Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2403.02937

Quantum Algorithms in a Superposition of Spacetimes

Omri Shmueli

Published Mar 5, 2024• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum computers are expected to revolutionize our ability to process information. The advancement from classical to quantum computing is a product of our advancement from classical to quantum physics -- the more our understanding of the universe grows, so does our ability to use it for computation. A natural question that arises is, what will physics allow in the future? Can more advanced theories of physics increase our computational power, beyond quantum computing? An active field of research in physics studies theoretical phenomena outside the scope of explainable quantum mechanics, that form when attempting to combine Quantum Mechanics (QM) with General Relativity (GR) into a unified theory of Quantum Gravity (QG). QG is known to present the possibility of a quantum superposition of causal structure and event orderings. In the literature of quantum information theory, this translates to a superposition of unitary evolution orders. In this work we show a first example of a natural computational model based on QG, that provides an exponential speedup over standard quantum computation (under standard hardness assumptions). We define a model and complexity measure for a quantum computer that has the ability to generate a superposition of unitary evolution orders, and show that such computer is able to solve in polynomial time two of the fundamental problems in computer science: The Graph Isomorphism Problem ($\mathsf{GI}$) and the Gap Closest Vector Problem ($\mathsf{GapCVP}$), with gap $O\left( n \sqrt{n} \right)$. These problems are believed by experts to be hard to solve for a regular quantum computer. Interestingly, our model does not seem overpowered, and we found no obvious way to solve entire complexity classes that are considered hard in computer science, like the classes $\mathbf{NP}$ and $\mathbf{SZK}$.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2403.02937

Related papers

Quantum Computing: The Next Frontier in Technology

Aruna M. Jarju

Quantum computing represents a revolutionary leap in computational power, leveraging the principles of quantum mechanics to process information in fundamentally new ways. Unlike classical computers, which use bits to represent data as 0s or 1s, quantum computers use quantum bits or qubits, enabling the phenomena of superposition and entanglement to perform complex calculations more efficiently (Nielsen & Chuang, 2010). This article explores the basic principles of quantum computing, the different models and algorithms that have been developed, and the current state of quantum hardware. The power of quantum computing lies in its ability to solve certain types of problems exponentially faster than classical computers. For instance, Shor's algorithm can factorize large integers in polynomial time, posing a significant threat to classical encryption methods (Shor, 1997). Similarly, Grover's algorithm provides a quadratic speedup for unstructured search problems, showcasing the potential for dramatic improvements in database search capabilities (Grover, 1996). These algorithms exemplify how quantum computing can revolutionize fields that rely on complex computations. Quantum hardware, however, is still in its nascent stage, with significant challenges to be overcome. Current quantum computers, such as those developed by IBM and Google, have demonstrated quantum supremacy but are limited by issues of qubit coherence and error rates (Arute et al., 2019). Quantum error correction and the development of more stable qubit technologies are critical areas of ongoing research (Preskill, 2018). Despite these challenges, recent advancements in quantum hardware and algorithms continue to drive the field forward, promising transformative impacts on industries such as cryptography, drug discovery, and artificial intelligence. As quantum computing continues to advance, it holds the promise of solving problems that are currently intractable for classical computers, paving the way for unprecedented technological and scientific advancements (Shor, 1997; Grover, 1996). This article provides a comprehensive overview of the current landscape of quantum computing, discussing its foundational principles, key algorithms, hardware challenges, and potential applications. By understanding these aspects, we can better appreciate the profound implications of quantum computing for the future of technology and science.

•Aug 11, 2025•2 citations

Unitary Closed Timelike Curves can Solve all of NP

Omri Shmueli

Born in the intersection between quantum mechanics and general relativity, indefinite causal structure is the idea that in the continuum of time, some sets of events do not have an inherent causal order between them. Process matrices, introduced by Oreshkov, Costa and Brukner (Nature Communications, 2012), define quantum information processing with indefinite causal structure -- a generalization of the operations allowed in standard quantum information processing, and to date, are the most studied such generalization. Araujo et al. (Physical Review A, 2017) defined the computational complexity of process matrices, and showed that polynomial-time process matrix computation is equivalent to standard polynomial-time quantum computation with access to a weakening of post-selection Closed Timelike Curves (CTCs), that are restricted to be $\textit{linear}$. Araujo et al. accordingly defined the complexity class for efficient process matrix computation as $\mathbf{BQP}_{\ell CTC}$ (which trivially contains $\mathbf{BQP}$), and posed the open question of whether $\mathbf{BQP}_{\ell CTC}$ contains computational tasks that are outside $\mathbf{BQP}$. In this work we solve this open question under a widely believed hardness assumption, by showing that $\mathbf{NP} \subseteq \mathbf{BQP}_{\ell CTC}$. Our solution is captured by an even more restricted subset of process matrices that are purifiable (Araujo et al., Quantum, 2017), which (1) is conjectured more likely to be physical than arbitrary process matrices, and (2) is equivalent to polynomial-time quantum computation with access to $\textit{unitary}$ (which are in particular linear) post-selection CTCs. Conceptually, our work shows that the previously held belief, that non-linearity is what enables CTCs to solve $\mathbf{NP}$, is false, and raises the importance of understanding whether purifiable process matrices are physical or not.

