Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2403.00616 · npj Quantum Information

Gate-set evaluation metrics for closed-loop optimal control on nitrogen-vacancy center ensembles in diamond

Philipp J. Vetter, Thomas Reisser, Maximilian G. Hirsch, Tommaso Calarco, Felix Motzoi, Fedor Jelezko, Matthias M. Müller

Published Oct 2, 2024• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A recurring challenge in quantum science and technology is the precise control of their underlying dynamics that lead to the desired quantum operations, often described by a set of quantum gates. These gates can be subject to application-specific errors, leading to a dependence of their controls on the chosen circuit, the quality measure and the gate-set itself. A natural solution would be to apply quantum optimal control in an application-oriented fashion. In turn, this requires the definition of a meaningful measure of the contextual gate-set performance. Therefore, we explore and compare the applicability of quantum process tomography, linear inversion gate-set tomography, randomized linear gate-set tomography, and randomized benchmarking as measures for closed-loop quantum optimal control experiments, using a macroscopic ensemble of nitrogen-vacancy centers in diamond as a test-bed. Our work demonstrates the relative trade-offs between those measures and how to significantly enhance the gate-set performance, leading to an improvement across all investigated methods.

DOI
10.1038/s41534-024-00893-y

Related papers

Gate Optimization via Efficient Two-Qubit Benchmarking for NV Centers in Diamond

Alessandro Marcomini, Philipp J. Vetter, Tommaso Calarco +3 more

High-fidelity gate implementation requires sophisticated control pulses that steer the quantum system to undergo the desired transformation. Quantum Optimal Control allows to derive these control pulses in an open-loop fashion based on numerical simulations. However, their precision can be limited by incomplete knowledge of the system. Closed-loop optimization overcomes this limitation by incorporating feedback from measurements, provided a suitable and efficient measure of the gate performance can be defined. In this article, we present an efficient method to evaluate the performance of a two-qubit gate by preparation and measurement of only two quantum states, enabling experimental closed-loop optimization with a metric previously believed to be limited to open-loop control. We tailor the approach to nitrogen-vacancy centers in diamond and, through numerical simulations, demonstrate how the method can optimize a two-qubit gate while reducing the number of required measurements by two orders of magnitude compared to standard process tomography under realistic experimental settings.

quant-pharXiv:2603.08581•Mar 10, 2026•1 citation

Nitrogen-vacancy centers in diamond as a platform for quantum sensing, control, and simulation

Philipp J. Vetter

Quantum technologies are transitioning from proof-of-principle experiments to practical everyday applications. As this transition unfolds, it remains unclear which quantum system will offer the most suitable platform for specific tasks. While many candidate systems offer excellent control and demonstrate rapid progress, they often require demanding operating conditions such as cryogenic temperatures down to the millikelvin range. The nitrogen-vacancy (N-V) center in diamond is a notable exception. This optically active defect allows full control of its electronic spin state at room temperature and maintains long coherence times under ambient conditions, a prerequisite for many applications. This accessibility makes the N-V center uniquely suited for translating fundamental quantum concepts into deployable technologies. The applicability of N-V centers in quantum sensing, quantum control, and quantum simulation is the central focus of this thesis. After an introductory overview of the field, the thesis introduces the experimental and theoretical concepts that are necessary to understand the presented results. It proceeds to show how the operating regime of N-V centers as sensors for AC magnetic fields and nuclear spins can be extended to low and zero magnetic bias fields. Many commonly used sensing protocols require a magnetic bias field, which can alter the investigated dynamics or may be infeasible to apply due to experimental constraints. This work describes how established sensing protocols can be adjusted for operation under these conditions, and presents novel sensing protocols that enable the detection of AC magnetic fields and nuclear spins in a regime where conventional protocols fail. These results highlight that precise control of the underlying quantum system is a must. Such control can be optimized using quantum optimal control, which allows one to improve the underlying gate operations in a closed-loop, black-box manner, provided a figure of merit can be found which reliably evaluates the gate-set's performance. As this performance can depend on the specific application, the following part of this thesis defines and benchmarks several figures of merit for closed-loop optimal control using an ensemble of N-V centers. The strengths and limitations of these figures of merit are discussed, and the dependence of the optimization performance on several control and experimental parameters is analyzed. The achieved results are applicable to a broad range of other physical platforms, and can serve as a reference for experimental groups that aim to optimize their gate operations using optimal control. Building upon these insights into quantum control, the next part of this thesis presents the fabrication, control, and application of a room-temperature quantum simulator based on thin nuclear spin layers in diamond. A detailed assessment of the growth process is provided, and the dynamics that allow nearby N-V centers to initialize and read out the nuclear spins are thoroughly investigated. Furthermore, the nuclear spin layer is employed to create and study discrete time-crystalline order. The results demonstrate a scalable route for exploring quantum many-body phenomena under ambient conditions. The thesis concludes with a summary and discussion of all results and provides an outlook on future work based on these findings. In conclusion, this thesis demonstrates and expands the versatile use of N-V centers in diamond for quantum sensing, control, and simulation, highlighting their potential as a practical platform for future quantum technologies.

