Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2402.18790 · ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing (STOC)

The Power of Unentangled Quantum Proofs with Non-negative Amplitudes

Fernando Granha Jeronimo, Pei Wu

Published May 16, 2023• 16 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum entanglement is a fundamental property of quantum mechanics and it serves as a basic resource in quantum computation and information. Despite its importance, the power and limitations of quantum entanglement are far from being fully understood. Here, we study entanglement via the lens of computational complexity. This is done by studying quantum generalizations of the class NP with multiple unentangled quantum proofs, the so-called QMA(2) and its variants. The complexity of QMA(2) is known to be closely connected to a variety of problems such as deciding if a state is entangled and several classical optimization problems. However, determining the complexity of QMA(2) is a longstanding open problem, and only the trivial complexity bounds ⊆ (2) ⊆ are known.

DOI
10.1145/3564246.3585248

Related papers

The QMA(2) UniverseComplexity, Entanglement, and Optimization

Fernando Granha Jeronimo, Pei Wu, Itai Leigh

The complexity class QMA(2), featuring two unentangled quantum provers, occupies a central yet poorly understood position in quantum complexity theory. While superficially a modest extension of QMA, unentanglement fundamentally changes both the algorithmic and complexitytheoretic landscape, connecting QMA(2) to deep questions in separability testing, polynomial optimization, and hardness of approximation. Over the past two decades, QMA(2) has inspired a rich body of work spanning restricted verification models, semidefinite and Sum-of-Squares hierarchies, and surprising links to classical problems such as the Unique Games Conjecture. This survey provides an overview of these developments, emphasizing structural insights, algorithmic techniques, and known barriers, while highlighting how progress on QMA(2) continues to illuminate the interplay between quantum information, convex optimization, and classical complexity theory.

ACM SIGACT News•Mar 31, 2026•5 citations

The Power of Unentanglement (Extended Abstract)

Scott Aaronson, Salman Beigi, Andrew Drucker +2 more

The class QMA(k), introduced by Kobayashi et al., consists of all languages that can be verified using k unentangled quantum proofs. Many of the simplest questions about this class have remained embarrassingly open: for example, can we give any evidence that k quantum proofs are more powerful than one? Can we show any upper bound on QMA(k), besides the trivial NEXP? Does QMA(k) = QMA(2) for k ≥ 2? Can QMA(k) protocols be amplified to exponentially small error? In this paper, we make progress on all of the above questions. • We give a protocol by which a verifier can be convinced that a 3SAT formula of size n is satisfiable, with constant soundness, given Õ (√n) unentangled quantum witnesses with O (log n) qubits each. Our protocol relies on Dinur’s version of the PCP Theorem and is inherently non-relativizing. • We show that assuming the famous Additivity Conjecture from quantum information theory, any QMA(2) protocol can be amplified to exponentially small error, and QMA(k) = QMA(2) for all k ≥ 2. • We give evidence that QMA(2) ⊆ PSPACE, by showing that this would follow from “strong amplification” of QMA(2) protocols. • We prove the nonexistence of “perfect disentanglers” for simulating multiple Merlins with one.

•Jan 1, 2008•0 citations

Quantum interactive proofs and the complexity of separability testing

Gus Gutoski, Patrick M. Hayden, Kevin Milner +1 more

We identify a formal connection between physical problems related to the detection of separable (unentangled) quantum states and complexity classes in theoretical computer science. In particular, we show that to nearly every quantum interactive proof complexity class (including $\mathsf{BQP}$, $\mathsf{QMA}$, $\mathsf{QMA}(2)$, and $\mathsf{QSZK}$), there corresponds a natural separability testing problem that is complete for that class. Of particular interest is the fact that the problem of determining whether an isometry can be made to produce a separable state is either $\mathsf{QMA}$-complete or $\mathsf{QMA}(2)$-complete, depending upon whether the distance between quantum states is measured by the one-way LOCC norm or the trace norm. We obtain strong hardness results by employing prior work on entanglement purification protocols to prove that for each $n$-qubit maximally entangled state there exists a fixed one-way LOCC measurement that distinguishes it from any separable state with error probability that decays exponentially in $n$.

