Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2402.19235

Measurement schemes in AQFT, contextuality and the Wigner\'s friend Gedankenexperiment

Felipe Dilho Alves

Published Apr 17, 2024• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Measurements have historically presented a problem for the consistent description of quantum theories, be it in non-relativistic quantum mechanics or in quantum field theory. Drawing on a recent surge of interest in the description of measurements in Algebraic Quantum Field theory, it was decided that this dissertation would be focused on trying to close the gap between the description of measurements proposed by K. Hepp in the 70's, considering decoherence of states in quasilocal algebras and the new framework of generally covariant measurement schemes proposed recently by C. Fewster and R. Verch. Another recent result that we shall also consider is the Frauchinger-Renner Gedankenexperiment, that has taken inspiration on Hepp's article about decoherence based measurements to arrive at a no-go result about the consistency of quantum descriptions of systems containing rational agents, we shall seek to provide a closure for the interpretation of this result. In doing so we naturally arrive at the study of the contextual properties of measurement setups.

DOI
10.11606/d.43.2024.tde-04062024-105026

Related papers

How to Ensure Logical Consistency of Quantum Theory

Jindřich Krčmář

Predictions of quantum theory have been confirmed experimentally in the microscopic domain with no known exceptions. This success motivates physicists to assume universal validity of the theory. To put the predictions of the quantum theory to the test in the domain of more complex systems researchers like e.g. Eugene Wigner have proposed carefully designed Gedankenexperiments revealing unexpected difficulties of the theory. Daniela Frauchiger and Renato Renner have recently suggested an extension of the Gedankenexperiment commonly known as Wigner's friend and arrived at a conclusion that one agent, upon observing a particular measurement outcome, must conclude that another agent has predicted the opposite outcome with certainty. Their analysis shows that quantum theory cannot consistently describe the use of itself. Here, we will study the mentioned Gedankenexperiments and introduce an approach leading to consistent predictions of quantum theory, independent of observer using the theory.

arXiv:1904.07437•Apr 15, 2019•0 citations

Consistency in the description of quantum measurement: Quantum theory can consistently describe the use of itself

Joseph M. Renes

Recent extended formulations of the Wigner's friend thought experiment throw the measurement problem of quantum mechanics into sharper relief. Here I respond to an invitation by Renner to provide a consistent and concrete set of rules for quantum mechanics which can avoid the apparent paradox formulated by Frauchiger and Renner [Nat. Comm. 9, 3711 (2018)]. I propose a slight addition to standard textbook quantum mechanics, in the form of two rules, which avoids the paradox. The first specifies when a given quantum dynamics can be interpreted as a measurement. Potentially any dynamics can, but doing so depends on the context of other performed operations. The second requires that a joint context be used to determine whether several different dynamical evolutions can all be interpreted as measurement. The paradox is then avoided because not every participant in the Frauchiger-Renner thought experiment regards the stated dynamical descriptions of the experiment as measurements.

arXiv:2107.02193•Jul 5, 2021•39 citations

Wigner's Friend and Bell's Field Beables

Jeffrey Alan Barrett

A field-theoretic version of Wigner’s friend (1961) illustrates how the quantum measurement problem arises for field theory. Similarly, considering spacelike separate measurements of entangled fields by ob-servers akin to Wigner’s friend shows the sense in which relativistic constraints make the measurement problem particularly difficult to resolve in the context of a relativistic field theory. We will consider proposals by Wigner (1961), Bloch (1967), Helwig and Kraus (1970), and Bell (1984) for resolving the measurement problem for quantum field theory. We will conclude by considering the possibility of giving up rich dynamical explanation in the context of a many-maps formu-lation of relativistic quantum field theory. 1. Wigner’s Friend When Eugene Wigner wrote his now famous paper (1961) on the dynam-ical role of observers in quantum mechanics, quantum field theory was flour-