•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

Introduction to quantum optimal control for quantum sensing with nitrogen-vacancy centers in diamond

Phila Rembold, Nimba Oshnik, Matthias M. Müller +3 more

Diamond based quantum technology is a fast emerging field with both scientific and technological importance. With the growing knowledge and experience concerning diamond based quantum systems comes an increased demand for performance. Quantum optimal control (QOC) provides a direct solution to a number of existing challenges as well as a basis for proposed future applications. Together with a swift review of QOC strategies, quantum sensing, and other relevant quantum technology applications of nitrogen-vacancy (NV) centers in diamond, the authors give the necessary background to summarize recent advancements in the field of QOC assisted quantum applications with NV centers in diamond.

arXiv:2004.12119•AVS Quantum Science•Jun 1, 2020•172 citations

Single nitrogen-vacancy centers in diamond for spin quantum control

Francesco Poggiali

The thesis focuses on one of the most promising experimental platforms for quantum technologies: Single nitrogen-vacancy (NV) centers in diamond. This quantum system is composed by the spins of the valence electrons of the crystalline point defects and their nearby nuclei. Quite generally, a fundamental requirement to exploit the potentialities of the quantum nature of a system is its precise control. However, this always involves new challenges, related to the need to protect the quantum system from the environment (i.e. preserving the quantum nature of the system itself) and the desire to develop measurement protocols that can enhance its performance for quantum applications. Therefore, I focused my Ph.D. work to find novel solutions to these challenges.

•Jan 1, 2019•0 citations

Robust coherent optimal control of nitrogen-vacancy quantum bits in diamond

Andreas Angerer

During the last ten years, basic quantum operations on a single electronic spins in the nitrogen-vacancy defect center in diamond have been a rich field of study. Quantum operations coherently manipulating the spin of the nitrogen-vacancy center have become promising candidates for easy to manipulate qubits. However in order to implement these qubits in quantum computers robust high-fidelity control is needed. Building on an existing confocal microscopy setup, pulsed and quadrature-amplitude modulated microwave signals were used to realize coherent spin manipulation measurements. Especially designed Smooth Optimal Control pulses (robust against detuning and different control amplitudes) were used to develop measurement schemes resulting in the aforementioned increase of fidelity. The first part of the thesis describes the implementation of these pulses into the existing experimental setup and the calibration work necessary prior to measurements, due to imperfections of devices in the microwave chain. The second part is dedicated to the analysis of the pulses applied to a single spin by comparing the experimental results to theoretical simulations. This was done not only for one resonant spin with accurate control amplitude, but also for a range of different detunings and amplitudes. A more thorough analysis of the pulses was then achieved by using state/process tomography, resulting in a complete description of the process induced by these optimized pulses. Finally, after verifying the effect of the pulses, measurement schemes for sensing alternating magnetic fields were implemented, resulting in measurements with improved sensitivity for magnetic fields.

