Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2401.17006 · Quantum

Classical certification of quantum gates under the dimension assumption

Jan Nöller, Nikolai Miklin, Martin Kliesch, Mariami Gachechiladze

Published Aug 8, 2025• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The rapid advancement of quantum hardware necessitates the development of reliable methods to certify its correct functioning. However, existing certification tests fall short, as they either suffer from systematic errors or do not guarantee that only a correctly functioning quantum device can pass the test. We introduce a certification method for quantum gates tailored for a practical server-user scenario, where a classical user tests the results of exact quantum computations performed by a quantum server. This method is free from the systematic state preparation and measurement (SPAM) errors. For single-qubit gates, including those that form a universal set for single-qubit quantum computation, we demonstrate that our approach offers soundness guarantees based solely on the dimension assumption. Additionally, for a highly-relevant phase gate – which corresponds experimentally to a π/2 -pulse – we prove that the method's sample complexity scales as O(ε−1) relative to the average gate infidelity ε . By combining the SPAM-error-free and sound notion of certification with practical applicability, our approach paves the way for promising research into efficient and reliable certification methods for full-scale quantum computation.

DOI
10.22331/q-2025-08-08-1825

Related papers

Sound and Efficient Certification of High-Quality Qubit Operations: Theory and Experiment

Nikolai Miklin, Jan Nöller, José Martínez +4 more

Can a high-quality quantum gate be certified when uncharacterized state-preparation and measurement errors are dominant? Can this be achieved with low experimental overhead? Here, we introduce a sound black-box certification protocol for a single-qubit gate based on a small set of fixed, deterministic sequences. From the data, the protocol derives finite-sample bounds on the gate's rotation eigenvalue, a gauge-invariant property. Its phase reveals the accuracy of the rotation angle, while its modulus quantifies the loss of coherence under repeated gate applications. We implement the protocol on a $^{40}\mathrm{Ca}^{+}$ trapped-ion processor and certify the $\sqrt{\mathrm{X}}$-gate rotation eigenvalue using $22\,000$ circuit executions, and demonstrate the robustness of certification to state-preparation and measurement errors by deliberately degrading the readout. Finally, we prove that these spectral constraints imply, up to a physically meaningful unitary change of basis, a rigorous average gate-fidelity lower bound for every time-independent qubit model compatible with the data. In both readout settings, the spectral bounds yield the same fidelity certificate of $99.94(3)\%$ with $99\%$ confidence. Our results establish a new standard for quantum-gate certification by combining soundness and experimental efficiency without requiring trusted reference operations, randomized circuits, or model fitting.

quant-pharXiv:2608.17005•Aug 19, 2026•0 citations

Benchmarking gate-based quantum computers via certification of qubit von Neumann measurements

Paulina Lewandowska, Martin Beseda

Abstract In this report, we explore benchmarking gate-based quantum devices based on the certification of quantum measurements, which can be viewed as an extension of quantum hypothesis testing. Here, we are interested in a binary certification scheme in which the null and alternative hypotheses are qubit von Neumann measurements. The certification procedure can be used to evaluate the accuracy of Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum devices. To support this methodology, we contribute benchmarks to PyQBench, an open-source Python library for benchmarking gate-based quantum computers. We provide a user-friendly command-line interface for certifying measurements from the Fourier family. For more advanced scenarios, PyQBench can also be used as a Python library, allowing users to define custom measurement schemes and error models. The latest version of PyQBench is designed to support IBM Q devices through integration with the Qiskit library, enabling seamless benchmarking on real quantum hardware. By providing flexible benchmarking tools, PyQBench addresses the critical need for reliable performance metrics in the NISQ era, contributing to the development of error mitigation techniques and the verification of quantum measurement fidelity.

