Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2403.14752 · Physical Review Research

From equivalent Lagrangians to inequivalent open quantum system dynamics

Anirudh Gundhi, Oliviero Angeli, Angelo Bassi

Published Dec 28, 2025• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Lagrangians can differ by a total derivative without altering the equations of motion, thus encoding the same physics. This is true both classically and quantum mechanically. We show, however, that in the context of open quantum systems, two Lagrangians that differ by a total derivative can lead to inequivalent reduced dynamics. While these Lagrangians are connected via unitary transformations at the level of the global system-plus-environment description, the equivalence breaks down after tracing out the environment. We argue that only those Lagrangians for which the canonical and mechanical momenta of the system coincide lead to operationally meaningful dynamics. Applying this insight to quantum electrodynamics (QED), we derive the master equation for bremsstrahlung due to an accelerated nonrelativistic electron upto second order in the interaction. The resulting reduced dynamics predicts decoherence in the position basis and closely matches the Caldeira-Leggett form, thus resolving previous discrepancies in the literature. Our findings have implications for both QED and gravitational decoherence, where similar ambiguities arise.

DOI
10.1103/4rpx-zj2x

Related papers

Ambiguities in Quantizing a Classical System

Ian H. Redmount, Wai-Mo Suen, K. Young

One classical theory, as determined by an equation of motion or set of classical trajectories, can correspond to many unitarily {\em in}equivalent quantum theories upon canonical quantization. This arises from a remarkable ambiguity, not previously investigated, in the construction of the classical (and hence the quantized) Hamiltonian or Lagrangian. This ambiguity is illustrated for systems with one degree of freedom: An arbitrary function of the constants of motion can be introduced into this construction. For example, the nonrelativistic and relativistic free particles follow identical classical trajectories, but the Hamiltonians or Lagrangians, and the canonically quantized versions of these descriptions, are inequivalent. Inequivalent descriptions of other systems, such as the harmonic oscillator, are also readily obtained.

arXiv:gr-qc/9904042•Apr 19, 1999•1 citation

Master equation for systems interacting with linearized gravity

Oliviero Angeli, Anirudh Gundhi, Angelo Bassi

We investigate the open quantum dynamics of a system of two masses interacting with an environment of linearized gravitational waves. We formulate the analysis in terms of the observable proper distance between the two masses, and show that the canonical variables obtained from the standard Lagrangian, expressed in terms of the Fermi normal coordinates, are not suitable for an effective description of the system. We resolve this issue through a unitary transformation that provides a physically meaningful system--environment decomposition and derive the master equation to leading order in $G$. Its dissipative sector reproduces the classical energy loss due to gravitational-wave emission, while the noisy contributions suppress coherences between states with different mass quadrupole, or effectively, different proper separations. In the regime where the proper distance can be described by considering small quantum fluctuations around an average distance $l_0$, the dynamics reduces to a Caldeira--Leggett-type equation, with a decoherence rate dependent on the baseline length $l_0$.

quant-pharXiv:2608.06121•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Aug 7, 2026•0 citations

Gravitational waves and quantum systems: dynamics, decoherence, and the limits of electrodynamical analogy

Linda M. van Manen

This thesis investigates the role of gravitational waves in quantum systems, motivated by advances in our understanding of the quantum–gravity interface and efforts to identify experimental signatures of quantum gravity. It focuses on gravitational decoherence and the interplay between internal energy and centre-of-mass dynamics in composite quantum systems, complemented by a study of internal-energy effects in gravitationally mediated entanglement. First, we develop relativistic Hamiltonian formulations showing that changes in a composite system’s internal energy increase its gravitational mass rather than alter its momentum. This removes earlier ad hoc arguments for eliminating “anomalous friction forces”. We show that gravitational waves act as a dynamical background, inducing curvature-dependent forces that modify total momentum. Second, we revisit a thought experiment in which tensions between causality and complementarity arise. We identify a scenario in which these tensions follow from energy–mass equivalence, making the effect specific to gravitational interactions. In a gravitationally mediated entanglement experiment using Newtonian gravity as mediator, we investigate whether decohering gravitational radiation can resolve the apparent conflict. Finally, we build upon a model of gravitational decoherence consistent with general relativity. This requires deriving a higher-derivative quantum Langevin equation and master equation. The resulting dynamics show that gravitational interactions induce decoherence in the canonical momentum basis of the quadrupole and generate acceleration- and jerk-dependent corrections absent in electrodynamics. Together, these results show that weak-field gravitational interactions leave distinct relativistic imprints on quantum systems, including effects unique to gravitational waves, providing potential signatures that distinguish gravity from other interactions.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Gravitational decoherence: A general nonrelativistic model

L. Asprea, Giulio Gasbarri, Angelo Bassi

We derive a general quantum master equation for the dynamics of a scalar bosonic particle interacting with a weak, stochastic and classical external gravitational field. The dynamics predicts decoherence in position, momentum and energy. We show how our master equation reproduces the results present in the literature by taking appropriate limits, thus explaining the apparent contradiction in their dynamical description. Our result is relevant in light of the increasing interest in the low energy quantum-gravity regime.

