. With the increasing demand for Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) devices, more third-party vendors are expected to offer quantum hardware as a service, raising the risk of proprietary information theft. To mitigate this, we propose a novel watermarking technique that uses the noise signature embedded during qGAN training as a non-invasive watermark. This watermark is detectable in the generated images, tracing the specific quantum hardware used for training and providing strong proof of ownership. To enhance security, we propose training qGANs on multiple quantum hardware, embedding a complex watermark comprising the noise signatures of all training hardware, making it difficult for adversaries to replicate. A machine learning classifier is developed to extract this watermark, identifying the training hardware from the generated images, thereby validating the authenticity of the model. The watermark signature is robust even when inference occurs on different hardware. We achieve watermark extraction accuracy of 100% for single-hardware training and ~ 90% for multi-hardware training setups. We also obtain a validation accuracy of ~ 90% on both single-hardware and multi-hardware training setups in the presence of temporal variation of noise. This watermarking method can be extended to other quantum machine learning models due to the strong modulation of parameter evolution by quantum noise during training.

DOI
10.1109/isqed65160.2025.11014340

Related papers

Quantum Generative Adversarial Networks: Generating and Detecting Quantum Product States

James E. Steck, Elizabeth Behrman

Machine learning can be used as a systematic method to non-algorithmically "program" quantum computers. Quantum machine learning enables us to perform computations without breaking down an algorithm into its gate "building blocks", eliminating that difficult step and potentially reducing unnecessary complexity. In addition, the machine learning approach is robust to both noise and to decoherence, which is ideal for running on inherently noisy NISQ devices which are limited in the number of qubits available for error correction. Here we apply our prior work in quantum machine learning technique, to create a QGAN, a quantum analog to the classical Stylenet GANs developed by Kerras for image generation and classification. A quantum system is used as a generator and a separate quantum system is used as a discriminator. The generator Hamiltonian quantum parameters are augmented by quantum "style" parameters which play the role of the style parameters used by Kerras. Both generator parameters are trained in a GAN MinMax problem along with quantum parameters of the discriminator Hamiltonian. We choose a problem to demonstrate the QGAN that has purely quantum information. The task is to generate and discriminate quantum product states. "Real" product states are generated to be detected and separated from "fake" quantum product states generated by the quantum generator. The problem of detecting quantum product states is chosen to demonstrate the QGAN because is well known as purely quantum mechanical, has no classical analog and is an open problem for quantum product states of more than 2 qubits. With proper encoding of image pixels into quantum states as density matrices, the method demonstrated here for this quantum problem is applicable to GAN image generation and detection, the problem so successfully demonstrated by Kerras's classical GAN, but can be hosted on and taking advantage of the nature of quantum computers.

•Aug 12, 2024•0 citations

A quantum GAN for entanglement detection and image classification

James E. Steck, Elizabeth Behrman

Machine learning can be used as a systematic method to non-algorithmically program quantum computers. Quantum machine learning enables us to perform computations without breaking down an algorithm into its gate building blocks, eliminating that difficult step and potentially reducing unnecessary complexity. In addition, the machine learning approach is robust to both noise and to decoherence, which is ideal for running on inherently noisy NISQ devices which are limited in the number of qubits available for error correction. Here we apply our prior work in quantum machine learning technique, to create a QGAN, a quantum analog to the classical Stylenet GANs developed by Kerras for image generation and classification. A quantum system is used as a generator and a separate quantum system is used as a discriminator. The generator Hamiltonian quantum parameters are augmented by quantum style parameters which play the role of the style parameters used by Kerras. Both generator parameters are trained in a GAN MinMax problem along with quantum parameters of the discriminator Hamiltonian. We choose a problem to demonstrate the QGAN that has purely quantum information. The task is to generate and discriminate quantum product states. Real product states are generated to be detected and separated from fake quantum product states generated by the quantum generator. The problem of detecting quantum product states is chosen to demonstrate the QGAN because is well known as purely quantum mechanical, has no classical analog and is an open problem for quantum product states of more than 2 qubits. With proper encoding of image pixels into quantum states as density matrices, the method demonstrated here is applicable to GAN image generation and detection that can be hosted on and take advantage of the nature of quantum computers.

arXiv:2408.12620•Aug 9, 2024•3 citations

Quantum generative adversarial network with automated noise suppression mechanism based on WGAN-GP

