Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2403.02343

Matters Arising: On physical nature of the optical deDroglie-Mackinnon wave packets. ARISING FROM Layton A. Hall and Ayman F. Abouraddy Nature Physics https://doi.org/10.1038/s41567-022-01876-6 (2023)

Peeter Saari, Ioannis M. Besieris

Published Feb 21, 2024• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Hall and Abouraddy [1] have reported first experimental observation of optical de Broglie-Mackinnon wave packets, which is a seminal achievement in the study of so-called non-diffracting optical pulses. These wave packets propagate in free space without spreading with subluminal relativistic velocities, i.e., with speeds slower but close to the velocity of light in vacuum. The experiments in [1] became possible thanks to the application of quite a witty method. Unfortunately, the explanation of the physical nature of the wave packets and their graphical and mathematical descriptions in the theoretical part of [1] suffer from some ambiguities that need to be clarified.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2403.02343

Related papers

Observation of optical de Broglie–Mackinnon wave packets

Layton A. Hall, Ayman F. Abouraddy

arXiv:2302.13194•Nature Physics•Jan 19, 2023•19 citations

Longitudinal Coherence in Neutron Interferometry

A. G. Klein, G. I. Opat, W. A. Hamilton

The proposition that the coherence length of de Broglie wave packets remains unchanged even though the length of the packets increases upon propagation is discussed and demonstrated.Received 27 December 1982DOI:https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.50.563©1983 American Physical Society

Physical Review Letters•Feb 21, 1983•93 citations

De Broglie wave in vacuum, matter and nanostructures

Philipp I. Vysikaylo, N. V. Samsonenko, M V Semin

Abstract Properties of de Broglie waves and their differences from any other waves, for example, electromagnetic, are discussed. Their little-known properties are given: 1) the propagation velocity is greater than the speed of light V > c ; 2) dispersion even in vacuum (waves of different frequencies propagate at different speeds, which results in the spreading of any wave packets associated with the particles); 3) the connection of the de Broglie wave with another physical wave moving with a speed v less than the speed of light, but so always v · V = c 2, and for the photons v = V = c. According to later views of de Broglie, this second wave is not the group wave. Possible mechanisms of generating the de Broglie waves based on spherical and cylindrical hollow quantum resonators, which can be specially created in matter using specific nanostructures are considered. Perhaps their nature itself realizes them for any micro-objects, regardless of their electrical, magnetic and gravitational properties. That is, this phenomenon is universal. Applications and realizations of this idea are discussed in the part II of our article.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jun 1, 2020•3 citations

On the Nature of Quantum Waves

L. Ellam

Technology majors when introduced to quantum concepts, invariably encounter difficulties in the understanding of matter waves. Further, de Broglie waves are usually considered to be different from the waves inherent in Schrodinger's equation. The purpose of this paper is to clarify the nature of quantum waves and to pursue the implications of wave-particle duality.

International Journal of Bahamian Studies•Dec 20, 2007•0 citations

Abandoning the de Broglie Matter‑Wave: Electrodynamic Origin of Quantum Wave‑Like Phenomena

Wuyuan Zhuang

The de Broglie matter‑wave hypothesis treats wave‑like behaviour as an intrinsic property of all microscopic particles. Based on the Charge‑Cluster Topology Hypothesis (CCTH), this paper points out that such postulate conflicts with multiple basic experimental facts: particle beams propagate in straight lines without spontaneous dispersion in disturbance‑free perfect vacuum; low‑velocity coherent particle beams do not produce spontaneous interference when intersecting in vacuum; electrically‑neutral particles and macroscopic neutral grains likewise exhibit no spontaneous wave‑like behaviour, in sharp contrast to light waves which can produce interference without gratings.This work argues that so‑called quantum wave‑like behaviour is not an intrinsic property of particles, but a statistical manifestation arising from deterministic electromagnetic interactions between charge‑packets and target nuclear charge‑clusters. Diffraction and interference patterns are superpositions of deflection landing positions of numerous independent events. Huygens secondary wave‑sources are equivalent mathematical descriptions of scattering centres rather than real expanding physical waves. The inverse proportional relation between equivalent wavelength and momentum originates from inertial impedance of electromagnetic coupling for high‑speed particles.This paper also challenges the ontological assumption that the uncertainty relation is a fundamental axiom of nature. Position‑momentum uncertainty is interpreted not as intrinsic fuzziness of individual particles, but as a statistical consequence of sensitive‑to‑initial‑conditions many‑body charge‑cluster dynamics plus electromagnetic perturbations introduced during detection. The mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics provides excellent phenomenological fitting for microscopic observations, yet does not directly represent underlying physical reality.Unified physical interpretations for relativistic mass‑increase, deep inelastic scattering and high‑energy particle showers are provided, together with several testable predictions. This manuscript presents a candidate‑hypothesis‑level argument. Quantum entanglement is outside the present framework; precise internal topology of nucleonic charge‑packets and quantitative treatment of gravitation remain unfinished. This preprint is derived from the CCTH theoretical series. It provides an alternative ontological interpretation for quantum wave‑like phenomena instead of negating the computational validity of quantum‑mechanical mathematics. Testable predictions are proposed. Quantum entanglement is explicitly marked as an unresolved boundary issue; precise nucleon internal topology and quantitative gravitation treatment remain unfinished.