•Dec 22, 2011•1 citation

Measurements and state updates in quantum field theory

Michele Busti

In recent years, a fully covariant framework was developed by Fewster and Verch to describe measurement processes in quantum field theory (QFT), resolving long-standing causality issues arising from trying to adapt standard non-relativistic rules to QFT. This framework is described in terms of the algebraic formulation of QFT (AQFT), which is a naturally well-suited approach for theories on curved spacetimes. While it is known that, in certain models, the class of non-selective measurements preserves the singularity structure associated with so-called Hadamard quantum states, the effect of selective measurements on these states is not yet fully established. This thesis presents a first approach to complete the picture. Techniques from microlocal analysis, distribution theory, and operator algebras are employed to study how the act of performing a selective measurement on a quantum field alters the singularity structure of its Hadamard states. It is shown that there are multiple ways to set up selective measurements, conditioned on local effects of the quantum Weyl algebra, that preserve the Hadamard condition of the preparation state. Conversely, analytical limits where the Hadamard condition is lost are also identified. Examples carrying relevant physical interpretations are presented alongside the development of these general results. Finally, an explicit model is chosen to carry out perturbative computations to analyze the extent to which a measurement process induces variations in the energy density of a specific QFT.

•Jul 24, 2026•0 citations

Lectures on measurement in quantum field theory

Christopher J. Fewster

These lectures present a brief introduction to measurement theory for QFT in possibly curved spacetimes introduced by the author and R. Verch [Comm. Math. Phys. 378 (2020) 851-889]. Topics include: a brief introduction to algebraic QFT, measurement schemes in QFT, state updates, multiple measurements and the resolution of Sorkin's "impossible measurement" problem. Examples using suitable theories based on Green hyperbolic operators are given, and the interpretational significance of the framework is briefly considered. The basic style is to give details relating to QFT while taking for granted various facts from the theory of globally hyperbolic spacetimes.

arXiv:2504.17437•Apr 24, 2025•2 citations

The measurement problem is the measurement problem is the measurement problem

Veronika Baumann, Arne Hansen, Stefan Wolf

Recently, it has been stated that single-world interpretations of quantum theory are logically inconsistent. The claim is derived from contradicting statements of agents in a setup combining two Wigner's-friend experiments. Those statements stem from applying the measurement-update rule subjectively, i.e., only for the respective agent's own measurement. We argue that the contradiction expresses the incompatibility of collapse and unitarity - resulting in different formal descriptions of a measurement - and does not allow to dismiss any specific interpretation of quantum theory.

