Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2402.14916 · Nature Communications

Entanglement microscopy and tomography in many-body systems

Ting-Tung Wang, Menghan Song, Liuke Lyu, William Witczak‐Krempa, Zi Yang Meng

Published Jan 2, 2025• 23 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum entanglement uncovers the essential principles of quantum matter, yet determining its structure in realistic many-body systems poses significant challenges. Here, we employ a protocol, dubbed entanglement microscopy, to reveal the multipartite entanglement encoded in the full reduced density matrix of the microscopic subregion in spin and fermionic many-body systems. We exemplify our method by studying the phase diagram near quantum critical points (QCP) in 2 spatial dimensions: the transverse field Ising model and a Gross-Neveu-Yukawa transition of Dirac fermions. Our main results are: i) the Ising QCP exhibits short-range entanglement with a finite sudden death of the LN both in space and temperature; ii) the Gross-Neveu QCP has a power-law decaying fermionic LN consistent with conformal field theory (CFT) exponents; iii) going beyond bipartite entanglement, we find no detectable 3-party entanglement with our two witnesses in a large parameter window near the Ising QCP in 2d, in contrast to 1d. We further establish the singular scaling of general multipartite entanglement measures at criticality and present an explicit analysis in the tripartite case. Quantum entanglement contains important information about quantum systems, but its calculation is challenging. Here the authors develop a quantum Monte Carlo technique for full tomography on microscopic subregions of a system, enabling extraction of multipartite quantum entanglement in large scale models.

DOI
10.1038/s41467-024-55354-z

Related papers

Multiparty entanglement microscopy of quantum Ising models in one, two, and three dimensions

Liuke Lyu, Menghan Song, Ting-Tung Wang +2 more

Entanglement microscopy reveals the true quantum correlations among the microscopic building blocks of many-body systems [Nat. Commun. 16, 96 (2025)]. Using this approach, we study the multipartite entanglement of the quantum Ising model in 1D, 2D, and 3D. We first obtain the full reduced density matrix (tomography) of subregions that have at most four sites via quantum Monte Carlo, exact diagonalization, and the exact solution in 1D. We then analyze both bipartite and genuine multipartite entanglement (GME) among the sites in the subregion. To do so, we use a variety of measures including the negativity, as well as a true measure of GME: the genuinely multipartite concurrence (or GME concurrence), and its computationally cheaper lower bound ${I}_{2}$. We provide a complete proof that ${I}_{2}$ bounds the GME concurrence, and show how the symmetries of the state simplify its evaluation. For adjacent sites, we find three- and four-spin GME present across large portions of the phase diagram, reaching a maximum near the quantum critical point. In 1D, we identify the singular scaling of the derivative $d{I}_{2}/dh$ approaching the critical point. We observe a sharp decrease in GME with increasing dimensionality, consistent with the monogamous nature of entanglement. Furthermore, we find that GME vanishes for subregions consisting of nonadjacent sites in both 2D and 3D, offering a stark illustration of the short-ranged nature of entanglement in equilibrium quantum matter [arXiv:2402.06677]. Finally, we analyze the most collective form of entanglement by evaluating the GME concurrence among all spins in the lattice, which can be obtained from a simple observable: the single-site transverse magnetization. This global concurrence is larger in 1D compared to 2D and 3D, but it is relatively less robust against perturbations such as local measurements.

arXiv:2412.12533•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 22, 2025•8 citations

Entanglement architecture of beyond-Landau quantum criticality

Menghan Song, Ting-Tung Wang, Liuke Lyu +2 more

Quantum critical points beyond the Landau paradigm exhibit fractionalized excitations and emergent gauge fields. Here, we use entanglement microscopy--full tomography of the reduced density matrix of small subregions and subsequent extraction of their quantum correlations--to resolve the entanglement architecture near such exotic critical points. We focus on genuine multipartite entanglement (GME). Through unbiased quantum Monte Carlo sampling of RDMs across conventional O(2)/O(3) Wilson-Fisher transitions, and unconventional XY$^*$, and Néel-VBS transitions in (2+1)d, we discover a dichotomy: Landau criticality amplifies GME within compact subregions, while non-Landau criticality redistributes entanglement into larger, loopy configurations. Key signatures at non-Landau criticality include the absence of three-spin GME, and the loss of non-loopy entanglement in unicursal regions. Similar results in a critical resonating valence bond wavefunction confirm this multipartite entanglement structure as a common feature of emergent gauge theories. Our findings reveal a distinct entanglement architecture in beyond-Landau quantum critical theories.

