Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2403.19258 · Nature Communications

Finite-time scaling beyond the Kibble-Zurek prerequisite in Dirac systems

Zhi Zeng, Yin-Kai Yu, Zhixuan Li, Zi-Xiang Li, Shuai Yin

Published Jul 4, 2025• 14 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The conventional Kibble-Zurek mechanism and the finite-time scaling provide universal descriptions of the driven critical dynamics from gapped initial states based on the adiabatic-impulse scenario. Here we investigate the driven critical dynamics in two-dimensional Dirac systems, which harbor semimetal and Mott insulator phases separated by the quantum critical point triggered by the interplay between fluctuations of gapless Dirac fermions and order parameter bosons. We find that despite the existence of the gapless initial phase, the driven dynamics can still be captured by the finite-time scaling form. This leads us to propose a criterion for the validity of Kibble-Zurek mechanism with a gapless initial state. Accordingly, our results generalize the Kibble-Zurek theory to incorporate composite fluctuations and relax its requirement for a gapped initial state to systems accommodating gapless Dirac fermionic excitations. Our work not only brings fundamental perspective into the nonequilibrium critical dynamics, but also provides an approach to fathom quantum critical properties in fermionic systems. The Kibble-Zurek mechanism and finite-time scaling provide descriptions of the driven critical dynamics from gapped initial states. Here, the authors generalize these theories to Dirac systems accommodating gapless initial states.

DOI
10.1038/s41467-025-61611-6

Related papers

Universal Driven Critical Dynamics of Entanglement Entropy

Chang-Yu Shen, Shuai Yin, Zi-Xiang Li

The Kibble-Zurek mechanism (KZM) and finite-time scaling (FTS) provide a foundational framework for driven critical dynamics, yet their predictive power has been largely confined to local observables. Here, we establish a universal finite-time scaling theory for the nonequilibrium dynamics of quantum entanglement. Using unbiased quantum Monte Carlo simulations, we investigate the corner entanglement entropy of (2+1)-dimensional interacting Dirac fermions driven from ordered phases toward a quantum critical point. We find that the corner entanglement accurately obeys a universal driven scaling governed by the driving rate and system size, persisting whether the initial ordered state is fully gapped or hosts gapless Goldstone modes. Crucially, this dynamical entanglement exhibits a logarithmic dependence on the driving rate, from which the universal corner coefficient of the underlying conformal field theory can be robustly extracted far from equilibrium. These results generalize the KZM from local observables to the intrinsic nonlocal quantum information measures, offering a practical blueprint for characterizing quantum criticality and entanglement on programmable quantum simulators.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2609.03854•Sep 4, 2026•0 citations

Kibble-Zurek mechanism beyond adiabaticity: Finite-time scaling with critical initial slip

Yingyi Huang, Shuai Yin, Qijun Hu +1 more

The Kibble-Zurek mechanism demands an initial adiabatic stage before an impulse stage to have a frozen correlation length that generates topological defects in a cooling phase transition. Here we study such a driven critical dynamics but with an initial condition that is near the critical point and that is far away from equilibrium. In this case, there is no initial adiabatic stage at all and thus adiabaticity is broken. However, we show that there again exists a finite length scale arising from the driving that divides the evolution into three stages. A relaxation--finite-time-scaling--adiabatic scenario is then proposed in place of the adiabatic-impulse-adiabatic scenario of the original Kibble-Zurek mechanism. A unified scaling theory, which combines finite-time scaling with critical initial slip, is developed to describe the universal behavior and is confirmed with numerical simulations of a two-dimensional classical Ising model.

arXiv:1503.02762•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jan 8, 2016•20 citations

