Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2404.02918 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Comment on “Towards exact solutions for the superconducting T c induced by electron-phonon interaction”

Grgur Palle

Published Jul 22, 2024• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In a series of recent papers starting with , Liu, Yang, Pan claim to have determined the exact dressed electron-boson vertex for a number of very general interacting many-body problems by inverting certain Ward-Takahashi identities. Here, we point out that their Ward-Takahashi identities are missing terms which make the inversion of the identities impossible. One therefore cannot formulate exact self-contained integral equations for the dressed electron propagator. In addition, the proposed vertex expressions do not reproduce well-established results for the leading perturbative corrections. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.110.026501

Related papers

Ward identity preserving approach for investigation of phonon spectrum with self-energy and vertex corrections

Sudhakar Pandey

We propose an approach for investigating the many-body effects on the phonon spectrum in an electron-phonon coupled system by taking into account the electron self-energy and vertex corrections which respect the Ward identity representing the conservation of electronic charge. Our approach provides a systematic diagrammatic expansion of the phonon self-energy ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Pi}}}_{\mathbf{q}}(\ensuremath{\omega})$ in powers of the electron-phonon scattering strength squared $({g}^{2})$. In this approach the many-body corrections to the phonon spectrum vanish identically for the $\mathbf{q}=0$ mode due to an exact cancellation between the contributions arising from electron self-energy and vertex corrections. This cancellation holds irrespective of the microscopic details of the system such as dimensionality, adiabaticity, strength of electron-phonon scattering, etc. Our results demonstrate that the contributions of electron self-energy and vertex corrections are not only comparable but they also tend to cancel each other so that the phonon spectrum remains nearly unaffected due to many-body effects in the regime of long-wavelength excitations ($\mathbf{q}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$). Our results provide another constraint for the applicability of the Migdal theorem.

arXiv:2308.14379•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Aug 23, 2024•3 citations

Renormalization of the electron-phonon interaction by strong electronic correlations in high- Tc superconductors

R. Zeyher, Miodrag L. Kulić

The renormalization of the electron-phonon interaction by strong electronic correlations is studied using a one-band Hubbard model with infinite repulsion and nearest (t model) and nearest and second-nearest (tt\ensuremath{'} model) neighbor hopping terms and an on-site electron-phonon coupling. Using Hubbard's X operators and an extension from 2 to N degrees of freedom for the electrons the leading contributions for the electron self-energy and the vertex function in 1/N and the electron-phonon coupling constant are given and numerically evaluated for a square lattice. We find that the momentum dependence of the vertex function depends strongly on doping: For large dopings it is rather weak, with decreasing doping it becomes more and more pronounced leading to a strong reduction of the vertex at larger momentum transfers until, for very small dopings, the vertex essentially consists of a forward scattering peak with a width proportional to the doping. This behavior occurs both in the t and the tt\ensuremath{'} models and also in one dimension where analytic expressions are derived. Correlation effects also change ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}^{2}$F in general: The full-symmetric component ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}^{2}$${\mathit{F}}_{1}$ is in the t model somewhat, in the tt\ensuremath{'} model rather strongly suppressed, especially near half-filling; the other symmetry components ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}^{2}$${\mathit{F}}_{\mathit{i}}$ with i=2,...,5 increase strongly with decreasing doping and are of similar magnitude as ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}^{2}$${\mathit{F}}_{1}$ near half-filling.Including also direct Coulomb repulsion nontrivial symmetries such as d wave become more stable than the s-wave order parameter below a critical value for the doping even for the considered phonon-mediated superconductivity. Most dramatic, however, is the quenching of the resistivity due to electron-phonon scattering both in the t and the tt\ensuremath{'} models at intermediate and small dopings. This result may explain the absence of phonon features in the experimental transport coefficients of high-${\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}$ compounds. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Feb 1, 1996•143 citations

Nonperturbative Dyson-Schwinger equation approach to strongly interacting Dirac fermion systems