arXiv:2509.09983•Sep 12, 2025•4 citations

Multipartite-entanglement tomography of a quantum simulator

Marco Gabbrielli, Luca Lepori, Luca Pezzè

Multipartite-entanglement tomography, namely the quantum Fisher information (QFI) calculated with respect to different collective operators, allows to fully characterize the phase diagram of the quantum Ising chain in a transverse field with variable-range interaction. In particular, it recognizes the phase stemming from long-range (LR) antiferromagnetic interaction, a capability also shared by the spin squeezing. Furthermore, the QFI locates the quantum critical points, both with vanishing and nonvanishing mass gap. In this case, we also relate the finite-size power-law exponent of the QFI to the critical exponents of the model, finding a signal for the breakdown of conformal invariance in the deep LR regime. Finally, the effect of a finite temperature on the multipartite entanglement, and ultimately on the phase stability, is considered. In light of the current realizations of the model with trapped ions and of the potential measurability of the QFI, our approach yields a promising strategy to probe LR physics in controllable quantum systems.

arXiv:1809.01091•New Journal of Physics•Jan 2, 2019•39 citations

Uncovering entanglement entropy near Gross-Neveu criticality by a high-efficiency fermionic quantum Monte Carlo scanning

Weilun Jiang, Gaopei Pan, Zhe Wang +3 more

Entanglement entropy has become an important tool for identifying phases of matter and phase transitions in quantum systems using quantum Monte Carlo methods. While such approaches have achieved great success in systems composed of interacting spins/bosons, their application to interacting fermionic systems remains limited due to substantially higher computational cost. Here we show a more efficient Monte Carlo algorithm for fermionic systems that enables systematic exploration of entanglement entropy across a wide range of physical parameters. Based on the incremental technique along physical parameters, the method significantly reduces computational effort while maintaining accuracy. Using this approach, we study a two-dimensional square lattice Hubbard model, revealing the phase diagram that includes the Fermi surface and Goldstone modes. We further apply the method to the Gross-Neveu criticality and find that the scaling of the entanglement entropy follows a universal form quantified by the critical exponent ν. Further investigation reveals that the leading coefficient of the entanglement entropy decreases monotonically, rather than developing a local maximum as O(N) transition point. Entanglement entropy is a powerful tool for identifying quantum phases and phase transitions but calculating it in interacting fermionic systems remains challenging. Here, the authors introduce an efficient Monte Carlo method that reduces computational cost and reveals universal scaling across Gross-Neveu fermionic phase transitions.

arXiv:2409.20009•Communications Physics•Aug 4, 2026•12 citations

Designer Monte Carlo simulation for the Gross-Neveu-Yukawa transition

Yuzhi Liu, Wei Wang, Kai Sun +1 more

In this paper, we study the quantum criticality of Dirac fermions via large-scale numerical simulations, focusing on the Gross-Neveu-Yukawa chiral-Ising quantum critical point (QCP) with critical bosonic modes coupled with Dirac fermions. We show that finite-size effects at this QCP can be efficiently minimized via model design, which maximizes the ultraviolet cutoff and at the same time places the bare control parameters closer to the nontrivial fixed point to better expose the critical region. Combined with the efficient self-learning quantum Monte Carlo algorithm, which enables a nonlocal update of the bosonic field, we find that moderately large system size (up to $16\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}16$) is already sufficient to produce robust scaling behavior and critical exponents. The conductance of free Dirac fermions is also calculated, and its frequency dependence is found to be consistent with the scaling behavior predicted by the conformal field theory. The methods and model-design principles developed for this study can be generalized to other fermionic QCPs, and thus provide a promising direction for controlled studies of strongly correlated itinerant systems.

arXiv:1910.07430•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Feb 26, 2020•44 citations

