Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2404.09934

Beable-guided measurement theory

Aleksei M. Aleshin, Nikitin, Vladimir V., P. I. Pronin

Published Apr 15, 2024• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In quantum mechanics, randomness is postulated as a separate axiom. De Broglie's theory allows one to reproduce quantum phenomena from completely deterministic formalism. But the question of the quantum randomness emergency in the de Broglie-Bohm theory needs special attention. In the work [G. Tastevin, F. Laloë, Comptes Rendus. Physique, 2021, 22, 1, pp. 99-116], it was shown that it arises as a result of the device microscopic state influence on the measurement result. In our work, we investigate the genesis of the quantum randomness in the de Broglie's theory in more details. Namely, we investigate the target system and the device behaviour in the decoherence process and model the measurement of canonical-conjugate observables. We propose a thought experiment which tests the opportunity of the information transition using beable-parameters violating the uncertainty relation. We show that in the measurement process, the strong stochastic fluctuations of beable parameters arise randomising the system in accordance with the uncertainty relation. Nevertheless, we find anomalous models of measurement in which these fluctuations can be neglected. These special models require further investigation.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2404.09934

Related papers

The Quantum Measurement Problem: Foundations, Interpretations, and Recent Developments

Adam Dakhil Nasser

Quantum mechanics famously posits two distinct evolution rules for the state of a system: a deterministic, unitary time evolution under the Schr¨odinger equation, and a probabilistic “collapse” of the wavefunction upon measurement as dictated by the Born rule. The apparent inconsistency of these two dynamical laws – one continuous and one discontinuous – constitutes the quantum measurement problem. This foundational problem, which underlies the emergence of definite outcomes from quantum superpositions, has persisted since the theory’s inception. In this review, we present a comprehensive and rigorous examination of the measurement problem and survey the leading approaches that seek to resolve or circumvent it. We begin by formulating the measurement problem and its conceptual challenges. We then discuss in detail the major interpretations of quantum mechanics and theoretical frameworks addressing the problem: the Copenhagen interpretation, Everett’s many-worlds interpretation, de Broglie–Bohm pilot-wave theory, objective collapse models, the role of decoherence and environment-induced superselection, and epistemic approaches such as QBism. For each interpretation, we describe the core principles and mathematical formalism, assessing how (and whether) it attempts to solve the measurement problem. We also review modern developments and experiments relevant to quantum measurements, including tests of Bell inequalities, observations of decoherence and macroscopic superpositions, weak measurements and quantum eraser experiments, and thought experiments ‘a la Wigner’s friend. We highlight how these results inform the ongoing debate. Finally, we discuss open problems and challenges that remain in fully resolving the measurement problem.

•Apr 15, 2025•5 citations

The outcomes of measurements in the de Broglie–Bohm theory II

Franck Laloë, Geneviève Tastevin

Part I of this article discussed the quantum measurement process within the de Broglie–Bohm theory. In the experiment considered, the outcome of the measurements was primarily determined by the initial Bohmian positions within the measurement apparatus. This is nevertheless not always the case. Part II is a short addendum with a more general discussion: cases where the measurement results reveal the values of the positions attached to the measured system, the measurement apparatus, or both, are considered.

arXiv:2507.03596•Comptes Rendus Physique•Jul 4, 2025•0 citations

Could quantum decoherence and measurement be deterministic phenomena?

Jean-Marc Sparenberg, Réda Nour, Aylin Manço

The apparent random outcome of a quantum measurement is conjectured to be fundamentally determined by the microscopic state of the macroscopic measurement apparatus. The apparatus state thus plays the role of a hidden variable which, in contrast with variables characterizing the measured microscopic system, is shown to lead to a violation of Bell’s inequalities and to agree with standard quantum mechanics. An explicit realization of this interpretation is explored (for details, see [1]) for a primitive model of cloud chamber inspired by Mott [2]. Being highly non local, this interpretation of quantum mechanics is argued to open the way to faster-than-light information transfer.

arXiv:1212.2256•EPJ Web of Conferences•Jan 1, 2013•2 citations

A disputable assumption behind the empirical equivalence between pilot-wave theory and standard quantum mechanics

