Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2402.02813 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Promising regimes for the observation of topological degeneracy in spin chains

Alexander Sattler, Maria Daghofer

Published Jul 2, 2024• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Both the Haldane spin chain and a topologically dimerized chain feature topologically protected edge states that are expected to be robust against some kind of noise. To elucidate whether it might be feasible to create such edge states in dimerized chains in a controlled manner in solid states environments, e.g., as spin chains on surfaces, as has already been successfully achieved with the Haldane chain, we investigate their robustness with respect to long-range coupling, anisotropies, and finite chain length. The theoretical investigation is based on an alternating Heisenberg spin chain with spin-$1/2$, which is investigated using exact diagonalization. We find that dimerized chains and Haldane chains have robustness against long-range coupling and anisotropies. In particular, dimerized spin chains are significantly more robust than Haldane chains.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.110.024404

Related papers

Robustness of topological edge states in alternating spin chains against environment

Alexander Sattler, Maria Daghofer

Both the Haldane spin-$1$ chain and dimerized chains of spin-$1/2$ exhibit topologically protected edge states that are robust against specific perturbations. Recently, such spin chains have been specifically assembled on surfaces and we investigate here the robustness of these edge states against coupling to the surface. Since no physical system can be considered perfectly isolated, it is crucial to examine whether topological robustness is maintained in the presence of environmental coupling. We apply exact diagonalization to a Lindblad master equation that couples an alternating Heisenberg spin chain based on spins $1/2$ to a surface via various jump operators. The robustness of topological states is assessed via the time evolution of quantities such as the ground-state degeneracy, correlation function, entropy, and magnetization of edge states. We investigate chains built from dimers with antiferromagnetic and ferromagnetic intra-dimer coupling, which resemble Su-Schrieffer-Heeger and the Haldane models, resp., and assess the impact of $z$-axis anisotropy and longer-ranged couplings. Generally, we find that signatures of topological properties are more robust in Su-Schrieffer-Heeger-like chains than in Haldane-like chains.

arXiv:2505.22420•May 28, 2025•1 citation

Local dynamics and detection of topology in spin-1 chains

Alfonso Maiellaro, Hervé Aubin, Andrej Mesaroš +1 more

Antiferromagnetic spin-1 chains host the celebrated symmetry-protected topological Haldane phase, whose spin-$1/2$ edge states were evidenced in bulk by, e.g., electron spin resonance (ESR). To fully reveal and manipulate the spin-$1/2$ degree of freedom, one may build on the recent success in assembling effective spin-1 antiferromagnetic chains from nanographene and porphyrin molecules, and on the nascent technique of combined ESR and scanning tunneling microscopy, which is able to measure the spin dynamics site by site with atomic real-space resolution. In this Letter, we combine exact diagonalization and density matrix renormalization group to investigate the local dynamic spin structure factor of the different phases of the bilinear-biquadratic Hamiltonian with single-ion anisotropy in the presence of an external magnetic field. We find that the signature of the Haldane phase is a low-energy peak created by singlet-triplet transitions in the edge-state manifold. We predict that the signature peak is experimentally observable, although for chains of length above $N=30$ its energy should be first tuned by application of an external magnetic field. We fully characterize the peak in real space and energy, and further show its robustness to weak anisotropy and a relevant range of temperatures.

arXiv:2312.07147•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Dec 23, 2024•4 citations

Tunable topological phases in nanographene-based spin-1/2 alternating-exchange Heisenberg chains

Chenxiao Zhao, Gonçalo Catarina, Jinjiang Zhang +8 more

Unlocking the potential of topological order within many-body spin systems has long been a central pursuit in the realm of quantum materials. Despite extensive efforts, the quest for a versatile platform enabling site-selective spin manipulation, essential for tuning and probing diverse topological phases, has persisted. Here, we utilize on-surface synthesis to construct spin-1/2 alternating-exchange Heisenberg (AH) chains[1] with antiferromagnetic couplings $J_1$ and $J_2$ by covalently linking Clar's goblets -- nanographenes each hosting two antiferromagnetically-coupled unpaired electrons[2]. Utilizing scanning tunneling microscopy, we exert atomic-scale control over the spin chain lengths, parities and exchange-coupling terminations, and probe their magnetic response by means of inelastic tunneling spectroscopy. Our investigation confirms the gapped nature of bulk excitations in the chains, known as triplons[3]. Besides, the triplon dispersion relation is successfully extracted from the spatial variation of tunneling spectral amplitudes. Furthermore, depending on the parity and termination of chains, we observe varying numbers of in-gap $S=1/2$ edge spins, enabling the determination of the degeneracy of distinct topological ground states in the thermodynamic limit-either 1, 2, or 4. By monitoring interactions between these edge spins, we identify the exponential decay of spin correlations. Our experimental findings, corroborated by theoretical calculations, present a phase-controlled many-body platform, opening promising avenues toward the development of spin-based quantum devices.