arXiv:1611.01111•Nov 3, 2016•61 citations
Measurements have historically presented a problem for the consistent description of quantum theories, be it in non-relativistic quantum mechanics or in quantum field theory. Drawing on a recent surge of interest in the description of measurements in Algebraic Quantum Field theory, it was decided that this dissertation would be focused on trying to close the gap between the description of measurements proposed by K. Hepp in the 70's, considering decoherence of states in quasilocal algebras and the new framework of generally covariant measurement schemes proposed recently by C. Fewster and R. Verch. Another recent result that we shall also consider is the Frauchinger-Renner Gedankenexperiment, that has taken inspiration on Hepp's article about decoherence based measurements to arrive at a no-go result about the consistency of quantum descriptions of systems containing rational agents, we shall seek to provide a closure for the interpretation of this result. In doing so we naturally arrive at the study of the contextual properties of measurement setups.
Predictions of quantum theory have been confirmed experimentally in the microscopic domain with no known exceptions. This success motivates physicists to assume universal validity of the theory. To put the predictions of the quantum theory to the test in the domain of more complex systems researchers like e.g. Eugene Wigner have proposed carefully designed Gedankenexperiments revealing unexpected difficulties of the theory. Daniela Frauchiger and Renato Renner have recently suggested an extension of the Gedankenexperiment commonly known as Wigner's friend and arrived at a conclusion that one agent, upon observing a particular measurement outcome, must conclude that another agent has predicted the opposite outcome with certainty. Their analysis shows that quantum theory cannot consistently describe the use of itself. Here, we will study the mentioned Gedankenexperiments and introduce an approach leading to consistent predictions of quantum theory, independent of observer using the theory.
Recent extended formulations of the Wigner's friend thought experiment throw the measurement problem of quantum mechanics into sharper relief. Here I respond to an invitation by Renner to provide a consistent and concrete set of rules for quantum mechanics which can avoid the apparent paradox formulated by Frauchiger and Renner [Nat. Comm. 9, 3711 (2018)]. I propose a slight addition to standard textbook quantum mechanics, in the form of two rules, which avoids the paradox. The first specifies when a given quantum dynamics can be interpreted as a measurement. Potentially any dynamics can, but doing so depends on the context of other performed operations. The second requires that a joint context be used to determine whether several different dynamical evolutions can all be interpreted as measurement. The paradox is then avoided because not every participant in the Frauchiger-Renner thought experiment regards the stated dynamical descriptions of the experiment as measurements.
A field-theoretic version of Wigner’s friend (1961) illustrates how the quantum measurement problem arises for field theory. Similarly, considering spacelike separate measurements of entangled fields by ob-servers akin to Wigner’s friend shows the sense in which relativistic constraints make the measurement problem particularly difficult to resolve in the context of a relativistic field theory. We will consider proposals by Wigner (1961), Bloch (1967), Helwig and Kraus (1970), and Bell (1984) for resolving the measurement problem for quantum field theory. We will conclude by considering the possibility of giving up rich dynamical explanation in the context of a many-maps formu-lation of relativistic quantum field theory. 1. Wigner’s Friend When Eugene Wigner wrote his now famous paper (1961) on the dynam-ical role of observers in quantum mechanics, quantum field theory was flour-
In recent years, a fully covariant framework was developed by Fewster and Verch to describe measurement processes in quantum field theory (QFT), resolving long-standing causality issues arising from trying to adapt standard non-relativistic rules to QFT. This framework is described in terms of the algebraic formulation of QFT (AQFT), which is a naturally well-suited approach for theories on curved spacetimes. While it is known that, in certain models, the class of non-selective measurements preserves the singularity structure associated with so-called Hadamard quantum states, the effect of selective measurements on these states is not yet fully established. This thesis presents a first approach to complete the picture. Techniques from microlocal analysis, distribution theory, and operator algebras are employed to study how the act of performing a selective measurement on a quantum field alters the singularity structure of its Hadamard states. It is shown that there are multiple ways to set up selective measurements, conditioned on local effects of the quantum Weyl algebra, that preserve the Hadamard condition of the preparation state. Conversely, analytical limits where the Hadamard condition is lost are also identified. Examples carrying relevant physical interpretations are presented alongside the development of these general results. Finally, an explicit model is chosen to carry out perturbative computations to analyze the extent to which a measurement process induces variations in the energy density of a specific QFT.
These lectures present a brief introduction to measurement theory for QFT in possibly curved spacetimes introduced by the author and R. Verch [Comm. Math. Phys. 378 (2020) 851-889]. Topics include: a brief introduction to algebraic QFT, measurement schemes in QFT, state updates, multiple measurements and the resolution of Sorkin's "impossible measurement" problem. Examples using suitable theories based on Green hyperbolic operators are given, and the interpretational significance of the framework is briefly considered. The basic style is to give details relating to QFT while taking for granted various facts from the theory of globally hyperbolic spacetimes.
Recently, it has been stated that single-world interpretations of quantum theory are logically inconsistent. The claim is derived from contradicting statements of agents in a setup combining two Wigner's-friend experiments. Those statements stem from applying the measurement-update rule subjectively, i.e., only for the respective agent's own measurement. We argue that the contradiction expresses the incompatibility of collapse and unitarity - resulting in different formal descriptions of a measurement - and does not allow to dismiss any specific interpretation of quantum theory.