Jorge Manero, R. Muciño, Elias Okon

The de Broglie-Bohm pilot-wave theory asserts that a complete characterization of an $N$-particle system is given by its wave function together with the (at-all-times-defined) positions of the particles, with the wave function always satisfying the Schrödinger equation and the positions evolving according to the deterministic "guiding equation". A complete agreement with the predictive apparatus of standard quantum mechanics, including the uncertainty principle and the probabilistic Born rule, is then said to emerge from these equations, without having to confer any special status to measurements or observers. Two key elements behind the proof of this complete agreement are absolute uncertainty and the POVM theorem. The former involves an alleged "naturally emerging, irreducible limitation on the possibility of obtaining knowledge within pilot-wave theory" and the latter establishes that the outcome distributions of all measurements are described by POVMs. Here, we argue that the derivations of absolute uncertainty and the POVM theorem depend upon the questionable assumption that "information is always configurationally grounded". We explain in detail why the offered rationale behind such an assumption is deficient and explore the consequences of having to let go of it.

arXiv:2508.06667•Aug 8, 2025•4 citations

Could quantum decoherence and measurement be deterministic phenomena?

Jean-Marc Sparenberg, Réda Nour, Aylin Manço

Abstract. The apparent random outcome of a quantum measurement is conjectured to be fundamentally determined by the microscopic state of the macroscopic measurement apparatus. The apparatus state thus plays the role of a hidden variable which, in contrast with variables characterizing the measured microscopic system, is shown to lead to a vi-olation of Bell’s inequalities and to agree with standard quantum mechanics. An explicit realization of this interpretation is explored (for details, see [1]) for a primitive model of cloud chamber inspired by Mott [2]. Being highly non local, this interpretation of quantum mechanics is argued to open the way to faster-than-light information transfer.

•Sep 5, 2013•3 citations

Heisenberg Uncertainty Relation Derived as a Special Limiting Case of a Single Elementary Phase Cycle (v.02).

Hennadii Kovalov

The proposed geometric model is not a return to 19th-century classical mechanics, but rather builds on the latest trends in Planck-scale deterministic cellular automata ('t Hooft, 2021), the theory of internal quantum clocks (Donadi, 2023), and the nonlinear quantum dynamics of asymmetric rotors (Micheli and Stone, 2022). The model directly resolves the topological crisis of describing light nuclei as saturated manifolds, documented in the current literature (Manton, 2022; Lau, 2020). We derive a direct, non-linear relation between the internal phase time per radian , the macroscopically observable coordinate time , and the relative energy fluctuation . Through rigorous differentiation and integration of these phase relations, we demonstrate that for topologically synchronized systems, the product of energy and observable time constitutes a strict dynamic process invariant: . Moving beyond phenomenological interpretations, we deduce the classical Heisenberg uncertainty relation without invoking independent quantum postulates, showing it to be a special boundary limit governing a single elementary phase cycle () under critical fluctuation. Furthermore, we prove that Louis de Broglie’s matter wave equation () is not an independent axiom but emerges naturally as the spatial displacement executed by a localized particle during a single complete internal chronal rotation. Finally, we bridge the gap between microscopic quantum reversibility and the macroscopic thermodynamic arrow of time by analyzing the dynamics of synchronization breakdown and phase slippage () using the latest advancements in deterministic quantum mechanics.

