Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2402.00736 · Physical Review Research

Global sampling of Feynman's diagrams through normalizing flow

Luca Leoni, Cesare Franchini

Published Jul 8, 2024• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Normalizing flows (NF) are powerful generative models with increasing applications in augmenting Monte Carlo algorithms due to their high flexibility and expressiveness. In this work we explore the integration of NF in the diagrammatic Monte Carlo (DMC) method, presenting an architecture designed to sample the intricate multidimensional space of Feynman's diagrams through dimensionality reduction. By decoupling the sampling of diagram order and interaction times, the flow focuses on one interaction at a time. This enables one to construct a general diagram by employing the same unsupervised model iteratively, dressing a zero-order diagram with interactions determined by the previously sampled order. The resulting NF-augmented DMC method is tested on the widely used single-site Holstein polaron model in the entire electron-phonon coupling regime. The obtained data show that the model accurately reproduces the diagram distribution by reducing sample correlation and observables' statistical error, constituting the first example of global sampling strategy for connected Feynman's diagrams in the DMC method. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

DOI
10.1103/physrevresearch.6.033041

Related papers

Flow-Based Generative Sampling for the Auxiliary-Field Hubbard Model

Dominic Schuh

Understanding strongly correlated electron systems remains one of the central challenges in condensed matter physics. Finding ab initio descriptions of non-perturbative systems is of great importance for modeling carbon-based materials such as graphene or fullerenes. In this regime, computational methods become indispensable tools for performing simulations, making predictions, and ultimately comparing to experiments. The Hubbard model offers a minimal description of the dynamics of electrons in such materials. As exact methods are limited to small system sizes by the exponentially growing Hilbert space, larger-scale first-principle studies rely on numerical approaches. Alongside powerful Hamiltonian-based methods, the auxiliary-field description of the model offers a natural setting for Lagrangian-based Monte Carlo sampling. However, substantial challenges, such as lack of ergodicity and the numerical sign problem, arise in these approaches, leading to long autocorrelation times, biased results, and large statistical uncertainties. In recent years, generative models, especially normalizing flows, have been applied extensively to various theories to address shortcomings of traditional Monte Carlo-based algorithms, such as critical slowing down or topological freezing. While these approaches have shown promise in alleviating these issues, a poorly understood and unfavorable scaling of these methods has stalled their progress, and whether they can reach state-of-the-art system sizes in lattice quantum chromodynamics remains to be seen. This motivates the application of these methods to condensed matter systems, where physically relevant system sizes are reachable at substantially smaller scales. In this work, we study for the first time the application of generative models to the finite-temperature auxiliary-field Hubbard model. We begin by employing an equivariant normalizing flow that respects multiple symmetries inherent to the Boltzmann distribution, demonstrating a substantial improvement in sampling efficiency over Hybrid Monte Carlo and standard non-equivariant flows. We further develop Symmetry-Enforcing Stochastic Modulation (SESaMo), a more scalable algorithm capable of modeling both exact and broken symmetries in normalizing flows, and show that it achieves significantly higher effective sample sizes than traditional equivariant techniques at large system sizes. Equipped with SESaMo, we compute physical observables at half-filling in excellent agreement with exact diagonalization at substantially lower computational cost than Hybrid Monte Carlo. We then turn to the doped Hubbard model, where the theory exhibits a numerical sign problem. We introduce an annealing scheme to simulate the Hubbard model at finite chemical potential in the spin basis. Making use of the less severe sign problem in this description, the annealing scheme enables ergodic sampling of the multi-modal distribution, yielding more accurate results with substantially reduced uncertainties compared to state-of-the-art optimized Hybrid Monte Carlo. Lastly, we employ a masked autoencoder for distribution estimation to learn the Boltzmann distribution of the discrete auxiliary-field Hubbard model. Preliminary results show a significantly higher effective sample size compared to normalizing flows with continuous degrees of freedom, while also exhibiting a milder sign problem than the continuous spin basis.

