Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2401.16728 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Limitations and improvements of the relaxation time approximation in the quantum master equation: Linear conductivity in insulating systems

Ibuki Terada, Sota Kitamura, Hiroshi Watanabe, Hiroaki Ikeda

Published May 17, 2024• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The nonequilibrium steady states of quantum materials have many challenges. Here, we highlight issues with the relaxation time approximation (RTA) for the dc conductivity in insulating systems. The RTA to the quantum master equation (QME) is frequently employed as a simple method, yet this phenomenological approach is exposed as containing a fatal flaw, displaying non-negligible dc conductivity in the linear response regime. We find that the puzzling behavior is caused by the fact that the density matrix in the RTA incompletely incorporates the first order of the external field. To solve this problem, we have derived a calculation scheme based on the QME that ensures correct behavior in low electric fields. Our method reproduces well the overall features of the exact electric currents in the whole field region. It is not time consuming, and its application to lattice systems is straightforward. This method will encourage progress in this research area as a simple way to more accurately describe nonequilibrium steady states.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.109.l180302

Related papers

Reduced density matrix for nonequilibrium steady states: A modified Redfield solution approach

Juzar Thingna, Jian‐Sheng Wang, Peter Hänggi A

We describe a method to obtain the reduced density matrix (RDM) correct up to second order in system-bath coupling in nonequilibrium steady-state situations. The RDM is obtained via a scheme based on analytic continuation, using the time-local Redfield-like quantum master equation, which was earlier used by the same authors [J. Chem. Phys. 136, 194110 (2012)] to obtain the correct thermal equilibrium description. This nonequilibrium modified Redfield solution is then corroborated with the exact RDM obtained via the nonequilibrium Green's function technique for the quantum harmonic oscillator. Lastly, the scheme is compared to different quantum master equations (QMEs), namely the time-local Redfield-like and the Lindblad-like QMEs, in order to illustrate the differences between each of these approaches.

arXiv:1307.2512•Physical Review E•Nov 20, 2013•57 citations

Determinantal quantum theory of d.c. electrical conductivity

André Fortini

\nthe quantum calculation of the d.c. electrical conductivity for an electron system is reconsidered by using an improved form of the long-time solution of the density matrix. The starting time-evolution equation which is written as a linear system in the Liouville space of discrete quantum states, is first solved in terms of Cramer's determinants and next suitably adapted to tranport problems. The calculation of the statistical average of the many-body current density, in the presence of scattering potential, is carried out in the thermodynamic limit, using a characteristic property of collision matrices introduced earlier by van Hove as the so-called $\\delta$-singularity. In contrast to previous methods based on kinetic equations solved by perturbations, Kubo's theory, or Mori type memory functions, the resolution of an integral equation, initially included in Cramer's formulae, is no longer required. Among its major advantages, the method succeeds in overcoming the well known zero frequency divergent behaviour of the conductivity. It also yields an explicit expression of an effective relaxation time which is just constructed out of those diagonal transition sequences responsible for self-energy effects in van Hove's theory. This expression which only assumes the randomization of phases of initial states can be used to get tractable expansions in powers of the collision potential. Its range of validity is limited by the effect of collisions on equilibrium statistics, which is shown to be negligible within the Peierls criterion, $\\hbar / \\tau \\ll \\mu$, $\\tau$ being the relaxation time and $\\mu$ the Fermi energy. Finally, the comparison of the present approach with the elementary transport theory reveals that the relaxation time is close to the standard expression, even though the latter would be exactly recovered, in lowest order of collisions, only on disregarding divergent terms arising beyond second order.\n

Journal de Physique I•May 1, 1992•0 citations

A Perturbative Method for Nonequilibrium Steady State of Open Quantum Systems

Tatsuro Yuge, Ayumu Sugita

We develop a method of calculating the nonequilibrium steady state (NESS) of an open quantum system that is weakly coupled to reservoirs in different equilibrium states. We describe the system using a Redfield-type quantum master equation (QME). We decompose the Redfield QME into a Lindblad-type QME and the remaining part $\mathcal{R}$. Regarding the steady state of the Lindblad QME as the unperturbed solution, we perform a perturbative calculation with respect to $\mathcal{R}$ to obtain the NESS of the Redfield QME. The NESS thus determined is exact up to the first order in the system-reservoir coupling strength (pump/loss rate), which is the same as the order of validity of the QME. An advantage of the proposed method in numerical computation is its applicability to systems larger than those in methods of directly solving the original Redfield QME. We apply the method to a noninteracting fermion system to obtain an analytical expression of the NESS density matrix. We also numerically demonstrate the method in a nonequilibrium quantum spin chain.

arXiv:1409.0312•Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Dec 4, 2014•9 citations