arXiv:1308.5788•Theory of Computing•Jan 1, 2015•43 citations

QMA(2) with Limited Shared Entanglement

Alex Della Schiava, Ranitha Mataraarachchi

In $\mathsf{QMA}(2)$, two computationally unbounded provers submit unentangled quantum witnesses to a polynomial-time quantum verifier. We ask whether allowing limited shared entanglement between the two provers changes the power of $\mathsf{QMA}(2)$. To this end, we formalize $\mathsf{QMA}(2;h)$, a variant in which the provers initially share $h$ EPR pairs, as suggested by Aaronson, Beigi, Drucker, Fefferman, and Shor (ToC~2009). We show that polynomially many shared EPR pairs give the provers no cheating advantage: $\mathsf{QMA}(2)\subseteq\mathsf{QMA}(2;h)$ for $h=\operatorname{poly}(n)$. For logarithmically many pairs, the power of $\mathsf{QMA}(2)$ remains unchanged, strengthening this inclusion to $\mathsf{QMA}(2)=\mathsf{QMA}(2;h)$ for $h=O(\log n)$. Finally, we introduce a variant that also allows classical communication between the provers when preparing the witnesses. This setting is particularly revealing for logarithmic-size witnesses: assuming $\mathsf{NP}\nsubseteq\mathsf{BQP}$, we show that superlogarithmically many shared EPR pairs strictly reduce the model's computational power.

quant-pharXiv:2609.39668•Oct 1, 2026•0 citations

The Power of Unentanglement

Scott Aaronson, Salman Beigi, Andrew Drucker +2 more

The class QMA(k), introduced by Kobayashi et al., consists of all languages that can be verified using k unentangled quantum proofs. Many of the simplest questions about this class have remained embarrassingly open: for example, can we give any evidence that k quantum proofs are more powerful than one? Can we show any upper bound on QMA(k), besides the trivial NEXP? Does QMA(k)=QMA(2) for kges2? Can QMA(k) protocols be amplified to exponentially small error? In this paper, we make progress on all of the above questions. *We give a protocol by which a verifier can be convinced that a 3SAT formula of size n is satisfiable, with constant soundness, given O tilde(radicn) unentangled quantum witnesses with O(log n) qubits each. Our protocol relies on Dinur's version of the PCP Theorem and is inherently non-relativizing. *We show that assuming the famous Additivity Conjecture from quantum information theory, any QMA(2) protocol can be amplified to exponentially small error, and QMA(k)=QMA(2) for all kges=2. *We give evidence that QMA(2) sube PSPACE, by showing that this would follow from "strong amplification" of QMA(2) protocols. *We prove the nonexistence of "perfect disentanglers" for simulating multiple Merlins with one.

IEEE Conference on Computational Complexity (CCC)•Jun 1, 2008•31 citations

Quantum proof systems and entanglement theory

Salman Abolfathe Beikidezfuli

Quantum complexity theory is important from the point of view of not only theory of computation but also quantum information theory. In particular, quantum multi-prover interactive proof systems are defined based on complexity theory notions, while their characterization can be formulated using LOCC operations. On the other hand, the main resource in quantum information theory is entanglement, which can be considered as a monotonic decreasing quantity under LOCC maps. Indeed, any result in quantum proof systems can be translated to entanglement theory, and vice versa. In this thesis I mostly focus on quantum Merlin-Arthur games as a proof system in quantum complexity theory. I present a new complete problem for the complexity class QMA. I also show that computing both the Holevo capacity and the minimum output entropy of quantum channels are NP-hard. Then I move to the multiple-Merlin-Arthur games and show that assuming some additivity conjecture for entanglement of formation, we can amplify the gap in QMA(2) protocols. Based on the same assumption, I show that the QMA(k)-hierarchy collapses to QMA(2). I also prove that QMAlog(2), which is defined the same as QMA(2) except that the size of witnesses is logarithmic, with the gap n-(3+e) contains NP. Finally, motivated by the previous results, I show that the positive partial transpose test gives no bound on the trace distance of a given bipartite state from the set of separable states.