•Mar 1, 2014•1 citation

Efficiency of optimal control for noisy spin qubits in diamond

Hendry M. Lim, Genko T. Genov, Roberto Sailer +4 more

Decoherence is a major challenge for quantum technologies, whose negative effects can be mitigated by quantum optimal control. The decoherence dynamics significantly varies depending on the characteristics of the system’s environment, consequently affecting the optimization outcomes. In this work, we investigate the optimization of a negatively charged nitrogen-vacancy ( NV − ) center qubit-spin-inversion control pulse, and observe two error-compensation mechanisms, depending on how long the correlation time is compared to the pulse duration. Additionally, we analyze the effects of control space constraints and optimization options to identify a strategy to improve the optimization performance. Finally, we present experimental realizations of the optimized pulses, exhibiting the applicability of the procedure. Our work serves as a generic yet essential guide to implementing optimal control in the presence of realistic noise.

arXiv:2411.05078•Physical Review Applied•Nov 20, 2025•5 citations
A recurring challenge in quantum science and technology is the precise control of their underlying dynamics that lead to the desired quantum operations, often described by a set of quantum gates. These gates can be subject to application-specific errors, leading to a dependence of their controls on the chosen circuit, the quality measure and the gate-set itself. A natural solution would be to apply quantum optimal control in an application-oriented fashion. In turn, this requires the definition of a meaningful measure of the contextual gate-set performance. Therefore, we explore and compare the applicability of quantum process tomography, linear inversion gate-set tomography, randomized linear gate-set tomography, and randomized benchmarking as measures for closed-loop quantum optimal control experiments, using a macroscopic ensemble of nitrogen-vacancy centers in diamond as a test-bed. Our work demonstrates the relative trade-offs between those measures and how to significantly enhance the gate-set performance, leading to an improvement across all investigated methods.
High-fidelity gate implementation requires sophisticated control pulses that steer the quantum system to undergo the desired transformation. Quantum Optimal Control allows to derive these control pulses in an open-loop fashion based on numerical simulations. However, their precision can be limited by incomplete knowledge of the system. Closed-loop optimization overcomes this limitation by incorporating feedback from measurements, provided a suitable and efficient measure of the gate performance can be defined. In this article, we present an efficient method to evaluate the performance of a two-qubit gate by preparation and measurement of only two quantum states, enabling experimental closed-loop optimization with a metric previously believed to be limited to open-loop control. We tailor the approach to nitrogen-vacancy centers in diamond and, through numerical simulations, demonstrate how the method can optimize a two-qubit gate while reducing the number of required measurements by two orders of magnitude compared to standard process tomography under realistic experimental settings.
Quantum technologies are transitioning from proof-of-principle experiments to practical everyday applications. As this transition unfolds, it remains unclear which quantum system will offer the most suitable platform for specific tasks. While many candidate systems offer excellent control and demonstrate rapid progress, they often require demanding operating conditions such as cryogenic temperatures down to the millikelvin range. The nitrogen-vacancy (N-V) center in diamond is a notable exception. This optically active defect allows full control of its electronic spin state at room temperature and maintains long coherence times under ambient conditions, a prerequisite for many applications. This accessibility makes the N-V center uniquely suited for translating fundamental quantum concepts into deployable technologies. The applicability of N-V centers in quantum sensing, quantum control, and quantum simulation is the central focus of this thesis. After an introductory overview of the field, the thesis introduces the experimental and theoretical concepts that are necessary to understand the presented results. It proceeds to show how the operating regime of N-V centers as sensors for AC magnetic fields and nuclear spins can be extended to low and zero magnetic bias fields. Many commonly used sensing protocols require a magnetic bias field, which can alter the investigated dynamics or may be infeasible to apply due to experimental constraints. This work describes how established sensing protocols can be adjusted for operation under these conditions, and presents novel sensing protocols that enable the detection of AC magnetic fields and nuclear spins in a regime where conventional protocols fail. These results highlight that precise control of the underlying quantum system is a must. Such control can be optimized using quantum optimal control, which allows one to improve the underlying gate operations in a closed-loop, black-box manner, provided a figure of merit can be found which reliably evaluates the gate-set's performance. As this performance can depend on the specific application, the following part of this thesis defines and benchmarks