Linear response theory revisited. II. The master equation approach

K. M. van Vliet

We consider a system perturbed by an external field and subject to dissipative processes. From the von Neumann equation for such a system in the weak coupling limit we derive an inhomogeneous master equation, i.e., a master equation with dissipative terms and streaming terms, using Zwanzig’s projection operator technique in Liouville space. From this equation the response function, as well as expressions for the generalized conductivity and susceptibility, is obtained. It is shown that for large times only the diagonal part of the density operator is required. The various expressions are found to be in complete harmony with previous results (Part I) obtained via the van Hove limit of the Kubo–Green linear response formulas. In order to account for the properties at quantum frequencies, the evolution of the nondiagonal part in the weak coupling limit is also established. The complete time dependent behavior of the dynamic variables in the van Hove limit is expressed by B (t) =exp[−(Λd−iℒ0) t] B, where Λd is the master operator and L0 the Liouville operator in the interaction picture. The cause of irreversibility is discussed. Finally, the inhomogeneous master equation is employed to obtain as first moment equation a Boltzmann equation with streaming terms, applicable to quantum systems.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Dec 1, 1979•81 citations

Going beyond quantum Markovianity and back to reality: An exact master equation study

Zhao-Ming Wang, Wu, S. L., Mark Byrd +1 more

The precise characterization of dynamics in open quantum systems often presents significant challenges, leading to the introduction of various approximations to simplify a model. One commonly used strategy involves Markovian approximations, assuming a memoryless environment. In this study, such approximations are not used and an analytical dynamical depiction of an open quantum system is provided. The system under consideration is an oscillator that is surrounded by a bath of oscillators. The resulting dynamics are characterized by a second-order complex coefficient linear differential equation, which may be either homogeneous or inhomogeneous. Moreover, distinct dynamical regions emerge, depending on certain parameter values. Notably, the steady-state average excitation number (AEN) of the system shows rapid escalation with increasing non-Markovianity, reflecting the intricacies of real-world dynamics. In cases where there is detuning between the system frequency and the environmental central frequency within a non-Markovian regime, the AEN maintains its initial value for an extended period. Furthermore, the application of pulse control can effectively protect the quantum system from decoherence effects without using approximations. The pulse control can not only prolong the relaxation time of the oscillator, but can also be used to speed up the relaxation process, depending on the specifications of the pulse. By employing a kick pulse, the Mpemba effect can be observed in the non-Markovian regime in a surprisingly super-cooling-like effect.

arXiv:2411.17197•Nov 26, 2024•10 citations

Linear response theory for open systems: Quantum master equation approach

Masashi Ban, Sachiko Kitajima, Toshihico Arimitsu +1 more

A linear response theory for open quantum systems is formulated by means of the time-local and time-nonlocal quantum master equations, where a relevant quantum system interacts with a thermal reservoir as well as with an external classical field. A linear response function that characterizes how a relaxation process deviates from its intrinsic process by a weak external field is obtained by extracting the linear terms with respect to the external field from the quantum master equation. It consists of four parts. One represents the linear response of a quantum system when system-reservoir correlation at an initial time and correlation between reservoir states at different times are neglected. The others are correction terms due to these effects. The linear response function is compared with the Kubo formula in the usual linear response theory. To investigate the properties of the linear response of an open quantum system, an exactly solvable model for a stochastic dephasing of a two-level system is examined. Furthermore, the method for deriving the linear response function is applied for calculating two-time correlation functions of open quantum systems. It is shown that the quantum regression theorem is not valid for open quantum systems unless their reduced time evolution is Markovian.

