Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2403.09368 · The Journal of Chemical Physics

Unveiling the dynamical genesis of quantum entanglement in linear systems: Internal causality breaking in the reduced subsystem evolution

Shuang-Kai Yang, Wei-Min Zhang

Published Dec 15, 2025• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Utilizing the general theory of open quantum systems to investigate the exact dynamical evolution of simple bilinear systems, we discover a mechanism of the dynamical genesis of quantum entanglement. We focus in detail on the exact quantum evolution dynamics of two photonic modes (or any two bosonic modes) coupled to each other through a linear interaction, as the simplest system of open quantum systems that we have investigated in the past two decades. Such a linear coupling alone fails to produce two-mode entanglement. We also start with an initially separable pure state of the two modes. By solving exactly the quantum equation of motion without relying on the probabilistic interpretation, we find that when the initial state of one mode is different from a coherent state (a minimum uncertainty wave packet with equal variance in the conjugate quadratures that corresponds to a well-defined classically "particle"), the causality in the time-evolution of each mode is internally violated. It also leads to the emergence of quantum entanglement between the two modes. The lack of causality is the nature of statistics. We discover that it is the internal violation of causality in the reduced (subsystem) dynamical evolution that results in the emergence of entanglement and statistic probability in quantum mechanics, even though the dynamical evolution of the whole system completely obeys the deterministic Schrödinger equation. This conclusion is valid for the quantum dynamics of more complicated composite systems. It may provide the fundamental mechanism of the dynamical genesis for both the entanglement and the statistical probability within the deterministic framework of quantum mechanics, which is the longest-standing problem that has not been fully understood since the birth of quantum mechanics.

DOI
10.1063/5.0298701

Related papers

Entanglement by linearSU(2) transformations: generation and evolution of quantum vortex states

G. S. Agarwal, J Banerji

We consider the evolution of a two-mode system of bosons under the action of a Hamiltonian that generates linear SU (2) transformations. The Hamiltonian is generic in that it represents a host of entanglement mechanisms, which can thus be treated in a unified way. We start by solving the quantum dynamics analytically when the system is initially in a Fock state. We show how the two modes get entangled by evolution to produce a coherent superposition of vortex states in general, and a single vortex state under certain conditions. The degree of entanglement between the modes is measured by finding the explicit analytical dependence of the Von Neumann entropy on the system parameters. The reduced state of each mode is analysed by means of its correlation function and spatial coherence function. Remarkably, our analysis is shown to be equally as valid for a variety of initial states that can be prepared from a two-mode Fock state via a unitary transformation and for which the results can be obtained by mere inspection of the corresponding results for an initial Fock state. As an example, we consider a quantum vortex as the initial state and also find conditions for its revival and charge conjugation. While studying the evolution of the initial vortex state, we have encountered and explained an interesting situation in which the entropy of the system does not evolve whereas its wavefunction does. Although the modal concept has been used throughout the paper, it is important to note that the theory is equally applicable for a two-particle system in which each particle is represented by its bosonic creation and annihilation operators.

arXiv:quant-ph/0607220•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Aug 29, 2006•32 citations

The emergence of classical mixtures from an entangled quantum state

Mark G. Kuzyk

Unveiling the dynamical genesis of quantum entanglement in linear systems: Internal causality breaking in the reduced subsystem evolution

American Journal of Physics•Sep 21, 2023•0 citations

Rise and fall of quantum and classical correlations in open-system dynamics

Michael Khasin, Ronnie Kosloff

Interacting quantum systems evolving from an uncorrelated composite initial state generically develop quantum correlations---entanglement. As a consequence, a local description of interacting quantum systems is impossible as a rule. A unitarily evolving (isolated) quantum system generically develops extensive entanglement: the magnitude of the generated entanglement will increase without bounds with the effective Hilbert space dimension of the system. It is conceivable that coupling of the interacting subsystems to local dephasing environments will restrict the generation of entanglement to such extent that the evolving composite system may be considered as approximately disentangled. This conjecture is addressed in the context of some common models of a bipartite system with linear and nonlinear interactions and local coupling to dephasing environments. Analytical and numerical results obtained imply that the conjecture is generally false. Open dynamics of the quantum correlations is compared to the corresponding evolution of the classical correlations and a qualitative difference is found.

arXiv:quant-ph/0605140•Physical Review A•Jul 6, 2007•14 citations

DYNAMICS OF QUANTUM ENTANGLEMENT IN RELATIVISTIC OPEN SYSTEMS*

Madalin Calamanciuc, Аурелиан Исар

We review the results obtained by investigating, in the framework of the theory of open systems based on completely positive quantum dynamical semigroups, the time evolution of quantum entanglement of two different bimodal systems, each one interacting with a thermal environment. The first system is formed of the free massless bosonic mode of a stationary observer in a region that is asymptotically flat (Kruskal observer) or freely falling in Schwarzschild black hole, and the mode of a uniformly accelerated observer hovering outside the event horizon of black hole. For initial bimodal Gaussian squeezed thermal states of the system, we show that under the influence of Hawking radiation the quantum entanglement of the two modes is destroyed in a finite time, for non-zero values of the temperature of the thermal environment, i.e. the phenomenon of entanglement sudden death takes place. The second system consists of two bosonic modes associated with a scalar quantum field in de Sitter space, characterized by two regions that are causally disconnected and described using open universe coordinates on two open charts. The survival time of the entanglement of this bimodal system strongly depends on the competition between the contrary effects provided by the squeezing of the initial bimodal state, the curvature of de Sitter space, the mass parameter and the thermal environment. It is shown that the entanglement is minimized for values 1/2 and 3/2 of the mass parameter, corresponding to the conformally coupled scalar field and, respectively, minimally coupled massless field.