Xiao‐Yin Pan, Zhao-Kun Yang, Xin Li +1 more

Studying the strong correlation effects in interacting Dirac fermion systems is one of the most challenging problems in modern condensed matter physics. The long-range Coulomb interaction and the fermion-phonon interaction can lead to a variety of intriguing properties. In the strong-coupling regime, weak-coupling perturbation theory breaks down. The validity of $1/N$ expansion with $N$ being the fermion flavor is also in doubt since $N$ equals to 2 or 4 in realistic systems. Here, we investigate the interaction between $(1+2)$- and $(1+3)$-dimensional massless Dirac fermions and a generic scalar boson, and develop an efficient nonperturbative approach to access the strong-coupling regime. We first derive a number of self-consistently coupled Ward-Takahashi identities based on a careful symmetry analysis and then use these identities to show that the full fermion-boson vertex function is solely determined by the full fermion propagator. Making use of this result, we rigorously prove that the full fermion propagator satisfies an exact and self-closed Dyson-Schwinger integral equation, which can be solved by employing numerical methods. A major advantage of our nonperturbative approach is that there is no need to employ any small expansion parameter. Our approach provides a unified theoretical framework for studying strong Coulomb and fermion-phonon interactions. It may also be used to approximately handle the Yukawa coupling between fermions and order-parameter fluctuations around continuous quantum critical points. Our approach is applied to treat the Coulomb interaction in undoped graphene. We find that the renormalized fermion velocity exhibits a logarithmic momentum dependence but is nearly energy independent, and that no excitonic gap is generated by the Coulomb interaction. These theoretical results are consistent with experiments in graphene.

arXiv:2003.10371•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Aug 23, 2021•13 citations

Comment on “Integrable Chain of Electrons Interacting With Phonons,” By M. E. Zhuravlev, V. A. Ivanov, and V. V. Achkasov, JETP Lett. 63, 94 (1996)

F. Marsiglio

We note that the exactly solvable electron-phonon Hamiltonian presented in that paper can be solved by a more direct route via the Lang-Firsov transformation.

Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics Letters•Dec 1, 1996•0 citations

Comment on “Electron Spectral Function and Algebraic Spin Liquid for the Normal State of Underdoped High Tc Superconductors”

Dmitri V. Khveshchenko

Comment on the Letter by W. Rantner and X-G. Wen, Phys. Rev. Lett. v.86, p.3871 (2001).

arXiv:cond-mat/0306079•Physical Review Letters•May 13, 2003•5 citations

Many-body theory beyond G W : Towards a complete description of two-body correlated propagation