Scaling in driven dynamics starting in the vicinity of a quantum critical point

Shuai Yin, Chung-Yu Lo, Pochung Chen

Driven dynamics across a quantum critical point is usually described by the Kibble-Zurek scaling. Although the original Kibble-Zurek scaling requires an adiabatic initial state, it has been shown that scaling behaviors exist even when the driven dynamics is triggered from a thermal equilibrium state exactly at the critical point, in spite of the breakdown of the initial adiabaticity. In this paper, we show that the existence of the scaling behavior can be generalized to the case of the initial state being a thermal equilibrium state near the critical point. We propose a scaling theory in which the initial parameters are included as additional scaling variables due to the breakdown of the initial adiabaticity. In particular, we demonstrate that for the driven critical dynamics in a closed system, the nontrivial thermal effects are closely related to the initial distance to the critical point. We numerically confirm the scaling theory by simulating the real-time dynamics of the one-dimensional quantum Ising model at both zero and finite temperatures.

arXiv:1607.01840•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Aug 25, 2016•11 citations

Nonequilibrium critical dynamics with emergent supersymmetry

Zhi Zeng, Yin-Kai Yu, Zixiang Li +1 more

Proposed as an elegant symmetry relating bosons and fermions, spacetime supersymmetry (SUSY) has been actively pursued in both particle physics and emergent phenomena in quantum critical points (QCP) of topological quantum materials. However, how SUSY casts the light on nonequilibrium dynamics remains open. In this letter, we investigate the Kibble-Zurek dynamics across a QCP with emergent $\mathcal{N}=2$ spacetime SUSY between the Dirac semimetal and a superconductor through large-scale quantum Monte Carlo simulation. The scaling behaviors in the whole driven process are uncovered to satisfy the full finite-time scaling (FTS) forms. More crucially, we demonstrate that the emergent SUSY manifests in the intimate relation between the FTS behaviors of fermionic and bosonic observables, namely the fermions and bosons acquire the identical anomalous dimensions. Our work not only brings a fundamental new ingredient into the critical theory with SUSY, but also provide the theoretical guidance to experimental detect of QCP with emergent SUSY from the perspectives of Kibble-Zurek mechanism and FTS.

arXiv:2408.06138•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jul 23, 2025•10 citations

Non-commutative Dynamic Approaches to the Kibble-Zurek Scaling Limit with an Initial Gapless Order

Zhe Wang, Chengxiang Ding, Dongxu Liu +3 more

Nonequilibrium many-body physics is one of the core problems in modern physics, while the dynamical scaling from a gapless phase to the critical point is a most important challenge with very few knowledge so far. In the driven dynamics with a tuning rate $R$ across the quantum critical point (QCP) of a system with size $L$, the finite-time scaling shows that the square of the order parameter $m^2$ obeys a simple scaling relation $m^2\propto R^{2β/νr}$ in the Kibble-Zurek (KZ) scaling limit with $RL^r\gg1$. Here, by studying the driven critical dynamics from a gapless ordered phase in the bilayer Heisenberg model, we unveil that the approaches to the scaling region dominated by the KZ scaling limit with $RL^r\gg1$ are {\it non-commutative}: this scaling region is inaccessible for large $R$ and finite medium $L$, while merely accessible for large $L$ and moderately finite $R$. We attribute this to the memory effect induced by the finite-size correction in the gapless ordered phase. This non-commutative property makes $m^2$ still strongly depends on the system size and deviates from $m^2\propto R^{2β/νr}$ even for large $R$. We further show that a similar correction applies to the imaginary-time relaxation dynamics. Our results establish an essential extension of nonequilibrium scaling theory with a gapless ordered initial state.

arXiv:2602.14599•Feb 16, 2026•1 citation

Driven dynamics of localization phase transition in the Aubry-André model with initial gapless extended states