Annals of the Academy of Romanian Scientists Series on Mathematics and Its Application•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

From Reversible Quantum Dynamics to Statistical Probability: A dynamical solution to the origin of probability and Hilbert's sixth problem

Wei-Min Zhang

Hilbert's sixth problem placed probability and mechanics at the center of the axiomatization of physics. It asks how irreversible statistical probability and thermodynamics can follow from the reversible, deterministic dynamics of a system. Building on an exact open quantum system theory developed in the past two decades, we construct a dynamical route from the reversible quantum dynamics to reduced statistics. For quadratic bosonic and fermionic systems bilinearly coupled to arbitrary environments, we derive the exact reduced density operator determined completely by a dissipative propagator u and a fluctuation correlation function v of the system. For continuous spectral densities with no bound-state pole, u vanishes in the long-time limit, information about the system initial states is lost completely, and the reduced density operator of systems approaches a thermal Gibbs state. Gapped spectral densities with localized bound states instead preserve long-time memory and prevent thermalization. We then remove the usual assumption of an initially thermal, mixed environment, start from a product of pure states for the system and environment, unitary evolution first generates system-environment entanglement and a periodic quasi-Gibbs reduced state for a finite environment. When the number of environmental degrees of freedom tends to infinity, the spectrum becomes continuous, the recurrence disappears, the exact reduced density operator converges to a thermal Gibbs state. The total entropy remains zero, whereas the system entropy becomes entanglement entropy and reaches its maximum. Probability is therefore not an additional random postulate imposed on unitary dynamics, it is the objective statistical structure of an open system in a composite. These results provide an exact, testable dynamical solution of the determinism to statistics.

quant-pharXiv:2609.18593•Sep 17, 2026•0 citations

Emergent dynamics from entangled mixed states

Andrea Valdés-Hernández, C. G. Maglione, A. P. Majtey +1 more

Entanglement is at the core of quantum physics, playing a central role in quantum phenomena involving composite systems. According to the timeless picture of quantum dynamics, entanglement may also be essential for understanding the very origins of dynamical evolution and the flow of time. Within this point of view, the Universe is regarded as a bipartite entity comprising a clock $C$ and a system $R$ (or ``rest of the Universe'') jointly described by a global stationary state, and the dynamical evolution of $R$ is construed as an emergent phenomena arising from the entanglement between $C$ and $R$. In spite of substantial recent efforts, many aspects of this approach remain unexplored, particularly those involving mixed states. In the present contribution we investigate the timeless picture of quantum dynamics for mixed states of the clock-system composite, focusing on quantitative relations linking the clock-system entanglement with the emerging dynamical evolution experienced by the system.

