Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2402.16937 · Physical Review Letters

Exact Calculations of Coherent Information for Toric Codes under Decoherence: Identifying the Fundamental Error Threshold

Jong Yeon Lee

Published May 29, 2025• 44 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The toric code is a canonical example of a topological error-correcting code. Two logical qubits stored within the toric code are robust against local decoherence, ensuring that these qubits can be faithfully retrieved as long as the error rate remains below a certain threshold. Recent studies have explored such a threshold behavior as an intrinsic information-theoretic transition, independent of the decoding protocol. These studies have shown that information-theoretic metrics, calculated using the Renyi (replica) approximation, demonstrate sharp transitions at a specific error rate. However, an exact analytic expression that avoids using the replica trick has not been shown, and the connection between the transition in information-theoretic capacity and the random bond Ising model (RBIM) has only been indirectly established. In this Letter, we present the first analytic expression for the coherent information of a decohered toric code, thereby establishing a rigorous connection between the fundamental error threshold and the criticality of the RBIM.

DOI
10.1103/hlfh-86yz

Related papers

Noisy Toric code and random-bond Ising model: The error threshold in a dual picture

Mohammad Hossein Zarei, Abolfazl Ramezanpour

It is known that noisy topological quantum codes are related to random-bond Ising models where the order-disorder phase transition in the classical model is mapped to the error threshold of the corresponding topological code. On the other hand, there is a dual mapping between classical spin models and quantum Calderbank-Shor-Steane (CSS) states where the partition function of a classical model defined on a hypergraph $H$ is written as an inner product of a product state and a CSS state on dual hypergraph $\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{H}$. It is then interesting to see what the interpretation is of the classical phase transition in the random-bond Ising model within the framework of the above duality, and whether such an interpretation has any connection to the error threshold of the corresponding topological CSS code. In this paper, we consider the above duality relation specifically for a two-dimensional random-bond Ising model. We show that the order parameter of this classical system is mapped to a coherence order parameter in a noisy Toric code model. In particular, a quantum phase transition from a coherent phase to a noncoherent phase occurs when the initial coherent state is affected by two sequences of bit-flip quantum channels where a quenched disorder is induced by measurement of the errors after the first channel. On the other hand, the above transition is directly related to the error threshold of the Toric code model. Accordingly, and since the noisy process can be applied to other topological CSS states, we conclude that the dual correspondence can also provide a useful tool for the study of error thresholds in different topological CSS codes.

arXiv:1911.10494•Physical Review A•Dec 10, 2019•4 citations

Intrinsic Error Thresholds in Nearly Critical Toric Codes

Zack Weinstein, Samuel J. Garratt

We study the protection of information in nearly critical topological quantum codes, constructed by perturbing topological stabilizer codes towards continuous quantum phase transitions. Our focus is on the transverse-field toric code subjected to local Pauli decoherence. Despite the strong quantum fluctuations of anyons when the transverse field is tuned infinitesimally close to the critical point, we show that a finite strength of Pauli decoherence remains necessary to irreversibly destroy information encoded in the ground-state manifold. Using a replica statistical physics mapping for the coherent information, we show that decoherence can be understood as introducing a two-dimensional inter-replica defect within a three-dimensional replica statistical physics model. A field theoretical analysis shows that this defect is perturbatively irrelevant to the bulk critical point, and cannot renormalize the transverse field strength, leading to a finite error threshold. We argue that a qualitatively similar conclusion can be drawn for a broad class of nearly critical topological codes, under a variety of decoherence channels.

cond-mat.stat-mechCross-listedarXiv:2603.14098•Mar 17, 2026•4 citations

Coherent information for Calderbank-Shor-Steane codes under decoherence

Ryotaro Niwa, Jong Yeon Lee

Stabilizer codes lie at the heart of modern quantum-error-correcting codes (QECCs). Of particular importance is a class called Calderbank-Shor-Steane (CSS) codes, which includes many important examples such as toric codes, color codes, and fractons. Recent studies have revealed that the decoding transition for these QECCs could be intrinsically captured by calculating information-theoretic quantities from the mixed state. Here we perform a simple analytic calculation of the coherent information for general CSS codes under local incoherent Pauli errors via diagonalization of the density matrices and mapping to classical statistical mechanical (SM) models. Our result establishes a rigorous connection between the decoding transition of the quantum code and the phase transition in the random classical SM model. It is also directly confirmed for CSS codes that exact error correction is possible if and only if the maximum-likelihood decoder always succeeds in the thermodynamic limit. Thus, the fundamental threshold is saturated by the optimal decoder.