Yanbing Tian, Cewen Tian, Zhe-Cheng Fan +2 more

Quantum Machine Learning (QML) has attracted significant attention for its potential to deliver exponential advantages over classical machine learning approaches, particularly in classification and recognition tasks. Quantum Generative Adversarial Networks (QGANs), a form of quantum machine learning, provide promising advantages in image processing and generation tasks when compared to classical technologies. However, the limitations of current quantum devices have led to suboptimal image quality and limited robustness in earlier methods. To overcome these challenges, we developed a hybrid quantum-classical approach, introducing CAQ, a quantum-classical Generative Adversarial Network (GAN) framework. Leveraging the latest WGAN-gradient penalty (GP) strategy, we trained and optimized the quantum generator, reduced the complexity of parameters, and implemented an adaptive noise input system that dynamically adjusts noise levels, thereby improving the model’s robustness. Additionally, we employed a remapping technique to transform the original image’s multimodal distribution into a unimodal one, thereby reducing the complexity of the learned distribution. Experiments on MNIST and Fashion-MNIST datasets show that CAQ generates grayscale images effectively, demonstrating its feasibility on near-term intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) computers.

EPJ Quantum Technology•Jun 23, 2025•14 citations

Survey of Quantum Generative Adversarial Networks (QGAN) to Generate Images

Mohammadsaleh Pajuhanfard, Rasoul Kiani, Victor S. Sheng

Quantum Generative Adversarial Networks (QGANs) represent a useful development in quantum machine learning, using the particular properties of quantum mechanics to solve the challenges of data analysis and modeling. This paper brings up a general analysis of five QGAN architectures, focusing on their evolution, strengths, weaknesses, and limitations in noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices. Primary methods like Entangling Quantum GAN (EQ-GAN) and Quantum state fidelity (QuGAN) concentrate on stability, convergence, and robust performance on small-scale datasets such as 2 × 2 grayscale images. Intermediate models such as Image Quantum GAN (IQGAN) and Experimental Quantum GAN (EXQGAN) provide new ideas like trainable encoders and patch-based sub-generators that are scalable to 8 × 8 datasets with increasing noise resilience. The most advanced method is Parameterized Quantum Wasserstein GAN (PQWGAN), which uses a hybrid quantum-classical structure to obtain high-resolution image processing for 28 × 28 grayscale datasets while trying to maintain parameter efficiency. This study explores, analyzes, and summarizes critical problems of QGANs, including accuracy, convergence, parameter efficiency, image quality, performance metrics, and training stability under noisy conditions. In addition, developing QGANs can generate and train parameters in quantum approximation optimization algorithms. One of the useful applications of QGAN is generating medical datasets that can generate medical images from limited datasets to train specific medical models for the recognition of diseases.

Mathematics•Dec 6, 2024•30 citations

QGAN Driven Hybrid Quantum—Classical Architectures for Efficient and Noise Resilient Machine Learning

B Gouthami, C. Janani, R.Banu priya +3 more

This paper introduces a novel hybrid quantumclassical model using QGAN (quantum generative adversarial network) to achieve more efficient, convergent and noiserobust machine learning for nearterm quantum (NISQ) applications. Unlike the existing GAN type models that were purely classical or purely quantum, to propose a quantum generator consisting of shallow variation circuits (48 qubits) together with a classical discriminator that is crucial for the stability of adversarial training. The empirical results on the MNIST dataset showed that were able to perform classification with an accuracy of 94.2%, an improvement of over 3.2% from a straightforward classical only approach, while NVGAN also improved its generative performance to a Fréchet Inception Distance (FID) score of 38.7 or 26% in quality enhancement from synthesis perspective. Both trainings converged 50 epochs earlier than each training when used the hybrid model (30% improvement in convergence). The key innovation of this work is bringing (1) to bear both the utility of the quantumenhanced feature representation to have at disposal, and (2) classical stability measures and erroraware optimizations (such as parameter clipping, early stopping), such that its hybridization enabled it to continue operating with$\mathbf{> 9 0 \%}$accuracy under cases of reasonable depolarizing/amplitude damping noise on an MLP where purely quantum formulations decayed to (approx 70%). Altogether, the paper validates the presented hybrid QGAN approach as a statistically substantiated noise robust and scalable representational tool for real world applications of quantum enhanced machine learning tasks on NISQ platforms.