•Aug 31, 2026•0 citations

Diagrammatic Monte Carlo for Finite Systems at Zero Temperature

Stefano Brolli, C. Barbieri, E. Vigezzi

High-order virtual excitations play an important role in microscopic models of nuclear reactions at intermediate energies. However, the factorial growth of their complexity has prevented their consistent inclusion in ab initio many-body calculations. For infinite systems at finite temperature, such drawbacks can be overcome using diagrammatic Monte Carlo techniques to resum entire series of Feynman diagrams. We present a diagrammatic Monte Carlo algorithm that can be applied to self-bound systems with discrete energy levels at zero temperature, and demonstrate its potential for the Richardson model of nuclear pairing. We show that sampling the topological space of diagrams allows the inclusion of high-order excitations that are neglected in state-of-the-art approximations used in nuclear physics and quantum chemistry. We propose that sampling the diagrammatic space can overcome the long-standing gap between our microscopic understanding of structure and reactions in nuclear physics.

arXiv:2501.02646•Physical Review Letters•May 9, 2025•9 citations

Simulating the Hubbard Model with Equivariant Normalizing Flows

Dominic Schuh, Janik Kreit, Evan Berkowitz +4 more

Generative models, particularly normalizing flows, have shown exceptional performance in learning probability distributions across various domains of physics, including statistical mechanics, collider physics, and lattice field theory. In the context of lattice field theory, normalizing flows have been successfully applied to accurately learn the Boltzmann distribution, enabling a range of tasks such as direct estimation of thermodynamic observables and sampling independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.) configurations. In this work, we present a proof-of-concept demonstration that normalizing flows can be used to learn the Boltzmann distribution for the Hubbard model. This model is widely employed to study the electronic structure of graphene and other carbon nanomaterials. State-of-the-art numerical simulations of the Hubbard model, such as those based on Hybrid Monte Carlo (HMC) methods, often suffer from ergodicity issues, potentially leading to biased estimates of physical observables. Our numerical experiments demonstrate that leveraging i.i.d. sampling from the normalizing flow effectively addresses these issues.

arXiv:2501.07371•International Symposium on Lattice Field Theory (LATTICE)•Feb 10, 2025•7 citations

Diagrammatic Monte Carlo Method for Many-Polaron Problems

Andrei S. Mishchenko, Naoto Nagaosa, Nikolay V. Prokof'ev

We introduce the first bold diagrammatic Monte Carlo approach to deal with polaron problems at a finite electron density nonperturbatively, i.e., by including vertex corrections to high orders. Using the Holstein model on a square lattice as a prototypical example, we demonstrate that our method is capable of providing accurate results in the thermodynamic limit in all regimes from a renormalized Fermi liquid to a single polaron, across the nonadiabatic region where Fermi and Debye energies are of the same order of magnitude. By accounting for vertex corrections, the accuracy of the theoretical description is increased by orders of magnitude relative to the lowest-order self-consistent Born approximation employed in most studies. We also find that for the electron-phonon coupling typical for real materials, the quasiparticle effective mass increases and the quasiparticle residue decreases with increasing the electron density at constant electron-phonon coupling strength.

arXiv:1406.4267•Physical Review Letters•Oct 16, 2014•76 citations

Diagrammatic Monte Carlo for the Hubbard Model

Evgeny Kozik, Kris Van Houcke, Emanuel Gull +4 more

We show that Monte Carlo sampling of the Feynman diagrammatic series (DiagMC) can be used for tackling hard fermionic quantum many-body problems in the thermodynamic limit by presenting accurate results for the repulsive Hubbard model in the correlated Fermi liquid regime. Sampling Feynman's diagrammatic series for the single-particle self-energy we can study moderate values of the on-site repulsion ($U/t \sim 4$) and temperatures down to $T/t=1/40$. We compare our results with high temperature series expansion and with single-site and cluster dynamical mean-field theory.

•Jul 5, 2009•0 citations

Decomposing Imaginary-Time Feynman Diagrams Using Separable Basis Functions: Anderson Impurity Model Strong-Coupling Expansion