quant-pharXiv:2410.04630•Oct 8, 2024•0 citations

Beyond Quantum Computers

Giulio Chiribella, Giacomo Mauro D’Ariano, Paolo Perinotti +1 more

The manuscript poses and addresses a new very fundamental issue in Quantum Computer Science, which is going to have a radical impact on the way we currently conceive quantum computation. We show that there exists a new kind of higher-order quantum computation, potentially much more powerful than the usual quantum processing, which is feasible, but cannot be realized by a usual quantum circuit. In order to implement this new kind of computations one needs to change the rules of quantum circuits, also considering circuits with the geometry of the connections that can be itself in a quantum superposition. The new kind of computation poses also fundamental problems for unexplored aspects of quantum mechanics in a non-fixed causal framework, which go far beyond computer-science problems, and may be of relevance in quantum gravity.

•Dec 1, 2009•17 citations

Lattice Based Crypto breaks in a Superposition of Spacetimes

Divesh Aggarwal, Agrawal, Shashwat, Rajendra Kumar

We explore the computational implications of a superposition of spacetimes, a phenomenon hypothesized in quantum gravity theories. This was initiated by Shmueli (2024) where the author introduced the complexity class $\mathbf{BQP^{OI}}$ consisting of promise problems decidable by quantum polynomial time algorithms with access to an oracle for computing order interference. In this work, it was shown that the Graph Isomorphism problem and the Gap Closest Vector Problem (with approximation factor $\mathcal{O}(n^{3/2})$) are in $\mathbf{BQP^{OI}}$. We extend this result by showing that the entire complexity class $\mathbf{SZK}$ (Statistical Zero Knowledge) is contained within $\mathbf{BQP^{OI}}$. This immediately implies that the security of numerous lattice based cryptography schemes will be compromised in a computational model based on superposition of spacetimes, since these often rely on the hardness of the Learning with Errors problem, which is in $\mathbf{SZK}$.

arXiv:2503.21400•Mar 27, 2025•0 citations

Proposed Experiments to Test the Foundations of Quantum Computing

Alan M. Kadin, Steven B. Kaplan

Quantum computing promises computational performance that is exponentially faster than any conceivable classical computer. This is due to the theoretically expected scaling of N entangled qubits, with parallel evolution of 2^N quantum states. This is in sharp contrast to classical computing, where N bits may have 2^N classical states, but only one at a time. It is widely believed that quantum superposition and entanglement have been demonstrated in several experimental systems, and that practical quantum computing can be achieved once sufficiently long quantum relaxation times are obtained. On the contrary, we suggest that there may be serious problems with quantum computing on both the macroscopic and microscopic levels, and that the experiments thus far have not proven the existence of non-classical superposition states, which are necessary for the proper functioning of qubits. In order to investigate this further, we propose new experiments in three physical systems: electron spins, single photons, and superconducting loops. We further suggest that certain more limited classes of quantum computing, such as quantum annealing, do not require quantum entanglement, and can achieve significant performance enhancements even if universal quantum computing proves to be impossible.