International Conference on Communication, Computing and Electronics Systems (ICCCES)•Jan 21, 2026•0 citations

Quantum generative adversarial learning in photonics

Yizhi Wang, Shichuan Xue, Yaxuan Wang +10 more

Quantum generative adversarial networks (QGANs), an intersection of quantum computing and machine learning, have attracted widespread attention due to their potential advantages over classical analogs. However, in the current era of noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) computing, it is essential to investigate whether QGANs can perform learning tasks on near-term quantum devices usually affected by noise and even defects. In this Letter, using a programmable silicon quantum photonic chip, we experimentally demonstrate the QGAN model in photonics for the first time to our knowledge and investigate the effects of noise and defects on its performance. Our results show that QGANs can generate high-quality quantum data with a fidelity higher than 90%, even under conditions where up to half of the generator's phase shifters are damaged, or all of the generator and discriminator's phase shifters are subjected to phase noise up to 0.04π. Our work sheds light on the feasibility of implementing QGANs on the NISQ-era quantum hardware.

arXiv:2310.00585•Optics Letters•Sep 18, 2023•10 citations
Quantum Generative Adversarial Networks (qGANs) are leading image-generating quantum machine learning models. With the increasing demand for Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) devices, more third-party vendors are expected to offer quantum hardware as a service, raising the risk of proprietary information theft. To mitigate this, we propose a novel watermarking technique that uses the noise signature embedded during qGAN training as a non-invasive watermark. This watermark is detectable in the generated images, tracing the specific quantum hardware used for training and providing strong proof of ownership. To enhance security, we propose training qGANs on multiple quantum hardware, embedding a complex watermark comprising the noise signatures of all training hardware, making it difficult for adversaries to replicate. A machine learning classifier is developed to extract this watermark, identifying the training hardware from the generated images, thereby validating the authenticity of the model. The watermark signature is robust even when inference occurs on different hardware. We achieve watermark extraction accuracy of 100% for single-hardware training and ~ 90% for multi-hardware training setups. We also obtain a validation accuracy of ~ 90% on both single-hardware and multi-hardware training setups in the presence of temporal variation of noise. This watermarking method can be extended to other quantum machine learning models due to the strong modulation of parameter evolution by quantum noise during training.
Machine learning can be used as a systematic method to non-algorithmically "program" quantum computers. Quantum machine learning enables us to perform computations without breaking down an algorithm into its gate "building blocks", eliminating that difficult step and potentially reducing unnecessary complexity. In addition, the machine learning approach is robust to both noise and to decoherence, which is ideal for running on inherently noisy NISQ devices which are limited in the number of qubits available for error correction. Here we apply our prior work in quantum machine learning technique, to create a QGAN, a quantum analog to the classical Stylenet GANs developed by Kerras for image generation and classification. A quantum system is used as a generator and a separate quantum system is used as a discriminator. The generator Hamiltonian quantum parameters are augmented by quantum "style" parameters which play the role of the style parameters used by Kerras. Both generator parameters are trained in a GAN MinMax problem along with quantum parameters of the discriminator Hamiltonian. We choose a problem to demonstrate the QGAN that has purely quantum information. The task is to generate and discriminate quantum product states. "Real" product states are generated to be detected and separated from "fake" quantum product states generated by the quantum generator. The problem of detecting quantum product states is chosen to demonstrate the QGAN because is well known as purely quantum mechanical, has no classical analog and is an open problem for quantum product states of more than 2 qubits. With proper encoding of image pixels into quantum states as density matrices, the method demonstrated here for this quantum problem is applicable to GAN image generation and detection, the problem so successfully demonstrated by Kerras's classical GAN, but can be hosted on and taking advantage of the nature of quantum computers.
Machine learning can be used as a systematic method to non-algorithmically program quantum computers. Quantum machine learning enables us to perform computations without breaking down an algorithm into its gate building blocks, eliminating that difficult step and potentially reducing unnecessary complexity. In addition, the machine learning approach is robust to both noise and to decoherence, which is ideal for running on inherently noisy NISQ devices which are limited in the number of qubits available for error correction. Here we apply our prior work in quantum machine learning technique, to create a QGAN, a quantum analog to the classical Stylenet GANs developed by Kerras for image generation and classification. A quantum system is used as a generator and a separate quantum system is used as a discriminator. The generator Hamiltonian quantum parameters are augmented by quantum style parameters which play the role of the style parameters used by Kerras. Both generator parameters are trained in a GAN MinMax problem along with quantum parameters of the discriminator Hamiltonian. We choose a problem to demonstrate the QGAN that has purely quantum information. The task is to generate and discriminate quantum product states. Real product states are generated to be detected and separated from fake quantum product states generated by the quantum generator. The problem of detecting quantum product states is chosen to demonstrate the QGAN because is well known as purely quantum mechanical, has no classical analog and is an open problem for quantum product states of more than 2 qubits. With proper encoding of image pixels into quantum states as density matrices, the method demonstrated here is applicable to GAN image generation and detection that can be hosted on and take advantage of the nature of quantum computers.