Xinyu Wang, Wenjing Yu, Yue-Mei Sun +1 more

Recently, the driven dynamics of localization phase transition have garnered growing interest. However, studies so far have mainly considered initial localized states, whose driven dynamics follow the Kibble-Zurek mechanism (KZM). In this study, we investigate the driven dynamics of the localization phase transition in the Aubry-André model starting from a gapless extended state, which violates the adiabatic-impulse scenario of KZM. By linearly driving the quasiperiodic potential strength across the critical point, we numerically simulate the driven dynamics and analyze the scaling behavior of both the inverse participation ratio ( I ) and the dynamic deviation from the instantaneous ground-state energy ( D ) . We demonstrate that the driven dynamics starting from initially extended states satisfies the criterion for the applicability of KZM and its extension, finite-time scaling (FTS). The scaling functions governing the driven dynamics of both I and D have been derived based on FTS and numerically validated. We found that the scaling functions exhibit significant differences at large R and small R , and also differ considerably from the scaling functions when the initial state is localized, highlighting the crucial role of initial-state behavior. The established scaling laws remain robust across a wide range of system sizes and driving rates, providing testable predictions for experimental realizations.

arXiv:2509.06358•Physical Review Research•Jan 7, 2026•4 citations
The conventional Kibble-Zurek mechanism and the finite-time scaling provide universal descriptions of the driven critical dynamics from gapped initial states based on the adiabatic-impulse scenario. Here we investigate the driven critical dynamics in two-dimensional Dirac systems, which harbor semimetal and Mott insulator phases separated by the quantum critical point triggered by the interplay between fluctuations of gapless Dirac fermions and order parameter bosons. We find that despite the existence of the gapless initial phase, the driven dynamics can still be captured by the finite-time scaling form. This leads us to propose a criterion for the validity of Kibble-Zurek mechanism with a gapless initial state. Accordingly, our results generalize the Kibble-Zurek theory to incorporate composite fluctuations and relax its requirement for a gapped initial state to systems accommodating gapless Dirac fermionic excitations. Our work not only brings fundamental perspective into the nonequilibrium critical dynamics, but also provides an approach to fathom quantum critical properties in fermionic systems. The Kibble-Zurek mechanism and finite-time scaling provide descriptions of the driven critical dynamics from gapped initial states. Here, the authors generalize these theories to Dirac systems accommodating gapless initial states.
The Kibble-Zurek mechanism (KZM) and finite-time scaling (FTS) provide a foundational framework for driven critical dynamics, yet their predictive power has been largely confined to local observables. Here, we establish a universal finite-time scaling theory for the nonequilibrium dynamics of quantum entanglement. Using unbiased quantum Monte Carlo simulations, we investigate the corner entanglement entropy of (2+1)-dimensional interacting Dirac fermions driven from ordered phases toward a quantum critical point. We find that the corner entanglement accurately obeys a universal driven scaling governed by the driving rate and system size, persisting whether the initial ordered state is fully gapped or hosts gapless Goldstone modes. Crucially, this dynamical entanglement exhibits a logarithmic dependence on the driving rate, from which the universal corner coefficient of the underlying conformal field theory can be robustly extracted far from equilibrium. These results generalize the KZM from local observables to the intrinsic nonlocal quantum information measures, offering a practical blueprint for characterizing quantum criticality and entanglement on programmable quantum simulators.
The Kibble-Zurek mechanism demands an initial adiabatic stage before an impulse stage to have a frozen correlation length that generates topological defects in a cooling phase transition. Here we study such a driven critical dynamics but with an initial condition that is near the critical point and that is far away from equilibrium. In this case, there is no initial adiabatic stage at all and thus adiabaticity is broken. However, we show that there again exists a finite length scale arising from the driving that divides the evolution into three stages. A relaxation--finite-time-scaling--adiabatic scenario is then proposed in place of the adiabatic-impulse-adiabatic scenario of the original Kibble-Zurek mechanism. A unified scaling theory, which combines finite-time scaling with critical initial slip, is developed to describe the universal behavior and is confirmed with numerical simulations of a two-dimensional classical Ising model.