•Jul 1, 2016•1 citation

Quantum Computation and Isomorphism Testing

David J. Rosenbaum

In this thesis, we study quantum computation and algorithms for isomorphism problems. Some of the problems that we cover are fundamentally quantum and therefore require quantum techniques. For other problems, classical approaches are more appropriate; however, we often give quantum variants of our classical algorithms as well. The field of quantum computation aims to accelerate algorithms by exploiting the laws of quantum mechanics. Several quantum algorithms are known that are exponentially faster than the best classical algorithms known for the same problems, including several which are relevant to cryptography. Quantum computing is therefore of great importance. On the theory side, it has already transformed our notions of which problems are tractable and which are not. On the practical side, the construction of a quantum computer would render many popular techniques for encryption obsolete. We derive several results in quantum computation. Quantum algorithms are normally formulated in an abstract way that ignores practical details such as where different parts of the computation are located physically. Using naive methods for translating these algorithms into practical quantum computing technologies increases the time complexity by a linear factor, while previous work reduced this factor to a square root. We further reduce this factor to a constant at the cost of requiring additional space. This retroactively justifies an important assumption made in many quantum algorithms. Another interesting problem is to determine the query complexity of extracting different types of information from physical processes. In the case of deterministic processes, it is well known that quantum algorithms cannot outperform deterministic algorithms by more than an exponential factor. We show --- somewhat surprisingly --- that when the process is allowed to be randomized, there are problems that have a constant quantum query complexity but cannot be solved classically no matter how many queries are made. In fact, we show how to construct such an infinity-vs-one separation from any weaker separation between the classical and quantum query complexities. In an isomorphism problem, we seek to determine if two algebraic or combinatorial objects have the same structure. One of the most well-known of these is the graph isomorphism problem, which is interesting since it is suspected to be of complexity intermediate between P and the NP-complete problems. We transition from quantum computation to isomorphism testing by considering the tree isomorphism problem. While linear-time classical algorithms are known for this problem, we show that a promising framework for developing efficient quantum algorithms for graph isomorphism, known as the state preparation approach, can also solve tree isomorphism. While this result might seem modest, it is important to know that the state preparation approach works for trees, since otherwise there would be little hope of using it to obtain efficient algorithms for more interesting classes of graphs. We also derive a powerful primitive along the way that is of independent interest. Next, we study the group isomorphism problem, which is a special case of graph isomorphism. Group isomorphism is suspected to be significantly easier than graph isomorphism, but still has unknown complexity. While group isomorphism is already of interest since it is a fundamental computational question about groups, searching for faster algorithms for group isomorphism is therefore also one way of approaching the graph isomorphism problem. We use collision detection methods to give a classical algorithm that obtains a square-root speedup over the best algorithm previously known for the general group isomorphism problem. For the solvable groups (which are conjectured to be difficult and contain almost all groups), we combine our collision detection techniques with group-theoretic methods to obtain a classical fourth-root speedup over the best algorithm known previously. Prior to this work, it was a longstanding open problem to obtain any improvement for either of these classes of groups. Finally, we give a general framework that yields speedups for many isomorphism problems. In particular, it yields the square-root speedup for testing isomorphism of general groups mentioned above. All of our group isomorphism-testing algorithms also have quantum variants that are slightly faster than their classical counterparts.