•Nov 4, 2026•0 citations

A matter of waves

September 2023 marked the centenary of “Ondes et quanta”, a paper in which French physicist Louis de Broglie proposed that matter is associated with a wave motion, and which ultimately won him the 1929 Nobel Prize for Physics.

Physics World•Nov 1, 2023•0 citations
Hall and Abouraddy [1] have reported first experimental observation of optical de Broglie-Mackinnon wave packets, which is a seminal achievement in the study of so-called non-diffracting optical pulses. These wave packets propagate in free space without spreading with subluminal relativistic velocities, i.e., with speeds slower but close to the velocity of light in vacuum. The experiments in [1] became possible thanks to the application of quite a witty method. Unfortunately, the explanation of the physical nature of the wave packets and their graphical and mathematical descriptions in the theoretical part of [1] suffer from some ambiguities that need to be clarified.
Abstract Properties of de Broglie waves and their differences from any other waves, for example, electromagnetic, are discussed. Their little-known properties are given: 1) the propagation velocity is greater than the speed of light V > c ; 2) dispersion even in vacuum (waves of different frequencies propagate at different speeds, which results in the spreading of any wave packets associated with the particles); 3) the connection of the de Broglie wave with another physical wave moving with a speed v less than the speed of light, but so always v · V = c 2, and for the photons v = V = c. According to later views of de Broglie, this second wave is not the group wave. Possible mechanisms of generating the de Broglie waves based on spherical and cylindrical hollow quantum resonators, which can be specially created in matter using specific nanostructures are considered. Perhaps their nature itself realizes them for any micro-objects, regardless of their electrical, magnetic and gravitational properties. That is, this phenomenon is universal. Applications and realizations of this idea are discussed in the part II of our article.
The de Broglie matter‑wave hypothesis treats wave‑like behaviour as an intrinsic property of all microscopic particles. Based on the Charge‑Cluster Topology Hypothesis (CCTH), this paper points out that such postulate conflicts with multiple basic experimental facts: particle beams propagate in straight lines without spontaneous dispersion in disturbance‑free perfect vacuum; low‑velocity coherent particle beams do not produce spontaneous interference when intersecting in vacuum; electrically‑neutral particles and macroscopic neutral grains likewise exhibit no spontaneous wave‑like behaviour, in sharp contrast to light waves which can produce interference without gratings.This work argues that so‑called quantum wave‑like behaviour is not an intrinsic property of particles, but a statistical manifestation arising from deterministic electromagnetic interactions between charge‑packets and target nuclear charge‑clusters. Diffraction and interference patterns are superpositions of deflection landing positions of numerous independent events. Huygens secondary wave‑sources are equivalent mathematical descriptions of scattering centres rather than real expanding physical waves. The inverse proportional relation between equivalent wavelength and momentum originates from inertial impedance of electromagnetic coupling for high‑speed particles.This paper also challenges the ontological assumption that the uncertainty relation is a fundamental axiom of nature. Position‑momentum uncertainty is interpreted not as intrinsic fuzziness of individual particles, but as a statistical consequence of sensitive‑to‑initial‑conditions many‑body charge‑cluster dynamics plus electromagnetic perturbations introduced during detection. The mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics provides excellent phenomenological fitting for microscopic observations, yet does not directly represent underlying physical reality.Unified physical interpretations for relativistic mass‑increase, deep inelastic scattering and high‑energy particle showers are provided, together with several testable predictions. This manuscript presents a candidate‑hypothesis‑level argument. Quantum entanglement is outside the present framework; precise internal topology of nucleonic charge‑packets and quantitative treatment of gravitation remain unfinished. This preprint is derived from the CCTH theoretical series. It provides an alternative ontological interpretation for quantum wave‑like phenomena instead of negating the computational validity of quantum‑mechanical mathematics. Testable predictions are proposed. Quantum entanglement is explicitly marked as an unresolved boundary issue; precise nucleon internal topology and quantitative gravitation treatment remain unfinished.