arXiv:2402.13590•Feb 21, 2024•15 citations

Randomness-driven Quantum Phase Transition in Bond-alternating Haldane Chain

Takayuki Arakawa, Synge Todo, Hajime Takayama

The effect of bond randomness on the spin-gapped ground state of the spin-1 bond-alternating antiferromagnetic Heisenberg chain is discussed. By using the loop cluster quantum Monte Carlo method, we investigate the stability of topological order in terms of the recently proposed twist order parameter [M. Nakamura and S. Todo: Phys. Rev. Lett. 89 (2002) 077204]. It is observed that the dimer phases as well as the Haldane phase of the spin-1 Heisenberg chain are robust against a weak randomness, though the valence-bond-solid-like topological order in the latter phase is destroyed by introducing a disorder stronger than the critical value.

arXiv:cond-mat/0410755•Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Apr 1, 2005•7 citations

Physics of integer-spin antiferromagnetic chains: Haldane gaps and edge states

Th. Jolicœur, O. Golinelli

The antiferromagnetic Heisenberg spin chain with integer spin has a short-range magnetic order and an excitation energy gap above the ground state. This so-called Haldane gap is proportional to the exchange coupling constant J of the Heisenberg chain. In this study, we discuss recent results about the spin dependence of the Haldane gap and conjecture an analytical formula valid asymptotically for large spin values. We then discuss the robustness of the edge states of the spin-1 chain by studying a spin-1 ladder using the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) algorithm. We show that the peculiar hidden topological order of the spin-1 chain disappears smoothly by increasing the ladder rung coupling without any intervening phase transition. This is evidence for the fragile character of the topological order of the spin-1 chain.

arXiv:1906.12207•Comptes Rendus Chimie•Jun 1, 2019•13 citations

Long range ordered, dimerized, large-D and Haldane phases in spin 1 chain compounds

Olga V. Maximova, Sergey V Streltsov, Alexander N. Vasiliev

In 1983, F. Duncan M. Haldane predicted a singlet ground state for isolated integer-spin one-dimensional antiferromagnets with low single-ion anisotropy D. Since then, a lot of species containing chains of integer spin ions were tested to check the basic conjecture on an energy gap separating the continuum of the excited states from the ground state. As a result of these studies, it has been established that there are numerous states competing with the Haldane phase, namely long-range ordered, dimerized, and large-D phases. The long-range magnetic order takes place due to sufficiently strong exchange interactions between adjacent chains. Dimerization results from the alternation of the exchange interactions within the chains. Both uniaxial and rhombic single-ion anisotropies can suppress the Haldane phase, which is robust only until some critical values. The choice between the competing phases depends also on exchange anisotropy. Excellent reviews on the basic results obtained during the first 20 years of investigation of these phenomena provided solid background for the future studies. Here, we present some developments in this field obtained over the next two decades of research on spin-1 chain systems.