•Jan 1, 2015•2 citations
Quantum computers are expected to revolutionize our ability to process information. The advancement from classical to quantum computing is a product of our advancement from classical to quantum physics -- the more our understanding of the universe grows, so does our ability to use it for computation. A natural question that arises is, what will physics allow in the future? Can more advanced theories of physics increase our computational power, beyond quantum computing? An active field of research in physics studies theoretical phenomena outside the scope of explainable quantum mechanics, that form when attempting to combine Quantum Mechanics (QM) with General Relativity (GR) into a unified theory of Quantum Gravity (QG). QG is known to present the possibility of a quantum superposition of causal structure and event orderings. In the literature of quantum information theory, this translates to a superposition of unitary evolution orders. In this work we show a first example of a natural computational model based on QG, that provides an exponential speedup over standard quantum computation (under standard hardness assumptions). We define a model and complexity measure for a quantum computer that has the ability to generate a superposition of unitary evolution orders, and show that such computer is able to solve in polynomial time two of the fundamental problems in computer science: The Graph Isomorphism Problem (GI\mathsf{GI}GI) and the Gap Closest Vector Problem (GapCVP\mathsf{GapCVP}GapCVP), with gap O(nn)O\left( n \sqrt{n} \right)O(nn​). These problems are believed by experts to be hard to solve for a regular quantum computer. Interestingly, our model does not seem overpowered, and we found no obvious way to solve entire complexity classes that are considered hard in computer science, like the classes NP\mathbf{NP}NP and SZK\mathbf{SZK}SZK.
Quantum computing represents a revolutionary leap in computational power, leveraging the principles of quantum mechanics to process information in fundamentally new ways. Unlike classical computers, which use bits to represent data as 0s or 1s, quantum computers use quantum bits or qubits, enabling the phenomena of superposition and entanglement to perform complex calculations more efficiently (Nielsen & Chuang, 2010). This article explores the basic principles of quantum computing, the different models and algorithms that have been developed, and the current state of quantum hardware. The power of quantum computing lies in its ability to solve certain types of problems exponentially faster than classical computers. For instance, Shor's algorithm can factorize large integers in polynomial time, posing a significant threat to classical encryption methods (Shor, 1997). Similarly, Grover's algorithm provides a quadratic speedup for unstructured search problems, showcasing the potential for dramatic improvements in database search capabilities (Grover, 1996). These algorithms exemplify how quantum computing can revolutionize fields that rely on complex computations. Quantum hardware, however, is still in its nascent stage, with significant challenges to be overcome. Current quantum computers, such as those developed by IBM and Google, have demonstrated quantum supremacy but are limited by issues of qubit coherence and error rates (Arute et al., 2019). Quantum error correction and the development of more stable qubit technologies are critical areas of ongoing research (Preskill, 2018). Despite these challenges, recent advancements in quantum hardware and algorithms continue to drive the field forward, promising transformative impacts on industries such as cryptography, drug discovery, and artificial intelligence. As quantum computing continues to advance, it holds the promise of solving problems that are currently intractable for classical computers, paving the way for unprecedented technological and scientific advancements (Shor, 1997; Grover, 1996). This article provides a comprehensive overview of the current landscape of quantum computing, discussing its foundational principles, key algorithms, hardware challenges, and potential applications. By understanding these aspects, we can better appreciate the profound implications of quantum computing for the future of technology and science.
Born in the intersection between quantum mechanics and general relativity, indefinite causal structure is the idea that in the continuum of time, some sets of events do not have an inherent causal order between them. Process matrices, introduced by Oreshkov, Costa and Brukner (Nature Communications, 2012), define quantum information processing with indefinite causal structure -- a generalization of the operations allowed in standard quantum information processing, and to date, are the most studied such generalization. Araujo et al. (Physical Review A, 2017) defined the computational complexity of process matrices, and showed that polynomial-time process matrix computation is equivalent to standard polynomial-time quantum computation with access to a weakening of post-selection Closed Timelike Curves (CTCs), that are restricted to be linear\textit{linear}linear. Araujo et al. accordingly defined the complexity class for efficient process matrix computation as BQPℓCTC\mathbf{BQP}_{\ell CTC}BQPℓCTC​ (which trivially contains BQP\mathbf{BQP}BQP), and posed the open question of whether BQPℓCTC\mathbf{BQP}_{\ell CTC}BQPℓCTC​ contains computational tasks that are outside BQP\mathbf{BQP}BQP. In this work we solve this open question under a widely believed hardness assumption, by showing that NP⊆BQPℓCTC\mathbf{NP} \subseteq \mathbf{BQP}_{\ell CTC}NP⊆BQPℓCTC​. Our solution is captured by an even more restricted subset of process matrices that are purifiable (Araujo et al., Quantum, 2017), which (1) is conjectured more likely to be physical than arbitrary process matrices, and (2) is equivalent to polynomial-time quantum computation with access to unitary\textit{unitary}unitary (which are in particular linear) post-selection CTCs. Conceptually, our work shows that the previously held belief, that non-linearity is what enables CTCs to solve NP\mathbf{NP}NP, is false, and raises the importance of understanding whether purifiable process matrices are physical or not.
The manuscript poses and addresses a new very fundamental issue in Quantum Computer Science, which is going to have a radical impact on the way we currently conceive quantum computation. We show that there exists a new kind of higher-order quantum computation, potentially much more powerful than the usual quantum processing, which is feasible, but cannot be realized by a usual quantum circuit. In order to implement this new kind of computations one needs to change the rules of quantum circuits, also considering circuits with the geometry of the connections that can be itself in a quantum superposition. The new kind of computation poses also fundamental problems for unexplored aspects of quantum mechanics in a non-fixed causal framework, which go far beyond computer-science problems, and may be of relevance in quantum gravity.