arXiv:1905.01121•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•May 19, 2021•27 citations

Environmental gravitational decoherence with a higher derivative theory

Linda M. van Manen

We discuss the decoherence in a quantum system induced by interaction with gravitational degrees of freedom that are part of a higher derivative theory. The deformation of a mass distribution due to gravitational waves acquires naturally a mass quadrupole moment. This adds higher derivative dynamics of the quadrupole moment to the unitary evolution of the system, where the quadrupole moment oscillates with the gravitational frequencies following a higher derivative theory. The consequence of higher derivatives in the dynamics is that four canonical variables describe the system. This departure from the usual particle position and momentum operators gives an entirely different interpretation of the decoherence basis. This model focuses on the open dynamics of the quadrupole moment, rather than on individual particles. As such, a short example is given to utilize quadrupole measurements to probe gravitational decoherence and noise. We first derive a Langevin equation for a lower derivative model and show how higher derivatives naturally emerge on the boundary. A quantum master equation is derived for the emerging quadrupole moment, considering that the environment is a higher derivative theory of gravity.

arXiv:2412.20929•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Mar 10, 2025•1 citation

THE LAGRANGIAN IN QUANTUM MECHANICS

P. A. M. Dirac

Quantum mechanics was built up on a foundation of analogy with the Hamiltonian theory of classical mechanics. This is because the classical notion of canonical coordinates and momenta was found to be one with a very simple quantum analogue, as a result of which the whole of the classical Hamiltonian theory, which is just a structure built up on this notion, could be taken over in all its details into quantum mechanics. Now there is an alternative formulation for classical dynamics, provided by the Lagrangian. This requires one to work in terms of coordinates and velocities instead of coordinates and momenta. The two formulations are, of course, closely related, but there are reasons for believing that the Lagrangian one is the more fundamental. In the first place the Lagrangian method allows one to collect together all the equations of motion and express them as the stationary property of a certain action function. (This action function is just the time-integral of the Lagrangian.) There is no corresponding action principle in terms of the coordinates and momenta of the Hamiltonian theory. Secondly the Lagrangian method can easily be expressed relativistically, on account of the action function being a relativistic invariant; while the Hamiltonian method is essentially non-relativistic in form, since it marks out a particular time variable as the canonical conjugate of the Hamiltonian function. For these reasons it would seem desirable to take up the question of what corresponds in the quantum theory to the Lagrangian method of the classical theory. A little consideration shows, however, that one cannot expect to be able to take over the classical Lagrangian equations in any very direct way. These equations involve partial derivatives of the Lagrangian with respect to the coordinates and velocities and no meaning can be given to such derivatives in quantum mechanics. The only differentiation process that can be carried out with respect to the dynamical variables of quantum mechanics is that of forming Poisson brackets and this process leads to the Hamiltonian theory. 1 We must therefore seek our quantum Lagrangian theory in an indirect way. We must try to take over the ideas of the classical Lagrangian theory, not the equations of the classical Lagrangian theory.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Aug 1, 2005•288 citations
Lagrangians can differ by a total derivative without altering the equations of motion, thus encoding the same physics. This is true both classically and quantum mechanically. We show, however, that in the context of open quantum systems, two Lagrangians that differ by a total derivative can lead to inequivalent reduced dynamics. While these Lagrangians are connected via unitary transformations at the level of the global system-plus-environment description, the equivalence breaks down after tracing out the environment. We argue that only those Lagrangians for which the canonical and mechanical momenta of the system coincide lead to operationally meaningful dynamics. Applying this insight to quantum electrodynamics (QED), we derive the master equation for bremsstrahlung due to an accelerated nonrelativistic electron upto second order in the interaction. The resulting reduced dynamics predicts decoherence in the position basis and closely matches the Caldeira-Leggett form, thus resolving previous discrepancies in the literature. Our findings have implications for both QED and gravitational decoherence, where similar ambiguities arise.
One classical theory, as determined by an equation of motion or set of classical trajectories, can correspond to many unitarily {\em in}equivalent quantum theories upon canonical quantization. This arises from a remarkable ambiguity, not previously investigated, in the construction of the classical (and hence the quantized) Hamiltonian or Lagrangian. This ambiguity is illustrated for systems with one degree of freedom: An arbitrary function of the constants of motion can be introduced into this construction. For example, the nonrelativistic and relativistic free particles follow identical classical trajectories, but the Hamiltonians or Lagrangians, and the canonically quantized versions of these descriptions, are inequivalent. Inequivalent descriptions of other systems, such as the harmonic oscillator, are also readily obtained.
We investigate the open quantum dynamics of a system of two masses interacting with an environment of linearized gravitational waves. We formulate the analysis in terms of the observable proper distance between the two masses, and show that the canonical variables obtained from the standard Lagrangian, expressed in terms of the Fermi normal coordinates, are not suitable for an effective description of the system. We resolve this issue through a unitary transformation that provides a physically meaningful system--environment decomposition and derive the master equation to leading order in GGG. Its dissipative sector reproduces the classical energy loss due to gravitational-wave emission, while the noisy contributions suppress coherences between states with different mass quadrupole, or effectively, different proper separations. In the regime where the proper distance can be described by considering small quantum fluctuations around an average distance l0l_0l0​, the dynamics reduces to a Caldeira--Leggett-type equation, with a decoherence rate dependent on the baseline length l0l_0l0​.