•Jan 1, 2009•0 citations
Quantum entanglement is a fundamental property of quantum mechanics and it serves as a basic resource in quantum computation and information. Despite its importance, the power and limitations of quantum entanglement are far from being fully understood. Here, we study entanglement via the lens of computational complexity. This is done by studying quantum generalizations of the class NP with multiple unentangled quantum proofs, the so-called QMA(2) and its variants. The complexity of QMA(2) is known to be closely connected to a variety of problems such as deciding if a state is entangled and several classical optimization problems. However, determining the complexity of QMA(2) is a longstanding open problem, and only the trivial complexity bounds ⊆ (2) ⊆ are known.
The complexity class QMA(2), featuring two unentangled quantum provers, occupies a central yet poorly understood position in quantum complexity theory. While superficially a modest extension of QMA, unentanglement fundamentally changes both the algorithmic and complexitytheoretic landscape, connecting QMA(2) to deep questions in separability testing, polynomial optimization, and hardness of approximation. Over the past two decades, QMA(2) has inspired a rich body of work spanning restricted verification models, semidefinite and Sum-of-Squares hierarchies, and surprising links to classical problems such as the Unique Games Conjecture. This survey provides an overview of these developments, emphasizing structural insights, algorithmic techniques, and known barriers, while highlighting how progress on QMA(2) continues to illuminate the interplay between quantum information, convex optimization, and classical complexity theory.
The class QMA(k), introduced by Kobayashi et al., consists of all languages that can be verified using k unentangled quantum proofs. Many of the simplest questions about this class have remained embarrassingly open: for example, can we give any evidence that k quantum proofs are more powerful than one? Can we show any upper bound on QMA(k), besides the trivial NEXP? Does QMA(k) = QMA(2) for k ≥ 2? Can QMA(k) protocols be amplified to exponentially small error? In this paper, we make progress on all of the above questions. • We give a protocol by which a verifier can be convinced that a 3SAT formula of size n is satisfiable, with constant soundness, given Õ (√n) unentangled quantum witnesses with O (log n) qubits each. Our protocol relies on Dinur’s version of the PCP Theorem and is inherently non-relativizing. • We show that assuming the famous Additivity Conjecture from quantum information theory, any QMA(2) protocol can be amplified to exponentially small error, and QMA(k) = QMA(2) for all k ≥ 2. • We give evidence that QMA(2) ⊆ PSPACE, by showing that this would follow from “strong amplification” of QMA(2) protocols. • We prove the nonexistence of “perfect disentanglers” for simulating multiple Merlins with one.
We identify a formal connection between physical problems related to the detection of separable (unentangled) quantum states and complexity classes in theoretical computer science. In particular, we show that to nearly every quantum interactive proof complexity class (including BQP\mathsf{BQP}BQP, QMA\mathsf{QMA}QMA, QMA(2)\mathsf{QMA}(2)QMA(2), and QSZK\mathsf{QSZK}QSZK), there corresponds a natural separability testing problem that is complete for that class. Of particular interest is the fact that the problem of determining whether an isometry can be made to produce a separable state is either QMA\mathsf{QMA}QMA-complete or QMA(2)\mathsf{QMA}(2)QMA(2)-complete, depending upon whether the distance between quantum states is measured by the one-way LOCC norm or the trace norm. We obtain strong hardness results by employing prior work on entanglement purification protocols to prove that for each nnn-qubit maximally entangled state there exists a fixed one-way LOCC measurement that distinguishes it from any separable state with error probability that decays exponentially in nnn.