We explore the computational implications of a superposition of spacetimes, a phenomenon hypothesized in quantum gravity theories. This was initiated by Shmueli (2024) where the author introduced the complexity class BQPOI\mathbf{BQP^{OI}}BQPOI consisting of promise problems decidable by quantum polynomial time algorithms with access to an oracle for computing order interference. In this work, it was shown that the Graph Isomorphism problem and the Gap Closest Vector Problem (with approximation factor O(n3/2)\mathcal{O}(n^{3/2})O(n3/2)) are in BQPOI\mathbf{BQP^{OI}}BQPOI. We extend this result by showing that the entire complexity class SZK\mathbf{SZK}SZK (Statistical Zero Knowledge) is contained within BQPOI\mathbf{BQP^{OI}}BQPOI. This immediately implies that the security of numerous lattice based cryptography schemes will be compromised in a computational model based on superposition of spacetimes, since these often rely on the hardness of the Learning with Errors problem, which is in SZK\mathbf{SZK}SZK.
Quantum computing promises computational performance that is exponentially faster than any conceivable classical computer. This is due to the theoretically expected scaling of N entangled qubits, with parallel evolution of 2^N quantum states. This is in sharp contrast to classical computing, where N bits may have 2^N classical states, but only one at a time. It is widely believed that quantum superposition and entanglement have been demonstrated in several experimental systems, and that practical quantum computing can be achieved once sufficiently long quantum relaxation times are obtained. On the contrary, we suggest that there may be serious problems with quantum computing on both the macroscopic and microscopic levels, and that the experiments thus far have not proven the existence of non-classical superposition states, which are necessary for the proper functioning of qubits. In order to investigate this further, we propose new experiments in three physical systems: electron spins, single photons, and superconducting loops. We further suggest that certain more limited classes of quantum computing, such as quantum annealing, do not require quantum entanglement, and can achieve significant performance enhancements even if universal quantum computing proves to be impossible.
In this thesis, we study quantum computation and algorithms for isomorphism problems. Some of the problems that we cover are fundamentally quantum and therefore require quantum techniques. For other problems, classical approaches are more appropriate; however, we often give quantum variants of our classical algorithms as well. The field of quantum computation aims to accelerate algorithms by exploiting the laws of quantum mechanics. Several quantum algorithms are known that are exponentially faster than the best classical algorithms known for the same problems, including several which are relevant to cryptography. Quantum computing is therefore of great importance. On the theory side, it has already transformed our notions of which problems are tractable and which are not. On the practical side, the construction of a quantum computer would render many popular techniques for encryption obsolete. We derive several results in quantum computation. Quantum algorithms are normally formulated in an abstract way that ignores practical details such as where different parts of the computation are located physically. Using naive methods for translating these algorithms into practical quantum computing technologies increases the time complexity by a linear factor, while previous work reduced this factor to a square root. We further reduce this factor to a constant at the cost of requiring additional space. This retroactively justifies an important assumption made in many quantum algorithms. Another interesting problem is to determine the query complexity of extracting different types of information from physical processes. In the case of deterministic processes, it is well known that quantum algorithms cannot outperform deterministic algorithms by more than an exponential factor. We show --- somewhat surprisingly --- that when the process is allowed to be randomized, there are problems that have a constant quantum query complexity but cannot be solved classically no matter how many queries are made. In fact, we show how to construct such an infinity-vs-one separation from any weaker separation between the classical and quantum query complexities. In an isomorphism problem, we seek to determine if two algebraic or combinatorial objects have the same structure. One of the most well-known of these is the graph isomorphism problem, which is interesting since it is suspected to be of complexity intermediate between P and the NP-complete problems. We transition from quantum computation to isomorphism testing by considering the tree isomorphism problem. While linear-time classical algorithms are known for this problem, we show that a promising framework for developing efficient quantum algorithms for graph isomorphism, known as the state preparation approach, can also solve tree isomorphism. While this result might seem modest, it is important to know that the state preparation approach works for trees, since otherwise there would be little hope of using it to obtain efficient algorithms for more interesting classes of graphs. We also derive a powerful primitive along the way that is of independent interest. Next, we study the group isomorphism problem, which is a special case of graph isomorphism. Group isomorphism is suspected to be significantly easier than graph isomorphism, but still has unknown complexity. While group isomorphism is already of interest since it is a fundamental computational question about groups, searching for faster algorithms for group isomorphism is therefore also one way of approaching the graph isomorphism problem. We use collision detection methods to give a classical algorithm that obtains a square-root speedup over the best algorithm previously known for the general group isomorphism problem. For the solvable groups (which are conjectured to be difficult and contain almost all groups), we combine our collision detection techniques with group-theoretic methods to obtain a classical fourth-root speedup over the best algorithm known previously. Prior to this work, it was a longstanding open problem to obtain any improvement for either of these classes of groups. Finally, we give a general framework that yields speedups for many isomorphism problems. In particular, it yields the square-root speedup for testing isomorphism of general groups mentioned above. All of our group isomorphism-testing algorithms also have quantum variants that are slightly faster than their classical counterparts.