arXiv:2407.02564•Physical Review A•Mar 3, 2025•22 citations

Geometry Dependence of Error Thresholds in Two-Dimensional Toric Codes

D. Lessing, A. Langheld, C. Krämer +2 more

We investigate how the lattice geometry influences the error thresholds of two-dimensional toric codes. In the presence of bit- or phase-flip errors, the toric code maps onto the two-dimensional random-bond Ising model (RBIM). We determine the critical behaviour of the RBIM using replica-exchange Monte Carlo simulations. While previous studies have explored thresholds for general lattice geometries under suboptimal decoders such as minimum-weight perfect matching, the rapid development of near-optimal decoders makes resolving the ultimate, maximum-likelihood code capacity relevant. We compute these optimal error thresholds on the Nishimori line for the square, honeycomb, triangular, dice, and kagome lattices. Owing to lattice duality, the phase-flip threshold on a given lattice is equivalent to the bit-flip threshold on its dual. We find that the optimal thresholds of dual-lattice pairs display a characteristic duality-driven splitting around the self-dual square-lattice, mirroring the qualitative behaviour observed for suboptimal decoders. While the average coordination number has the strongest impact on the error threshold, our results demonstrate that the detailed arrangement of vertices and plaquettes also plays a significant role in determining its precise value.

quant-pharXiv:2609.07579•Sep 8, 2026•1 citation

Mixed-State Topological Order under Coherent Noise

Seunghun Lee, Eun-Gook Moon

Mixed-state phases of matter under local decoherence have recently garnered significant attention due to the ubiquitous presence of noise in current quantum processors. One of the key issues is understanding how topological quantum memory is affected by realistic coherent noise, such as random rotation noise and amplitude-damping noise. In this work, we investigate the intrinsic error threshold of the two-dimensional toric code (TC), a paradigmatic topological quantum memory, under these types of coherent noise by employing both analytical and numerical methods based on the doubled-Hilbert-space formalism. A connection between the mixed-state phase of the decohered TC and a non-Hermitian Ashkin-Teller-type statistical-mechanics model is established, and the mixed-state phase diagrams under the coherent noise are obtained. We find remarkable stability of mixed-state topological order under random rotation noise with axes near the Y axis of qubits. We also identify intriguing extended critical regions at the phase boundaries, highlighting a connection with non-Hermitian physics. We argue that these phase boundaries provide upper bounds for the intrinsic error threshold, beyond which quantum error correction becomes impossible. We complement these findings by estimating the error thresholds for random rotation noise under standard quantum error correction, thereby providing lower bounds on the intrinsic error threshold.

arXiv:2411.03441•PRX Quantum•Jul 7, 2025•11 citations

Ising on the donut: Regimes of topological quantum error correction from statistical mechanics

Lucas H. English, Sam Roberts, Stephen D. Bartlett +2 more

Utility-scale quantum computers require quantum error correcting codes with large numbers of physical qubits to achieve sufficiently low logical error rates. The performance of quantum error correction (QEC) is generally predicted through large-scale numerical simulations, used to estimate thresholds, finite-size scaling, and exponential suppression of logical errors below threshold. The connection of QEC to models from statistical mechanics provides an alternative tool for analysing QEC performance. However, predicting the behaviour of these models also requires large-scale numerical simulations, as analytic solutions are not generally known. Here we exploit an exact mapping, from a toric code under bit-flip noise that is post-selected on being syndrome free to the exactly-solvable two-dimensional Ising model on a torus, to derive an analytic solution for the logical failure rate across its full domain of physical error rates. In particular, this mapping provides closed-form expressions for the logical failure rate in four distinct regimes: the path-counting, below-threshold (ordered), near-threshold (critical), and above-threshold (disordered) regimes. Our framework places a number of familiar and long-standing numerical observations on firm theoretical ground. It also motivates explicit ansatze for the conventional QEC setting of non-post-selected codes whose statistical mechanics mappings involve random-bond disorder. Specifically, we introduce an effective tension model for the below-threshold regime, and a new scaling ansatz for the near-threshold regime, derived from an analysis of the domain wall energy cost distributions. By bridging statistical mechanics theory and quantum error correction practice, our results offer a new toolkit for designing, benchmarking, and understanding topological codes beyond current computational limits.