In QMA(2)\mathsf{QMA}(2)QMA(2), two computationally unbounded provers submit unentangled quantum witnesses to a polynomial-time quantum verifier. We ask whether allowing limited shared entanglement between the two provers changes the power of QMA(2)\mathsf{QMA}(2)QMA(2). To this end, we formalize QMA(2;h)\mathsf{QMA}(2;h)QMA(2;h), a variant in which the provers initially share hhh EPR pairs, as suggested by Aaronson, Beigi, Drucker, Fefferman, and Shor (ToC~2009). We show that polynomially many shared EPR pairs give the provers no cheating advantage: QMA(2)⊆QMA(2;h)\mathsf{QMA}(2)\subseteq\mathsf{QMA}(2;h)QMA(2)⊆QMA(2;h) for h=poly⁡(n)h=\operatorname{poly}(n)h=poly(n). For logarithmically many pairs, the power of QMA(2)\mathsf{QMA}(2)QMA(2) remains unchanged, strengthening this inclusion to QMA(2)=QMA(2;h)\mathsf{QMA}(2)=\mathsf{QMA}(2;h)QMA(2)=QMA(2;h) for h=O(log⁡n)h=O(\log n)h=O(logn). Finally, we introduce a variant that also allows classical communication between the provers when preparing the witnesses. This setting is particularly revealing for logarithmic-size witnesses: assuming NP⊈BQP\mathsf{NP}\nsubseteq\mathsf{BQP}NP⊈BQP, we show that superlogarithmically many shared EPR pairs strictly reduce the model's computational power.
The class QMA(k), introduced by Kobayashi et al., consists of all languages that can be verified using k unentangled quantum proofs. Many of the simplest questions about this class have remained embarrassingly open: for example, can we give any evidence that k quantum proofs are more powerful than one? Can we show any upper bound on QMA(k), besides the trivial NEXP? Does QMA(k)=QMA(2) for kges2? Can QMA(k) protocols be amplified to exponentially small error? In this paper, we make progress on all of the above questions. *We give a protocol by which a verifier can be convinced that a 3SAT formula of size n is satisfiable, with constant soundness, given O tilde(radicn) unentangled quantum witnesses with O(log n) qubits each. Our protocol relies on Dinur's version of the PCP Theorem and is inherently non-relativizing. *We show that assuming the famous Additivity Conjecture from quantum information theory, any QMA(2) protocol can be amplified to exponentially small error, and QMA(k)=QMA(2) for all kges=2. *We give evidence that QMA(2) sube PSPACE, by showing that this would follow from "strong amplification" of QMA(2) protocols. *We prove the nonexistence of "perfect disentanglers" for simulating multiple Merlins with one.
Quantum complexity theory is important from the point of view of not only theory of computation but also quantum information theory. In particular, quantum multi-prover interactive proof systems are defined based on complexity theory notions, while their characterization can be formulated using LOCC operations. On the other hand, the main resource in quantum information theory is entanglement, which can be considered as a monotonic decreasing quantity under LOCC maps. Indeed, any result in quantum proof systems can be translated to entanglement theory, and vice versa. In this thesis I mostly focus on quantum Merlin-Arthur games as a proof system in quantum complexity theory. I present a new complete problem for the complexity class QMA. I also show that computing both the Holevo capacity and the minimum output entropy of quantum channels are NP-hard. Then I move to the multiple-Merlin-Arthur games and show that assuming some additivity conjecture for entanglement of formation, we can amplify the gap in QMA(2) protocols. Based on the same assumption, I show that the QMA(k)-hierarchy collapses to QMA(2). I also prove that QMAlog(2), which is defined the same as QMA(2) except that the size of witnesses is logarithmic, with the gap n-(3+e) contains NP. Finally, motivated by the previous results, I show that the positive partial transpose test gives no bound on the trace distance of a given bipartite state from the set of separable states.