Jason Kaye, Zhen Huang, Hugo U. R. Strand +1 more

We present a deterministic algorithm for the efficient evaluation of imaginary-time diagrams based on the recently introduced discrete Lehmann representation (DLR) of imaginary-time Green’s functions. In addition to the efficient discretization of diagrammatic integrals afforded by its approximation properties, the DLR basis is separable in imaginary-time, allowing us to decompose diagrams into linear combinations of nested sequences of one-dimensional products and convolutions. Focusing on the strong-coupling bold-line expansion of generalized Anderson impurity models, we show that our strategy reduces the computational complexity of evaluating an M th-order diagram at inverse temperature β and spectral width ω max from O ( ( β ω max ) 2 M − 1 ) for a direct quadrature to O ( M ( log ( β ω max ) ) M + 1 ) , with controllable high-order accuracy. We benchmark our algorithm using third-order expansions for multiband impurity problems with off-diagonal hybridization and spin-orbit coupling, presenting comparisons with exact diagonalization and quantum Monte Carlo approaches. In particular, we perform a self-consistent dynamical mean-field theory calculation for a three-band Hubbard model with strong spin-orbit coupling representing a minimal model of Ca 2 RuO 4 , demonstrating the promise of the method for modeling realistic strongly correlated multiband materials. For both strong and weak coupling expansions of low and intermediate order, in which diagrams can be enumerated, our method provides an efficient, straightforward, and robust blackbox evaluation procedure. In this sense, it fills a gap between diagrammatic approximations of the lowest order, which are simple and inexpensive but inaccurate, and those based on Monte Carlo sampling of high-order diagrams. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2307.08566•Physical Review X•Aug 26, 2024•17 citations
Normalizing flows (NF) are powerful generative models with increasing applications in augmenting Monte Carlo algorithms due to their high flexibility and expressiveness. In this work we explore the integration of NF in the diagrammatic Monte Carlo (DMC) method, presenting an architecture designed to sample the intricate multidimensional space of Feynman's diagrams through dimensionality reduction. By decoupling the sampling of diagram order and interaction times, the flow focuses on one interaction at a time. This enables one to construct a general diagram by employing the same unsupervised model iteratively, dressing a zero-order diagram with interactions determined by the previously sampled order. The resulting NF-augmented DMC method is tested on the widely used single-site Holstein polaron model in the entire electron-phonon coupling regime. The obtained data show that the model accurately reproduces the diagram distribution by reducing sample correlation and observables' statistical error, constituting the first example of global sampling strategy for connected Feynman's diagrams in the DMC method. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
Understanding strongly correlated electron systems remains one of the central challenges in condensed matter physics. Finding ab initio descriptions of non-perturbative systems is of great importance for modeling carbon-based materials such as graphene or fullerenes. In this regime, computational methods become indispensable tools for performing simulations, making predictions, and ultimately comparing to experiments. The Hubbard model offers a minimal description of the dynamics of electrons in such materials. As exact methods are limited to small system sizes by the exponentially growing Hilbert space, larger-scale first-principle studies rely on numerical approaches. Alongside powerful Hamiltonian-based methods, the auxiliary-field description of the model offers a natural setting for Lagrangian-based Monte Carlo sampling. However, substantial challenges, such as lack of ergodicity and the numerical sign problem, arise in these approaches, leading to long autocorrelation times, biased results, and large statistical uncertainties. In recent years, generative models, especially normalizing flows, have been applied extensively to various theories to address shortcomings of traditional Monte Carlo-based algorithms, such as critical slowing down or topological freezing. While these approaches have shown promise in alleviating these issues, a poorly understood and unfavorable scaling of these methods has stalled their progress, and whether they can reach state-of-the-art system sizes in lattice quantum chromodynamics remains to be seen. This motivates the application of these methods to condensed matter systems, where physically relevant system sizes are reachable at substantially smaller scales. In this work, we study for the first time the application of generative models to the finite-temperature auxiliary-field Hubbard model. We begin by employing an equivariant normalizing flow that respects multiple symmetries inherent to the Boltzmann distribution, demonstrating a substantial improvement in sampling efficiency over Hybrid Monte Carlo and standard non-equivariant flows. We further develop Symmetry-Enforcing Stochastic Modulation (SESaMo), a more scalable algorithm capable of modeling both exact and broken symmetries in normalizing flows, and show that it achieves significantly higher effective sample sizes than traditional equivariant techniques at large system sizes. Equipped with SESaMo, we compute physical observables at half-filling in excellent agreement with exact diagonalization at substantially lower computational cost than Hybrid Monte Carlo. We then turn to the doped Hubbard model, where the theory exhibits a numerical sign problem. We introduce an annealing scheme to simulate the Hubbard model at finite chemical potential in the spin basis. Making use of the less severe sign problem in this description, the annealing scheme enables ergodic sampling of the multi-modal distribution, yielding more accurate results with substantially reduced uncertainties compared to state-of-the-art optimized Hybrid Monte Carlo. Lastly, we employ a masked autoencoder for distribution estimation to learn the Boltzmann distribution of the discrete auxiliary-field Hubbard model. Preliminary results show a significantly higher effective sample size compared to normalizing flows with continuous degrees of freedom, while also exhibiting a milder sign problem than the continuous spin basis.