several figures of merit for closed-loop optimal control using an ensemble of N-V centers. The strengths and limitations of these figures of merit are discussed, and the dependence of the optimization performance on several control and experimental parameters is analyzed. The achieved results are applicable to a broad range of other physical platforms, and can serve as a reference for experimental groups that aim to optimize their gate operations using optimal control. Building upon these insights into quantum control, the next part of this thesis presents the fabrication, control, and application of a room-temperature quantum simulator based on thin nuclear spin layers in diamond. A detailed assessment of the growth process is provided, and the dynamics that allow nearby N-V centers to initialize and read out the nuclear spins are thoroughly investigated. Furthermore, the nuclear spin layer is employed to create and study discrete time-crystalline order. The results demonstrate a scalable route for exploring quantum many-body phenomena under ambient conditions. The thesis concludes with a summary and discussion of all results and provides an outlook on future work based on these findings. In conclusion, this thesis demonstrates and expands the versatile use of N-V centers in diamond for quantum sensing, control, and simulation, highlighting their potential as a practical platform for future quantum technologies.
Diamond based quantum technology is a fast emerging field with both scientific and technological importance. With the growing knowledge and experience concerning diamond based quantum systems comes an increased demand for performance. Quantum optimal control (QOC) provides a direct solution to a number of existing challenges as well as a basis for proposed future applications. Together with a swift review of QOC strategies, quantum sensing, and other relevant quantum technology applications of nitrogen-vacancy (NV) centers in diamond, the authors give the necessary background to summarize recent advancements in the field of QOC assisted quantum applications with NV centers in diamond.
The thesis focuses on one of the most promising experimental platforms for quantum technologies: Single nitrogen-vacancy (NV) centers in diamond. This quantum system is composed by the spins of the valence electrons of the crystalline point defects and their nearby nuclei. Quite generally, a fundamental requirement to exploit the potentialities of the quantum nature of a system is its precise control. However, this always involves new challenges, related to the need to protect the quantum system from the environment (i.e. preserving the quantum nature of the system itself) and the desire to develop measurement protocols that can enhance its performance for quantum applications. Therefore, I focused my Ph.D. work to find novel solutions to these challenges.
During the last ten years, basic quantum operations on a single electronic spins in the nitrogen-vacancy defect center in diamond have been a rich field of study. Quantum operations coherently manipulating the spin of the nitrogen-vacancy center have become promising candidates for easy to manipulate qubits. However in order to implement these qubits in quantum computers robust high-fidelity control is needed. Building on an existing confocal microscopy setup, pulsed and quadrature-amplitude modulated microwave signals were used to realize coherent spin manipulation measurements. Especially designed Smooth Optimal Control pulses (robust against detuning and different control amplitudes) were used to develop measurement schemes resulting in the aforementioned increase of fidelity. The first part of the thesis describes the implementation of these pulses into the existing experimental setup and the calibration work necessary prior to measurements, due to imperfections of devices in the microwave chain. The second part is dedicated to the analysis of the pulses applied to a single spin by comparing the experimental results to theoretical simulations. This was done not only for one resonant spin with accurate control amplitude, but also for a range of different detunings and amplitudes. A more thorough analysis of the pulses was then achieved by using state/process tomography, resulting in a complete description of the process induced by these optimized pulses. Finally, after verifying the effect of the pulses, measurement schemes for sensing alternating magnetic fields were implemented, resulting in measurements with improved sensitivity for magnetic fields.
Decoherence is a major challenge for quantum technologies, whose negative effects can be mitigated by quantum optimal control. The decoherence dynamics significantly varies depending on the characteristics of the system’s environment, consequently affecting the optimization outcomes. In this work, we investigate the optimization of a negatively charged nitrogen-vacancy ( NV − ) center qubit-spin-inversion control pulse, and observe two error-compensation mechanisms, depending on how long the correlation time is compared to the pulse duration. Additionally, we analyze the effects of control space constraints and optimization options to identify a strategy to improve the optimization performance. Finally, we present experimental realizations of the optimized pulses, exhibiting the applicability of the procedure. Our work serves as a generic yet essential guide to implementing optimal control in the presence of realistic noise.