Driven dynamics across a quantum critical point is usually described by the Kibble-Zurek scaling. Although the original Kibble-Zurek scaling requires an adiabatic initial state, it has been shown that scaling behaviors exist even when the driven dynamics is triggered from a thermal equilibrium state exactly at the critical point, in spite of the breakdown of the initial adiabaticity. In this paper, we show that the existence of the scaling behavior can be generalized to the case of the initial state being a thermal equilibrium state near the critical point. We propose a scaling theory in which the initial parameters are included as additional scaling variables due to the breakdown of the initial adiabaticity. In particular, we demonstrate that for the driven critical dynamics in a closed system, the nontrivial thermal effects are closely related to the initial distance to the critical point. We numerically confirm the scaling theory by simulating the real-time dynamics of the one-dimensional quantum Ising model at both zero and finite temperatures.
Proposed as an elegant symmetry relating bosons and fermions, spacetime supersymmetry (SUSY) has been actively pursued in both particle physics and emergent phenomena in quantum critical points (QCP) of topological quantum materials. However, how SUSY casts the light on nonequilibrium dynamics remains open. In this letter, we investigate the Kibble-Zurek dynamics across a QCP with emergent N=2\mathcal{N}=2N=2 spacetime SUSY between the Dirac semimetal and a superconductor through large-scale quantum Monte Carlo simulation. The scaling behaviors in the whole driven process are uncovered to satisfy the full finite-time scaling (FTS) forms. More crucially, we demonstrate that the emergent SUSY manifests in the intimate relation between the FTS behaviors of fermionic and bosonic observables, namely the fermions and bosons acquire the identical anomalous dimensions. Our work not only brings a fundamental new ingredient into the critical theory with SUSY, but also provide the theoretical guidance to experimental detect of QCP with emergent SUSY from the perspectives of Kibble-Zurek mechanism and FTS.
Nonequilibrium many-body physics is one of the core problems in modern physics, while the dynamical scaling from a gapless phase to the critical point is a most important challenge with very few knowledge so far. In the driven dynamics with a tuning rate RRR across the quantum critical point (QCP) of a system with size LLL, the finite-time scaling shows that the square of the order parameter m2m^2m2 obeys a simple scaling relation m2∝R2β/νrm^2\propto R^{2β/νr}m2∝R2β/νr in the Kibble-Zurek (KZ) scaling limit with RLr≫1RL^r\gg1RLr≫1. Here, by studying the driven critical dynamics from a gapless ordered phase in the bilayer Heisenberg model, we unveil that the approaches to the scaling region dominated by the KZ scaling limit with RLr≫1RL^r\gg1RLr≫1 are {\it non-commutative}: this scaling region is inaccessible for large RRR and finite medium LLL, while merely accessible for large LLL and moderately finite RRR. We attribute this to the memory effect induced by the finite-size correction in the gapless ordered phase. This non-commutative property makes m2m^2m2 still strongly depends on the system size and deviates from m2∝R2β/νrm^2\propto R^{2β/νr}m2∝R2β/νr even for large RRR. We further show that a similar correction applies to the imaginary-time relaxation dynamics. Our results establish an essential extension of nonequilibrium scaling theory with a gapless ordered initial state.
Recently, the driven dynamics of localization phase transition have garnered growing interest. However, studies so far have mainly considered initial localized states, whose driven dynamics follow the Kibble-Zurek mechanism (KZM). In this study, we investigate the driven dynamics of the localization phase transition in the Aubry-André model starting from a gapless extended state, which violates the adiabatic-impulse scenario of KZM. By linearly driving the quasiperiodic potential strength across the critical point, we numerically simulate the driven dynamics and analyze the scaling behavior of both the inverse participation ratio ( I ) and the dynamic deviation from the instantaneous ground-state energy ( D ) . We demonstrate that the driven dynamics starting from initially extended states satisfies the criterion for the applicability of KZM and its extension, finite-time scaling (FTS). The scaling functions governing the driven dynamics of both I and D have been derived based on FTS and numerically validated. We found that the scaling functions exhibit significant differences at large R and small R , and also differ considerably from the scaling functions when the initial state is localized, highlighting the crucial role of initial-state behavior. The established scaling laws remain robust across a wide range of system sizes and driving rates, providing testable predictions for experimental realizations.