Quantum Machine Learning (QML) has attracted significant attention for its potential to deliver exponential advantages over classical machine learning approaches, particularly in classification and recognition tasks. Quantum Generative Adversarial Networks (QGANs), a form of quantum machine learning, provide promising advantages in image processing and generation tasks when compared to classical technologies. However, the limitations of current quantum devices have led to suboptimal image quality and limited robustness in earlier methods. To overcome these challenges, we developed a hybrid quantum-classical approach, introducing CAQ, a quantum-classical Generative Adversarial Network (GAN) framework. Leveraging the latest WGAN-gradient penalty (GP) strategy, we trained and optimized the quantum generator, reduced the complexity of parameters, and implemented an adaptive noise input system that dynamically adjusts noise levels, thereby improving the model’s robustness. Additionally, we employed a remapping technique to transform the original image’s multimodal distribution into a unimodal one, thereby reducing the complexity of the learned distribution. Experiments on MNIST and Fashion-MNIST datasets show that CAQ generates grayscale images effectively, demonstrating its feasibility on near-term intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) computers.
Quantum Generative Adversarial Networks (QGANs) represent a useful development in quantum machine learning, using the particular properties of quantum mechanics to solve the challenges of data analysis and modeling. This paper brings up a general analysis of five QGAN architectures, focusing on their evolution, strengths, weaknesses, and limitations in noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices. Primary methods like Entangling Quantum GAN (EQ-GAN) and Quantum state fidelity (QuGAN) concentrate on stability, convergence, and robust performance on small-scale datasets such as 2 × 2 grayscale images. Intermediate models such as Image Quantum GAN (IQGAN) and Experimental Quantum GAN (EXQGAN) provide new ideas like trainable encoders and patch-based sub-generators that are scalable to 8 × 8 datasets with increasing noise resilience. The most advanced method is Parameterized Quantum Wasserstein GAN (PQWGAN), which uses a hybrid quantum-classical structure to obtain high-resolution image processing for 28 × 28 grayscale datasets while trying to maintain parameter efficiency. This study explores, analyzes, and summarizes critical problems of QGANs, including accuracy, convergence, parameter efficiency, image quality, performance metrics, and training stability under noisy conditions. In addition, developing QGANs can generate and train parameters in quantum approximation optimization algorithms. One of the useful applications of QGAN is generating medical datasets that can generate medical images from limited datasets to train specific medical models for the recognition of diseases.
This paper introduces a novel hybrid quantumclassical model using QGAN (quantum generative adversarial network) to achieve more efficient, convergent and noiserobust machine learning for nearterm quantum (NISQ) applications. Unlike the existing GAN type models that were purely classical or purely quantum, to propose a quantum generator consisting of shallow variation circuits (48 qubits) together with a classical discriminator that is crucial for the stability of adversarial training. The empirical results on the MNIST dataset showed that were able to perform classification with an accuracy of 94.2%, an improvement of over 3.2% from a straightforward classical only approach, while NVGAN also improved its generative performance to a Fréchet Inception Distance (FID) score of 38.7 or 26% in quality enhancement from synthesis perspective. Both trainings converged 50 epochs earlier than each training when used the hybrid model (30% improvement in convergence). The key innovation of this work is bringing (1) to bear both the utility of the quantumenhanced feature representation to have at disposal, and (2) classical stability measures and erroraware optimizations (such as parameter clipping, early stopping), such that its hybridization enabled it to continue operating with>90%\mathbf{> 9 0 \%}>90%accuracy under cases of reasonable depolarizing/amplitude damping noise on an MLP where purely quantum formulations decayed to (approx 70%). Altogether, the paper validates the presented hybrid QGAN approach as a statistically substantiated noise robust and scalable representational tool for real world applications of quantum enhanced machine learning tasks on NISQ platforms.
Quantum generative adversarial networks (QGANs), an intersection of quantum computing and machine learning, have attracted widespread attention due to their potential advantages over classical analogs. However, in the current era of noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) computing, it is essential to investigate whether QGANs can perform learning tasks on near-term quantum devices usually affected by noise and even defects. In this Letter, using a programmable silicon quantum photonic chip, we experimentally demonstrate the QGAN model in photonics for the first time to our knowledge and investigate the effects of noise and defects on its performance. Our results show that QGANs can generate high-quality quantum data with a fidelity higher than 90%, even under conditions where up to half of the generator's phase shifters are damaged, or all of the generator and discriminator's phase shifters are subjected to phase noise up to 0.04π. Our work sheds light on the feasibility of implementing QGANs on the NISQ-era quantum hardware.