Critical reviews in solid state and materials sciences/CRC critical reviews in solid state and materials sciences•Dec 14, 2020•27 citations
Both the Haldane spin chain and a topologically dimerized chain feature topologically protected edge states that are expected to be robust against some kind of noise. To elucidate whether it might be feasible to create such edge states in dimerized chains in a controlled manner in solid states environments, e.g., as spin chains on surfaces, as has already been successfully achieved with the Haldane chain, we investigate their robustness with respect to long-range coupling, anisotropies, and finite chain length. The theoretical investigation is based on an alternating Heisenberg spin chain with spin-1/21/21/2, which is investigated using exact diagonalization. We find that dimerized chains and Haldane chains have robustness against long-range coupling and anisotropies. In particular, dimerized spin chains are significantly more robust than Haldane chains.
Both the Haldane spin-111 chain and dimerized chains of spin-1/21/21/2 exhibit topologically protected edge states that are robust against specific perturbations. Recently, such spin chains have been specifically assembled on surfaces and we investigate here the robustness of these edge states against coupling to the surface. Since no physical system can be considered perfectly isolated, it is crucial to examine whether topological robustness is maintained in the presence of environmental coupling. We apply exact diagonalization to a Lindblad master equation that couples an alternating Heisenberg spin chain based on spins 1/21/21/2 to a surface via various jump operators. The robustness of topological states is assessed via the time evolution of quantities such as the ground-state degeneracy, correlation function, entropy, and magnetization of edge states. We investigate chains built from dimers with antiferromagnetic and ferromagnetic intra-dimer coupling, which resemble Su-Schrieffer-Heeger and the Haldane models, resp., and assess the impact of zzz-axis anisotropy and longer-ranged couplings. Generally, we find that signatures of topological properties are more robust in Su-Schrieffer-Heeger-like chains than in Haldane-like chains.
Antiferromagnetic spin-1 chains host the celebrated symmetry-protected topological Haldane phase, whose spin-1/21/21/2 edge states were evidenced in bulk by, e.g., electron spin resonance (ESR). To fully reveal and manipulate the spin-1/21/21/2 degree of freedom, one may build on the recent success in assembling effective spin-1 antiferromagnetic chains from nanographene and porphyrin molecules, and on the nascent technique of combined ESR and scanning tunneling microscopy, which is able to measure the spin dynamics site by site with atomic real-space resolution. In this Letter, we combine exact diagonalization and density matrix renormalization group to investigate the local dynamic spin structure factor of the different phases of the bilinear-biquadratic Hamiltonian with single-ion anisotropy in the presence of an external magnetic field. We find that the signature of the Haldane phase is a low-energy peak created by singlet-triplet transitions in the edge-state manifold. We predict that the signature peak is experimentally observable, although for chains of length above N=30N=30N=30 its energy should be first tuned by application of an external magnetic field. We fully characterize the peak in real space and energy, and further show its robustness to weak anisotropy and a relevant range of temperatures.
Unlocking the potential of topological order within many-body spin systems has long been a central pursuit in the realm of quantum materials. Despite extensive efforts, the quest for a versatile platform enabling site-selective spin manipulation, essential for tuning and probing diverse topological phases, has persisted. Here, we utilize on-surface synthesis to construct spin-1/2 alternating-exchange Heisenberg (AH) chains[1] with antiferromagnetic couplings J1J_1J1​ and J2J_2J2​ by covalently linking Clar's goblets -- nanographenes each hosting two antiferromagnetically-coupled unpaired electrons[2]. Utilizing scanning tunneling microscopy, we exert atomic-scale control over the spin chain lengths, parities and exchange-coupling terminations, and probe their magnetic response by means of inelastic tunneling spectroscopy. Our investigation confirms the gapped nature of bulk excitations in the chains, known as triplons[3]. Besides, the triplon dispersion relation is successfully extracted from the spatial variation of tunneling spectral amplitudes. Furthermore, depending on the parity and termination of chains, we observe varying numbers of in-gap S=1/2S=1/2S=1/2 edge spins, enabling the determination of the degeneracy of distinct topological ground states in the thermodynamic limit-either 1, 2, or 4. By monitoring interactions between these edge spins, we identify the exponential decay of spin correlations. Our experimental findings, corroborated by theoretical calculations, present a phase-controlled many-body platform, opening promising avenues toward the development of spin-based quantum devices.
The effect of bond randomness on the spin-gapped ground state of the spin-1 bond-alternating antiferromagnetic Heisenberg chain is discussed. By using the loop cluster quantum Monte Carlo method, we investigate the stability of topological order in terms of the recently proposed twist order parameter [M. Nakamura and S. Todo: Phys. Rev. Lett. 89 (2002) 077204]. It is observed that the dimer phases as well as the Haldane phase of the spin-1 Heisenberg chain are robust against a weak randomness, though the valence-bond-solid-like topological order in the latter phase is destroyed by introducing a disorder stronger than the critical value.
The antiferromagnetic Heisenberg spin chain with integer spin has a short-range magnetic order and an excitation energy gap above the ground state. This so-called Haldane gap is proportional to the exchange coupling constant J of the Heisenberg chain. In this study, we discuss recent results about the spin dependence of the Haldane gap and conjecture an analytical formula valid asymptotically for large spin values. We then discuss the robustness of the edge states of the spin-1 chain by studying a spin-1 ladder using the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) algorithm. We show that the peculiar hidden topological order of the spin-1 chain disappears smoothly by increasing the ladder rung coupling without any intervening phase transition. This is evidence for the fragile character of the topological order of the spin-1 chain.
In 1983, F. Duncan M. Haldane predicted a singlet ground state for isolated integer-spin one-dimensional antiferromagnets with low single-ion anisotropy D. Since then, a lot of species containing chains of integer spin ions were tested to check the basic conjecture on an energy gap separating the continuum of the excited states from the ground state. As a result of these studies, it has been established that there are numerous states competing with the Haldane phase, namely long-range ordered, dimerized, and large-D phases. The long-range magnetic order takes place due to sufficiently strong exchange interactions between adjacent chains. Dimerization results from the alternation of the exchange interactions within the chains. Both uniaxial and rhombic single-ion anisotropies can suppress the Haldane phase, which is robust only until some critical values. The choice between the competing phases depends also on exchange anisotropy. Excellent reviews on the basic results obtained during the first 20 years of investigation of these phenomena provided solid background for the future studies. Here, we present some developments in this field obtained over the next two decades of research on spin-1 chain systems.