•Nov 4, 2025•2 citations

Efficient Experimental Verification of Quantum Gates with Local Operations

Rui-Qi Zhang, Zhibo Hou, Jun-Feng Tang +5 more

Verifying the correct functioning of quantum gates is a crucial step toward reliable quantum information processing, but it becomes an overwhelming challenge as the system size grows due to the dimensionality curse. Recent theoretical breakthroughs show that it is possible to verify various important quantum gates with the optimal sample complexity of O(1/ε) using local operations only, where ε is the estimation precision. In this Letter, we propose a variant of quantum gate verification (QGV) that is robust to practical gate imperfections and experimentally realize efficient QGV on a 2-qubit controlled-not gate and a 3-qubit Toffoli gate using only local state preparations and measurements. The experimental results show that, by using only 1600 and 2600 measurements on average, we can verify with 95% confidence level that the implemented controlled-not gate and Toffoli gate have fidelities of at least 99% and 97%, respectively. Demonstrating the superior low sample complexity and experimental feasibility of QGV, our work promises a solution to the dimensionality curse in verifying large quantum devices in the quantum era.

arXiv:2107.02365•Physical Review Letters•Jan 14, 2022•9 citations

Sample-Efficient Device-Independent Quantum State Verification and Certification

Aleksandra Gočanin, Ivan Šupić, Borivoje Dakić

Authentication of quantum sources is a crucial task in building reliable and efficient protocols for quantum-information processing.Steady progress vis-à-vis verification of quantum devices in the scenario with fully characterized measurement devices has been observed in recent years.When it comes to the scenario with uncharacterized measurements, the so-called black-box scenario, practical verification methods are still rather scarce.Development of self-testing methods is an important step forward, but these results so far have been used for reliable verification only by considering the asymptotic behavior of large, identically and independently distributed (IID) samples of a quantum resource.Such strong assumptions deprive the verification procedure of its truly device-independent character.In this paper, we develop a systematic approach to device-independent verification of quantum states free of IID assumptions in the finite copy regime.Remarkably, we show that device-independent verification can be performed with optimal sample efficiency.Finally, for the case of independent copies, we develop a device-independent protocol for quantum state certification: a protocol in which a fragment of the resource copies is measured to warrant the rest of the copies to be close to some target state.

arXiv:2105.05832•PRX Quantum•Feb 1, 2022•39 citations

Robust Device-Independent Certification of Boolean-Phase Gates

Yunguang Han, Xingyuan Bu, Aleksandra Gočanin +1 more

Device-independent certification of a quantum gate requires the input and output tests to identify the same reference qubits. Self-testing the output Choi state alone does not guarantee this consistency. We develop a robust certification scheme for Boolean-phase gates, a broad family of computational-basis diagonal gates specified by Boolean functions. Boolean derivatives convert the target-dependent phase information into classical signs that can be evaluated from local measurement outcomes. This leads to Bell tests built from CHSH blocks using two binary measurements per party and no entangling measurements. At maximal violation, the tests self-test the normalized Choi state and the measured observables. Away from the maximum, they give an explicit affine lower bound on the extracted-state squared fidelity that is uniform over all Boolean functions and valid in arbitrary local dimensions. We then combine an identity test and a gate-output test in an independent-source network in which the reference devices use the same physical observables, obtaining a closed-form Choi-fidelity bound for an effective \(n\)-qubit channel. For CCZ, a joint six-party analysis gives a stronger robustness bound without changing the Bell expression or measurement settings. The construction shows how the algebraic structure of a gate can shift target-dependent information from quantum measurement design to classical processing of local outcomes.

quant-pharXiv:2609.09836•Sep 10, 2026•0 citations

Separate and efficient characterization of state-preparation and measurement errors using single-qubit operations