•Jun 12, 2026•0 citations
In quantum mechanics, randomness is postulated as a separate axiom. De Broglie's theory allows one to reproduce quantum phenomena from completely deterministic formalism. But the question of the quantum randomness emergency in the de Broglie-Bohm theory needs special attention. In the work [G. Tastevin, F. Laloë, Comptes Rendus. Physique, 2021, 22, 1, pp. 99-116], it was shown that it arises as a result of the device microscopic state influence on the measurement result. In our work, we investigate the genesis of the quantum randomness in the de Broglie's theory in more details. Namely, we investigate the target system and the device behaviour in the decoherence process and model the measurement of canonical-conjugate observables. We propose a thought experiment which tests the opportunity of the information transition using beable-parameters violating the uncertainty relation. We show that in the measurement process, the strong stochastic fluctuations of beable parameters arise randomising the system in accordance with the uncertainty relation. Nevertheless, we find anomalous models of measurement in which these fluctuations can be neglected. These special models require further investigation.
Quantum mechanics famously posits two distinct evolution rules for the state of a system: a deterministic, unitary time evolution under the Schr¨odinger equation, and a probabilistic “collapse” of the wavefunction upon measurement as dictated by the Born rule. The apparent inconsistency of these two dynamical laws – one continuous and one discontinuous – constitutes the quantum measurement problem. This foundational problem, which underlies the emergence of definite outcomes from quantum superpositions, has persisted since the theory’s inception. In this review, we present a comprehensive and rigorous examination of the measurement problem and survey the leading approaches that seek to resolve or circumvent it. We begin by formulating the measurement problem and its conceptual challenges. We then discuss in detail the major interpretations of quantum mechanics and theoretical frameworks addressing the problem: the Copenhagen interpretation, Everett’s many-worlds interpretation, de Broglie–Bohm pilot-wave theory, objective collapse models, the role of decoherence and environment-induced superselection, and epistemic approaches such as QBism. For each interpretation, we describe the core principles and mathematical formalism, assessing how (and whether) it attempts to solve the measurement problem. We also review modern developments and experiments relevant to quantum measurements, including tests of Bell inequalities, observations of decoherence and macroscopic superpositions, weak measurements and quantum eraser experiments, and thought experiments ‘a la Wigner’s friend. We highlight how these results inform the ongoing debate. Finally, we discuss open problems and challenges that remain in fully resolving the measurement problem.
Part I of this article discussed the quantum measurement process within the de Broglie–Bohm theory. In the experiment considered, the outcome of the measurements was primarily determined by the initial Bohmian positions within the measurement apparatus. This is nevertheless not always the case. Part II is a short addendum with a more general discussion: cases where the measurement results reveal the values of the positions attached to the measured system, the measurement apparatus, or both, are considered.
The apparent random outcome of a quantum measurement is conjectured to be fundamentally determined by the microscopic state of the macroscopic measurement apparatus. The apparatus state thus plays the role of a hidden variable which, in contrast with variables characterizing the measured microscopic system, is shown to lead to a violation of Bell’s inequalities and to agree with standard quantum mechanics. An explicit realization of this interpretation is explored (for details, see [1]) for a primitive model of cloud chamber inspired by Mott [2]. Being highly non local, this interpretation of quantum mechanics is argued to open the way to faster-than-light information transfer.
The de Broglie-Bohm pilot-wave theory asserts that a complete characterization of an NNN-particle system is given by its wave function together with the (at-all-times-defined) positions of the particles, with the wave function always satisfying the Schrödinger equation and the positions evolving according to the deterministic "guiding equation". A complete agreement with the predictive apparatus of standard quantum mechanics, including the uncertainty principle and the probabilistic Born rule, is then said to emerge from these equations, without having to confer any special status to measurements or observers. Two key elements behind the proof of this complete agreement are absolute uncertainty and the POVM theorem. The former involves an alleged "naturally emerging, irreducible limitation on the possibility of obtaining knowledge within pilot-wave theory" and the latter establishes that the outcome distributions of all measurements are described by POVMs. Here, we argue that the derivations of absolute uncertainty and the POVM theorem depend upon the questionable assumption that "information is always configurationally grounded". We explain in detail why the offered rationale behind such an assumption is deficient and explore the consequences of having to let go of it.
Abstract. The apparent random outcome of a quantum measurement is conjectured to be fundamentally determined by the microscopic state of the macroscopic measurement apparatus. The apparatus state thus plays the role of a hidden variable which, in contrast with variables characterizing the measured microscopic system, is shown to lead to a vi-olation of Bell’s inequalities and to agree with standard quantum mechanics. An explicit realization of this interpretation is explored (for details, see [1]) for a primitive model of cloud chamber inspired by Mott [2]. Being highly non local, this interpretation of quantum mechanics is argued to open the way to faster-than-light information transfer.
The proposed geometric model is not a return to 19th-century classical mechanics, but rather builds on the latest trends in Planck-scale deterministic cellular automata ('t Hooft, 2021), the theory of internal quantum clocks (Donadi, 2023), and the nonlinear quantum dynamics of asymmetric rotors (Micheli and Stone, 2022). The model directly resolves the topological crisis of describing light nuclei as saturated manifolds, documented in the current literature (Manton, 2022; Lau, 2020). We derive a direct, non-linear relation between the internal phase time per radian , the macroscopically observable coordinate time , and the relative energy fluctuation . Through rigorous differentiation and integration of these phase relations, we demonstrate that for topologically synchronized systems, the product of energy and observable time constitutes a strict dynamic process invariant: . Moving beyond phenomenological interpretations, we deduce the classical Heisenberg uncertainty relation without invoking independent quantum postulates, showing it to be a special boundary limit governing a single elementary phase cycle () under critical fluctuation. Furthermore, we prove that Louis de Broglie’s matter wave equation () is not an independent axiom but emerges naturally as the spatial displacement executed by a localized particle during a single complete internal chronal rotation. Finally, we bridge the gap between microscopic quantum reversibility and the macroscopic thermodynamic arrow of time by analyzing the dynamics of synchronization breakdown and phase slippage () using the latest advancements in deterministic quantum mechanics.