quant-pharXiv:2512.10399•PRX Quantum•Dec 12, 2025•8 citations
The toric code is a canonical example of a topological error-correcting code. Two logical qubits stored within the toric code are robust against local decoherence, ensuring that these qubits can be faithfully retrieved as long as the error rate remains below a certain threshold. Recent studies have explored such a threshold behavior as an intrinsic information-theoretic transition, independent of the decoding protocol. These studies have shown that information-theoretic metrics, calculated using the Renyi (replica) approximation, demonstrate sharp transitions at a specific error rate. However, an exact analytic expression that avoids using the replica trick has not been shown, and the connection between the transition in information-theoretic capacity and the random bond Ising model (RBIM) has only been indirectly established. In this Letter, we present the first analytic expression for the coherent information of a decohered toric code, thereby establishing a rigorous connection between the fundamental error threshold and the criticality of the RBIM.
It is known that noisy topological quantum codes are related to random-bond Ising models where the order-disorder phase transition in the classical model is mapped to the error threshold of the corresponding topological code. On the other hand, there is a dual mapping between classical spin models and quantum Calderbank-Shor-Steane (CSS) states where the partition function of a classical model defined on a hypergraph HHH is written as an inner product of a product state and a CSS state on dual hypergraph $\stackrel{\ifmmode \tilde{}\else \~{}\fi{}}{H}$. It is then interesting to see what the interpretation is of the classical phase transition in the random-bond Ising model within the framework of the above duality, and whether such an interpretation has any connection to the error threshold of the corresponding topological CSS code. In this paper, we consider the above duality relation specifically for a two-dimensional random-bond Ising model. We show that the order parameter of this classical system is mapped to a coherence order parameter in a noisy Toric code model. In particular, a quantum phase transition from a coherent phase to a noncoherent phase occurs when the initial coherent state is affected by two sequences of bit-flip quantum channels where a quenched disorder is induced by measurement of the errors after the first channel. On the other hand, the above transition is directly related to the error threshold of the Toric code model. Accordingly, and since the noisy process can be applied to other topological CSS states, we conclude that the dual correspondence can also provide a useful tool for the study of error thresholds in different topological CSS codes.
We study the protection of information in nearly critical topological quantum codes, constructed by perturbing topological stabilizer codes towards continuous quantum phase transitions. Our focus is on the transverse-field toric code subjected to local Pauli decoherence. Despite the strong quantum fluctuations of anyons when the transverse field is tuned infinitesimally close to the critical point, we show that a finite strength of Pauli decoherence remains necessary to irreversibly destroy information encoded in the ground-state manifold. Using a replica statistical physics mapping for the coherent information, we show that decoherence can be understood as introducing a two-dimensional inter-replica defect within a three-dimensional replica statistical physics model. A field theoretical analysis shows that this defect is perturbatively irrelevant to the bulk critical point, and cannot renormalize the transverse field strength, leading to a finite error threshold. We argue that a qualitatively similar conclusion can be drawn for a broad class of nearly critical topological codes, under a variety of decoherence channels.
Stabilizer codes lie at the heart of modern quantum-error-correcting codes (QECCs). Of particular importance is a class called Calderbank-Shor-Steane (CSS) codes, which includes many important examples such as toric codes, color codes, and fractons. Recent studies have revealed that the decoding transition for these QECCs could be intrinsically captured by calculating information-theoretic quantities from the mixed state. Here we perform a simple analytic calculation of the coherent information for general CSS codes under local incoherent Pauli errors via diagonalization of the density matrices and mapping to classical statistical mechanical (SM) models. Our result establishes a rigorous connection between the decoding transition of the quantum code and the phase transition in the random classical SM model. It is also directly confirmed for CSS codes that exact error correction is possible if and only if the maximum-likelihood decoder always succeeds in the thermodynamic limit. Thus, the fundamental threshold is saturated by the optimal decoder.