This thesis investigates the role of gravitational waves in quantum systems, motivated by advances in our understanding of the quantum–gravity interface and efforts to identify experimental signatures of quantum gravity. It focuses on gravitational decoherence and the interplay between internal energy and centre-of-mass dynamics in composite quantum systems, complemented by a study of internal-energy effects in gravitationally mediated entanglement. First, we develop relativistic Hamiltonian formulations showing that changes in a composite system’s internal energy increase its gravitational mass rather than alter its momentum. This removes earlier ad hoc arguments for eliminating “anomalous friction forces”. We show that gravitational waves act as a dynamical background, inducing curvature-dependent forces that modify total momentum. Second, we revisit a thought experiment in which tensions between causality and complementarity arise. We identify a scenario in which these tensions follow from energy–mass equivalence, making the effect specific to gravitational interactions. In a gravitationally mediated entanglement experiment using Newtonian gravity as mediator, we investigate whether decohering gravitational radiation can resolve the apparent conflict. Finally, we build upon a model of gravitational decoherence consistent with general relativity. This requires deriving a higher-derivative quantum Langevin equation and master equation. The resulting dynamics show that gravitational interactions induce decoherence in the canonical momentum basis of the quadrupole and generate acceleration- and jerk-dependent corrections absent in electrodynamics. Together, these results show that weak-field gravitational interactions leave distinct relativistic imprints on quantum systems, including effects unique to gravitational waves, providing potential signatures that distinguish gravity from other interactions.
We derive a general quantum master equation for the dynamics of a scalar bosonic particle interacting with a weak, stochastic and classical external gravitational field. The dynamics predicts decoherence in position, momentum and energy. We show how our master equation reproduces the results present in the literature by taking appropriate limits, thus explaining the apparent contradiction in their dynamical description. Our result is relevant in light of the increasing interest in the low energy quantum-gravity regime.
We discuss the decoherence in a quantum system induced by interaction with gravitational degrees of freedom that are part of a higher derivative theory. The deformation of a mass distribution due to gravitational waves acquires naturally a mass quadrupole moment. This adds higher derivative dynamics of the quadrupole moment to the unitary evolution of the system, where the quadrupole moment oscillates with the gravitational frequencies following a higher derivative theory. The consequence of higher derivatives in the dynamics is that four canonical variables describe the system. This departure from the usual particle position and momentum operators gives an entirely different interpretation of the decoherence basis. This model focuses on the open dynamics of the quadrupole moment, rather than on individual particles. As such, a short example is given to utilize quadrupole measurements to probe gravitational decoherence and noise. We first derive a Langevin equation for a lower derivative model and show how higher derivatives naturally emerge on the boundary. A quantum master equation is derived for the emerging quadrupole moment, considering that the environment is a higher derivative theory of gravity.
Quantum mechanics was built up on a foundation of analogy with the Hamiltonian theory of classical mechanics. This is because the classical notion of canonical coordinates and momenta was found to be one with a very simple quantum analogue, as a result of which the whole of the classical Hamiltonian theory, which is just a structure built up on this notion, could be taken over in all its details into quantum mechanics. Now there is an alternative formulation for classical dynamics, provided by the Lagrangian. This requires one to work in terms of coordinates and velocities instead of coordinates and momenta. The two formulations are, of course, closely related, but there are reasons for believing that the Lagrangian one is the more fundamental. In the first place the Lagrangian method allows one to collect together all the equations of motion and express them as the stationary property of a certain action function. (This action function is just the time-integral of the Lagrangian.) There is no corresponding action principle in terms of the coordinates and momenta of the Hamiltonian theory. Secondly the Lagrangian method can easily be expressed relativistically, on account of the action function being a relativistic invariant; while the Hamiltonian method is essentially non-relativistic in form, since it marks out a particular time variable as the canonical conjugate of the Hamiltonian function. For these reasons it would seem desirable to take up the question of what corresponds in the quantum theory to the Lagrangian method of the classical theory. A little consideration shows, however, that one cannot expect to be able to take over the classical Lagrangian equations in any very direct way. These equations involve partial derivatives of the Lagrangian with respect to the coordinates and velocities and no meaning can be given to such derivatives in quantum mechanics. The only differentiation process that can be carried out with respect to the dynamical variables of quantum mechanics is that of forming Poisson brackets and this process leads to the Hamiltonian theory. 1 We must therefore seek our quantum Lagrangian theory in an indirect way. We must try to take over the ideas of the classical Lagrangian theory, not the equations of the classical Lagrangian theory.