Fermion Disorder Operator at Gross-Neveu and Deconfined Quantum Criticalities

Zi Hong Liu, Weilun Jiang, Bin-Bin Chen +5 more

The fermion disorder operator has been shown to reveal the entanglement information in 1D Luttinger liquids and 2D free and interacting Fermi and non-Fermi liquids emerging at quantum critical points (QCPs) [W. Jiang et al., arXiv:2209.07103]. Here we study, by means of large-scale quantum Monte Carlo simulation, the scaling behavior of the disorder operator in correlated Dirac systems. We first demonstrate the logarithmic scaling behavior of the disorder operator at the Gross-Neveu (GN) chiral Ising and Heisenberg QCPs, where consistent conformal field theory (CFT) content of the GN-QCP in its coefficient is found. Then we study a 2D monopole-free deconfined quantum critical point (DQCP) realized between a quantum-spin Hall insulator and a superconductor. Our data point to negative values of the logarithmic coefficients such that the DQCP does not correspond to a unitary CFT. Density matrix renormalization group calculations of the disorder operator on a 1D DQCP model also detect emergent continuous symmetries.

arXiv:2212.11821•Physical Review Letters•Jun 28, 2023•43 citations
Quantum entanglement uncovers the essential principles of quantum matter, yet determining its structure in realistic many-body systems poses significant challenges. Here, we employ a protocol, dubbed entanglement microscopy, to reveal the multipartite entanglement encoded in the full reduced density matrix of the microscopic subregion in spin and fermionic many-body systems. We exemplify our method by studying the phase diagram near quantum critical points (QCP) in 2 spatial dimensions: the transverse field Ising model and a Gross-Neveu-Yukawa transition of Dirac fermions. Our main results are: i) the Ising QCP exhibits short-range entanglement with a finite sudden death of the LN both in space and temperature; ii) the Gross-Neveu QCP has a power-law decaying fermionic LN consistent with conformal field theory (CFT) exponents; iii) going beyond bipartite entanglement, we find no detectable 3-party entanglement with our two witnesses in a large parameter window near the Ising QCP in 2d, in contrast to 1d. We further establish the singular scaling of general multipartite entanglement measures at criticality and present an explicit analysis in the tripartite case. Quantum entanglement contains important information about quantum systems, but its calculation is challenging. Here the authors develop a quantum Monte Carlo technique for full tomography on microscopic subregions of a system, enabling extraction of multipartite quantum entanglement in large scale models.
Entanglement microscopy reveals the true quantum correlations among the microscopic building blocks of many-body systems [Nat. Commun. 16, 96 (2025)]. Using this approach, we study the multipartite entanglement of the quantum Ising model in 1D, 2D, and 3D. We first obtain the full reduced density matrix (tomography) of subregions that have at most four sites via quantum Monte Carlo, exact diagonalization, and the exact solution in 1D. We then analyze both bipartite and genuine multipartite entanglement (GME) among the sites in the subregion. To do so, we use a variety of measures including the negativity, as well as a true measure of GME: the genuinely multipartite concurrence (or GME concurrence), and its computationally cheaper lower bound I2{I}_{2}I2​. We provide a complete proof that I2{I}_{2}I2​ bounds the GME concurrence, and show how the symmetries of the state simplify its evaluation. For adjacent sites, we find three- and four-spin GME present across large portions of the phase diagram, reaching a maximum near the quantum critical point. In 1D, we identify the singular scaling of the derivative dI2/dhd{I}_{2}/dhdI2​/dh approaching the critical point. We observe a sharp decrease in GME with increasing dimensionality, consistent with the monogamous nature of entanglement. Furthermore, we find that GME vanishes for subregions consisting of nonadjacent sites in both 2D and 3D, offering a stark illustration of the short-ranged nature of entanglement in equilibrium quantum matter [arXiv:2402.06677]. Finally, we analyze the most collective form of entanglement by evaluating the GME concurrence among all spins in the lattice, which can be obtained from a simple observable: the single-site transverse magnetization. This global concurrence is larger in 1D compared to 2D and 3D, but it is relatively less robust against perturbations such as local measurements.
Quantum critical points beyond the Landau paradigm exhibit fractionalized excitations and emergent gauge fields. Here, we use entanglement microscopy--full tomography of the reduced density matrix of small subregions and subsequent extraction of their quantum correlations--to resolve the entanglement architecture near such exotic critical points. We focus on genuine multipartite entanglement (GME). Through unbiased quantum Monte Carlo sampling of RDMs across conventional O(2)/O(3) Wilson-Fisher transitions, and unconventional XY∗^*∗, and Néel-VBS transitions in (2+1)d, we discover a dichotomy: Landau criticality amplifies GME within compact subregions, while non-Landau criticality redistributes entanglement into larger, loopy configurations. Key signatures at non-Landau criticality include the absence of three-spin GME, and the loss of non-loopy entanglement in unicursal regions. Similar results in a critical resonating valence bond wavefunction confirm this multipartite entanglement structure as a common feature of emergent gauge theories. Our findings reveal a distinct entanglement architecture in beyond-Landau quantum critical theories.