Muhammad Qasim Khan, Leigh Norris, Lorenza Viola

Abstract In many platforms, errors from state-preparation and measurement (SPAM) dominate over single-qubit gate errors. To inform further hardware improvements and the development of more effective SPAM mitigation strategies, it is necessary to separately characterize the error contributions from SP and measurement (M). Here, we show how to construct a protocol that can efficiently and separately characterize the SP and M error parameters by using only high-fidelity single-qubit gates and repeated single-qubit measurements without reset. The measurements are assumed to be non-destructive and M errors are taken to be (spatially and temporally) uncorrelated and classical. Notably, the circuit depth of the protocol is independent of system size, and the target parameters may be characterized to a precision that is only limited by the number of experimental repetitions. We employ our protocol for the parallel characterization of SPAM errors on multiple qubits in the IBM quantum platform devices, where we find SP infidelities up to 6.57% and readout assignment errors up to 19.1%. Using numerical simulations, we also demonstrate how measurement-error mitigation that does not properly account for SP errors generally leads to a biased estimate of measured observable expectation values.

arXiv:2509.19448•Quantum Science and Technology•Apr 28, 2026•4 citations
The rapid advancement of quantum hardware necessitates the development of reliable methods to certify its correct functioning. However, existing certification tests fall short, as they either suffer from systematic errors or do not guarantee that only a correctly functioning quantum device can pass the test. We introduce a certification method for quantum gates tailored for a practical server-user scenario, where a classical user tests the results of exact quantum computations performed by a quantum server. This method is free from the systematic state preparation and measurement (SPAM) errors. For single-qubit gates, including those that form a universal set for single-qubit quantum computation, we demonstrate that our approach offers soundness guarantees based solely on the dimension assumption. Additionally, for a highly-relevant phase gate – which corresponds experimentally to a π/2 -pulse – we prove that the method's sample complexity scales as O(ε−1) relative to the average gate infidelity ε . By combining the SPAM-error-free and sound notion of certification with practical applicability, our approach paves the way for promising research into efficient and reliable certification methods for full-scale quantum computation.
Can a high-quality quantum gate be certified when uncharacterized state-preparation and measurement errors are dominant? Can this be achieved with low experimental overhead? Here, we introduce a sound black-box certification protocol for a single-qubit gate based on a small set of fixed, deterministic sequences. From the data, the protocol derives finite-sample bounds on the gate's rotation eigenvalue, a gauge-invariant property. Its phase reveals the accuracy of the rotation angle, while its modulus quantifies the loss of coherence under repeated gate applications. We implement the protocol on a 40Ca+^{40}\mathrm{Ca}^{+}40Ca+ trapped-ion processor and certify the X\sqrt{\mathrm{X}}X​-gate rotation eigenvalue using 22 00022\,00022000 circuit executions, and demonstrate the robustness of certification to state-preparation and measurement errors by deliberately degrading the readout. Finally, we prove that these spectral constraints imply, up to a physically meaningful unitary change of basis, a rigorous average gate-fidelity lower bound for every time-independent qubit model compatible with the data. In both readout settings, the spectral bounds yield the same fidelity certificate of 99.94(3)%99.94(3)\%99.94(3)% with 99%99\%99% confidence. Our results establish a new standard for quantum-gate certification by combining soundness and experimental efficiency without requiring trusted reference operations, randomized circuits, or model fitting.
Abstract In this report, we explore benchmarking gate-based quantum devices based on the certification of quantum measurements, which can be viewed as an extension of quantum hypothesis testing. Here, we are interested in a binary certification scheme in which the null and alternative hypotheses are qubit von Neumann measurements. The certification procedure can be used to evaluate the accuracy of Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum devices. To support this methodology, we contribute benchmarks to PyQBench, an open-source Python library for benchmarking gate-based quantum computers. We provide a user-friendly command-line interface for certifying measurements from the Fourier family. For more advanced scenarios, PyQBench can also be used as a Python library, allowing users to define custom measurement schemes and error models. The latest version of PyQBench is designed to support IBM Q devices through integration with the Qiskit library, enabling seamless benchmarking on real quantum hardware. By providing flexible benchmarking tools, PyQBench addresses the critical need for reliable performance metrics in the NISQ era, contributing to the development of error mitigation techniques and the verification of quantum measurement fidelity.