B. Cunningham

Starting with Hedin's equations, simple expressions for the irreducible self-energy are derived. The derivation with vertex effects included in the self-energy results in a number of terms beyond G W such as second-order screened exchange (the term that also gives rise to vertex/excitonic effects in the polarization) and an infinite series describing correlations between the added-particle (removed-hole) and the excited electrons and holes: the screened T -matrix channels. Two-body correlated propagation is considered, with the third propagating freely, however, three-body correlations are discussed and these can be added hierarchically to the method. For electron-hole propagation, the reducible polarization is calculated, which results in an expression for the self-energy that can be solved analytically without the need for widely used expensive numerical methods for frequency integration or having to adopt the plasmon-pole approximation. The method requires diagonalization of the usual particle-hole matrix—derived from the Bethe-Salpter equation—and also a particle-particle + hole -hole matrix that has a similar structure; with the second-order exchange present in all channels. The method goes beyond current widely used methods that adopt the G W approximation, whilst being in nature and requiring relatively modest extensions to existing functionality, e.g., it could be implemented in the sophisticated quasiparticle self-consistent framework. It is anticipated the method will significantly improve on the accuracy of current state-of-the-art calculations, improving our understanding of processes in simple and strongly correlated systems, with the additional contributions demanding a similar cost to methods that include vertex effects in the polarization only. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2411.03958•Physical Review Research•Dec 16, 2024•5 citations
In a series of recent papers starting with , Liu, Yang, Pan claim to have determined the exact dressed electron-boson vertex for a number of very general interacting many-body problems by inverting certain Ward-Takahashi identities. Here, we point out that their Ward-Takahashi identities are missing terms which make the inversion of the identities impossible. One therefore cannot formulate exact self-contained integral equations for the dressed electron propagator. In addition, the proposed vertex expressions do not reproduce well-established results for the leading perturbative corrections. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
We propose an approach for investigating the many-body effects on the phonon spectrum in an electron-phonon coupled system by taking into account the electron self-energy and vertex corrections which respect the Ward identity representing the conservation of electronic charge. Our approach provides a systematic diagrammatic expansion of the phonon self-energy ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Pi}}}_{\mathbf{q}}(\ensuremath{\omega})$ in powers of the electron-phonon scattering strength squared (g2)({g}^{2})(g2). In this approach the many-body corrections to the phonon spectrum vanish identically for the q=0\mathbf{q}=0q=0 mode due to an exact cancellation between the contributions arising from electron self-energy and vertex corrections. This cancellation holds irrespective of the microscopic details of the system such as dimensionality, adiabaticity, strength of electron-phonon scattering, etc. Our results demonstrate that the contributions of electron self-energy and vertex corrections are not only comparable but they also tend to cancel each other so that the phonon spectrum remains nearly unaffected due to many-body effects in the regime of long-wavelength excitations ($\mathbf{q}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$). Our results provide another constraint for the applicability of the Migdal theorem.
The renormalization of the electron-phonon interaction by strong electronic correlations is studied using a one-band Hubbard model with infinite repulsion and nearest (t model) and nearest and second-nearest (tt\ensuremath{'} model) neighbor hopping terms and an on-site electron-phonon coupling. Using Hubbard's X operators and an extension from 2 to N degrees of freedom for the electrons the leading contributions for the electron self-energy and the vertex function in 1/N and the electron-phonon coupling constant are given and numerically evaluated for a square lattice. We find that the momentum dependence of the vertex function depends strongly on doping: For large dopings it is rather weak, with decreasing doping it becomes more and more pronounced leading to a strong reduction of the vertex at larger momentum transfers until, for very small dopings, the vertex essentially consists of a forward scattering peak with a width proportional to the doping. This behavior occurs both in the t and the tt\ensuremath{'} models and also in one dimension where analytic expressions are derived. Correlation effects also change ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}^{2}$F in general: The full-symmetric component ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}^{2}$F1{\mathit{F}}_{1}F1​ is in the t model somewhat, in the tt\ensuremath{'} model rather strongly suppressed, especially near half-filling; the other symmetry components ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}^{2}$Fi{\mathit{F}}_{\mathit{i}}Fi​ with i=2,...,5 increase strongly with decreasing doping and are of similar magnitude as ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}^{2}$F1{\mathit{F}}_{1}F1​ near half-filling.Including also direct Coulomb repulsion nontrivial symmetries such as d wave become more stable than the s-wave order parameter below a critical value for the doping even for the considered phonon-mediated superconductivity. Most dramatic, however, is the quenching of the resistivity due to electron-phonon scattering both in the t and the tt\ensuremath{'} models at intermediate and small dopings. This result may explain the absence of phonon features in the experimental transport coefficients of high-Tc{\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}Tc​ compounds. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.
Studying the strong correlation effects in interacting Dirac fermion systems is one of the most challenging problems in modern condensed matter physics. The long-range Coulomb interaction and the fermion-phonon interaction can lead to a variety of intriguing properties. In the strong-coupling regime, weak-coupling perturbation theory breaks down. The validity of 1/N1/N1/N expansion with NNN being the fermion flavor is also in doubt since NNN equals to 2 or 4 in realistic systems. Here, we investigate the interaction between (1+2)(1+2)(1+2)- and (1+3)(1+3)(1+3)-dimensional massless Dirac fermions and a generic scalar boson, and develop an efficient nonperturbative approach to access the strong-coupling regime. We first derive a number of self-consistently coupled Ward-Takahashi identities based on a careful symmetry analysis and then use these identities to show that the full fermion-boson vertex function is solely determined by the full fermion propagator. Making use of this result, we rigorously prove that the full fermion propagator satisfies an exact and self-closed Dyson-Schwinger integral equation, which can be solved by employing numerical methods. A major advantage of our nonperturbative approach is that there is no need to employ any small expansion parameter. Our approach provides a unified theoretical framework for studying strong Coulomb and fermion-phonon interactions. It may also be used to approximately handle the Yukawa coupling between fermions and order-parameter fluctuations around continuous quantum critical points. Our approach is applied to treat the Coulomb interaction in undoped graphene. We find that the renormalized fermion velocity exhibits a logarithmic momentum dependence but is nearly energy independent, and that no excitonic gap is generated by the Coulomb interaction. These theoretical results are consistent with experiments in graphene.
Starting with Hedin's equations, simple expressions for the irreducible self-energy are derived. The derivation with vertex effects included in the self-energy results in a number of terms beyond G W such as second-order screened exchange (the term that also gives rise to vertex/excitonic effects in the polarization) and an infinite series describing correlations between the added-particle (removed-hole) and the excited electrons and holes: the screened T -matrix channels. Two-body correlated propagation is considered, with the third propagating freely, however, three-body correlations are discussed and these can be added hierarchically to the method. For electron-hole propagation, the reducible polarization is calculated, which results in an expression for the self-energy that can be solved analytically without the need for widely used expensive numerical methods for frequency integration or having to adopt the plasmon-pole approximation. The method requires diagonalization of the usual particle-hole matrix—derived from the Bethe-Salpter equation—and also a particle-particle + hole -hole matrix that has a similar structure; with the second-order exchange present in all channels. The method goes beyond current widely used methods that adopt the G W approximation, whilst being in nature and requiring relatively modest extensions to existing functionality, e.g., it could be implemented in the sophisticated quasiparticle self-consistent framework. It is anticipated the method will significantly improve on the accuracy of current state-of-the-art calculations, improving our understanding of processes in simple and strongly correlated systems, with the additional contributions demanding a similar cost to methods that include vertex effects in the polarization only. Published by the American Physical Society 2024