Multipartite-entanglement tomography, namely the quantum Fisher information (QFI) calculated with respect to different collective operators, allows to fully characterize the phase diagram of the quantum Ising chain in a transverse field with variable-range interaction. In particular, it recognizes the phase stemming from long-range (LR) antiferromagnetic interaction, a capability also shared by the spin squeezing. Furthermore, the QFI locates the quantum critical points, both with vanishing and nonvanishing mass gap. In this case, we also relate the finite-size power-law exponent of the QFI to the critical exponents of the model, finding a signal for the breakdown of conformal invariance in the deep LR regime. Finally, the effect of a finite temperature on the multipartite entanglement, and ultimately on the phase stability, is considered. In light of the current realizations of the model with trapped ions and of the potential measurability of the QFI, our approach yields a promising strategy to probe LR physics in controllable quantum systems.
Entanglement entropy has become an important tool for identifying phases of matter and phase transitions in quantum systems using quantum Monte Carlo methods. While such approaches have achieved great success in systems composed of interacting spins/bosons, their application to interacting fermionic systems remains limited due to substantially higher computational cost. Here we show a more efficient Monte Carlo algorithm for fermionic systems that enables systematic exploration of entanglement entropy across a wide range of physical parameters. Based on the incremental technique along physical parameters, the method significantly reduces computational effort while maintaining accuracy. Using this approach, we study a two-dimensional square lattice Hubbard model, revealing the phase diagram that includes the Fermi surface and Goldstone modes. We further apply the method to the Gross-Neveu criticality and find that the scaling of the entanglement entropy follows a universal form quantified by the critical exponent ν. Further investigation reveals that the leading coefficient of the entanglement entropy decreases monotonically, rather than developing a local maximum as O(N) transition point. Entanglement entropy is a powerful tool for identifying quantum phases and phase transitions but calculating it in interacting fermionic systems remains challenging. Here, the authors introduce an efficient Monte Carlo method that reduces computational cost and reveals universal scaling across Gross-Neveu fermionic phase transitions.
In this paper, we study the quantum criticality of Dirac fermions via large-scale numerical simulations, focusing on the Gross-Neveu-Yukawa chiral-Ising quantum critical point (QCP) with critical bosonic modes coupled with Dirac fermions. We show that finite-size effects at this QCP can be efficiently minimized via model design, which maximizes the ultraviolet cutoff and at the same time places the bare control parameters closer to the nontrivial fixed point to better expose the critical region. Combined with the efficient self-learning quantum Monte Carlo algorithm, which enables a nonlocal update of the bosonic field, we find that moderately large system size (up to $16\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}16$) is already sufficient to produce robust scaling behavior and critical exponents. The conductance of free Dirac fermions is also calculated, and its frequency dependence is found to be consistent with the scaling behavior predicted by the conformal field theory. The methods and model-design principles developed for this study can be generalized to other fermionic QCPs, and thus provide a promising direction for controlled studies of strongly correlated itinerant systems.
The fermion disorder operator has been shown to reveal the entanglement information in 1D Luttinger liquids and 2D free and interacting Fermi and non-Fermi liquids emerging at quantum critical points (QCPs) [W. Jiang et al., arXiv:2209.07103]. Here we study, by means of large-scale quantum Monte Carlo simulation, the scaling behavior of the disorder operator in correlated Dirac systems. We first demonstrate the logarithmic scaling behavior of the disorder operator at the Gross-Neveu (GN) chiral Ising and Heisenberg QCPs, where consistent conformal field theory (CFT) content of the GN-QCP in its coefficient is found. Then we study a 2D monopole-free deconfined quantum critical point (DQCP) realized between a quantum-spin Hall insulator and a superconductor. Our data point to negative values of the logarithmic coefficients such that the DQCP does not correspond to a unitary CFT. Density matrix renormalization group calculations of the disorder operator on a 1D DQCP model also detect emergent continuous symmetries.