Verifying the correct functioning of quantum gates is a crucial step toward reliable quantum information processing, but it becomes an overwhelming challenge as the system size grows due to the dimensionality curse. Recent theoretical breakthroughs show that it is possible to verify various important quantum gates with the optimal sample complexity of O(1/ε) using local operations only, where ε is the estimation precision. In this Letter, we propose a variant of quantum gate verification (QGV) that is robust to practical gate imperfections and experimentally realize efficient QGV on a 2-qubit controlled-not gate and a 3-qubit Toffoli gate using only local state preparations and measurements. The experimental results show that, by using only 1600 and 2600 measurements on average, we can verify with 95% confidence level that the implemented controlled-not gate and Toffoli gate have fidelities of at least 99% and 97%, respectively. Demonstrating the superior low sample complexity and experimental feasibility of QGV, our work promises a solution to the dimensionality curse in verifying large quantum devices in the quantum era.
Authentication of quantum sources is a crucial task in building reliable and efficient protocols for quantum-information processing.Steady progress vis-à-vis verification of quantum devices in the scenario with fully characterized measurement devices has been observed in recent years.When it comes to the scenario with uncharacterized measurements, the so-called black-box scenario, practical verification methods are still rather scarce.Development of self-testing methods is an important step forward, but these results so far have been used for reliable verification only by considering the asymptotic behavior of large, identically and independently distributed (IID) samples of a quantum resource.Such strong assumptions deprive the verification procedure of its truly device-independent character.In this paper, we develop a systematic approach to device-independent verification of quantum states free of IID assumptions in the finite copy regime.Remarkably, we show that device-independent verification can be performed with optimal sample efficiency.Finally, for the case of independent copies, we develop a device-independent protocol for quantum state certification: a protocol in which a fragment of the resource copies is measured to warrant the rest of the copies to be close to some target state.
Device-independent certification of a quantum gate requires the input and output tests to identify the same reference qubits. Self-testing the output Choi state alone does not guarantee this consistency. We develop a robust certification scheme for Boolean-phase gates, a broad family of computational-basis diagonal gates specified by Boolean functions. Boolean derivatives convert the target-dependent phase information into classical signs that can be evaluated from local measurement outcomes. This leads to Bell tests built from CHSH blocks using two binary measurements per party and no entangling measurements. At maximal violation, the tests self-test the normalized Choi state and the measured observables. Away from the maximum, they give an explicit affine lower bound on the extracted-state squared fidelity that is uniform over all Boolean functions and valid in arbitrary local dimensions. We then combine an identity test and a gate-output test in an independent-source network in which the reference devices use the same physical observables, obtaining a closed-form Choi-fidelity bound for an effective nnn-qubit channel. For CCZ, a joint six-party analysis gives a stronger robustness bound without changing the Bell expression or measurement settings. The construction shows how the algebraic structure of a gate can shift target-dependent information from quantum measurement design to classical processing of local outcomes.
Abstract In many platforms, errors from state-preparation and measurement (SPAM) dominate over single-qubit gate errors. To inform further hardware improvements and the development of more effective SPAM mitigation strategies, it is necessary to separately characterize the error contributions from SP and measurement (M). Here, we show how to construct a protocol that can efficiently and separately characterize the SP and M error parameters by using only high-fidelity single-qubit gates and repeated single-qubit measurements without reset. The measurements are assumed to be non-destructive and M errors are taken to be (spatially and temporally) uncorrelated and classical. Notably, the circuit depth of the protocol is independent of system size, and the target parameters may be characterized to a precision that is only limited by the number of experimental repetitions. We employ our protocol for the parallel characterization of SPAM errors on multiple qubits in the IBM quantum platform devices, where we find SP infidelities up to 6.57% and readout assignment errors up to 19.1%. Using numerical simulations, we also demonstrate how measurement-error mitigation that does not properly account for SP errors generally leads to a biased estimate of measured observable expectation values.