Cyclic classical and quantum thermal machines show higher efficiency when the strokes are carried out quasi-statically. Recent theoretical and experimental work on figures of merit for thermal machines show that they have an advantage when operating in environments with negative temperatures. In an experimental proof of concept [Phys. Rev. Lett. 122, 240602 (2019)], it was shown that quantum Otto engines operating at negative temperatures can exhibit a behavior in which the faster the cycle is carried out, the higher the efficiency. In this work, we make use of the concept of entropy production and friction work to explain this counterintuitive behavior, and we show that it only occurs when reservoirs have negative temperatures.
Cyclic classical and quantum thermal machines show higher efficiency when the strokes are carried out quasi-statically. Recent theoretical and experimental work on figures of merit for thermal machines show that they have an advantage when operating in environments with negative temperatures. In an experimental proof of concept [Phys. Rev. Lett. 122, 240602 (2019)], it was shown that quantum Otto engines operating at negative temperatures can exhibit a behavior in which the faster the cycle is carried out, the higher the efficiency. In this work, we make use of the concept of entropy production and friction work to explain this counterintuitive behavior, and we show that it only occurs when reservoirs have negative temperatures.
Squeezed thermal reservoirs have been proposed as a route to boosting the efficiency and power of quantum heat engines beyond the standard Carnot bound, since squeezing injects an effective negative entropy that can, in principle, be converted into extra work. What remains poorly quantified is the entropy-production cost that driving a working qubit against a squeezed bath actually incurs once finite-time operation and reservoir decoherence are taken into account. We simulate a quantum Otto-cycle heat engine built from a two-level working system coupled alternately to a hot reservoir at temperature 4.2 K, squeezed with squeezing parameter r ranging from 0 to 1.2, and an unsqueezed cold reservoir at 0.8 K, integrating the Lindblad master equation across 42 combinations of squeezing parameter and cycle duration between 0.05 and 2.0 (in units of the inverse qubit gap). At r = 0, mean entropy production per cycle was 0.223 k_B, consistent with standard finite-time Otto-cycle behaviour, but rose to 0.361 k_B at r = 1.2, a 62% increase, even as extractable work per cycle increased by 41%, from 0.184 to 0.259 (in units of the qubit gap). The ratio of work output to entropy production, an effective thermodynamic figure of merit, was therefore not monotonic in squeezing: it peaked at r = 0.6, where work per unit entropy produced reached 0.98, 15% above the unsqueezed value of 0.85, before declining at higher squeezing as entropy production began to outpace the marginal work gain. Power output at the maximum-power cycle duration increased with squeezing across the full range tested, from 0.31 (gap units) at r = 0 to 0.52 at r = 1.2, a 68% gain, but efficiency at maximum power fell from 0.41 to 0.33 over the same range, a trade-off traced out in detail in Table 1. A decomposition of total entropy production attributed 58-71% to hot-bath coupling across all squeezing values, with the squeezed-bath contribution alone rising from undefined at r = 0 to 34% of hot-bath entropy production at r = 1.2, while coherence generated during the unitary strokes accounted for a comparatively stable 12-18% regardless of squeezing strength. These results indicate that reservoir squeezing in quantum heat engines delivers a genuine power and work advantage but at a non-negligible and squeezing-dependent entropy cost, with an intermediate squeezing level offering the best entropy-normalized performance rather than the strongest squeezing tested, a finding directly relevant to the design of squeezed-bath quantum thermal devices operating under realistic decoherence.
Conventional quantum Otto engines based on effective-negative-temperature reservoirs rely on an assumption of perfect thermalization. In this study, the authors investigate the impact of non-Markovianity in these engines by terminating strokes before reaching thermal equilibrium, revealing that higher non-Markovianity enhances maximum efficiency but reduces overall performance over an extended period of functioning time. The authors also identify a class of effective-negative-temperature-based necessarily transient quantum Otto engines.
Classical thermodynamics, which focuses on macroscopic systems in equilibrium, has given rise to various theories to address systems out of equilibrium over time. Recently, quantum thermodynamics has emerged as a theory dedicated to describe microscopic quantum systems. A notable application of this theory is found in the development of thermal engines, where the working substance is a microscopic quantum system. In this work, we present the essential theoretical formulation to understand entropy production in quantum systems and its impact on thermal machines. The approach involves exploring quantum friction and conducting a deeper analysis of the laws of thermodynamics on a fundamental scale. Examining the effects of these phenomena in a Quantum Otto Heat Engine, we highlight the implications of quantum friction on engine performance. Particularly noteworthy is the observation that operating the cycle with a reservoir with effective negative temperature enhances the engine efficiency significantly. This improvement is attributed to strategic choices in the populations of excited states in the reservoirs, revealing an innovative approach to optimizing performance in quantum systems. Additionally, we extend the Nernst heat theorem for a single qubit. This result not only presents intriguing theoretical implications but is also supported by numerical simulations and experiments using Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR). These pieces of evidence uphold the remarkable convergence of Helmholtz free energy and internal energy as the temperature approaches zero Kelvin, underscoring the practical applicability of these theorems in quantum systems.
We perform an experiment in which a quantum heat engine works under two reservoirs, one at a positive spin temperature and the other at an effective negative spin temperature, i.e., when the spin system presents population inversion. We show that the efficiency of this engine can be greater than that when both reservoirs are at positive temperatures. We also demonstrate the counterintuitive result that the Otto efficiency can be beaten only when the quantum engine is operating in the finite-time mode.
Abstract Recent theoretical and experimental studies in quantum heat engines show that, in the quasi-static regime, it is possible to have higher efficiency than the limit imposed by Carnot, provided that engineered reservoirs are used. The quasi-static regime, however, is a strong limitation to the operation of heat engines, since an infinitely long time is required to complete a cycle. In this paper we propose a two-level model as the working substance to perform a quantum Otto heat engine surrounded by a cold thermal reservoir and a squeezed hot thermal reservoir. Taking advantage of this model we show a striking achievement, that is to attain unity efficiency even at non-null power.
Abstract We study the performance of a quantum Otto cycle using a harmonic work medium and undergoing collisional dynamics with finite-size reservoirs. We span the dynamical regimes of the work strokes from strongly non-adiabatic to quasi-static conditions, and address the effects that non-Markovianity of the open-system dynamics of the work medium can have on the efficiency of the thermal machine. While such efficiency never surpasses the classical upper bound valid for finite-time stochastic engines, the behaviour of the engine shows clear-cut effects induced by both the finiteness of the evolution time, and the memory-bearing character of the system-environment evolution.