Physical Review A•Feb 27, 2017•22 citations
The nonequilibrium steady states of quantum materials have many challenges. Here, we highlight issues with the relaxation time approximation (RTA) for the dc conductivity in insulating systems. The RTA to the quantum master equation (QME) is frequently employed as a simple method, yet this phenomenological approach is exposed as containing a fatal flaw, displaying non-negligible dc conductivity in the linear response regime. We find that the puzzling behavior is caused by the fact that the density matrix in the RTA incompletely incorporates the first order of the external field. To solve this problem, we have derived a calculation scheme based on the QME that ensures correct behavior in low electric fields. Our method reproduces well the overall features of the exact electric currents in the whole field region. It is not time consuming, and its application to lattice systems is straightforward. This method will encourage progress in this research area as a simple way to more accurately describe nonequilibrium steady states.
We describe a method to obtain the reduced density matrix (RDM) correct up to second order in system-bath coupling in nonequilibrium steady-state situations. The RDM is obtained via a scheme based on analytic continuation, using the time-local Redfield-like quantum master equation, which was earlier used by the same authors [J. Chem. Phys. 136, 194110 (2012)] to obtain the correct thermal equilibrium description. This nonequilibrium modified Redfield solution is then corroborated with the exact RDM obtained via the nonequilibrium Green's function technique for the quantum harmonic oscillator. Lastly, the scheme is compared to different quantum master equations (QMEs), namely the time-local Redfield-like and the Lindblad-like QMEs, in order to illustrate the differences between each of these approaches.
\nthe quantum calculation of the d.c. electrical conductivity for an electron system is reconsidered by using an improved form of the long-time solution of the density matrix. The starting time-evolution equation which is written as a linear system in the Liouville space of discrete quantum states, is first solved in terms of Cramer's determinants and next suitably adapted to tranport problems. The calculation of the statistical average of the many-body current density, in the presence of scattering potential, is carried out in the thermodynamic limit, using a characteristic property of collision matrices introduced earlier by van Hove as the so-called delta\\deltadelta-singularity. In contrast to previous methods based on kinetic equations solved by perturbations, Kubo's theory, or Mori type memory functions, the resolution of an integral equation, initially included in Cramer's formulae, is no longer required. Among its major advantages, the method succeeds in overcoming the well known zero frequency divergent behaviour of the conductivity. It also yields an explicit expression of an effective relaxation time which is just constructed out of those diagonal transition sequences responsible for self-energy effects in van Hove's theory. This expression which only assumes the randomization of phases of initial states can be used to get tractable expansions in powers of the collision potential. Its range of validity is limited by the effect of collisions on equilibrium statistics, which is shown to be negligible within the Peierls criterion, hbar/taullmu\\hbar / \\tau \\ll \\muhbar/taullmu, tau\\tautau being the relaxation time and mu\\mumu the Fermi energy. Finally, the comparison of the present approach with the elementary transport theory reveals that the relaxation time is close to the standard expression, even though the latter would be exactly recovered, in lowest order of collisions, only on disregarding divergent terms arising beyond second order.\n
We develop a method of calculating the nonequilibrium steady state (NESS) of an open quantum system that is weakly coupled to reservoirs in different equilibrium states. We describe the system using a Redfield-type quantum master equation (QME). We decompose the Redfield QME into a Lindblad-type QME and the remaining part R\mathcal{R}R. Regarding the steady state of the Lindblad QME as the unperturbed solution, we perform a perturbative calculation with respect to R\mathcal{R}R to obtain the NESS of the Redfield QME. The NESS thus determined is exact up to the first order in the system-reservoir coupling strength (pump/loss rate), which is the same as the order of validity of the QME. An advantage of the proposed method in numerical computation is its applicability to systems larger than those in methods of directly solving the original Redfield QME. We apply the method to a noninteracting fermion system to obtain an analytical expression of the NESS density matrix. We also numerically demonstrate the method in a nonequilibrium quantum spin chain.
We consider a system perturbed by an external field and subject to dissipative processes. From the von Neumann equation for such a system in the weak coupling limit we derive an inhomogeneous master equation, i.e., a master equation with dissipative terms and streaming terms, using Zwanzig’s projection operator technique in Liouville space. From this equation the response function, as well as expressions for the generalized conductivity and susceptibility, is obtained. It is shown that for large times only the diagonal part of the density operator is required. The various expressions are found to be in complete harmony with previous results (Part I) obtained via the van Hove limit of the Kubo–Green linear response formulas. In order to account for the properties at quantum frequencies, the evolution of the nondiagonal part in the weak coupling limit is also established. The complete time dependent behavior of the dynamic variables in the van Hove limit is expressed by B (t) =exp[−(Λd−iℒ0) t] B, where Λd is the master operator and L0 the Liouville operator in the interaction picture. The cause of irreversibility is discussed. Finally, the inhomogeneous master equation is employed to obtain as first moment equation a Boltzmann equation with streaming terms, applicable to quantum systems.
The precise characterization of dynamics in open quantum systems often presents significant challenges, leading to the introduction of various approximations to simplify a model. One commonly used strategy involves Markovian approximations, assuming a memoryless environment. In this study, such approximations are not used and an analytical dynamical depiction of an open quantum system is provided. The system under consideration is an oscillator that is surrounded by a bath of oscillators. The resulting dynamics are characterized by a second-order complex coefficient linear differential equation, which may be either homogeneous or inhomogeneous. Moreover, distinct dynamical regions emerge, depending on certain parameter values. Notably, the steady-state average excitation number (AEN) of the system shows rapid escalation with increasing non-Markovianity, reflecting the intricacies of real-world dynamics. In cases where there is detuning between the system frequency and the environmental central frequency within a non-Markovian regime, the AEN maintains its initial value for an extended period. Furthermore, the application of pulse control can effectively protect the quantum system from decoherence effects without using approximations. The pulse control can not only prolong the relaxation time of the oscillator, but can also be used to speed up the relaxation process, depending on the specifications of the pulse. By employing a kick pulse, the Mpemba effect can be observed in the non-Markovian regime in a surprisingly super-cooling-like effect.
A linear response theory for open quantum systems is formulated by means of the time-local and time-nonlocal quantum master equations, where a relevant quantum system interacts with a thermal reservoir as well as with an external classical field. A linear response function that characterizes how a relaxation process deviates from its intrinsic process by a weak external field is obtained by extracting the linear terms with respect to the external field from the quantum master equation. It consists of four parts. One represents the linear response of a quantum system when system-reservoir correlation at an initial time and correlation between reservoir states at different times are neglected. The others are correction terms due to these effects. The linear response function is compared with the Kubo formula in the usual linear response theory. To investigate the properties of the linear response of an open quantum system, an exactly solvable model for a stochastic dephasing of a two-level system is examined. Furthermore, the method for deriving the linear response function is applied for calculating two-time correlation functions of open quantum systems. It is shown that the quantum regression theorem is not valid for open quantum systems unless their reduced time evolution is Markovian.