High-order virtual excitations play an important role in microscopic models of nuclear reactions at intermediate energies. However, the factorial growth of their complexity has prevented their consistent inclusion in ab initio many-body calculations. For infinite systems at finite temperature, such drawbacks can be overcome using diagrammatic Monte Carlo techniques to resum entire series of Feynman diagrams. We present a diagrammatic Monte Carlo algorithm that can be applied to self-bound systems with discrete energy levels at zero temperature, and demonstrate its potential for the Richardson model of nuclear pairing. We show that sampling the topological space of diagrams allows the inclusion of high-order excitations that are neglected in state-of-the-art approximations used in nuclear physics and quantum chemistry. We propose that sampling the diagrammatic space can overcome the long-standing gap between our microscopic understanding of structure and reactions in nuclear physics.
Generative models, particularly normalizing flows, have shown exceptional performance in learning probability distributions across various domains of physics, including statistical mechanics, collider physics, and lattice field theory. In the context of lattice field theory, normalizing flows have been successfully applied to accurately learn the Boltzmann distribution, enabling a range of tasks such as direct estimation of thermodynamic observables and sampling independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.) configurations. In this work, we present a proof-of-concept demonstration that normalizing flows can be used to learn the Boltzmann distribution for the Hubbard model. This model is widely employed to study the electronic structure of graphene and other carbon nanomaterials. State-of-the-art numerical simulations of the Hubbard model, such as those based on Hybrid Monte Carlo (HMC) methods, often suffer from ergodicity issues, potentially leading to biased estimates of physical observables. Our numerical experiments demonstrate that leveraging i.i.d. sampling from the normalizing flow effectively addresses these issues.
We introduce the first bold diagrammatic Monte Carlo approach to deal with polaron problems at a finite electron density nonperturbatively, i.e., by including vertex corrections to high orders. Using the Holstein model on a square lattice as a prototypical example, we demonstrate that our method is capable of providing accurate results in the thermodynamic limit in all regimes from a renormalized Fermi liquid to a single polaron, across the nonadiabatic region where Fermi and Debye energies are of the same order of magnitude. By accounting for vertex corrections, the accuracy of the theoretical description is increased by orders of magnitude relative to the lowest-order self-consistent Born approximation employed in most studies. We also find that for the electron-phonon coupling typical for real materials, the quasiparticle effective mass increases and the quasiparticle residue decreases with increasing the electron density at constant electron-phonon coupling strength.
We show that Monte Carlo sampling of the Feynman diagrammatic series (DiagMC) can be used for tackling hard fermionic quantum many-body problems in the thermodynamic limit by presenting accurate results for the repulsive Hubbard model in the correlated Fermi liquid regime. Sampling Feynman's diagrammatic series for the single-particle self-energy we can study moderate values of the on-site repulsion (U/t∼4U/t \sim 4U/t∼4) and temperatures down to T/t=1/40T/t=1/40T/t=1/40. We compare our results with high temperature series expansion and with single-site and cluster dynamical mean-field theory.
We present a deterministic algorithm for the efficient evaluation of imaginary-time diagrams based on the recently introduced discrete Lehmann representation (DLR) of imaginary-time Green’s functions. In addition to the efficient discretization of diagrammatic integrals afforded by its approximation properties, the DLR basis is separable in imaginary-time, allowing us to decompose diagrams into linear combinations of nested sequences of one-dimensional products and convolutions. Focusing on the strong-coupling bold-line expansion of generalized Anderson impurity models, we show that our strategy reduces the computational complexity of evaluating an M th-order diagram at inverse temperature β and spectral width ω max from O ( ( β ω max ) 2 M − 1 ) for a direct quadrature to O ( M ( log ( β ω max ) ) M + 1 ) , with controllable high-order accuracy. We benchmark our algorithm using third-order expansions for multiband impurity problems with off-diagonal hybridization and spin-orbit coupling, presenting comparisons with exact diagonalization and quantum Monte Carlo approaches. In particular, we perform a self-consistent dynamical mean-field theory calculation for a three-band Hubbard model with strong spin-orbit coupling representing a minimal model of Ca 2 RuO 4 , demonstrating the promise of the method for modeling realistic strongly correlated multiband materials. For both strong and weak coupling expansions of low and intermediate order, in which diagrams can be enumerated, our method provides an efficient, straightforward, and robust blackbox evaluation procedure. In this sense, it fills a gap between diagrammatic approximations of the lowest order, which are simple and inexpensive but inaccurate, and those based on Monte Carlo sampling of high-order diagrams. Published by the American Physical Society 2024