We investigate how the lattice geometry influences the error thresholds of two-dimensional toric codes. In the presence of bit- or phase-flip errors, the toric code maps onto the two-dimensional random-bond Ising model (RBIM). We determine the critical behaviour of the RBIM using replica-exchange Monte Carlo simulations. While previous studies have explored thresholds for general lattice geometries under suboptimal decoders such as minimum-weight perfect matching, the rapid development of near-optimal decoders makes resolving the ultimate, maximum-likelihood code capacity relevant. We compute these optimal error thresholds on the Nishimori line for the square, honeycomb, triangular, dice, and kagome lattices. Owing to lattice duality, the phase-flip threshold on a given lattice is equivalent to the bit-flip threshold on its dual. We find that the optimal thresholds of dual-lattice pairs display a characteristic duality-driven splitting around the self-dual square-lattice, mirroring the qualitative behaviour observed for suboptimal decoders. While the average coordination number has the strongest impact on the error threshold, our results demonstrate that the detailed arrangement of vertices and plaquettes also plays a significant role in determining its precise value.
Mixed-state phases of matter under local decoherence have recently garnered significant attention due to the ubiquitous presence of noise in current quantum processors. One of the key issues is understanding how topological quantum memory is affected by realistic coherent noise, such as random rotation noise and amplitude-damping noise. In this work, we investigate the intrinsic error threshold of the two-dimensional toric code (TC), a paradigmatic topological quantum memory, under these types of coherent noise by employing both analytical and numerical methods based on the doubled-Hilbert-space formalism. A connection between the mixed-state phase of the decohered TC and a non-Hermitian Ashkin-Teller-type statistical-mechanics model is established, and the mixed-state phase diagrams under the coherent noise are obtained. We find remarkable stability of mixed-state topological order under random rotation noise with axes near the Y axis of qubits. We also identify intriguing extended critical regions at the phase boundaries, highlighting a connection with non-Hermitian physics. We argue that these phase boundaries provide upper bounds for the intrinsic error threshold, beyond which quantum error correction becomes impossible. We complement these findings by estimating the error thresholds for random rotation noise under standard quantum error correction, thereby providing lower bounds on the intrinsic error threshold.
Utility-scale quantum computers require quantum error correcting codes with large numbers of physical qubits to achieve sufficiently low logical error rates. The performance of quantum error correction (QEC) is generally predicted through large-scale numerical simulations, used to estimate thresholds, finite-size scaling, and exponential suppression of logical errors below threshold. The connection of QEC to models from statistical mechanics provides an alternative tool for analysing QEC performance. However, predicting the behaviour of these models also requires large-scale numerical simulations, as analytic solutions are not generally known. Here we exploit an exact mapping, from a toric code under bit-flip noise that is post-selected on being syndrome free to the exactly-solvable two-dimensional Ising model on a torus, to derive an analytic solution for the logical failure rate across its full domain of physical error rates. In particular, this mapping provides closed-form expressions for the logical failure rate in four distinct regimes: the path-counting, below-threshold (ordered), near-threshold (critical), and above-threshold (disordered) regimes. Our framework places a number of familiar and long-standing numerical observations on firm theoretical ground. It also motivates explicit ansatze for the conventional QEC setting of non-post-selected codes whose statistical mechanics mappings involve random-bond disorder. Specifically, we introduce an effective tension model for the below-threshold regime, and a new scaling ansatz for the near-threshold regime, derived from an analysis of the domain wall energy cost distributions. By bridging statistical mechanics theory and quantum error correction practice, our results offer a new toolkit for designing, benchmarking, and understanding topological codes beyond current computational limits.