arXiv:2009.12451•Physical Review A•Nov 20, 2020•3 citations
Utilizing the general theory of open quantum systems to investigate the exact dynamical evolution of simple bilinear systems, we discover a mechanism of the dynamical genesis of quantum entanglement. We focus in detail on the exact quantum evolution dynamics of two photonic modes (or any two bosonic modes) coupled to each other through a linear interaction, as the simplest system of open quantum systems that we have investigated in the past two decades. Such a linear coupling alone fails to produce two-mode entanglement. We also start with an initially separable pure state of the two modes. By solving exactly the quantum equation of motion without relying on the probabilistic interpretation, we find that when the initial state of one mode is different from a coherent state (a minimum uncertainty wave packet with equal variance in the conjugate quadratures that corresponds to a well-defined classically "particle"), the causality in the time-evolution of each mode is internally violated. It also leads to the emergence of quantum entanglement between the two modes. The lack of causality is the nature of statistics. We discover that it is the internal violation of causality in the reduced (subsystem) dynamical evolution that results in the emergence of entanglement and statistic probability in quantum mechanics, even though the dynamical evolution of the whole system completely obeys the deterministic Schrödinger equation. This conclusion is valid for the quantum dynamics of more complicated composite systems. It may provide the fundamental mechanism of the dynamical genesis for both the entanglement and the statistical probability within the deterministic framework of quantum mechanics, which is the longest-standing problem that has not been fully understood since the birth of quantum mechanics.
We consider the evolution of a two-mode system of bosons under the action of a Hamiltonian that generates linear SU (2) transformations. The Hamiltonian is generic in that it represents a host of entanglement mechanisms, which can thus be treated in a unified way. We start by solving the quantum dynamics analytically when the system is initially in a Fock state. We show how the two modes get entangled by evolution to produce a coherent superposition of vortex states in general, and a single vortex state under certain conditions. The degree of entanglement between the modes is measured by finding the explicit analytical dependence of the Von Neumann entropy on the system parameters. The reduced state of each mode is analysed by means of its correlation function and spatial coherence function. Remarkably, our analysis is shown to be equally as valid for a variety of initial states that can be prepared from a two-mode Fock state via a unitary transformation and for which the results can be obtained by mere inspection of the corresponding results for an initial Fock state. As an example, we consider a quantum vortex as the initial state and also find conditions for its revival and charge conjugation. While studying the evolution of the initial vortex state, we have encountered and explained an interesting situation in which the entropy of the system does not evolve whereas its wavefunction does. Although the modal concept has been used throughout the paper, it is important to note that the theory is equally applicable for a two-particle system in which each particle is represented by its bosonic creation and annihilation operators.
Interacting quantum systems evolving from an uncorrelated composite initial state generically develop quantum correlations---entanglement. As a consequence, a local description of interacting quantum systems is impossible as a rule. A unitarily evolving (isolated) quantum system generically develops extensive entanglement: the magnitude of the generated entanglement will increase without bounds with the effective Hilbert space dimension of the system. It is conceivable that coupling of the interacting subsystems to local dephasing environments will restrict the generation of entanglement to such extent that the evolving composite system may be considered as approximately disentangled. This conjecture is addressed in the context of some common models of a bipartite system with linear and nonlinear interactions and local coupling to dephasing environments. Analytical and numerical results obtained imply that the conjecture is generally false. Open dynamics of the quantum correlations is compared to the corresponding evolution of the classical correlations and a qualitative difference is found.
We review the results obtained by investigating, in the framework of the theory of open systems based on completely positive quantum dynamical semigroups, the time evolution of quantum entanglement of two different bimodal systems, each one interacting with a thermal environment. The first system is formed of the free massless bosonic mode of a stationary observer in a region that is asymptotically flat (Kruskal observer) or freely falling in Schwarzschild black hole, and the mode of a uniformly accelerated observer hovering outside the event horizon of black hole. For initial bimodal Gaussian squeezed thermal states of the system, we show that under the influence of Hawking radiation the quantum entanglement of the two modes is destroyed in a finite time, for non-zero values of the temperature of the thermal environment, i.e. the phenomenon of entanglement sudden death takes place. The second system consists of two bosonic modes associated with a scalar quantum field in de Sitter space, characterized by two regions that are causally disconnected and described using open universe coordinates on two open charts. The survival time of the entanglement of this bimodal system strongly depends on the competition between the contrary effects provided by the squeezing of the initial bimodal state, the curvature of de Sitter space, the mass parameter and the thermal environment. It is shown that the entanglement is minimized for values 1/2 and 3/2 of the mass parameter, corresponding to the conformally coupled scalar field and, respectively, minimally coupled massless field.
Hilbert's sixth problem placed probability and mechanics at the center of the axiomatization of physics. It asks how irreversible statistical probability and thermodynamics can follow from the reversible, deterministic dynamics of a system. Building on an exact open quantum system theory developed in the past two decades, we construct a dynamical route from the reversible quantum dynamics to reduced statistics. For quadratic bosonic and fermionic systems bilinearly coupled to arbitrary environments, we derive the exact reduced density operator determined completely by a dissipative propagator u and a fluctuation correlation function v of the system. For continuous spectral densities with no bound-state pole, u vanishes in the long-time limit, information about the system initial states is lost completely, and the reduced density operator of systems approaches a thermal Gibbs state. Gapped spectral densities with localized bound states instead preserve long-time memory and prevent thermalization. We then remove the usual assumption of an initially thermal, mixed environment, start from a product of pure states for the system and environment, unitary evolution first generates system-environment entanglement and a periodic quasi-Gibbs reduced state for a finite environment. When the number of environmental degrees of freedom tends to infinity, the spectrum becomes continuous, the recurrence disappears, the exact reduced density operator converges to a thermal Gibbs state. The total entropy remains zero, whereas the system entropy becomes entanglement entropy and reaches its maximum. Probability is therefore not an additional random postulate imposed on unitary dynamics, it is the objective statistical structure of an open system in a composite. These results provide an exact, testable dynamical solution of the determinism to statistics.
Entanglement is at the core of quantum physics, playing a central role in quantum phenomena involving composite systems. According to the timeless picture of quantum dynamics, entanglement may also be essential for understanding the very origins of dynamical evolution and the flow of time. Within this point of view, the Universe is regarded as a bipartite entity comprising a clock CCC and a system RRR (or ``rest of the Universe'') jointly described by a global stationary state, and the dynamical evolution of RRR is construed as an emergent phenomena arising from the entanglement between CCC and RRR. In spite of substantial recent efforts, many aspects of this approach remain unexplored, particularly those involving mixed states. In the present contribution we investigate the timeless picture of quantum dynamics for mixed states of the clock-system composite, focusing on quantitative relations linking the clock-system entanglement with the emerging dynamical evolution experienced by the system.